STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 491 This was in the year 438-437. Four or five years later the case against Phidias came to trial. As the Eleans refused to surrender him he was con- demned and his bail was forfeited. On the completion of the statue of Zeus in the year 432-431 the Eleans showed their gratitude to Phidias by con- ferring isotelia on him. The strength of Nicole's reconstruction lies in the fact that it accounts for practically all of the statements of the ancient authorities. It explains how Aristophanes (Pax 605 ff .) connected the trial of Phidias and the Mega- rian decree. Even the elder Seneca's incredible statement that the Eleans secured the services of Phidias by agreeing to pay 100 talents if they did not return him to Athens appears to be wrong only in the amount. But we may well hesitate to believe that the Eleans were willing to forfeit the enormous sum of 40 talents even to secure and retain the services of so distinguished an artist as Phidias. Is it not possible that the reference is to the amount of gold on the Zeus statue ? The gold used for the Athena statue weighed 44 talents (Schol. Aristoph. Pax 605). Limitations of space and the laudable desire to publish the document as speedily as possible precluded a full treatment of the subject on the basis of the extensive modern literature. Until this is done Nicole's views will be accepted with more or less reservation. Robebt J. Bonner Roman Stoicism. By E. Vernon Arnold, Litt.D. Cambridge: University Press, 1911. Pp. ix+468. $3.50. This excellent book may be recommended to the English student as the best guide to the subject. It ioes not, of course, attempt to supersede Zeller, or to take the place of the abundant special French and German literature on Stoicism referred to in the appended bibliography. But it is a much more solid performance than Davidson's The Stoic Creed or Capes's little hand- book, and its 467 pages give opportunity for a more extended treatment of the theme than is possible in Hicks's Stoics and Epicureans. Writing avowedly for students of Latin literature, Professor Arnold has constructed the history of Stoicism as far as possible from the writings of Cicero and Seneca, copiously quoted in the footnotes. But with the aid of Von Arnim's fragments, Zeller, Stein, Pearson, and Schmekel, whom he sometimes follows quite closely, he has made the work a sufficient compendium of Stoic doctrine as a whole. The first three chapters, broadly introductory, are entitled "The World Religions," "Heraclitus and Socrates," "The Academy and the Porch." The fourth and fifth chapters, on the preaching of Stoicism, and the Stoic sect in Rome, complete the historic introduction. The doctrine follows in ten chapters, "Of Reason and Speech," "The Foundations of Physics," 492 Book Reviews "The Universe," "The Supreme Problems," "Religion," "The Kingdom of the Soul," "The Law for Humanity," "Daily Duties," "Sin and Weak- ness, " " Counsels of Perfection, " and the whole concludes with two admi- rable chapters on "Stoicism in Roman History and Literature," and "The Stoic Strain in Christianity. " The book, originally composed in the form of lectures, is pleasant read- ing, and if one admits the standpoint of perhaps excessive sympathy with Stoicism it is essentially sound in scholarship. "To understand Stoicism," says the author, "a man must himself become for the time being a Stoic .... whilst constantly referring to the original authorities, he will allow much to be forgotten and in other cases he will draw out more meaning than the writers themselves set in their words" (p. 28). This gives the reader fair warning. And if the reviewer were to apply these critical principles to Mr. Arnold's own book he would have nothing but praise for the way in which the author has accomplished the task which he set himself. But in a technical journal it may be permissible to indicate some reserves and to call attention to a few inadvertences or errors. 1. In the introductory chapters, and indeed, throughout the book, there is, I think, some exaggeration of the debt of Greek philosophy to oriental thought. The proemium of Diogenes Laertius is quoted with approval (p. 3) ; Xenophon, we are told, derived from Cyrus his belief in the immor- tality of the soul (p. 10); the doctrine of the Aoyos is traced to Persism (pp. 12, 19, etc.); we are told that the emissaries of Buddhism "must" often have appeared in the Hellenistic world (p. 15), and that the system of Zeno "deals with all the great themes touched upon by Chaldaism, Persism, and Buddhism" (p. 17). And lastly Lightfoot is quoted with approval to the effect that "Stoicism was the earliest offspring of the union between the religious consciousness of the East and the intellectual culture of the West" (p. 29). This is of course partly a matter of opinion. The Greek mind doubtless received impressions from the Orient, and it is impossible to deter- mine a priori the precise measure of its debt. But, as Zeller has shown, the evolution of Greek philosophy is quite intelligible and complete in it- self, and it seems unnecessary therefore to multiply hypotheses. More- over, the vague appeal to oriental influence sometimes leads to neglect or misinterpretation of the Greek sources. It may or may not be true that Persian monotheism influenced the Greek religious thought of the fifth cen- tury. But it is quite fanciful to say (p. 38) that "the same Aeschylus who (in his Persae) celebrates the defeat of the national enemy, a few years later (in Ms Agamemnon) questions whether the Supreme Ruler be really pleased with the Greek title of Zeus and the Greek method of worshiping him. " This is simply to mislead the student with regard to a commonplace of Greek idiom and Greek religious language. It is wholly fantastic to see a concession to the religion of Persia in the words of the chorus, Zeis oo-rts ttot' itrrlv ei toS' aujroi <£iA.ov Ke*A»7/teVa>, as it is to say (p. 46) that it might Book Reviews 493 be fairly argued that Socrates was introducing the most essential parts of the religion of the national enemy, Persia. 