STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 473 Demosthenis Orationes. Edidit Caeolus Ftjhb. Editio maior, Volumen I. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1914. Pp. xxxi+535. M. 4.50. The Teubner text of Demosthenes has long been in need of a thorough- going revision. Blass's edition of 1884 embodied personal views that have not found general acceptance, some of which, indeed, the editor himself had materially changed before his death, some even as early as 1890, when he published his Rede vom Krauze. The most important of these views of Blass was his conviction that quotations from Demosthenes as found in Greek rhetoricians and grammarians often furnished a more ancient and reliable text than even the best MSS of the orator himself. Without sufficiently determining for each rhetorician whether or not he was accustomed to depend on memory for his quotations (a question that by no means admits a safe answer in some cases) and without sufficient critical apparatus for those authors, Blass ventured to make large use of these citations as evidence for the text of Demosthenes. The bad effects of this procedure needed to be eliminated from the Teubner text. Again, Blass was so zealous in the application of the unquestioned prin- ciple of the avoidance of hiatus by Demosthenes, and the far less definite "rule" of the avoidance of a succession of three or more short syllables, that he frequently secured conformity to the principle and the rule by the accept- ance of inferior manuscript testimony, and sometimes by pure conjecture. This procedure could not give a reliable text. Still more serious was the damage wrought by Blass in the Teubner text by his attempt to secure in it the particular rhythmical movements and cor- respondences which at that time he believed he had discovered. The fact that he soon passed on to other rhythmical theories left his text of 1884 out of date even for himself, and in its use of rhythmical theory as a part of critical apparatus it met no acceptance whatever from other scholars. In view of the great extent of the revision demanded, it is not surprising that Fuhr puts out the new text, not as a fifth edition of the old, but as a new work. In his preface Fuhr briefly refers to the more recent discussions as to the original editions of Demosthenes' works and ancient revisions of them. He then gives in fifteen pages a description of the MSS, with references to the latest critical literature. He agrees with all scholars in holding S as of supreme authority, yet not infallible; he believes L to have been written from a MS that was itself a copy from S. A list of the papyrus fragments is added, with a brief statement of their small value as against the other MSS. He divides the MSS into three classes as against the four families of Butcher's Oxford text, for where Butcher makes P and Y members of a distinct family, Fuhr classes them with F. The plan of the Teubner texts allows Fuhr to give only brief critical notes. In ordinary cases he cites only the reading of 474 Book Reviews the leading member of each class, S, F, A; but under the sign V he often cites a reading on which F and Q agree. For the first four speeches, where A is only in small part available, because of its mutilation, he makes large use of U, citing from his own collation even insignificant variations and mis- takes. He of course notes every variation of his own text from S, except in matters like elision and the v movable. He records conjectures of modern scholars to some extent. As to quotations in the rhetoricians and grammarians, Fuhr reminds us of the possibility that an ancient author was quoting in any given case from memory, or intentionally changing the phraseology; further, that when he did quote from his own copy of Demosthenes, there is even greater danger of the corruption of the text of these writers as transmitted to us than of the older and better MSS of Demosthenes; and, finally, that for many of these writers we have as yet no critical editions. He concludes: "Quae cum ita sint, testimoniis illis non multum tribuo, multo