STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 372 Book Reviews fills out the history of the famous simile. Literary appreciation Mr. Mooney seldom attempts; iii. 747 may be "one of the intensely human passages in Greek literature," but has it not also a taint of sensationalism that is truly Hellenistic? It is easier, however, to make reservations, corrections, and additions than it is to edit a Hellenistic poet who has long been neglected. Mr. Mooney has been courageous and, within well-defined limits, competent. He has made Apollonius accessible to a number of willing readers even if he has not contributed in any large measure to our knowledge of Hellenistic usage or of the many interesting aspects of Hellenistic poetry. Henry W. Prescott University op Chicago Die sogenannten Sententiae Varronis. Von Peter Germann. III. Band, 6. Heft of Studien zur Geschichte und Kultur des Alter- tums, herausgegeben von E. Dberup. Paderborn: Ferdinand Schoningh, 1910. Pp. 99. M. 2.80. In the Einleitung, pp. 1-6, the author traces the history of our knowledge of these sententiae, from the publication of part of them in certain works of Vincent of Beauvais, 1250-54, to the recension of the full collection given, in 1865, by A. Riese, on pp. 265-72 of his M . Terenti Varronis Saturarum Menippearum Reliquiae. In this valuable bibliographical survey the views of all who in books or articles have examined the collection are given. As early as 1624, it appears, the Varronian authorship of the sententiae, appar- ently attested by the ascriptions in the MSS, was questioned, but no one had exhaustively examined the matter. As late as 1856, Chappuis, in his elaborate discussion, had positively ascribed the collection to Varro; Riese had held that the sententiae were in part at least derived from Varro. Teuffel- Schwabe 5 (see Warr's translation, § 169. 2) and Schanz, I, 2 3 , S. 450, were evidently not ready to deny absolutely the Varronian authorship, though Teuffel-Schwabe, after quoting five sententiae from the collection, said, "It is true that all these sayings remind us even more of Seneca in style and spirit." There was, then, room for a definitive discussion of the sententiae with a view to determining, if possible, the authorship of the collection. To this end Germann, on pp. 7-29, deals with the interrelation of the MSS, as the basis of an authoritative text. The conclusions reached seem unassailable; the problems were, indeed, simple. On pp. 30-42 the text of the 158 sen- tentiae is given, with an elaborate apparatus criticus, far more exhaustive and valuable than that in Riese. It seems regrettable, however, that the author did not indicate in his text, by typographical devices, departures from the MSS, and that he did not indicate, in a short conspectus lectionum, how far his text differs from Riese's. The differences appear, in fact, in only about fifteen places; in general Germann's text is the better. Book Reviews 373 On pp. 44-74 we have " Bemerkungen zu den einzelnen Sentenzen." The author evidently did not aim to write an exhaustive commentary; many interesting matters of syntax and vocabulary are passed over. Germann was concerned primarily with the thought of the sententiae; he adduces parallels from Varro, Cicero, Horace, Ovid, Publilius Syrus, and, above all, from Seneca the philosopher. Chappuis had already noted many parallels from Seneca without, however, realizing their bearing on the question of authorship; to these Germann adds largely. Valuable as this collection of parallels is, one gets the feeling that the author had early made up his mind that the main source of the sententiae was Seneca; at any rate he is most diligent in his quest for Senecan parallels. For example, on 138, Citra per- fectionem omne est principiwm, he fails to cite such an elaborate foreshadowing of the idea as we have in Cicero Brutus 69-71 (cf. especially 71, nihil est enim simvl et invention et perfectum). Perhaps, too, not sufficient allowance is made for the proverbial character of much of the sententiae or for the fact that, since the prevailing philosophy of our collection is Stoic, of necessity most clear-cut parallels will be parallels with Seneca. Pp. 75-84 deal with the sources. Here the hint's scattered throughout the Bemerkungen are gathered together. Assuming that his collections of parallels is exhaustive (an unjustifiable assumption, I fear), Germann con- cludes that Varro is not the source or even an important source; there are few