STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 220 Book Reviews to prove beyond cavil that the corruptions attributed to transcription are correctly explained. Meantime, the clearly and cautiously written mono- graph may be recommended to the careful study of beginners in our seminars. Charles Burton Gulick Harvard Univbrsitt M. Tulli Ciceronis ad M. Brutum et M. Bruti ad M. TulKum Ciceronem Epistularum Liber Nanus. Recensuit H. Sjogren. Gotoburgi : Eranos' Forlag (Lipsiae: Harrassowitz), 1910. By a regrettable delay in the editorial office, notice of this slender but important volume has been deferred until the present time, when a belated and apologetic welcome is more in order than a detailed examination. Not so very long ago a justly distinguished editor of Cicero's correspond- ence did not shrink from saying, "Baiter is a scholar of high eminence, and of his valuable contributions to the knowledge of the letters by far the most important undoubtedly is this — he has rendered superfluous any other col- lation of the mss which are the sources of our knowledge If every editor who does not reproduce the text of Baiter must have himself collated the mss, then the work of Baiter has been thrown away. Scientific facts once ascertained do not call for repeated verification at the hands of each successive inquirer: why should not a collation once satisfactorily exe- cuted be regarded as final for the purposes of future editors? I conceive that an editor of the letters should accept without question the record which Baiter has given of the readings of M and the other mss of the letters," etc. Unfortunately too many other students have been quite content also to spare themselves much operam et oleum by following in the path of the superb insouciance just quoted (there have been one or two praiseworthy exceptions). The result has been that up to the present time general uncertainty has pre- vailed about the testimony of the MSS on many critical points in the letters to Atticus, Quintus, and Brutus especially, though there has been plenty of brilliant conjectural coruscation. Fireworks are indeed more illuminating in darkness than in dayUght. Fortunately Mr. Sjogren has not disdained the long, strenuous, and often dull labor of making new collations of a considerable number of MSS, instead of relying upon the reports of earher days. How much we owe to Mr. Sjogren in comparison with Baiter in even the one matter of the colla- tion of M, an inspection of their reports of readings in almost any single letter will plainly indicate. An untimely fate swept away C. A. Lehmann, from whom much had been hoped, but Mr. Sjogren promises to be a vafiant and perhaps a better substitute for him. Since the appearance of his Commentationes Tullianae in 1910, in which he lucidly and convincingly demonstrated his general principles of criticism, and elucidated a consider- Book Reviews 221 able number of individual passages from the Letters, expectation of solid and trustworthy work from him has been fully justified. This first fascicle of his critical edition is without preface, for the preface is properly to be found in his Commentationes. As a critical supplement must also be considered his Tvlliana i et ii, which have appeared in Eranos X and XI (1910, 1911). He has been bolder than his predecessors in that he has placed the five letters we owe to Cratander ahead of the eighteen (or rather twenty-one) still extant in MSS, precisely as Cratander's testimony and the contents of the letters themselves dictate, and he has labelled the whole as Book IX, following the testimony of Nonius therein, which L. MiiUer doubted, but others have not hesitated to accept. For the first five letters Cratander is of course the only source. On the remaining number the editor has the Welcome note, "Codices MbdmsEGHNPV ipse contuli, tantum inspexi." Of the division of these into two classes he has treated in his Commentationes, which need not be discussed here. A useful addition to the critical apparatus is also a record of the readings of the Venice edition of 1470 and the second Ascerisius edition (1522), as well as that of Cratander (1528), whereby some judgment of the character of Cratander's work may be formed. Some readings of the Roman edition of 1470 are also included. In general the editorial work shows a thorough acquaintance with Cicero's writings and great sanity of judgment, tending toward what appears a per- fectly rational conservatism, which would uphold as Ciceronian many MS readings that have been censured by previous critics. The same excellent characteristics, it may here be briefly remarked, mark the edition of the letters ad Quintum Fratrem, which appeared a year later (1911). For the letters to Atticus we are yet waiting with eager and confident anticipation; and we may be permitted to hope that Mendelssohn's work will not be thought to render superfluous an edition of ad Familiares also by Mr. Sjogren. E. T. M. La phrase a verbe "Ure" en latin. Par J. Marouzeatj. Paris: Geuthner, 1910. Pp. viii+334. We have in this book an exhaustive study of the position of the forms of the verb esse in the comedians, especially in attributive phrases. M. Marou- zeau premises (but does not prove) that an adjective denoting quaUty pre- cedes its noun, and one denoting class follows its noun; then inversion in either case produces emphasis. — "With respect to the copula, the position of the subject is indifferent, that of the attribute is significant" (p. 35), e.g., Asin. 220-21. — Bonus est answers the question quid est? Est bonus answers honusne est f Marouzeau lays a good deal of stress (pp. 53 ff.) upon reprise, the harking back, in inverse order, to an idea that has already been expressed, e.g., Bacch. 385, 387 (C, D, meter, against the banal order of B). He justly