STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Les Civilisations prShelliniques dans le bassin de la Mer Sgee. Deux- ieme edition revue et augmentee; avec 325 gravures et 18 planches horstexte, dont cinq en couleurs. By Ren£ Dussaud. Paris: Librairie Paul Geuthner, 1914. Pp. x+482. Fr. 24. This beautiful new edition of M. Dussaud's Civilisations prehelleniques is no mere reprint of the first. The subject-matter is augmented by one- half; the list of full-page engravings is increased from four to eighteen, five of them beautifully colored; certain chapters, like those on Troy, Mycenae, and Tiryns, that were abbreviated to a fault in the first edition, have been expanded to twice their former length and greatly improved. The chapter on the Aegean influence in Egypt and in Syria is a welcome addition. Various plans and tables, notably the comparative chronological table of the Aegean civilizations, and a full index enhance the convenience and the usableness of the book. The scope of the work is most clearly seen in the title-headings of its eight chapters: "Prehellenic Crete," "The Cyclades," "Troy and the Troad," "Continental Greece and the Mycenaean Civilization," "Cyprus," "The Aegean Influence in Egypt and Syria," "Cults and Myths," "The Aegean Peoples." M. Dussaud has put together in convenient and readable form the results of the excavations of Arthur Evans at Cnossus; Harriet Boyd-Hawes and her fellow-laborers at Gournia, Vasiliki, etc.; Dorpfeld at Troy; Schliemann at Troy, Mycenae, Tiryns, Orchomenus, etc.; Seager at Mochlos; Edith Hall at Sphoungaras; Halbherr at Phaestus; Edgar and Atkinson at Phy- lakopi; and the Greek archaeologists in all parts of Hellas. English, Ger- man, Italian, and American, as well as French, discoveries and the literatures bearing on the subject are given full recognition. He accepts practically all of Dorpf eld's results at Troy, Tiryns, Triphylian Pylus; but the great German's Leucas-Ithaca is rejected, without arguments, in favor of the traditional names of the Ionian Islands. It seems like a rather trivial effort to cherish a "different opinion," when he corrects Dorpfeld's round num- bers (which can be only approximate and make no pretensions at being any- thing else) from 2500-2000 b.c. to 2400-1900 B.C., and 2000-1500 b.c. to 1900-1400 b.c, as the respective dates of the second and third to fifth cities on the site of ancient Troy. 460 Book Reviews 461 The history of those prehistoric ages is presented to us, not so much through traditions handed down by the later times as through the con- temporary documents that by the discoveries of the last few decades have multiplied many times the knowledge we had of them a quarter of a century ago. The book contains but little in the way of original contribution to the science of pre-Hellenic antiquities; but M. Dussaud does give, in clear, well- arranged, and attractive form, a resume of all that has thus far been con- tributed to our knowledge of the civilizations of the Mediterranean basin. He presents the facts of art and archaeology and anthropology and discusses the various theories that have been brought forth, choosing, when the theories clash, the one that seems to him to be the most probable. His choice is usually sane; but, when (pp. 453, 454, for example) he identifies the Schardina (Sherden) of the Egyptian records with the "people of Sardis," he fails altogether to note their probable identification with the Sardinians — a theory that receives exceptional support from their association with the Sicilians (cf. Breasted, History of Egypt, pp. 440, 462, 477, et passim). The enormous literature, English, French, German, Greek, and Italian, that has grown up about the Minoan-Mycenaean civilization of the Medi- terranean has all been read and thoroughly digested by the author; he has apparently visited and studied on the ground all the great seats of Minoan civilization and speaks with the clearness and vividness of personal autopsy. Only rarely does he swerve from absolute accuracy of statement, as, for example, p. 191, where we are told that in the palaces of Crete we have access from one room to another only by means of a simple door or un couloir tres court; and yet a hallway like the west corridor at Cnossus, 230 feet long, or even the east corridor, 75 feet long, can hardly be designated as tres court. The bird reproduced in Fig. 176 is most obviously not a poule d'eau but a vulture or a turkey-buzzard. And the accepted date of the purification of Delos is not 425 (p. 97) but 427-426. The book, with its rich illustrative material and its beautiful paper and type, presents a very attractive appearance. But unfortunately it is marred by carelessness in the proofreading. Not to mention omitted periods (for example, at the bottom of p. 69) and dislocated hyphens (for example, pp. 18, 22, 26, 29, and 31), p. 44 closes with the end of a paragraph while p. 45 opens with the middle of a detached sentence which has no beginning. Much more serious, however, is the lack of care in the verification of refer- ences and citations: for example, for Fig. 286 and Fig. 299 (p. 154) we should read Fig. 287 and Fig. 300; for Fig. 182 (p. 256) read Fig. 183; for Fig. 205 (p. 289) read Fig. 206; for Fig. 265 (p. 362 infra) read Fig. 266; similar errors abound; and some erroneous citations (for example, p. 416, n. 4; Fig. 187 and Fig. 286, p. 430) I have not been able to run down at all. M. Dussaud's work is invaluable both to the student or teacher who may have a general interest in Mycenaean antiquities and to the specialist 462 Book Reviews in those fields. It does, though in briefer and more compact form, for the whole wide field what Schuchhardt's book did for Schliemann's excavations; not only is the entire field covered, but the whole literature of the subject is presented in the citations. Waltek Miller Univeksity op Missouri Omphalos. Eine philologisch-archaologisch-volkskundliche Ab- handlung uber die Vorstellungen. der Griechen und anderer Volker vom "Nabel der Erde." Von W. H. Roscher. Leip- zig, 1913. Pp. 140; 9 plates. M. 8. (From Vol. XXIX of the Abhandlungen der Sachs. Ges. der Wiss.) In this monograph the veteran mythologist offers an elaborate investi- gation of the myths, cults, and monuments of the Greeks which have to do with the idea of a "navel of the earth," and illustrates them with numerous parallels drawn from the folk-lore of other peoples, civilized and savage. The first chapter treats of the etymology of o/u.<£a\os and umbilicus, and of the different applications of these words; then (pp. 12-19) discusses the significance of the navel in various superstitious practices. The examples drawn from modern Greek folk-lore are of particular interest. In the second chapter Roscher shows that the idea of a definite place being the actual physical center of the world is a widespread one, occurring among people in lower as well as in higher stages of culture. He has not overlooked the part played in these beliefs by local pride (pp. 35, 132); but the humorously inclined American reader may miss a reference to Holmes's Autocrat (chap, vi), with its memorable witticisms about "the hub of the solar system," and the axis of the earth which "sticks out visibly through the center of each and every town or city." In the third chapter, Roscher elaborates a theory which he had stated more succinctly elsewhere, to the effect that in the seventh and sixth cen- turies the ancient sanctuary of Apollo at Branchidae laid claim to the pos- session of the center of the earth. He explains the words kl a£ovos KaO-qixiv-q, used by Iamblichus of the prophetess of Branchidae (De Mysteriis, 3. 11, p. 127 P.), as meaning "sitting on an omphalos." Representations of an omphalos are seen upon coins of Miletus and its colonies Cyzicus and Sinope (pp. 47-53). Roscher believes, however, that the real "earth-navel" at Branchidae was the x^fm yi?s from which the prophetic spring arose, while the omphalos in the conventional sense, the rounded cone of stone, was only a mark for the sacred spot. Chap, iv, the longest of the work, some fifty pages, contains an exhaust- ive discussion of Delphi and its oracle as the center of the world, and of the Delphic omphalos. The literary evidence is not merely noted, but cited,