STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 522 Book Reviews surpasses Midler's because of the excellent arrangement by declensions, etc. Misprints have not been searched for by the reviewer, but incidentally the odd-looking Gwynu, for Gwynn, in the apparatus to ii. 22. 44, was noted. We are grateful to Hosius for the pains he has taken in the production of this conservative book. It marks an advance in that it offers a judicious presentation of current theory. There is no breaking away at any point, and therein lies his weakness as well as his strength. B. L. Ullman University of Pittsburgh Cacus der Rinderdieb. Von Friedrich MOnzer. Program zur Rektoratsfeier der Universitat Basel. Basel: Friedrich Rein- hardt, Universitatsbuchdruckerei, 1911. Pp. 136. The appearance of another dissertation upon the Hercules and Cacus myth within a year of the publication of Winter's The Myth of Hercules at Rome in the University of Michigan Studies, Humanistic Series, IV, 171-273 (reviewed in Classical Philology, VII, No. 1, 98-99, by Walter Miller) is evidence of the continued interest of students of religion in this vexed question. While the great value of Winter's thesis lies perhaps in his second chapter on the "Relationship and Sources of the Versions," the most inter- esting part of Mtinzer's study is his analysis of the myth in the Augustan poets and historians. The work is perhaps more significant as a study of the literary and mythological technique of the Augustan age than as a direct contribution to the analysis of the Cacus myth itself. A brief summary of the four chapters will show wherein Mtinzer's treatment of the material differs in emphasis and conclusions from Winter's. In his introduction (pp. 1-7) Munzer informs us that he will discuss Cacus rather than Hercules, assuming the Greek origin of the hero, that he will confine himself to the literary tradition of the Augustan age, and the researches of pre-Augustan and post-Augustan antiquarians and commen- tators. In chap, i, pp. 8-26, we have "Technik und Disposition der Erzah- lung bei Vergil, Properz, Ovid." Mtinzer's method is here one of great minuteness, not to say excessive diffuseness. The main result of the analysis is to show that Vergil gave himself free scope for poetic invention by deviating from the tradition and by romantically elaborating the figure of Cacus and the fight with Hercules, that Propertius iv. 9 eliminates Evander from the story, and that Ovid Fasti i. 543 ff., while closer to Vergil, has a more consistent regard for the unities of time and place. The results of the second chapter, "Analyse der Erzahlung bei Vergil, Properz, Ovid" (pp. 27-70) are more important, for here by a careful comparison of the three poets Munzer deduces the common "mythic formula." This formula should, however, have been definitely stated. Equally significant are the differences. In general Vergil's narrative Book Reviews 523 is one descriptively elaborated according to Greek epic traditions and romantically heightened in keeping with his own temperament. His Cacus is an epic monstrum, half animal, half god, the son of Vulcan, dwelling in a wild cave, horrid with the signs of slaughter. The pursuit of Hercules is almost the tracking of a wild beast. In the description of Cacus and his cave there are traces of the influence of Odyssey ix. 106 ff., Polyphemus and his cave; in the story of the theft of the oxen, of the Homeric hymn to Hermes (75-78, 211, 220, 344), and in the fight, of the conflict in the Iliad (xx. 50-75 and 161-75). Miinzer's strictures (p. 57) on Winter's use of the Typhoeus story from Hesiod's Theogony 1. 