minus sophistarum imita- tionibus, quippe quos oratoris verba cum se imitando oratorem superare posse confiderent saepe ipsos mutasse credam" (p. xxv). Fuhr therefore quotes such testimony only occasionally, except in the case of Didymus, Dionysius, and Hermogenes; these authors, available in critical editions, he cites regularly. In matters of hiatus and groups of short syllables two classes of cases are to be distinguished: first, there are very many cases where the hiatus would be removed, or the series of breves broken up, by the use of ordinary elision, aphaeresis, crasis, the use of v movable (both before vowels and consonants), and especially by the marking of slight, but necessary, pauses. In another class of cases we have real hiatus or breves, removable only by alterations of the text that are more than formal. As to cases of the first class the editor of a critical text might take the position that these are cases to be managed in oral delivery, and that the printed text need not attempt to show these elisions, pauses, etc. Such an editor would content himself with printing the text of S literatim (except as to pauses). But no recent editor takes this position, for the usage of S as to elision and the v movable is so haphazard and inconsistent that it can claim no significance. We could not tolerate, e.g., such a text as S gives in 18. 197 o-v Se ovtc Irtpa era-es (o-v 8' oW erep' e?ires Fuhr), or in 18. 224 Tore 8e avrb to irpayfn' av eKpivero i' avrov (tots S' alrb to irpayp.' av eKpiW ifp' avrov Fuhr), or in 18. 193 p.r) Sj) tovto s oiy^ airavra ocra ivrjv Kara avOpunrivov \oyurfwv (furj Sr) toC0' ofy avavB' 6V Ivrjv /car' avdpurmvov Xoyto-fjiov Fuhr). Editors are agreed in holding S as of no authority in these matters, but they differ considerably in the extent to which they follow con- sistent principles of their own. With Fuhr's edition we naturally compare Goodwin's critical edition of the De corona (1901), Butcher's Oxford text (1903), which contains the same speeches as this first volume of Fuhr's (Speeches I-XIX), and Humphrey's De corona (1912), which, while not put Book Reviews 475 forth as a critical edition of the speech, gives in some respects the best text that we have. Goodwin seems to have given little attention to hiatus. He elides freely, beyond the elisions of S, but on no discernible principle; we find such needless cases of hiatus as dyuuva Alo~)(fvov 3 ; irpaypa airb avayKafca and dywva evo-rrjo-dpevos 4 (but dyw' ipuoi 5); re iSt'ov 8; Oedo-axrde u>s . . . . jSe/SiWa rj . . . . kolvo. irrepev .... KaTa\prjio-ao-Oe 77817 .... ivheSeiyfie im 10. So inconsistent a text would be defensible only by an editor who was copying S throughout; this Goodwin does not do. Butcher consistently elides to avoid hiatus; occasionally, however, where there is a distinct pause, yet a pause not sufficient in Butcher's judgment to warrant punctuation, he marks the pause by refraining from elision; some pauses of this sort are caused by the dwelling of the voice on an emphatic word (see Butcher's preface) . The following are instances in the De corona (I have taken this speech for the more minute examination, as it is here that we have the editions of Goodwin and Humphreys for comparison) : o tot' &vopd£ovTO tjviV e&wpoSoKovv 46; etr' aXr/Or) .... km Trpoo-fjKovra eiTe Kal ipevSf) 57; Kal Sid ye tovto SpOSts irrrpiovprjv 113; i' ots 8' io-Tes eoiKe, tow 'AOrjvaiois irdrpia ovS' dvcKTa oiS' ep.s eoiKev rot's 'A$7)vaioi l s rrdrpi' ovS' dvexr' ovS' ep.Ka r) 10; tovto ye iv 21; u>vopAt,ovro rjviK.' 