STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 212 Book Reviews tion into which he does not often enter, or in larger questions where he is generally right. A captious critic might ask whether iXavTta is ever used in the good sense of " self-respect ; " and might point out that though Aristotle's debt to Plato, and especially to the too-much-neglected Laws is explicitly acknowledged, the general method of Mr. Barker's exposition remains that of the usual Aristotelian who invariably exaggerates his author's originality and employs all the arts of interpretation to minim- ize his self-contradictions instead of accepting his inconsistencies as the inevitable result of his unsuccessful attempts to emancipate himself in appearance from the Platonism that was bred in the bone. It would be pleasant to quote some of Mr. Barker's many apt and pregnant state- ments of the essential analogies and differences to be noted in a compari- son of ancient and modern political life and theory. But there is space only to recommend his volume to the general student of ancient life and particularly to all authors of textbooks of the History of Political Theories. Paul Shobey Decimus Junius Brutus Albinus. A Historical Study. By Ber- nard Camillus Bondubant. Chicago dissertation. Chicago : The University of Chicago Press, 1907. Pp. 113. $0.75. This dissertation, written under the direction of Professor Abbott gives in detail the life, character and influence of Decimus Brutus, estab- lishing the various facts by full citation of authorities. The work has been carefully done and the results arrived at are, in general, sound. Mis- prints are rare, press work and paper excellent. The introduction includes a summary of contents, a table of dates of important events connected with the life of Brutus after the death of Caesar, and a selected bibliog- raphy. The dissertation itself is divided into three chapters: I, "The Career of Decimus Brutus to the Year 45 b. c.;" II, "Decimus' Part in the Assassination of Caesar;" III, " Decimus' Administration of Cisalpine Gaul and the War with Antonius." In the first chapter the tracing of the ancestry of Brutus is interesting, but not conclusive; the defense of Sempronia (pp. 22), mother of Brutus, against the charges of Sallust is hopeless and opposed to Bondurant's excellent handling of sources in the major portion of his work; on p. 23 the adoption of Brutus and his name Albinus are correctly explained, but I miss the reference to Eckhel, Vol. V, p. 187, where a fuller proof of this position appears. By far the best portion of the chapter is the description of the career of Brutus under Caesar in Gaul. Particularly happy is the treatment (p. 26) of the sources for the naval battle against the Veneti. The second chapter is, in the main, less satisfactory owing to the rather labored defense of Decimus Brutus. In this portion Bondurant often appears a eulogist Book Reviews 213 rather than a historian. He has also devoted far too much attention (pp. 41-51) to an attack on Caesar and his imperial designs. Though this is an interesting section, it interrupts the treatment of the life of Brutus and yet offers no adequate apology for his action. In the third chapter the author has been more happy in his defense of Brutus. The conflicting statements of the sources have been well handled, and where the report favoring Brutus has been adopted, the reasons are generally adequate. The comparison of sources for the period has been so thoroughly made, that a tabulation of the results, showing their relative value, could easily have been made. In glancing through the footnotes I was not surprised to see that Bondurant ranks Appian much higher than Dio for the period. In some cases he probably goes too far in following Appian, notably on p. 94, where the opposing statements of Livy, Velleius, etc., are dis- regarded. A helpful index of proper names completes the book. Henry A, Sandebs University of Michigan The Language of Parody; a Study of the Diction of Aristo- phanes. By Edwaed William Hope. Johns Hopkins Dissertation, 1905. The reason assigned for this treatise is that while parody in the comic poets has been the subject of dissertations and more pretentious works, there has been no systematic treatment of the language of parody with a collection of the words by which parodic effects were secured. This Mr. Hope's dissertation does for Aristophanes, aiming to give " a complete list of those words by the use of which Aristophanes departs from the usage of the ordinary Athenian life of his day, and rises to the loftier tone of tragedy or other kinds of poetry;" adding, too, dialectical words with which Aristophanes depicts the manners of his provincial fellow- countrymen. But while passages of parody or paratragedy, detected by scholiasts and modern scholars, are mainly the ones where the higher tone is consciously sought, the formal limits of known parody are too narrow; and many poetic words in this collection are not found in parodic lines. Further, the travesty often consists merely in holding up to view the ordinary affairs of daily occurrence, or in using the words of the common crafts to describe higher matters, or in substituting vulgar or commonplace words for tragic expressions. Certain characters may always be expected to use grand language, e. g., Euripides that of the tragic stage, as also Socrates in The Clouds, Aeschylus a lofty style abounding in epic words, Lamachus epic and tragic phraseology. A close comparison of the language used by different characters is often illuminating, e. g., after a poetical word has been used