STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 504 Book Reviews Reitzenstein's essay consists of an academic discourse followed by notes elaborating important points in his address. The notes enlarge upon the relation of Apuleius to Sisenna, and of Sisenna to Aristides, reinterpret the difficult proemium of the Metamorphoses, incidentally attempt to clarify the meanings of fabula and historia, and offer a new interpretation of Posi- dippus' epigram (A.P. XII, 98). Throughout the discourse and the notes the discussion of the theories of Jahn and Friedlander, the treatment of myth and Marchen, lead to significant generalizations. Although in details the author's characteristic ingenuity is often apparent, the new application of the magical formula and the deductions seem valid. Henry W. Phescott The University op Chicago Homer in der Neuzeit von Dante bis Goethe. Italien, Frankreich, England, Deutschland. Von Georg Finsler. Pp. xiii+530. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1912. M. 12. Professor Finsler's book is an outgrowth of the Homer which he wrote for the series "Aus deutschen Lesebiichern" in 1908. It is a supplement to the final chapter of that work on Die Homerkritik. But the supplement has expanded into an independent contribution to the important branch of comparative literature represented by such books as Zielinski's Cicero, Reinhardstottner's Plautus, Siiss's Aristophanes und die Nachwelt, and Kerlin's Theocritus. These cross-section books, as they may be called, follow the history and influence of one of the great classic authors through the Middle Ages, the Renaissance, and the modern literature of France, England, Germany, and Italy. The multiplication of such monographs is a pre-condition of anything that deserves the name of comparative litera- ture and their production is facilitated with the appearance of each addi- tional work of the kind, as well as by the existence of such convenient compendiums as Sandys' History of Classical Scholarship and Saintsbury's History of Criticism. The book before us is an excellent specimen of its class. Professor Finsler, as readers of his Homer and his Platon und die aristotelische Poetik are aware, is measurably free from the faults which French and English tradition attributes to the typical German savant. He eschews Hegelian abstraction, mixed metaphor, and what DeQuincey styles the omnibus type of sentence. He tells a readable story in logically constructed paragraphs and clean-cut sentences of moderate length, and though he has, I regret to say, a theory of the composition of the Iliad, he does not obtrude it upon the reader, or seek to support it by perpetual point-making. He has worked at a distance from large libraries, and the self-imposed limitation, "from Dante to Goethe," excludes from his purview the most Book Reviews 505 interesting portion of modern English literature. But within these limits he has done his work carefully. He has read an enormous amount of Renaissance and sixteenth-, seventeenth-, and eighteenth-century criticism of Homer, and reports upon it faithfully and intelligently. In this the main value of the book consists. It not only expounds the Homeric literary criticism of Vida, Castelveltro, Tassoni, Gravina, Vico, Cesarotti, Du Bellay, Scaliger, Heinsius, Vossius, Boileau, Le Bossu, Rapin, d'Aubignac, Terrasson, Webbe, Puttenham, Rymer, Dennis, and the rest, but it analyzes the "Epics" of Trissino, Marino, Graziani, Ronsard, DuBartas, Chapelain, Scudery,, Desmarets, Voltaire, Chamberlayne, Cowley, Davenant, Blackmore, Glover, and Wilkie. Professor Finsler has read these immortal productions as Prantl studied the Byzantine logicians of the Middle Ages — that no man need ever peruse them again. The Italian and the German sections are, I think, the best, though the latter is somewhat overloaded with Opitz, Haller, Breitinger, Bodmer, Sulzer, Gesner, et tows ces gargons l&. They doubtless have their signifi- cance for the specialist in Germanic philology. But for the true cosmopoli- tan, modern German literature begins with Winckelmann, Lessing, Herder, and Goethe of whom Professor Finsler writes well and about whom we would gladly hear more. The central topic of the French section is the old story of the "querelle" of the ancients and moderns, which Professor Finsler has restudied in the original documents but which henceforth we hope will be taken for granted in works of this kind with references to Finsler, Rigault, Macaulay, Saints- bury, and Jebb's Bentley. The English section, though faithfully worked out, is, as was to be expected, the least satisfactory part of the book to an English reader. The "values" are not quite right. Chamberlayne, Black- well, and Wilkie are taken too seriously. Chapman fails to suggest Keats' sonnet, Cowper is overrated, and the pitfalls which idiom prepares for the comparative litterateur are amusingly exemplified by the observation (p. 299) that Dryden found the translation of the Iliad a fatiguing task "und er habe zwischen den hitzigen Geschichten, heats, mancher Erholungspause bedurft." Dryden's own words are: "And many pauses are required for refreshment betwixt the heats, the Iliad itself being a third part longer than all Virgil's works together." Paul Shorey Cicero im Wandel der Jahrhunderte. By Th. Zielinski. Leipzig: Teubner, 1912. Pp. viii+371. M. 6. The third edition of Zielinski's now classical book announces itself "als eine durchgesehene." Despite the altered format and pagination the changes are very slight. The table of contents differs only in the numera- tion of the sections, the index only by the omission of the false reference