STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 343 than the Semitist is aware of. Since most of the documents from which the names are taken are dated, or, if undated, can usually be assigned an approximate date which will hardly be more than a half-century too high or too low, it will be seen that they furnish an invaluable aid to the study of the movements of the Aryans in Asia Minor in the second pre-Christian millennium. _ _ _ d. d. luckbnbill University op Chicago Juvenalis Declamans. Etude sur la rMtorique declamatoire dans les satires de Juvenal. Par Jostte de Decker. Gand: Van Goethem & Cie., 1913. Fr. 9. In this work M. de Decker seeks to show that the rhetorical element in Juvenal is due to the poet's previous practice of oratory. Martial (vii. 91. 1) calls Juvenal facundus, and the anonymous Vita in a probably authentic passage ("ad mediam fere aetatem declamavit animi magis causa quam quod scholae se aut foro praepararet") relates that he spoke in public until about middle life. This does not mean that Juvenal was a teacher or an advocate (this view being expressly disclaimed by the Vita); his oratorical activity is rather to be associated with the post-scholastic assemblies for public speak- ing, which de Decker with a new marshaling of the evidence has set before us in a clearer light. The purpose of these salles de declamation was to furnish the aspiring orator with an opportunity for practical training. Men took part in them as a preparation for the forum or as an outlet for their intel- lectual energies. To the latter class Juvenal (whose participation in the Seances oratoires is altogether probable) doubtless belonged, as the Vita suggests. Whatever his motive, he came in contact here with rhetorical influences which impressed him deeply and which he carried over into the later field of satire. However, to know what these influences were, we need documents which reveal the ideas and the manner of presentation which Juvenal encountered. Fortunately, the author maintains, we possess such documents in the Suasoriae et controversiae of the elder Seneca, and he pro- ceeds accordingly to a detailed comparison between them on the one hand and the Satires on the other. The first chapter deals with the similar treatment of stock themes— De fortuna, De crudelitate, De saeculo, De divitiis. Under De saecvio the orators appear to have declaimed against the shortcomings of women and de Decker believes that Juvenal's fulminations are mainly echoes of oratorical conven- tions. There are similarities also in the arrangement and presentation of subject-matter, such as disproportion of parts, digressions, proof by example, imaginary auditors, antithesis, and climax. In the department of style proper Juvenal in common with the orators makes use of apostrophe, hyber- pole, anaphora, rhetorical question, and the like. The satires most affected by rhetorical influences are i, ii, vii, viii, x, xiii, xiv, xv; those least so are iii, v, viii, ix, xi. 344 Book Reviews The outcome of the author's study is to render very probable the relation for which he contends between Juvenal, the orator, and Juvenal, the poet. In details he is inclined to push the argument to extremes and to attribute too little to the poet's contact with life. Thus Juvenal's attitude toward women need not be a mere rhetorical pose borrowed from the commonplaces of the orators. It was the attitude substantially of many of his contem- poraries and there is evidence that it was not altogether unwarranted by experience. Indeed, the whole section on invention is much less convincing than the others. M. de Decker (p. 9) expresses surprise that his method of attacking the subject had not been anticipated. It is true no one else has made a similar study of Juvenal, but Eduard Norden in the part of pointing the way (Kunstprosa, I, 273, 1, 336 ff.; Eirdeitung in die Altertumsioissenschaft, I, 516) should not be overlooked. Neverthless the author has achieved a very pains- taking, scholarly, and, in many ways, illuminating piece of work. Jefferson Elmore Stanford University Athenian Clubs in Politics and Litigation. By George Miller Calhoun. "Bulletin of the University of Texas," Humanistic Series, No. 14. Austin, Tex., 1913. Pp. 172. The title of this book has been chosen with great care. It is of "clubs in politics" that Dr. Calhoun treats, not of "political clubs." In other words, he is under no necessity to define the character of any association found in Athens; he has merely to connect it with politics or litigation. That Athenian society was honeycombed with clubs everyone who has studied it closely knows. The community simply teemed with "brother- hoods, orgeones, gennetae, messmates, burial unions, thiasotae, men setting out for piracy or trade," to quote the words of the "Solonian" law which legalized associations. Hence the presumption is that every citizen had £Ta?poi of some sort. The suggestion, however, is often conveyed by Dr. Calhoun that the craTpoi imply a iraiptux; or, to quote Thucydides, a club «ri &'kcus Kal dpxais, where, in my judgment at least, the proof that such was its character is lacking. In such cases the question is, not as Dr. Calhoun puts it, Could his hetairoi have assisted such and such a man in politics and legislation? but, Did they? In fact, a large part of Dr. Cal- houn's book is taken up with describing the political and judicial situations in which the influence of clubs may have been effective. Herein the author has displayed an accurate and detailed knowledge of political and legal procedure in Athens, as well as much skill in unfolding the opportunities which existed for bribery and corruption. I note in the full bibliography the omission of Pantazides' pamphlet Ilepi r&v ev 'Xdrjvai.% tto\itiku>v 'EraipeW, which was printed in Athens by Blastos in 1892. W. S. Ferguson