STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 464 Book Reviews Index Verborum Catullianus. By Monroe Nichols Wetmore. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1912. $2.00. If the exhortation to the preparation of special lexicons to classical authors be, on account of commercial considerations, a counsel of perfection, it still remains true that even word-indexes are of great and permanent value. Nor is their practical value at all impaired by the progress of the Thesaurus Linguae Latinae, despite the judgment of the editors of that slowly advan- cing work, which judgment is said to be in the contrary direction. Professor Wetmore's Index Verborum Vergilianus has already found a welcome, and the same greeting should be accorded to this volume, which shows similar painstaking care, and is compiled on the same system. The variant readings of seven editions of Catullus are recorded in it. To the choice of the pre- ferred seven no exception could well be taken, unless perhaps in one particu- lar. In the unprejudiced judgment of the present reviewer a school edition published in this country some twenty years ago seems unduly promoted to honor in being included in the circle of dignities. In the arrangement of the citations a saving of space might have been not infrequently effected without the slightest loss of practical clearness, or of anything else unless of precise consistency, which is not always a virtue of consequence. The lemma palimpsestus will serve as an example. The word occurs but once, and is cited in the form palimpseston, with reference to the variants of editions EMR immediately following in parentheses. It was surely needless to con- tinue this with cross-references to palimpseston from these same variants, which must of course have fallen already under the reader's eye. By omis- sion of the repetition of the variants, the lemma could have been reduced to about two-fifths of its present dimensions, and the presentation would actually have gained instead of lost in clearness. The sum of the many such possible economies of space would be considerable. As it is, the Index proper fills 115 large octavo pages, and the book costs two dollars, a pro- hibitive price to many students. The word-index in Schwabe's edition covers less than half as many pages (of smaller type, to be sure), and these pages are hardly more than half the size of those in Mr. Wetmore's book, while the cost of Schwabe's entire unbound volume — preface, text, apparatus criticus, indexes, and all — was only one and one-half marks. Only in a form that is not so expensive as is this volume from the Yale Press can we look for effective publication of word-indexes. This is doubtless a word of advice to publishers even more than to future editors. E. T. M. Libanii Opera. Recensuit Richardus Foerster. Vol. VII: Dedamationes XXXI-LI. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1913. With the seventh volume the Declamations are complete. Foerster here forsakes the order of Reiske; omits three declamations by Choricius, Book Reviews 465 of whose works he is preparing an edition; and includes the "antilogia" of Gregory to the probably spurious Declamation XXXIV. In his preface he defends himself at some length and with great indignation from the criti- cisms of his edition by Maas in the Deutsche Literaturzeitung, 1912. These are often unfair or trivial, but they would have been more appropri- ately refuted elsewhere than in a Teubner volume that runs to 739 pages. Maas regrets that no analyses of the speeches are given, as though this were usual in a Teubner critical edition. To gain space for these he would like to strike out "countless allusions to parallel passages." But students of the reminiscence Greek of the fourth Christian century will be thankful for Foerster's industry in tracing such echoes, or the parallels that show where the author is using a well-worn sophistic commonplace. Maas has evidently never had to spend time in hunting down these tags and fleeting allusions, the recognition of which is often necessary to the mere comprehension of innumerable passages in the Greek of this period. Even Foerster, in spite of heroic efforts, does not exhaust the field. For instance, in the "Monody of the Avaricious Man" (LI) he might have added to his long list of writers who have used the famous Pindaric locus about the shower of gold that descended on the Rhodians, Julian's echo of it in 290 B; and to the references for the expression "to split the cumin seed," in the same speech, might be added