STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 519 ii. 34. 31; Santen proposed tu satins musam leviorem imitere Phiktae; Postgate reads t. s. musis I, i. Philetam. Dr. Enk misquotes both scholars. ii. 34. 61-82: Dr. Enk seems not to be aware that Marx had proposed this order. iii. 3. 33: Scaliger should be credited with the reading adopted. iii. 7. 22: Dr. Enk ascribes to Thompson quae notat Argynnus praeda moramtis aquae, whereas he really proposed qua natat. iii. 13. 6: Mueller and others are misquoted. They actually read et venite rubra. iii. 13. 24: the MSS have fida (not fide). iii. 15. 3: Guyet (not Hertzberg )should be credited with elatus. iii. 17. 27: Baehrens should be credited with the reading adopted. iii. 18. 1: Baehrens' tundit is ascribed to Hartman. iii. 19. 10: rabidae (not rabida) Itali. iii. 21. 25 (last line, p. 276) : the compend Miiller refers to was ux (not ut) . iii. 22. 25: soda is given by Hosius to Puccius (not Francius). iii. 24. 4: N (not Otto) is Phillimore's warrant for the question mark. iv. 1. 88: Hosius gives Schipper's pericla to the Italians. iv. 7. 4: for quo via we should perhaps have ad quam viam, or the like. iv. 7. 37: et belongs to Luetjohann (not Postgate). I am glad to find that Dr. Enk likes my interpretation of iii. 24. 9 ff . (A.J.P. XXX, 54 ff.). B. O. Foster Leland Stanford Junior University Latin and Greek in American Education vrith Symposia on the Value of Humanistic Studies. Francis W. Kelsey, Editor. New- York: Macmillan, 1911. Pp. x+396. $1.50. The biggish volume entitled Latin and Greek in American Education brings together a number of really significant papers, that are, or ought to be, already well known to teachers of the classics in this country. In their new form they constitute a valuable and accessible armory, from which even the most timid champion of the good cause may draw effective weapons either for attack or defense. The contributors represent the most diverse walks of life from don to diplomat, from business man to theologian; and they are all agreed that the classics offer a most valuable preliminary train- ing alike for practical affairs or a professional career. Indeed, the note of praise is so uniform that human perversity is likely to react; but even that danger is guarded against by the insertion of a number of anti-classical letters received by Mr. Harvey W. Wiley in reply to a questionnaire. There is practically nothing for a classically minded reviewer to say except by way of congratulating the editor both on his undertaking and its execution. The 520 Book Reviews book is welcome and important. It is safe to say that every individual with a living interest in our national education ought to read it with care; but it is equally certain that it will be least used where it is most needed. F. B. N. Hellems Sex. Propertii elegiarum libri IV, recensuit Caroltjs Hosius. Leipzig: Teubner, 1911. Pp. xiv+190. M. 2. This edition at once takes its place as the standard text edition of Proper- tius. In the Teubner series it is the successor of Muller's edition which antedates it by 41 years. The work is a conservative one, and no startling novelties are to be found therein. It is a careful digest of the work of scholars in the last generation. The preface opens with the statement that one who writes concerning the Propertian MSS these days must repeat much that is trite; that Baehrens in his edition of 1880 laid a firm foundation not yet overturned; that he clearly distinguished the classes, chose good representatives of each, and carefully collated the variant readings; but that he erred grievously in judg- ing his MSS and in restoring his text. These words show clearly the trend of Hosius' edition. The opinion expressed may be said to be the current one, though the reviewer, for one, does not agree with this high estimate of Baehrens' work. In the Corrigenda the editor states that he received the reviewer's article on the MSS of Propertius (Classical Philology VI [1911], 282) too late for use. It is possible that he would have modified his views concerning the MSS had he received it earlier. No new MSS are made use of and little is added to our knowledge of the familiar ones, only F having been re-examined by Hosius. As a result of this new study of F, Baehrens' miserable collation (for which he practically apologized) is corrected in a number of places, though by no means in all. Hosius, like Baehrens, fails to distinguish between the correcting hands — a matter of detail which is by no means unimportant (see Classical Philology, loc. cit.). A few gleanings from photographs of N of which Hosius availed himself are added. N is rightly rated highest, but the erroneous statement commonly made is repeated that it alone is free from the interpolations of the humanists. It is even suggested that A is a copy of Petrarch's MS (cf. Classical Philology loc. cit.). In 1891 Hosius suggested Neap. IV F 20 as an additional repre- sentative of the AF family where A fails us, but he temporarily abandons this as a result of Postgate's well-grounded objections and his own re-examination, until a careful study (apparently undertaken by a student of his) 1 will estab- lish the truth. The Holkham MS (Postgate's L) is adopted into the appa- ratus as a good representative of the AF class. Baehrens' DV are accepted 1 Since this review was written there has appeared (1912) a Greifswald dissertation by A. Hanel, a student of Hosius, entitled De Propertii Codice Neapolita.no 268 ( =IV F 20). Hanel maintains that this MS is of some value.