STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 466 Book Reviews had to murder them to avoid the ruinous expense. In short, this volume with few exceptions is a set of studies in the character of a group of Shylocks who justify their meanness with exhausting ingenuity. Foerster says that with the sixth volume only half his task was com- pleted, and there remain the Letters, the progymnasmata, the life of Demos- thenes with the hypotheses of his Orations, the "epistolary characters," and innumerable fragments. We may therefore suppose that the edition when complete will amount to at least twelve volumes. Wilmee Cave Wright Bbtn Mawr College The Divisions in the Plays of Plautus and Terence. By Frederick M. Foster. University of Michigan Studies in Language and Literature, Vol. 1, No. 3, 1914. "The plays of Plautus, as they appear in the manuscripts, are rigidly divided into five acts each"; in his first sentence Dr. Foster has fallen into an unfortunate error. The act-divisions in the plays of Plautus were, of course, first defined by Renaissance editors and are quite without respectable manuscript authority; Foster could well have spared his pains in justifying his rejection of such "traditional" division. Foster regards the vacant stage as an essential criterion of act-division, though granting, of course, that all vacant stages do not mark the ends of acts and real pauses in the action. For the selection of these real pauses he utilizes "criteria which seem to have escaped the notice of commentators," viz., "express statements by actors that they are about to leave the stage," and "no clue given as to the identity of the oncoming actor." Leo and Legrand (see Leo, Der Monolog im Drama [1908], 51; 54, n. 5; 57, n. 6; 61; etc.; Legrand, Daos [1910], 477; 483; etc.) seem to have taken sufficient account of these announcements of exit and entrance; Foster, strangely enough, does not mention Legrand's work. In determining the ends of acts by noting the absence of these announcements Foster attaches an added importance to them which is quite unsupported by evidence of critical value. In a number of instances ill-founded reasoning on the plot- development limits the use of these criteria (see p. 7, and on Asin. 544; 809; Bac. 384; 924; Capt. 497; 515; Epid. 665; etc.); in other cases their presence passes unnoticed, to all appearances, and does not involve the division of plays in his scheme (Aul. 397; 623; 627; Cos. 530; Cure. 532; Merc. 956; Stick. 648; Ad. 510). Not infrequently his choice of pauses in the action is quite unfortunate (Aid. 586; Cist. 652; Miles 1393, where he has, by implication, quite misinterpreted Prescott's argument, Han. Stud., XXI, 34 ff.; Pseud. 766; 1051, where he has misunderstood Leo's comment, Monolog, 60; Stick. 673). On p. 12 he is again the victim of unwise generalization; the rule there Book Reviews 467 laid down is frequently violated throughout the dissertation (e.g., Amph. 860; 1052; Aid. 586; Capt. 767; Cas. 758; Cure. 215; Men. 445; Miles 595). On p. 11, Bac. 180 f. is palpably misinterpreted; on p. 16, the division at Men. 965 disregards the fact that the stage is not then vacant; similarly, on p. 21, the entrance of the senex is announced (Haut. 1000) and forbids division at 1002. On p. 22, Foster is, I think, in error in considering the stage occupied at Eun. 390 and Phorm. 314; on the other hand, his sugges- tion (pp. 12 f .) that Nicobulus remains on the stage as a silent actor during Chrysalus' monody (Bac. 925 ff.) certainly deserves consideration. The typography is excellent throughout; I have noted only the following errors: on p. 13, 1. 19, for "520" read "530"; on p. 14, 1. 11, for "954" read "854." Clinton C. Conrad University op Chicago Scythians and Greeks. By Ellis H. Minns, M.A. Cambridge University Press, 1913. Pp. xl+720. This is an imposing summary of facts and opinions regarding the history and antiquities of the region north of the Black Sea. In this region dwelt or roamed the tribes known to the Greeks as Scythians, while on the coast several Greek colonies were planted, Olbia, Chersonese, Panticapaeum, and so on. Exploration in these lands has been fruitful, but reports have been difficult of access, especially since the Russian Archaeological Commission adopted the policy of publishing only in the Russian language. Mr. Minns appears to be proficient in that language, as well as otherwise equipped for his laborious task. His work represents years of research. It is far more extensive than the Antiquites de la Russie meridionals of Kondakov and Tolstoy, edited in French in 1891 by M. S. Reinach. The book is profusely illustrated, but, as the author says, he has deliber- ately sacrificed quality to quantity. To the writer of the present notice the most welcome illustrations are those on pp. 204 A, B, C, D. These give from photographs the most beautiful Greek drawings in existence, the tinted drawings on ivory found in a Scythic tomb near Panticapaeum. All pre- viously published illustrations of these drawings go back, not to photographs, but to one set of copies made by hand.