2. The overestimate of Stoicism leads to some neglect of the priority of Plato and Aristotle. Professor Arnold repudiates the view of Antiochus that Stoicism is merely a new terminology for ideas borrowed from the Academy and the Lyceum (p. 152). He argues that the entire spirit and tendency of the Stoic philosophy is opposed to Platonism and therefore original. That is a tenable thesis. But it does not justify the repeated introduction of specific ideas, clearly formulated by Plato, as if they were new and characteristic Stoic discoveries. For example, on p. 87, Professor Arnold speaks of a passage of Cleanthes in which we are "introduced to an ethical paradox of the highest importance to Stoicism: that good and evil are set in the will and the intention, and are not dependent upon the action. " This elementary moral principle may or may not be a paradox. But it is explicitly stated in Plato's Laws. Again, while there is a general acknowl- edgment that the later Stoics Platonized, nothing is said of the repeated quotations of Plato by Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius. There is only the barest allusion to the anticipation of the entire Stoic theodicy in Plato's Laws. And in the final chapter the beginning of the Fourth Gospel is referred to Stoicism, not Platonism. Again it is a complete misunderstand- ing of the work of Plato and Aristotle in science to write (on p. 74) that "they [the Stoics and Epicureans] agreed in removing the barrier which Socrates had set up against the pursuit of natural science" (cf. also p. 175). The tyro could only infer from this that the Stoics and Epicureans cultivated science more than the Platonists and Aristotelians did, than which nothing could be farther from the truth. 3. The weakest point in the exposition of Stoic doctrine is the account of the psychology, which Professor Arnold possibly despaired of making intelligible in a lecture. He perhaps reads too much modern meaning into his texts when he asks us to distinguish carefully between the simple sensa- tion, the mind picture, and the notion, or idea. For this is what the ancients rarely did. They usually distinguished two things only: sense, and infer- ence from sense, the action of mind, but rarely isolated the percept from the sensation on the one hand and the concept on the other. There is also, I think, some inadequacy in the treatment of do-w/uara. It is somewhat mis- leading to say (p. 146) "thought is immaterial." The Xcktov, which is imma- terial, is not the phrase, or word, nor yet the idea, but, if I understand it, the "meaning" of the word, or perhaps rather the meaning of the predica- tion or the sentence. For it is not quite clear that in the case of general nouns the Stoics always assumed an immaterial \zkt6v between the word and the idea, both of which were material. 4. Lastly, among minor inadvertences, I note the following: The word viro0«m is used as a synonym for the iSen. in Plato (p. 57). This is common doctrine in England, and its occurrence here is sufficiently explained by the 494 Book Reviews dedication of this volume to Professor Henry Jackson. It is nevertheless a demonstrable misinterpretation of a passage of the Phaedo, and will some time be recognized as such. On p. 142 obrcptWaoros does not quite mean "such as no reasoning process can shake." On p. 145 prj/xa and KaTrjyopripa are identified. Strictly, perhaps too strictly, speaking, I think prum is the infinitive. On p. 167 koivS>s iroiov and tSicos iroiov are not quite correctly exemplified by "heat in the universe and heat in particular objects." The l&Cats iroiov is more nearly the haecceitas of the schoolmen, the aOpoiayM. of Plato's Theaetetus, an individual thing regarded as a complex of qualities or predicates rather than as an Aristotelian first substance. On p. 193, the statement that in the conflagration the Deity "may at last claim for himself a period of rest during which he will contemplate with calmness the history of the universe that has passed away and plan for himself a better one to follow" is a rhetorical amplification of Senecan rhetoric hardly to be recon- ciled with the recognition on the same page of the doctrine that all things will recur in a cycle. On p. 391, we are told that " in a happy phrase Vergil sums up the whole ethics of Stoicism .... the Stoic sage can hesitate or be hasty, can love or weep, but the sovereignty of his mind is never upset. "Calm in his soul he abides, and the tears roll down but in vain." But surely in mens immota manet, lacrimae volvuntur inanes, it is not the tears of Aeneas but those of Dido that "rolled down in vain." Paul Shorey Eurythmia, vel compositio rythmica prosae antiquae. Exposuit Cabolus Zander. I, Eurythmia Demosthenis. Leipzig: Otto Harrassowitz, 1910. In the preface to The Crown of Wild Olive, Ruskin writes, "No proud one ! | no jewelled ] circlet flaming through heaven above the height | of the unmerited throne, | only some few | leaves of wild olive, | cool to the tired brow, | through a few years of peace. | It should have been of gold, they thought; but Jupiter was poor; | this was the best the god could give them. I Seeking a greater than this, | they had known it a mockery. | Not in war, j not in wealth, | not in tyranny, | was there any happiness | to be found for them | — only in kindly peace, | fruitful and free." These words easily fall into the following eurhythmic scheme : ■-II- - L- w_w_|_-~_ A