STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 452 Book Reviews He may, for instance, wish to know why Professor Reid believes that twenty- six communities of Sicily belonged to the public domain (p. 327), that Athens and Rome signed afoedus aequum in the First Macedonian War (p. 423), and that Flamininus should be considered a great expansionist (p. 73). The book is not easy reading. The sentences are detached, and the style in general has surrendered much to space-saving bluntness. However, the classicist of the new world, who never escapes the precept that he must entertain his audience in order to save a supposedly dying cause, is inclined to envy the good fortunes of those who, like Professor Reid, still dare to preserve the gloria aritudinis. Tennby Frank Brtn Mawe Le futur grec. Par Victor Magnien. Paris: Champion, 1912. Two vols. Pp. xii+444; ix+337. Fr. 20. M. Magnien, a pupil of Meillet's, has collected a large part of the enor- mous mass of material presented by the Greek future, and has classified it from two points of view. The first or formal classification is based upon the following seven categories: (1) the "first" future — Avow, Xvo-oimu; (2) the "second" future — ipS>, 6avov/Mu; (3) such forms as ct/u, ?8o/uu; (4) the "third" future — 7r«ra txrofuu; (5) the " second " future passive — ypa^ijo-o/wu; (6) the "first" future passive— XvOrjvofmi; (7) the "Doric" future — Kivryrm, ia-a-tiTcu. The lists and the brief accompanying discussions occupy the whole of the larger first volume. This part of the work will prove most valuable; it is to be hoped that we may some day have similar tables of the various types of present, aorist, and perfect. The work seems to have been well and thoroughly done. The greater part of the second volume is devoted to a classification of the same material according to meaning and syntax. The last few pages of text are devoted to a discussion of the origin of the Greek future. The author evidently intended to study his material without prejudice and to base his theoretical contribution upon the foundation thus laid. As a matter of fact, however, he had his final conclusion in mind from the beginning, and it has colored his presentation of the evidence at countless points. As a result there are numerous statements, especially in the second volume, which seem hopelessly arbitrary unless the reader knows what is to come in the final section. One can save himself a great deal of bewilderment by starting at the end of the book! The conclusion is, in brief, that all Greek futures except those like ei/xt and ISoywai, and also the Italic s-futures, as well as the Sanskrit and Lith- uanian futures, come from Indo-European desiderative presents of the types represented by Latin viso, Sanskrit vivrtsati, Lithuanian kldusiu (from *kleuesi e / o) , and perhaps one or two others. It is a plausible theory — sug- gested apparently by Meillet — and it probably represents a part of the truth. Book Reviews 453 Magnien, however, does considerably less than justice to the rival theory that the Greek future is in the main an aorist subjunctive. Most of the objections which he raises may be easily met. The predominance of the middle inflection in the Greek future may stand in some relation to the fact that in Sanskrit the s-aorist has middle inflection more frequently than the other aorists have. The fact that many Greek verbs have an s-future but no s-aorist may simply mean that the s-future (originally aorist subjunctive) spread more rapidly than the corresponding s-aorist indicative because there was no rival future formation to be crowded off the field. The first aorist subjunctive was preferred to the second aorist subjunctive for the reason that the short thematic vowel of the former was more easily associated with the other indicative forms. Our author seems not to appreciate at all the positive evidence for the subjunctive origin of the s-future. He discusses the extensive confusion in Homer between future indicative and aorist subjunctive, but he does not realize that such a state of affairs in our earliest document indicates a close relationship between the two formations. He does not explain how Latin faxo, which he regards as a thematic indicative of a desiderative formation, can have a non-thematic optative like faxim. Whether the contribution of the Indo-European desideratives to the Greek future was small or large, Magnien is certainly wrong in trying to find a desiderative force in the future of historic times whenever the context will permit such an interpretation. He regards the future infinitive after verbs of hoping, promising, etc., as desiderative; Iliad ix. 371 (d nva wov Aava&v ?ti tX.irtrai ifairaTyvtiv) means "s'il a dans la pensee le d6sir de tromper encore quelqu'un des Grecs," and he gets the word desir from the tense of the infinitive rather than from IXwerat. Similarly Iliad i. 296 (ov yap kywy'' in