STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS English Literature and the Classics. Collected by G. S. Gordon. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1912. Pp. 252. 6s. These attractive lectures, though delivered at Oxford in the winter of 1911-12, are of the university extension or summer-school type and appeal to the educated public rather than to the philological specialist. Like most collections of this kind, the book does not quite redeem the promise of its ambitious title. Less than half of the contributors attempt any serious con- secutive study of the influence of their author on modern literature. One of the best of the essays in this regard, as well as the longest, is the editor's paper on " Theophrastus and His Imitators." Mr. Gordon, after a sufficient account of the Characters of Theophrastus, shows how a similar literary form was developed in England, first out of the mediaeval rhetorical exercise known as the descriptio, and later under the influence of the Latin version and commentary of Casaubon. He then traces the history of "characters" and comedy humors in English literature down to the time when the work of LaBruyere prepared the way for that of Addison, who, not always success- fully, fused the "character" and the essay. This plain substantial fare is spiced with some rather phantastical speculation on the dependence of this entire literary tradition on Aristotle's doctrine of the mean and the revolt of the renaissance and superman nature against this "burgess notion." The twentieth-century Englishman, inspired by Wilde and Shaw, is highly resolved that at any cost of rhetoric he will not be commonplace, rational, "burgess," or virtuous. "Pericles," says Mr. Gordon ironically, "had hit the perfect note, 'Beauty without expense,' and the moderate man cheered a compromise. But Beauty at any cost is the Renaissance ideal." Mr. Gordon thinks that "Alcibiades and his friends would have understood this." The superman not only scorns Mill and Jebb and Tennyson but must have his fling at Pericles, Sophocles, and Pindar. Professor Phillimore gives, largely after Rohde, a sketch of the origins and extant remains of the Greek romances, emphasizing, as was to be expected, the rdle of Philostratus. He refers in a postcript to Dr. Wolff's learned volume which "displays how much that thesis-writers will not will- ingly let die in English literature was derived from the Greek novelists." With all the superiorities which it derives from a more thorough secondary training and with all its brilliant virtuosity English scholarship would nevertheless be the better for a little more of this despised German-American thesis-writing. 202 Book Reviews 203 Mr. A. C. Clark's "Ciceronianism" is in the main a readable resume 1 of Zielinski's Cicero im Wandel der Jahrhunderte, twice reviewed in this Journal. Professor Stewart renovates the well-worn theme of Platonism in English poetry by practically ignoring Spenser, the "Intimations of Immortality," and "Epipsychidion," and taking Wordsworth's "Prelude" as the only true gospel. His eloquent study is based on his personal definition of "personal Platonism" and therefore owes no account of itself to a purely historical and matter-of-fact criticism. "The only Latin poet who can be supposed to have influenced the spirit of mediaeval literature is Ovid," wrote Lowell long ago. Mr. S. G. Owen, like Lowell whom he does not quote, celebrates the quality in Ovid which he calls imagination, and which Wordsworth and Coleridge would perhaps rather have designated as fancy. Mr. Owen is apparently not acquainted with Professor Rand's paper on Ovid in the Harvard volume, and Professor Schevill's recent study of Ovid and the Spanish Renaissance in the University of California Publications in Modern Philology came, of course, too late for his use. He gives us mainly a somewhat detailed account of the debt to Ovid of Chaucer, Gower, and (after Sidney Lee and Max Durnhofer) of Shakespeare. Mr. Garrod, conscious of his Matthew Arnold, writes beautifully about the wistful pathos with which the conflict of the Celt and the Roman in Virgil invests the self-contradictions of that glorious failure, the Aeneid. I do not know whether this is true. But the spell of Virgil is real, and Mr. Garrod helps us to feel it. Mr. R. J. E. Tiddy writes on "Satura and Satire" from the standpoint of the discriminating literary critic, not from that of the con- jectural philologist. He ignores altogether the recent American and Ger- man literature of the subject and takes for granted the distinction between the old per saturam medley of Ennius and Varro and the sharp denunciatory tongue-lashing manner which Lucilius took over from the old Greek comedy. He is mainly interested, however, in tracing through English literature the contrast between the two types of ethical and castigatory satire, and exhibit- ing the debt of both to the great Latin satirists, and the community of spirit between the older English ethical satire and the early literature of Rome. Mr. Godley's essay is mainly an excellent characterization of the rhetoric, epigram, stichomythia, point-making, and pedantic erudition of Senecan tragedy. In the two or three pages devoted to the history of its influence he does not mention the considerable modern literature of the subject. His concluding statement that the Senecan style influenced French tragedy more than English needs more qualification than he gives to it. "Rhetorical purple patches," he says, "and rhetorical rotundity of phrasing appeal to France as they never could to England." No educated Frenchman would concede this. French tragedy imitated the structure of Senecan tragedy and the rhetorical evolution of the long speeches. The English drama took the purple patches and sometimes transmuted them into brave translunary things. 204 Book Reviews The recent fashion of romantic and sentimental anthropology seems to have made a complete conquest of Professor Murray, and while the mood is on him he can see in Greek literature nothing but origins and survivals. In his epoptic moments he views the art of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides in an apocalyptic vision or prehistoric "Walpurgisnacht Traum" of "Dromena," "Vegetation-Heroes," "Sexual taboos," "Daimones of divers sorts," "thirsty tribesmen," and communal dancers with "rhythmical yearning of the whole body towards the emotion that we cannot define." Professor Murray, of course, can reverse the spell at pleasure and quote the vat Kal ix€/j.va.vtro. Goodwin renders, "he was growing above all their heads, i.e., so as to threaten them all." Humphreys (critical note) says: "All the interpretations ascribe to vero /caoWrd/vicvos, he was growing on to everything, i.e., he was getting his clutches into everything f" This is not convincing, and the London Athenaeum reviewer seems right in defending the ordinary interpretation. In § 24: tl yap /cat y8ovA.dyu.ei/ot p.eTen-ip.ireo-6' av, Goodwin simply trans- lates: "With what possible object [/cat] would you have been sending?" Humphreys' note is: "r( yap /cat ySouAd/uevoi, 'With what conceivable pur-