Julian Caesars 312 A. Maas reproached Foerster with not emending irapa tovto to 8ta tovto in Vol. IV, 115, 16. Apagel retorts Foerster, and cites six cases from Libanius of the causal irapd, calling it a singularis praepo- sitionis irapd usus Libanianus. The use was not confined to Libanius; cf. Julian 224 B and 360 D: trap' ipi to. tov Koo-pov irpdypara avaTerpairrai. The twenty declamations in the present volume are all exercises in XapaKTijpurpMi and are sometimes preceded by a irpodetopla in which the Sophist expounds briefly the characters and motives of the person involved, and in one case (XXXIV) before passing on to the peXerr] he addresses his audience as though he were speaking the prologue of a play ex ... . iravTa)(ov to rjOoi iv TiS t,-qTrjpaTi o-ecrtaKapev o-KOire.1v vperepov. In Several of the speeches the speaker demands from the Senate a permit to commit suicide and a draught of hemlock for the purpose. Lipsius declared (Meier-Schoemann, Att. Process, p. 381) that such a practice was a pure figment of Libanius; Foerster, however, cites Valerius Maximus ii. 6. 7, who says that in his time this custom was observed by the citizens of Mar- seilles and the islanders of Ceos, and, from having met with it in Ceos, Valerius concludes that it was borrowed from Greece. The first four declamations, with Gregory's "antilogia," display the ^°s of the avaricious man, and are followed by four that deal with disputes between rich and poor. The fortieth declamation is a speech in a murder case which reads like a sensa- tional paragraph from the daily press. The speaker defends himself for having murdered his daughter and her husband on the ground that the latter had so persecuted the daughter and so pitilessly blackmailed himself that he 466 Book Reviews had to murder them to avoid the ruinous expense. In short, this volume with few exceptions is a set of studies in the character of a group of Shylocks who justify their meanness with exhausting ingenuity. Foerster says that with the sixth volume only half his task was com- pleted, and there remain the Letters, the progymnasmata, the life of Demos- thenes with the hypotheses of his Orations, the "epistolary characters," and innumerable fragments. We may therefore suppose that the edition when complete will amount to at least twelve volumes. Wilmee Cave Wright Bbtn Mawr College The Divisions in the Plays of Plautus and Terence. By Frederick M. Foster. University of Michigan Studies in Language and Literature, Vol. 1, No. 3, 1914. "The plays of Plautus, as they appear in the manuscripts, are rigidly divided into five acts each"; in his first sentence Dr. Foster has fallen into an unfortunate error. The act-divisions in the plays of Plautus were, of course, first defined by Renaissance editors and are quite without respectable manuscript authority; Foster could well have spared his pains in justifying his rejection of such "traditional" division. Foster regards the vacant stage as an essential criterion of act-division, though granting, of course, that all vacant stages do not mark the ends of acts and real pauses in the action. For the selection of these real pauses he utilizes "criteria which seem to have escaped the notice of commentators," viz., "express statements by actors that they are about to leave the stage," and "no clue given as to the identity of the oncoming actor." Leo and Legrand (see Leo, Der Monolog im Drama [1908], 51; 54, n. 5; 57, n. 6; 61; etc.; Legrand, Daos [1910], 477; 483; etc.) seem to have taken sufficient account of these announcements of exit and entrance; Foster, strangely enough, does not mention Legrand's work. In determining the ends of acts by noting the absence of these announcements Foster attaches an added importance to them which is quite unsupported by evidence of critical value. In a number of instances ill-founded reasoning on the plot- development limits the use of these criteria (see p. 7, and on Asin. 544; 809; Bac. 384; 924; Capt. 497; 515; Epid. 665; etc.); in other cases their presence passes unnoticed, to all appearances, and does not involve the division of plays in his scheme (Aul. 397; 623; 627; Cos. 530; Cure. 532; Merc. 956; Stick. 648; Ad. 510). Not infrequently his choice of pauses in the action is quite unfortunate (Aid. 586; Cist. 652; Miles 1393, where he has, by implication, quite misinterpreted Prescott's argument, Han. Stud., XXI, 34 ff.; Pseud. 766; 1051, where he has misunderstood Leo's comment, Monolog, 60; Stick. 673). On p. 12 he is again the victim of unwise generalization; the rule there