46; r}8iKrjo-$e iv 100; Idiom irrevOvvo's 117; SiSopeva 6p.oXoyu>v 119; o-vpfidvTa iv 168; dya0a eh 213; cfcaora iyto 214. Fuhr consistently removes hiatus by elision. In the Crown Speech I have noted only these exceptions: yiyvopeva em 64; r}8iKrjo-6e iv 100; ravra v 'EAXtjvw, ei tovti to prjp.', aXka. p.rj tovti Sn\i)(9rjv eyio, ij Sevpl ttjv X £ 'p'j aXXa. p.r] 8evpl iraprjvtyKa 232; cSt'Sao-Kes ypap-pmr', iya> 8' Icpoirwv 265. It is hard to defend elision in cases like these; if the pause is sufficient to warrant the printed sign, it is certainly sufficient (in Demosthenic prose) to neutralize the hiatus. Friedrich Schiller has recently put forth the hypothesis that in a con- siderable number of cases where the reading of S has hiatus that is avoided by the readings of other MSS the reading of S is correct, the others going back to a text that had been corrected by an editor for the express purpose of removing hiatus, but without an exact understanding of Demosthenes' usage (" Zu dem Hiate bei Demosthenes," Festschrift d. Gymnas. zu Hirsch- berg, 1912). The whole question needs a more thorough investigation. Zander's collection of cases of hiatus (Eurythmia, Leipzig, 1910, pp. 429-38) is useful. As to Demosthenes' avoidance of breves there is no common consent among scholars. (I use the term breves in the restricted sense in which Blass has made it familiar, a group of three or more short syllables not immediately followed by a pause, and not lying entirely within a single word, unless the final syllable of the word is the final syllable of the group.) Is this avoidance of breves a "law" of Demosthenes' composition, a "rule" with more or less exceptions, or a mere tendency (perhaps almost unconscious) ? Blass gave it such weight that he did not hesitate to adopt an inferior reading, and sometimes to alter the text outright, to avoid breves. Here, as in the case of hiatus, there are two classes of possible alterations: the first are merely formal, where the group of breves may be broken up by the elision of a vowel, by the use of v movable before a consonant, by aphaeresis, or the substitution of one form of a given word for another (e.g., elvem for li/exa, XPV V f° r *XPV V > tooto«t[o] for roaovrov. avrov for lavrov, rj/3ov\.6p.r]v for iftov\.6- p,rjv, pnv for eftoS) . Punctuation also will very often break up an apparent group of short syllables. Here it is often a question whether the pause that is clearly sufficient to lengthen the last syllable of a group is strong enough to warrant the use of a comma. This is particularly true when, as so often in the orators, the pause is rhetorical rather than syntactical; not infrequently the balance of kola or even of kommata demands so distinct a pause in delivery that it may well be marked for the eye of the reader. The rhetorical struc- ture is so essential to the appreciation of a Greek speech that we may well use punctuation more freely than in other prose. Perhaps Blass, in his constant anxiety to avoid breves, punctuated too freely, but certainly Fuhr Book Reviews 477 goes too far in his reaction against this; in Fuhr's text we too often find apparent breves that would be broken up by a comma which is well justified on rhetorical, sometimes on syntactical, grounds. In this respect Humphreys gives the better text, avoiding both extremes, but usually alert for the removal of needless breves. Fuhr's scrupulous use of elision to avoid hiatus keeps his text free from one class of needless breves that abound in Goodwin's text; e.g., Goodwin has irtirpa.yp.iva. ipavriS 4; tc iSiov 8; kolvo. viripcv 10; iv8i&ti)(8t iirl 10; irpdy- para. ikeyxqvs 15; ocra virtp 17; a Tort u)vopa£ovTO 46; Jcuparo mo 93. But in the use of v movable Fuhr sometime disregards the question of brr., often following the reading of S, though he admits that in this respect S has no authority. Blass had, by an entirely legitimate use of -v, removed a host of apparent breves; some of these reappear in Fuhr's text; so awiKrwi /Lie Sikcums 101; Tots y' d/xiapMKoai Kara tovs 121; TertX.tvTr)KO(ri Trap' avrd 285; avt8r)Ke Bvm/uv 290. More numerous are the cases where breves are caused by Fuhr's use of -v to avoid hiatus, where he should have elided: icrnv 6 Ta 6-qfia.itav 41; ytyovev aiTia 42; irapekrjkuda/ 6 tS>v 48; ZirparTev dSiKcov 69; •yeyovev olSa 70; iK@if$r)Kev a lrpoeiirare 80; yiypa 135; ?jrpa|ev virtp v/jmv 139; eirot'ijtrci/ airokicrOcu 142; irvy^avcv Z)(ov 174; ■yeyovev olov 198. In the following cases Fuhr makes right use of -v (in each case following S) to avoid brr., where Humphreys neglects it: 'Ap.iKTwxiiv 86£avTa 156; ovcriv ptpiSt 176; «x £I/ T ° ' iavrm (avr