STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 214 Book Reviews by one character its prosaic equivalent will often in the next line or two be used to designate the same thing by another character, this close connec- tion of picturesque and prosaic words frequently amounting to clear proof that Aristophanes employed the unusual word designedly. Sometimes, too, the use of the prosaic synonym at a greater remove, but where the situation or thought is similar, is significant, and not infrequently this internal criticism is the only means of judging. A word occurring several times and always in parody may be assumed to be not of every-day speech, but serving as a vehicle for the poet's humor; but classification is not always so sure, for most of the words of the collection occur both in and out of parody. The evidence to be used in classifying words depends on questions like the following: "In what kind of meter is the word prevailingly found? What prose writers use it? What poets? How often? In what way? Does it prevail in poetry or in prose? What characters in our plays use it? or in addressing whom? or in speaking of whom? Was there any other word that could have been used? Is it a favorite with any particular author?" Often a word apparently belonging to the higher style of Aristophanes occurs in classic prose, and in such cases the following must be borne in mind: use by the orators, especially the later ones, is generally good evidence against a word being poetic. Plato is full of poetry and poetic words; and Thucydides and Xenophon in their usage often depart far from the later standards of Attic prose; Herodotus has much in common with tragedy, especially Sophoclean tragedy. Synonyms are a great help in classifying words, as is also the prox- imity of other picturesque words and their number. "Parodic words occur in patches or bundles." "The plays differ greatly in the amount of parody they contain. In The Frogs where Euripides and Aeschylus wrangle, while Dionysus and the chorus stand by to judge and mock, we have the greatest amount of parody. Next comes the Thesmophoriazusae, with Euripides and his relative quoting tags of tragic verses to each other in antiphonal chant, while Agathon and his servant help to swell the total. The Acharnians and The Birds both have considerable parody, while the Lysistrata has very little, etc." The work seems to be very carefully done. C. F. S. The Frogs of Aristophanes. Edited by T. Gr. Tuckeb. New York : Macmillan, 1906. Pp. lx + 276. 2s. Qd. Whoever henceforth shall teach the Frogs in English, ignorant of this edition (owrapos ToiG>v8e \6y\vap-Q thrice repeated) should be pre- ferred to that of H. Eichards in Class. Rev. XV (1901), p. 389 (viz. aiSS>, then twice or-avow) is to me unaccountable. 455. If we translate ' For we alone have sun and gracious light,' Tucker's initial accent on eo-nv is needless. 570 and 574 assigned to Dionysus can surely not be so happy as if given to Xanthias, as van Leeuwen. 610-11 a. Tucker takes from Dionysus and gives to Aeacus, to save Dionysus from a "very unnatural position." This seems to me naive. 645. ovv for ovk is purposeless, if not worse. See Koch on Nub. 1066, or Ktihner-Gerth II, p. 204. 665. irpwvas is labor lost. 896. Again it is lost labor to defend a text proved corrupt by the antistrophe. 936. Why suggest ttoV ap', when the text irot' irr' is so amply protected by 173, Pax 704, Av. 1514? 1203. "Qu. Kara K<#8dpu>vV No, it would spoil the intentional singsong of the thrice-heard rhythm ~ ~ _. 1210. Iva ml: note on k /teV y'? The argument for here adding ye is curious: 1st, the formula dAA' ovv ■ ... ye is well known; 2d, "the combination pJv ye is also very common." Ergo: "probably we should read p.eV y'." 1307. TaSt y' for Her- mann's TaSe y' results in an unpleasant and unmitigated anapaest in the 4th foot, which I leave to Mr. Starkie's tender mercy (Vesp., p.xxxvii), as also the query on 286: oW&v ovv i0i? 1323. That the misshapen "TroSa" exemplified in irepi/JaAA' should receive no explanation is perhaps to be expected in a book so mute as this on lyric meters. Yet I hold it a Book Reviews 217 serious delinquency when Aristophanes is taught with his rhythms omitted. Granted that we have little certitude on the details, yet we do know that the songs of the Greek drama were rhythmical. Better there- fore give if-it-be-but-a-hint of their ancient effect through our modern rhythms than leave them in utter sprawling prose. Misprints sometimes occur (e. g. Dioneia in note on 650), and wrong references are thick (e. g. p. 85, 1. 5, read 17, not 14; p. 86, 1. 3, read 677, not 647; p. 99, 1. 4 of note on 97, read 573, not 57; p. 117, 1. 11 from bottom, read 380, not 310; and these are but the beginning!). Neverthe- less, in returning to the upper world, as Dionysus did by Aeschylus, I shall choose Tucker and leave the rest. L. L. Foeman Cornell University A Short History of Greek Literature from Homer to Julian. By Wilmee Cave Wbight, Ph.D. New York: American Book Co., 1907. Pp. 543. $1.50. This book, which appears in the "Greek Series for Colleges and Schools," edited under the supervision of Professor Herbert Weir Smyth, does credit to its authoress, who is evidently well acquainted with the opinions of modern scholars as well as with the works of the Greek writers. The views expressed are sane and reasonable, and the style is, on the whole, agreeable in spite of a few lapses into figurative expressions of doubtful taste. So (p. 31) it is said of critics of the style of the Homeric poems that they "range over the same ground, but they never put up the same game," and (p. 45) the cyclic poets are said to owe their "second-hand immortality" to the "antiseptic quality" of the Homeric poems. In a small book which contains the history of the rich literature of more than a thousand years much must necessarily be omitted, and it is therefore only to be expected that those writers whose works are lost or preserved only in fragments are for the most part passed over in silence or with very brief mention. It would, however, have been well to impress upon the reader in some way the fact that in the Alexandrian period and the succeeding centuries the quantity of Greek literature produced was vastly greater than is indicated by the comparatively small number of writers whose works are discussed. Many of those whose works are lost exercised no little influence upon Roman writers, and through them upon the literature of later times. While it is probable that the lost works (like some of the extant works) of many post-classical writers had no great literary excellence, the immense literary activity of the post-classical period is of great importance in the history of literature. The analysis of the style of each author is clear, and as accurate as the brief space allotted to it allows, but it is doubtful if such analysis