STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 376 Book Reviews its previous history, with noteworthy literature bearing on the subject. See, e.g., the notes on Messene, Locri, and Rhegium in chap. 1. The same is true of the brief biographical notices on the first appearance of historical personages, as, e.g., that on Brasidas in chap. 11. Thucydidean usage is carefully noted everywhere. By this is meant (1) words apparently coined by Thucydides; (2) aTraf tlpijixeya or rare terms; (3) Ionic or poetic words and constructions; (4) peculiarities of Thucydidean sjoitax. The notes involving all such points show careful and constant use especially of the Classen-Steup commentary. But there is abundant evidence everywhere that Stahl, Shilleto, Kriiger, Hude, Boehme-Widmann, Goeller, Bloomfield, Arnold, and Jowett were always consulted. The manifest object has been to give the reader the helps that are really necessary to understanding the text. Praiseworthy lucidity as well as brevity characterizes the notes, and the edition can be heartily recommended as an excellent one for school and college work. The indexes — Greek, 13 pages; English (including names and places) 8 pages, in double columns — are unusually full. C. F. S. University of Wisconsin Aristarchs Atketesen in der Homerkritik. By Adolph Roembb. Leipzig: Teubner, 1912. Pp. xii+528. M. 16. This book is a continuation of the work of over thirty years in which the author has devoted himself with peculiar enthusiasm to the attempted dis- covery of the true Aristarchus. The results of all this labor are most dis- tressing, since they apparently prove that the scholia in Ven. A, hitherto regarded of unique value in estimating the merits and defects of Aristarchus, are founded on ignorance and dishonesty, also that Aristonicus did not have the abiUty or the desire to interpret him truthfully, that Didymus was unable to comprehend the great Alexandrian, and lastly that the excerptor, who has preserved in part the comments of Aristarchus as mutilated by Aristonicus and Didymus, was himself ignorant, incompetent, and dishonest. Roemer groups these three, Aristonicus, Didymus, and the excerptor, under the heading "The perfidious and scandalous group of swindlers." How are we to reach the true original through this triple barrier of ignorance and im- posture ? The attempt is frankly impossible, but here and there certain in- dications may be found, chiefly in Eustathius, Porphyrius, and Townleanus B, with an occasional hint from Plutarch and Athenaeus, while the supposedly valuable scholia in Ven. A are to be ignored as entirely worthless. No work based on the reliability of Ven. A is of any value, hence this sad verdict on p. 501 : " So wenig wie Lehrs hatte Cobet eine Ahnung von der Aristarchischen Exegese." This book is most difficult reading and demands the widest study in the same field in order to be able to determine the worth of the arguments, a study Book Reviews 377 few or none besides the author himself could have made. By the most intricate and erudite comparison of scattered scholia, Eustathius, and Porphyrius, it is shown that Ven. A credits Aristarchus with the very the- ories which he vigorously fought. Two examples will suffice to show how false these comments of A are. X 329 : ov8' ap' aw' axTi^apayov ficAxjj ra/it )(akKol3dpaa, of)a Tt fuv irpoTuiiroi OL/Mi^oijixvoi iiracriTLV. to which Ven. A has the following: (a) dBertiTou. on -yeXoibs el ij fieXia iirerr)Sev<7e htj airora/Mv Tov a.(Ta(Ti,v, OTi to ck tv;^s povoi, oI;vo8otou koI *Ap«7TO<^avous]. iris ■yap ktX. (/8) [ avTiXcyo Se 81' viro/ivij/wtTcov o ' ApiaTap)(OS, oTi TavTa a.<^' kavTon> iroul XeyovTa 6 7ron;T^s tov 'AvtiAoxov-] Aristarchus was not the apostle of the law of analogy, but the opponent, and his position in practically all matters was the reverse of that implied in Ven. A. Thus the structure erected on these schoha bj' Cobet, Lehrs, and their followers crumbles. Having removed the errors Roemer tries to give a revaluation of the work of the Alexandrians. His conclusions are as follows, though the foundations on which they rest are admittedly weak, since A is not to be regarded; Zenodotus had no conception of Homer or his times, and so accordingly tried to force Mm into the mold of a third-century philosopher, and ignoring tradition he emended or excluded verses at will; Aristophanes, though less radical, made no contribution to the appreciation of the Iliad and the Odyssey; Aristarchus was the first to grasp either the functions of an editor or the meaning of Homer. He saw that Homer belonged to a different world in culture, morals, and mythology; accordingly he did not try to fit Homer into the ideas of Alexandria, but let Homer interpret his own age, and advanced the true principle of explaining Homer from Homer. Aristarchus has never been sm'passed in the ability and industry with which he investigated epic poetry. He was not understood, since a myth grew up about him that his 378 Book Reviews work was done under inspiration, whereas it was the fruit of careful and systematic observations. His work was a mystery to Aristonicus and Didymus, who failed utterly to comprehend the meaning or results of his labors, and their faulty transcripts or comments were in turn mutilated by an incompetent and indolent excerptor. The recovery of Aristarchus, without the discovery of new materials, is impossible. The results of Roemer's studies are staggering and might well discourage anyone from studying the scholia to Homer, since it is impossible for any but the specialist to rectify a mistake or omission by the ready knowledge of Eustathius, Porphyrius, or outlying comments — comments not referring to the passage in question and whose meaning can be grasped only by the most shrewd combinations. The importance of the author's work is such that there is a real need that all his writings in this field be collected into a single, compact volume. This is not an impossibility, since Professor Roemer's style is pecuharly adapted to condensation. John A. Scott NORTHWESTEBN UNIVERSITY The Golden Latin Gospels in the Library of J. Pierpont Morgan Now Edited for the First Time, with Critical Introduction and Notes, and Accompanied by Four Full-Page Facsimiles. By H. C. HosKiEB. New York: Privately Printed, MCMX. This is a sumptuous and elaborate edition of the beautiful Gospels, written in golden letters on purple vellum, which formerly belonged to the collection of the Duke of Hamilton, and are frequently denominated "Ham- ilton 251." The present editor adopts the symbol f>. The volume contains an Introduction, of over 100 pages, devoted to a description of the manuscript, with detailed comparisons and discussions of other Vulgate MSS in connection with it. This Introduction is followed by Preliminary Remarks, giving different views as to the date and origin of the MS, and a careful, detailed description of the various hands to be distinguished in it, with peculiarities of each. And finally, we have the "Lectiones Variae," a list of peculiar readings, with comparison of a large number of other MSS, quotations from the Fathers, etc. An Appendix deals with another bibhcal fragment M in the Morgan library. It is a pity that so important a book should be disfigured by the style in which the subject-matter is treated. A serious work for the use of scholars is not the place for the facetiousness and diffuseness which characterize Mr. Hoskier's discussions. His paragraphing is excessive and unsystematic; he often makes independent sentences out of subordinate clauses (e.g. pp. xcv,