STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 493 Menandrea ex papyris et membranis vetustissimis. Iterum edidit Alfredus Koekte. Lipsiae: Bibliotheca scriptorum Grae- corum et Romanorum Teubneriana, 1912. Editio minor, paper M. 1.80, board M. 2.20; editio maior, paper M. 3, board M. 3.40. After Kretschmar's dissertation, De Menandri reliquiis nuper repertis, Leipzig, 1906, had become practically inaccessible, and Lefebvre's expensive publication of the Aphroditopolis finds had proved inadequate, students of Menander began to feel keenly the need of a cheap, convenient, and trustworthy publication of all the "new" Menander — a need largely filled by Koerte's edition of 1910. Herein were included the newly discovered fragments of the following plays: the five Cairo plays, viz., Heros (f), Epitrepontes, Samia (?), Periceiromene (including the Leipzig and Oxy- rhynchus fragments), and an unknown play; the Geneva fragment of the Georgos; a Berlin comic fragment, doubtfully assigned to the Citharistes; the Oxyrhynchus fragments of the Colax and Perinthia; a fragment of the Coneiazomenae, preserved in the library at Dorpat, called to Koerte's attention by Gregory Zereteli, and here published for the first time; and the St. Petersburg fragments of the Phasma and of an unknown play which Koerte, with vigorous arguments against Capps and others, refuses to identify with the Epitrepontes. The present edition adds the Heidelberg fragment of the Periceiromene, the Oxyrhynchus fragment of the Misoumenos, and eleven badly mutilated fragments of the Cairo papyrus, one of which positively identifies the Heros, and others are of importance for the plot of the Epitrepontes. The recent finds now total about 2,200 complete or fragmentary verses from thirteen or fourteen plays. Koerte's new edition omits the transcript of the papyrus which faced the edited text in the first edition, but gives simply the running text with criti- cal apparatus. Thanks largely to Jensen and to Lefebvre's second edition, both of whom he seems to report accurately, Koerte has modified and, for the most part, improved his readings in some 200 passages. Now more con- servative, he rarely omits to note in his commentary the few restorations that do not conform to reported gaps or traces. Unfortunately, as a rule, he does not report the number of lost letters at the beginnings of lines, nor indicate the occurrence of the double point. Over a score of his reports of his own first edition are inaccurate. Apart from obvious misprints, e.g., Pk. 196, MAITNAC, and probable misprints in indicating uncertain and lost letters, several reports seem to show a certain lack of candor: E. 464, "potius K vel N agnovit K." for "vel K, vel l~, vel N, vel TT, vix T"; S. 292, "<1>YAAET"' for "YAAZEA"; J. II 15, "TITIC .... CTTOTG: Capps K 2 ., TITI (vel H) . . . . CTT0T6: K 1 ." for ''"'TITITH (vel I) .... CTTOTG:" (K 2 . seems to indicate approval of another editor's 494 Book Reviews report upon re-examination of the papyrus!); J. II 16, "OCC K.; XAIPC G vel 0, non UJ) K. Capps" for "initio OCC vel UJCE; in fine potius PE quam PUJ." In any event, how can Koerte adopt Wil.'s x a V> [<&A.a ™'s ? Koerte's list of other editors' supplements appears arbitrary; the selec- tion is neither happy nor satisfactory. The student, who would know the trend of scholarly opinion, must have constant recourse to the critical notes of other editions. Koerte often quotes a restoration for one line and omits the companion restoration for the- following line. He adopts or cites readings, since abandoned by their authors. However one may differ with Koerte's distribution of r61es or his conception of the plots, as advanced in the excellent preface of the editio maior, his views are almost always worthy of consideration, a courtesy which he does not always vouchsafe to the views of others. Typographical errors abound, especially in the Index Verborum, where no attempt seems to have been made to rectify the numerous inaccuracies and omissions of the first edition. A few selected notes: Pk. 208, Professor Capps has observed "that lieya ti povrut Sudh.; 514, iart toi Capps; 523, vovBerqvtK; 566, punctuation; 578, iy$(mi; 589, Sophrona cannot say $ ypavs, etc. S. 316, a-tunnj. Pk. 383-97, unpardonable omission of Capps' readings, K. not the skilled papyrologist to impugn the testimony of other men's eyes; 446, "docuit," nay, "assumpsit." J. II 39, Jernstedt, from fr. 581 K. New oaths, or clarified context of old ones: H. 79, 82, E. 431.41, 501.2, S. 68, Pk. 192, J. I 52, 54, 55, 62, fr. v 3. Note J. I 62, wpos tj?s 'Eo-rias, senex Laches, in perplexity concerning his domestic affairs; Pk. 221, vrj tov K 1 ., tjttov Sudh. K 2 . One leaves this edition of Menander disappointed. It is our best Menander, but neither in scholarly accuracy nor editorial judgment, worthy either of publisher or editor. F. Wahhen Weight Smith College