STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 375 argument is found on pp. 43-44, where he points out how impossible it would have been for any Roman in that stormy period to have risen so far above the strife of party as to write a wholly objective account of the struggle, which should afterward have been accepted as the only adequate source. The second essay deals with the administration of the ager puhlicus before the Gracchan period, for the purpose of overthrowing Niese's conten- tion that legislation fixing the amount of public land to be held by any indi- vidual dated only from a few years before 133 B.C., and formed no part of the Licinian laws of 367. Niese's view has been generally accepted, but Cardinali's discussion of the matter is keen, clear, and in the main convincing. He seems to have shown with reasonable certainty that some form of limita- tion was contained in the Licinian legislation. In connection with the provisions of the lex Sempronia, Cardinali argues that possessio of the ager publicus had been enjoyed by socii as well as by cives, and that the process of confiscation of excess holdings by the state bore harder on the former than on the latter. He agrees with Lange and Beloch, against Mommsen, Kornemann, and Meyer, that socii did not participate in the new distribution. In tracing the history of the lex Sempronia, Cardinali takes a position half-way between those who believe that the law was fully carried out, and those who think that, although the ager pvblicus was separated from that rightfully in the hands of individuals, little actual distribution took place. He also maintains with much plausibility that the lex Thoria of 111 B.C. was not a reactionary measure as is generally supposed. S. B. P. Thucydides, Book iv. Edited by A. W. Spbatt, M.A., Fellow and Tutor of St. Catherine's College, Cambridge. Cambridge: The University Press, 1912. Book iv of Thucydides has been prepared on the same plan as Mr. Spratt's two other books in the "Pitt Press Series," namely Thuc. iii and vi. Below the text at the foot of the page are noted important variants, corrections, and conjectures — especially of Cobet, Hude, van Herwerden, Dobree, Rutherford, and others — although a complete apparatus criticus for the book has not been attempted. These footnotes are bare statements of fact. Brief arguments or discussions on disputed points of text are given, when deemed necessary, in connection with the explanatory notes, not reserved for a critical appendix at the end. In fact the appendix — only four pages — is devoted mainly to historical questions. The introduction, which is short — only ten pages — discusses "The Prelude to the Ten Years' War." The explanatory notes are very brief, as a rule, but consistently helpful. Admirable especially are those of an informational character, which on the first mention of an important place give a concise statement of 376 Book Reviews its previous history, with noteworthy literature bearing on the subject. See, e.g., the notes on Messene, Locri, and Rhegium in chap. 1. The same is true of the brief biographical notices on the first appearance of historical personages, as, e.g., that on Brasidas in chap. 11. Thucydidean usage is carefully noted everywhere. By this is meant (1) words apparently coined by Thucydides; (2) airai tiprj/xeya or rare terms; (3) Ionic or poetic words and constructions; (4) peculiarities of Thucydidean syntax. The notes involving all such points show careful and constant use especially of the Classen-Steup commentary. But there is abundant evidence everywhere that Stahl, Shilleto, Kriiger, Hude, Boehme-Widmann, Goeller, Bloomfield, Arnold, and Jowett were always consulted. The manifest object has been to give the reader the helps that are really necessary to understanding the text. Praiseworthy lucidity as well as brevity characterizes the notes, and the edition can be heartily recommended as an excellent one for school and college work. The indexes — Greek, 13 pages; English (including names and places) 8 pages, in double columns — are unusually full. C. F. S. University of Wisconsin Aristarchs Atketesen in der Homerkritik. By Adolph Roemeb. Leipzig: Teubner, 1912. Pp. xii+528. M. 16. This book is a continuation of the work of over thirty years in which the author has devoted himself with peculiar enthusiasm to the attempted dis- covery of the true Aristarchus. The results of all this labor are most dis- tressing, since they apparently prove that the scholia in Ven. A, hitherto regarded of unique value in estimating the merits and defects of Aristarchus, are founded on ignorance and dishonesty, also that Aristonicus did not have the ability or the desire to interpret him truthfully, that Didymus was unable to comprehend the great Alexandrian, and lastly that the excerptor, who has preserved in part the comments of Aristarchus as mutilated by Aristonicus and Didymus, was himself ignorant, incompetent, and dishonest. Roemer groups these three, Aristonicus, Didymus, and the excerptor, under the heading "The perfidious and scandalous group of swindlers." How are we to reach the true original through this triple barrier of ignorance and im- posture ? The attempt is frankly impossible, but here and there certain in- dications may be found, chiefly in Eustathius, Porphyrius, and Townleanus B, with an occasional hint from Plutarch and Athenaeus, while the supposedly valuable scholia in Ven. A are to be ignored as entirely worthless. No work based on the reliability of Ven. A is of any value, hence this sad verdict on p. 501 : " So wenig wie Lehrs hatte Cobet eine Ahnung von der Aristarchischen Exegese." This book is most difficult reading and demands the widest study in the same field in order to be able to determine the worth of the arguments, a study