820 ff. are justified. In Proper- tius we have a three-headed monster from the Geryones cycle, apparently killed by the club of Hercules. Where Vergil heightened his background to make an appropriate epic setting for his conflict Ovid softens his to a silvan landscape; his Cacus is a gigantic herdsman. In chap, iii (pp. 71-91), "Livius und Dionysios," Livy's Cacus is a human herdsman dwelling among his fellows, killed by the club of Hercules. Miinzer argues that there is no euhemerization here, on the ground of the romantic individualism of Vergil's treatment illustrated in the preceding chapter: that therefore we infer the priority of the Livian over the Vergilian Cacus. Against this we might argue: (1) the strong euhemeristic tendency in Livy, Book i; (2) the probable existence of a divine pair Cacus and Caca. (3) For the priority of Vergilian conception of Cacus as a fire spirit, the strongest testimony is, to the mind of the reviewer, to be found in the asser- tion in Servius on Aeneid viii. 190 ff. that Caca, his feminine counterpart, was worshiped in her sanctuary by the Vestal Virgins with an ever-burning fire. Cacus and Caca must stand together as Wissowa has seen. In any case Miinzer is hardly justified, as on page 102, in view of the large part which euhemerism plays in the historical and antiquarian sources, in denying any relationship between the notice on the sacellum Cacae and Cacus himself. Still less, cf . p. 100, n. 102, in regarding her as a euhemerization of the bellow- ing cow parallel to the Iwpa in Livy's rationalistic variant for the Romulus and Remus story. In Dionysius i. 38. 4 we have two accounts. The first or fivOuios Adyos agrees essentially with Livy's sober account and lacks the romantic coloring of Vergil; the second or aXrflio-Ttpos Adyos is purely rationalistic and therefore of secondary interest. Chap, iv (pp. 92-117), "Die antike Forschung und ihr Material" is one of much interest, and on the whole is convincing. Miinzer discusses the treatment of the myth in (1) Servius on Aeneid viii. 203, partly dependent on Verrius Flaccus; (2) the Origo Gentis Romanae, partly dependent on Cassius Hemina and Veranius, (3) Solinus partly dependent on Cn. Gellius, and (4) Diodorus iv. 21, partly dependent on Timaeus. The ground covered corresponds in general to that in Winter's chap, iii, "The Original Form of the Myth." In contrast with the conservatism of Wissowa, Religion und Kidtus, p. 230, who holds that the main elements in the story are aetiological 524 Book Reviews and that we have no right to place their origin much anterior to Vergil him- self, Mtinzer endeavors to give the kernel of the legend a place in the earlier Roman annalists. It is not possible here to go into the details of the argument, but to the present reviewer it seems probable that the substance of the myth antedated Vergil by a considerable period (1) on the evidence of Winter's study of the sources; (2) because the euhemeristic element which bulks so large in the citations from Cassius Hemina, Cn. Gellius, and Timaeus, probably presupposes an earlier unrationalized version of the myth developed under Greek influence attached to the divine pair Cacus and Caca, and accounting aetiologically, as Wissowa has seen, for the proximity of the cults of Hercules Invictus at the Ara Maxima, the cult of Juppiter Inventor, and the scalae Cacae. Pp. 118-21 consider the representations of Cacus on coins. Pp. 121-31, by Paul Wolters, form an appendix on the representa- tions in other works of art. None of the latter can be referred to Cacus with certainty. Finally, Gruppe's review of Winter, Berliner philologische Wochenschrift, 1911, pp. 998-1004, should be cited here. The present reviewer lacks the assurance to describe as "a ring of proof" the cloudy mass of conjecture in which Gruppe envelops the notice of the origin of the aborigines in Festus ep. 266 a, 27 M, and then refers it to a legend of the Apollo temple at Cumae. Equally dubious seems to be the effort to trace the struggle of Hercules for his cattle to a legend of Croton transferred thence to Cumae by the founder of a sanitarium at the sulphur springs at Baiae and still later transported to Rome where Latinus replaced Lakinos and was later himself replaced by Cacus! Nor is the attempt to connect this ingeniously woven mythical complex with the notice of Cn. Gellius, who calls Cacus a Campanian king, any more convincing. At most we should be justified in using the evidence of this passage only as a possible indication for the Cumaean origin of the Hercules legend at Rome. Classical mythology must submit to the same sober laws of scientific procedure as the other branches of classical philology, ne dum vitat humum, nubes et inania captet Geobge Conveese Fiske University of Wisconsin