STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 367 and, as a six months' trial has convinced me, insufficient for novices. Even in the publications of Grenfell and Hunt, which are intended for scholars, more corrections of misspelled words and misused cases, tenses, forms, and pronouns are given than in this chrestomathy for beginners. The footnotes supplied by Wilcken and Mitteis are good, but there should be more of them. It may be taken for granted that all who have a professional reason for knowing the papyri — I mean the historian, philologist, theologue, and jurist — will henceforth make the acquaintance of their subject through this work. It deserves, however, a wider public. The lover of Greek literature is less happily situated than the lover of Greek art. He has nothing by which to control his appreciation of his masterpieces comparable with the vase- paintings, tombstones, gems, terra cottas, frescoes, and graffiti which relieve the works of Pheidias and Praxiteles from their splendid isolation. The papyri bring him nearer to the natural mode of expression of the generality of Greeks than any other extant writings. They are at the same time the most intimate revelation we possess of the common acts and thoughts of men who, though resident in a foreign land among an alien people and them- selves oftentimes metis, are yet near enough to the ancient Greeks to make those teachers of the classics who ignore their ways and ideas do so at their own peril. The time is past when the ancient world lays its rich stores of human experience before all men of cultivation. But such of them as can still read Greek will find many things in this collection of petitions, letters, court records, marriage contracts, wills, official reports, and odds and ends to chuckle over, to wonder at, and to move them to pity and reflection. W. S. Ferguson Les institutions militaires de I' Egypte sous les Lagides. Par Jean Lesquier. Paris: Leroux, 1911. Pp. xviii-f-381. The preface of this book is dated in October, 1908, the addendum in December, 1909, and the title-page in 1911. An interval of two or three years between the printing and the publication of a book exposes an author to serious risk, especially in a rapidly advancing subject like papyri studies. In this case, for example, M. Lesquier has been unable to use Rostowzew's epoch-making Studien zur Geschichte des romischen Kolonates, notwithstand- ing that it deals very closely with his theme and was issued in 1910. In another respect, too, the author rests at a disadvantage when compared with his critics: he was unable to use the Grundzuge of Wilcken and Mitteis, which was printed in July- August, 1911. We hasten to add, however, that his general position is strengthened rather than weakened by the unseen work of his distinguished German contemporaries. The need of a treatise like Les institutions militaires de I'Egy-pte sous les Lagides is best proven by the reluctance with which Wilcken in his Grund- zuge attacks the subject without it. "Nur ungern," he says, p. 382, 368 Book Reviews " behandle ich daher jetzt den Stoff, doch darf wenigstens ein kurzer Uber- blick hier nicht fehlen." The earlier works by Paul Meyer and Schubart were premature; yet upon them the best summarization hitherto accessible — that of BoucheVLeclercq in his standard Histoire des Lagides — was largely dependent. A detailed study, based upon an exhaustive examination of the papyri, into the sources, organization, distribution, and employment of the Ptolemaic soldiers, yields to M. Lesquier this general result, that for the first time we are in a position to understand the relations, and the changes of relations, between Macedonians and natives in Egypt. We come thereby very close to the secret of the strength and weakness of the Ptolemies. In two notable particulars the practice of the early Ptolemies differed from that of the later. By both the standing army was farmed out; but the early kings kept it moving from dry or marsh lands, when it had reclaimed them, to other lands in need of reclamation, whereas the later kings let sons succeed fathers both in the army and in the farms which their parents' labor and money had redeemed. The penalty was that the army became immobile and ceased to add to the rent-paying domain of its master. The other notable difference consists not alone in the fact that a higher grade of military cleruchs, the so-called catoecs, appeared in the second century B.C. when lots were given to policemen as well as to soldiers, but also in the fact that the natives were then admitted freely to both services. M. Lesquier, indeed, thinks that the fiax^t were enrolled in the army from the beginning and that the much-discussed innovation of 218 B.C. involved the opening of the standing force to all classes of Egyptians. This seems to me unproven and unlikely. It implies the drawing of a distinction between the soldier caste and the other natives which must have been observable in many particulars had it really existed. To me it seems probable that the standing army of the Ptolemies was closed to the natives till the reign of Philopator. Their use on the fleet and in the transport service and occasionally in an army operating abroad was quite a different matter from keeping them continually under arms in Egypt itself. The proof of this contention is, moreover, found in the fact, established clearly by M. Lesquier, that after 218 B.C., and not before> the Macedonian and other foreign soldiers, despite the retention of their names and of their social, political, and economic status, were gradually absorbed by the natives. Responsibility for this disastrous issue is fastened too closely by M. Lesquier on the moral and political sluggishness of Ptolemy Euergetes. It was, indeed, a serious matter that this much overpraised monarch kept his troops employed for the last twenty years of his life cultivating his lands in Egypt. His successor could bring them so incompletely into action that he was forced to call the natives to his assistance when attacked by Antiochus the Great. The important point seems to me to be this, that, despite the danger which their prompt mutiny disclosed, the later Ptolemies were unable to dispense with Egyptian soldiers because the loss of their empire in 202-200 Book Reviews 369 B.C. cut them off from the districts from which their predecessors had been wont to draw their supply of new troops. The serious dependence of the domestic policy of the Ptolemies upon their foreign policy has not, I venture to think, been stressed sufficiently by M. Lesquier. Three points noted at random will indicate how much this book offers to those who are not specialists in Egyptian history: (1) The normal infantry- man's lot in Egypt contained thirty jugera, as did the holding of land given by Tiberius Gracchus to his new Roman soldiers. (2) The various ethne in the Ptolemaic army, like the Jews in Alexandria, were governed by their own laws. (3) The sons of the Ptolemaic military cleruchs — oi t^s imyovrjs — played much the same role in the recruiting of the Ptolemies as the sons begotten by Roman soldiers from the women in the neighborhood of their camps — the so-called ex castris — played in providing the legions in the station- ary castra with suitable candidates for some of their vacancies. W. S. Feeguson The " Argonautica " of Apollonius Rhodius. Edited with introduction and commentary by George W. Mooney, M.A. London: Longmans, Green & Co., 1912. Pp. 454. Mr. Mooney is a pioneer. The Argonautica has been frequently trans- lated into Latin, English, and other languages, but a commentary has not appeared for almost a century; and the exegesis in the editions of Hoelzlin, Shaw, Flangini, and Brunck-Schaefer is far inferior to the commentary pro- vided for many other classical authors in the seventeenth and eighteenth cen- turies. The present editor offers introductory chapters on the poet's life, the sources, the poem, other works of the poet, MSS, scholia, editions and trans- lations; his text rests on no independent collations, but is apparently his own; his apparatus criticus is culled from Merkel and others with some additions from the critical studies of more recent years; an appendix deals with the question of double recension, and with meter; there are indexes of proper names, of Greek words treated in the notes, but not of subject-matter. The purpose of the editor is not stated; we are not told whether he is addressing his work to scholars or to elementary students; he has provided a book that will immediately help the beginner in Hellenistic poetry and even the classical teacher who knows his Homer and Vergil, but has lacked courage to read Apollonius. Mr. Mooney, however, has made no effort to interpret, in the full sense of the term, either the poem or the poet. His introduction is a neat compilation of useful information; his notes give help in hard places, correct judiciously the translations of Way and others, the lexicons, and earlier editors, describe briefly Homeric and Apollonian usage, supply not a little in the way of parallel passages from earlier and contem- porary poetry with the usual stock of material from Vergil and Valerius Flaccus, and explain allusions to people and places. The value of such