instances in which we can bring our sententiae into close and real connec- tion with Varro's known words or thoughts. Again, not one author of all those who, down to the end of antiquity, derived their knowledge directly or indirectly from Varro, cites as Varronian a single sententia from our collec- tion. The many parallels between our sententiae and Cicero, Germann explains as due to the similarity of the philosophical problems handled both by Cicero and the sententiae; besides, in these cases we can regularly cite parallels from other Latin authors: in a word, we are dealing merely with stock themes. There are points of contact between the sententiae and Horace, as with Ovid; once, in each case, there is use of the phraseology of these poets. There are more points of contact with Publilius Syrus; some- times, where there is close resemblance in thought, there is also evidence of metrical form. On p. 79, however, Germann declares plainly his conclusion that "die Werke Senecas tatsachlich als Quelle eines betrachtlichen Teiles der Sammlung zu gelten haben." We have not only parallels in thought, but direct use of Seneca's words and phrases, at times in very different con- nections (p. 89) ; see the striking examples gathered on pp. 81-82. On the whole, in spite of my doubt concerning the exhaustiveness of the citations of parallels from authors other than Seneca, I think Germann has made out a case for Seneca as the chief source of these sententiae. The concluding pages, 85-89, deal with the "Entstehung der Spruch- sammlung." Here, because the author rightly refuses to indulge in specu- lation and sticks closely to the few things he can fairly claim to have proven. 374 Book Reviews we find little that is definite. Only sententiae 1-152, he holds, belonged to the original collection; to cite but one bit of evidence for this view, one MS shows a subscription after 152. Who the author was and when the collection was put together Germann does not attempt to say. To sum up, we have an interesting book, whose chief merit, apart from its orderly presentation of material, the excellence of its method, and its resolute refusal to claim more than the evidence warrants, lies in the demon- stration of the close parallelism, in thought and language both, between the sententiae and the philosophical works of Seneca. Thus the belief of Ger- mann's more immediate predecessors in the Varronian authorship of the collection is disproved, and demonstration is made that Teuffel-Schwabe's connection of the sententiae with Seneca is, at the least, very much more than a mere guess. It may be added, finally, that the sententiae are far from uninteresting in themselves. One oft-repeated thought is that no teacher can be of much value or power who listens to others merely that he may repeat audita. Charles Knapp Columbia University Studi Graccani. By Giuseppe Cakdinali. Rome: E. Loescher & Co., 1912. Pp. iv+212. This book contains four essays on the sources of the history of the Gracchi, the agrarian question in general, the provisions of the lex Sempronia and the history of its enforcement. Much has been written of late on this subject, and the critical acumen of the modern German school abundantly exhibited. Cardinali represents a somewhat more conservative tendency, and in discussing the sources of Gracchan history he takes issue with Meyer and Kornemann in particular in their assumption of a single source of the Latin tradition. He maintains that, while Posidonius is the source of the account in Diodorus and the Auctor ad Herennium, of the other accounts in Latin authors, in Plutarch and in Appian, there are three distinct Latin sources — the original Latin source of Appian, a pre-Ciceronian, and Livy. The last two appear fused in Valerius Maximus, Florus, Cassius Dio, and perhaps Velleius. The Livian tradition is quite foreign to Plutarch and the Auctor ad Herennium. In Plutarch we have the pre-Ciceronian and the original of Appian and perhaps others still. Hardly any kind of investigation can lead to greater absurdities than that of sources, and Cardinali is to be congratulated on having exhibited more self-restraint and sanity of judgment than some of his predecessors. He refuses to accept Kornemann's Fannius, and does not attempt to elimi- nate entirely the element of individuality that may be found even in the most slavish of compilers. In general his criticisms are well taken, and his conclusions deserve careful attention. A good illustration of his skill in