STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 113 On the Language of Vitruvius. By Mobeis H. Moegan. Reprint from the Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences XLI, No. 23 (Feb. 1906), pp. 467-502. That statistics designed to show that an author's language and style are characteristic of a given epoch need a searching examination from every possible point of view in order to be valid, is shown in a striking way in this scholarly and fair-minded study. Attention has been called to this fact more than once, especially by WSlfflin in various articles in the Arch, filr Lat. Lex., but it continues to be cheerfully ignored. In two papers, one published in Danish in 1896, the other in English in 1898, Ussing attempted to show that the De architectura of Vitruvius was written about the middle of the third century by an amateur in the subject, who drew his material mainly from Varro. This thesis he defended by arguments based on its subject-matter and on its language and style. The work has also been assigned to the reign of Titus, though that it belongs to the time of Augustus is still probably the prevailing opinion. Without attempting to decide at present between the last two dates, or to consider the arguments based on the subject- matter, Morgan makes it very clear that nearly all the peculiarities in language and style which are cited by Ussing as characteristic of late Latin may be paralleled in Republican, Augustan, or Silver Latin, while the few which remain cannot be regarded as significant in a treatise on a technical subject, written by a man unpracticed in literary work. One point, which does not affect the general conclusions of the paper, is not clear to me. In the sentence: non enim atria minora ab maioribus easdem possunt habere symmetriarum rationes (142. 2 R), Morgan says that there is no idea of comparison in ab maioribus. Now while it is perfectly evident, assuming that ab be translated " than," that, in the courteous language of the Thesaurus, minora ab maioribus nihil est, it is not easy to see what meaning other than "compared with" can by any possibility be given to ab in the passage in question. Morgan's own translation is: "In the case of smaller atria the symmet- rical proportion cannot be the same as in larger." This is quite correct, but the meaning of ab maioribus must be "compared with greater," whether it be taken with minora, which is possible with that meaning, or with easdem, which seems to be Morgan's view (cf. "the same as in larger"). The suggestion of the Thesaurus that the phrase is to be taken with habere seems to me incorrect, as well as inconsistent with the other examples in the chapter in which the passage is cited. It will be observed that in most of the examples in this chapter ( Thes. 39. 10 ff.) the phrase with ab modifies an adjectival word. Habere ab has a distinct meaning (see A. L. L. X, p. 491. 5), so that the sentence is not parallel with Caes. Orat. Gell. v. 13. 6: quibus (clientibus) etiam a propinquis 114 Book Reviews nostris opem ferre instituimus i. propinquis relictis vel prae propinquis (Thes. 39. 45) except that the developed meaning "compared with" suits ab in both. If the phrase be taken with easdem, it may be explained as the opposite of alius ab, which is not uncommon. Personally I am inclined, both on account of the word -order and the lack of examples of idem ab, to take ab maioribus with minora. That it is not African Latin, and that in A. L. L. X, p. 500. 18 the sentence should have been cited in full, I cheerfully admit. Whether ab was actually taken in the sense of "than" by Wolfflin and myself I cannot now remember. I surely hope not. John C. Rolfe Grundzilge der Sprachpsychologie. Von Ottmak Dittkich. Bd. I: Einleitung und allgemein psychologische Grundlegung. Mit einem Bilderatlas. Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1903. Pp. xv + 786. Bilderatlas pp. 95. This forms the first volume of what promises to be the most exhaust- ive treatise on the psychology of language yet undertaken. Only the smaller part of the first volume (pp. 1-77, §§ 1-157) is devoted to a general introduction; by far the larger portion (pp. 78-724, §§ 158-2173) deals with questions of general psychology, viz., the nervous system in its anatomical and physiological aspects. An Atlas, which contains 114 extremely well-executed illustrations, accompanies this second part, which is so completely given over to psychological problems that a review of it must be left to the specialist. Its value to the linguistic investigator is mainly that of a very carefully arranged digest in which he will find assembled a large mass of psychological data which it would cost much time and trouble to collect and arrange by himself. On the whole, the majority of the topics here discussed touch only in a remote and indirect way upon what may be properly termed linguistic or phi- lological problems. Without wishing to criticize Dittrich for his very elaborate and painstaking exposition of the fundamental facts of nerve- psychology, I cannot suppress the fear that some philologists will be frightened away from a further pursuit of linguistic psychology by such a formidable array of information as is here offered as "Grundlegung." The Introduction discusses the relation of linguistic psychology to general psychology and to philology. It then takes up the concept of 'social psychology' (Wundt's 'Volkerpsychologie'= Dittrich's 'Gemein- psychologie ') and criticizes in this connection (in agreement with Wundt) Paul's attack on Lazarus und Stein thal's ' Volkerpsychologie,' as well as Paul's own ' Principienwissenschaft.' Strangely enough Paul, in the third edition (1898) of his 'Principien,' has not taken any notice whatever