STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 94 Book Reviews ing. Summers is especially well qualified to discuss post-Augustan poetry. Sandys shows a real genius for conciseness and precision in his sketch of Roman prose from Cato to Cassiodorus. The article on Roman philosophy by Hicks is good, though it suffers from the same drawback as the chapter on art. Brief articles on natural history and science, and medicine by Pa3me close the chapter. Chap, ix (pp. 728-805), dealing with epigraphy, paleog- raphy, and textual criticism, is the work of Sandys, Thompson, and Post- gate. Sandys' article is good; a comparison of Thompson's article with his article on the same subject in the Encyclopaedia Britannica shows that he has a different class of readers in mind — the references here are fewer, the bib- liography is smaller, the illustrations are almost entirely drawn from classi- cal texts and the style is more "popular." Both, it is needless to say, are admirable. I allow myself here a single criticism in detail. The Harley MS of Cicero's De oratore belongs, as I shall show in a forthcoming paper, near the middle, not at the end of the ninth century (p. 784) ; the statement made in the footnote on p. 785 that there are only a few MSS in which the letter h is indicated by the corrector by the Greek rough breathing is surely incorrect; I should say this usage is rather common. The use of the smooth breathing, on the contrary, to delete an h is extremely rare. Postgate's excellent article on textual criticism may be supplemented by his discussion of the same subjects in the Encyclopaedia Britannica and his "Flaws in Classical Research" (Proceedings of the British Academy, 1908). The last chapter (pp. 806-69), dealing with language, meter, and history of scholarship, is written by Giles, Verrall, and Sandys, obviously appropriate selections. The last two articles may be supplemented by the two similar ones by the same authors in the Companion to Greek Studies. The history of scholarship is brought down to Traube and Boissier, the former of whom is named along with Lachmann as "among the glories of the German period of classical scholarship." The use of the book is facilitated by a table of contents (23 pages) and four indices: I, of persons, deities, and races (4 pages); II, of places, rivers, and mountains (3 pages); III, of scholars and modern writers (2 pages); IV, of Latin words and phrases (12 pages, containing more than 2,700 references). Charles H. Beeson The University op Chicago Libanii Opera. Recensuit Richardus Foeestek. Vol. VI. Dec- lamationes xiii-xxx. Leipzig: Teubner, 1911. Pp. 660. The sixth volume of Foerster's Lihanius is the most entertaining, so far, and there are pieces in it that should rank high among the curiosities of literature. The opening declamation, a great favorite, is an impassioned attack by the Corinthians on the Athenians who in the famous siege of Book Reviews 95 430 B.C. reduced the Potidaeans to the necessity of cannibalism. This outrage against Nature (17 $ixrts), whom Libanius, like any modem, calls the greatest of all deities, ought to be avenged by a general boycott of Athens. Libanius describes the siege as an Irishman might write of the siege of Limerick, though indignation is often forgotten in the pleasure of dwelling on horrible details. He plays with the idea of o-oi/m o^/tia with an ingenuity that is often comic, and like all his tribe falls into anticlimax, as when in the list of desecrated deities he includes Kaipos. Foerster prints here Gregory's Antilogia in defense of the conduct of Athens. Both speeches abound in echoes of Thucydides. Thirty-five years ago, Foerster defended the genuineness of xv and xvi against Cobet, but his faith has weakened, and he now hesitates in ascrib- ing to Libanius these declamations, always unpopular. Almost as little read were the seven "Philippics" which contain many imitations of Demos- thenes, especially of the De corona and the De falsa legatione. The second of this group (xviii) in which Hyperides advises Athens not to sell Demosthenes to Philip, Foerster will not give to Libanius. It is by some student of his works whose knowledge of history and of Greek was defective. Reiske rejected and Foerster suspects xix, in which Demosthenes asks for death to avoid being given up to Philip. The speech in which Demosthenes advises the Athenians to destroy the altar of Pity from which they had dragged him was the favorite in this group, whose plan is to place Demosthenes in a fictitious and pathetic situation and make him plead in Greek that is far from Demosthenic. The last of the historical declamations is an interest- ing experiment in Laconian brevity. Archidamus has broken the Spartan law that men under thirty should not make political speeches, and defends his action. Gasda ignoring this attempt at ^^os wished to cure the fre- quent asyndeton. Declamation xxv was very popular. A Corinthian rebukes his fellow- citizens for wishing to recall from exile Lais the younger, the Sicilian Phryne's rival, and gives a highly colored picture of the demoraUzation of Corinth by this one courtesan. Five " ethological " declamations follow. In four of these the speaker begs to be allowed to drink hemJock and gives his reasons. The ill-tempered man (5 8wkoA,os) himself a person of acutely sensitive hearing to whom the slightest noise is torture, has inadvertently married a talkative wife who drags the question of the origin of tragedy into a dis- cussion of the weather. Kock and Meineke thought that Libanius had in mind some comedy, perhaps Menander's AwtkoXos, but Foerster thinks the satire may have been drawn from a mime or from Greek comedy in general, or from some earlier xap««''W°'/*os- A letter wrongly attributed to Basil describes the success of Libanius in this em&iits, whose realism was much admired. In the sixteenth century, when a favorite subject of debate was "Should a man marry?" this declamation was translated into Latin and much quoted by sympathetic misogynists. Another characterization of a 96 Book Reviews SixTKoXos is that of a father asking for the hemlock because when he sUpped and fell in a badly paved street, his only son could not contain his glee. This is an amusing study of a speaker of the type of Timon the Misanthrope, who scorns his fellow-men, especially the jury of whom he is asking the favor of death, and hates even his own shadow. The next three declamations are by parasites; Foerster thinks, against Gasda's rejection, that their occasional illiteracy is due to ^06ov€p6i) begs for hemlock, is perhaps the frankest expression in Uterature of the acute chagrin that is caused by the sudden good fortune of a neighbor who has hitherto been as poor as oneself. Euthanasia is one's only resoiu-ce. Here then we have Libanius on his popular side, cynical, humorous, and a master of that ethological type which is frankly a caricature, written to amuse. There is a surprisingly long list of addenda et corrigenda. WiLMER Cave Wright Bbtn Mawb College October, 1911 Les 4pistrateges: contribution k I'^tude des institutions de I'Egypte gr^co-romaine. Par Victor Martin. Th^se. Geneve: Georg et Gie., 1911. Fr. 10. The epistrategos was an official set over Upper Egypt by the Ptolemies in the early part of the second century b.c. His immediate province was the Thebaid, but his authority reached farther up the Nile and over the routes leading eastward to the Red Sea. In fact at one time he safeguarded all Ptolemaic operations, iirl t^s 'IvSitaji koI 'Epv^pSs ^aX<£trcr>;s. Such an official was needed in. this region because of the tendency of Upper Egypt to fall away from the central government in Alexandria; and, since this separatist movement was due to the danger of attack from the south and to internal discontent, he had to be not only commander-in-chief of the army of defense but also head of the entire civil administration of the Thebaid. He was, accordingly, the intermediary between the nome officials and the great Alexandrian bureaus. His residence was not at Thebes, as one might expect, but at Ptolemais, the largest Greek city of the region. From there he made tours of inspection through his district. His rank was high in the Ptolemaic hierarchy. Under the Romans, changes were made. Two new epistrategoi were created, one for the Heptanomia and Arsinoites and the other for -^ KaTo) X