STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 124 Book Reviews I can see, after reading the passage over several times, have nothing to do with the Periochae at all, but with Livy only. For many of these problems definite solutions are not possible and are not expected; but this is all the more reason for a clear statement of the questions at issue and for some hint as to the author's attitude. F. W. Shipley Geburt, Hochzeit und Tod: Beitrdge zur vergleichenden Volkskxinde. Von Eenst Samtek. Leipzig und Berlin: Teubner, 1911. Pp. 222. Mit 7 Abbildungen im Text und auf 3 Tafeln. M. 6. This book represents the extension of Dr. Samter's earlier studies in ancient customs, such as his Familienfeste der Griechen und Romer (1901), Antiker und moderner Volksbrauch (1903), and Hochzeitsbrauche (1907). The dedication to Hermann Diels, under whose instruction in Greek religion the author sat twenty-five years ago, and the author's apology for employing the term Comparative Folklore indicate both the inspiration of the work and the newness of the science of which it treats. The title covers somewhat more than the book itself embraces. Not all the ancient rites practiced at birth, marriage, and death are discussed, but rather such rites as were common to two or three of these events, a more extended treatment of customs at death being reserved for later publication. Dr. Samter seems to have been successful in his endeavor to trace to their principal source many customs which, because of their antiquity and reinterpretation, have become enigmas to the folklorist. Such are the laying of persons upon the ground at birth and when dying; the precautions taken in behalf of as well as against the mother at childbirth; the use of weapons, torches, and candles at birth, marriage, and death; the rites of fire and water; the exchange of garments; the false bride; nakedness; the untying of knots, the rending of garments, and the unloosing of the hair; the prohibition of sleep to mother and child at the birth of the latter, to bride and bridegroom at marriage, and to the inmates of a house when death has occurred in their midst; the veiling of the mirror; the precautions against treading on the threshold; the prohibition against looking back; the use of salt; the interruption of the marriage procession; the use of blood and the color red in ceremonials; the offering of shoes at marriage and at death. These among others are the customs which Dr. Samter has singled out for extended discussion and whose origin he finds in the fear of spirits and the desire of man to placate or avert them. These spirits he believes to be in part the souls of the long-departed dead, and, in the case of funeral rites, the soul of the recently deceased also. The closing chapter of the book is devoted to evidences of ancestor worship at birth and at marriage. Dr. Samter employs the comparative method in his investigations. Book Reviews 125 The store of data upon which he builds his arguments is remarkably abundant and varied, thanks to the fund of folklore now available from the remote corners of peasant Europe and from Asia as well as from the lands of the Pacific. Aided by abundance of material, he has found it easy to eliminate the dissimilar and the complex until the essential feature of any particular set of customs has been determined. In his choice between the involved or abstract and the simple or natural explanation he has preferred the latter. In the words of Crawley, he has attempted to reconstruct primitive society not "with 'bricks of law,' but only with bricks of human nature mortared by religion." While this latest work of Dr. Samter is designed primarily to advance the science of comparative folklore, it will also hasten the settlement of some vexatious problems in ancient classical religion and customs, such as the origin of Anna Perenna, Charon's obol, the evil omen associated with stum- bling at the threshold, and the origin of the cult of the lares. Perhaps the author's most daring theory, which he owes in part to Dieterich (Mutter Erde), is that the laying of the newly born and the dying upon the ground is due to the belief that the spirit which animates the body dwells within the earth and that the soul can enter and leave the body most readily when the latter and the abode of the spirits are brought closely into contact. The belief in chthonic deities is a patent fact in Greek and Roman religion, while parthenogenesis was at least its remote associate. The doctrine of hostile souls, which forms one of the motives of the book, receives interesting confirmation in the terror-stricken flight of the Eskimo companions of Marvin after the recent drowning of the latter on Peary's journey to the Pole, and in their throwing all the effects of the deceased from the sledge that the spirit of the owner might not pursue them to claim its property. Herein is possibly found the underlying motive of the Roman Lemuria, evidently a far more primitive observance than the cult of the peaceable di manes. Dr. Samter's work would have been somewhat more complete had he added to the other critical periods of life that of puberty, when exposure to evil spirits seemed also to be specially imminent. A very few errors in spelling appear in terminations in English titles. The book as a whole is particularly attractive because of its rare illustrations. These represent the protection of the mother from evil spirits at childbirth, the throwing of the shoe at weddings, and the offering of shoes at death. The scenes portrayed are Greek. Although Dr. Samter owes much to numerous workers in his field, to whom he makes full acknowledgment, he deserves a leading place among them for pushing many a half-formed theory and some theories fully formed but not sufficiently authenticated to a reasonably complete conclusion. J. E. Chuech, Jb. University op Nevada