STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 453 satisfactory, is in a high degree suggestive and helpful. Even more stimulating is the chapter on " Italiot, Samnite, and Campanian Elements in the Earliest History of Rome," in which he sets forth the cultural relations of Rome with other peoples of Italy, and indicates various lines of research along which scholars will doubtless be able to make further contributions to the subject. In general the tendency of these studies is to free Rome from the isolation in which from Niebuhr to Mommsen her history has been studied, and to exhibit her as an Italian community living in close political, commercial, and general cultural relations with her neighbors both native and Greek. Notwithstanding some incon- sistencies and an occasional mistake, the work certainly adds new interest as well as fresh knowledge to early Italian and Sicilian history. The volume is made attractive in appearance by the excellent type and illustrations; but the translator in his effort to be faithful has often done violence to the English language. George Willis Botsfobd Columbia University Life in the Homeric Age. By Thomas Day Seymoue. New York: Macmillan. Pp. 704. $4.00 net. Amid the universal feeling of regret caused by the untimely death of Professor Seymour there is at least this element of consolation, that he was spared long enough to give to the world an enduring monument of his painstaking scholarship and life-long devotion to the study and interpretation of Homer. Life in the Homeric Age is a large volume of some seven hundred pages including a bibliography, a fairly complete index, maps, illustra- tions, and excellent views, handsomely bound and beautifully printed — a book to delight the eye and tempt the general reader. It is, however, too much in the form of a manual of Homeric antiquities to be readable as a whole, and will therefore be serviceable mainly for occasional study and reference. It covers, less exhaustively, the same general ground as the three elaborate volumes of Buchholz Die homerischen Realien, but is a work of independent research carried out with eyes open to the prog- ress in Homeric study, especially the vast amount of archaeological evidence which has been brought to bear on Homeric problems, since Buchholz wrote. However, the author treats archaeological questions only incidentally, indicating briefly here and there their significance in connection with the philological study of the poems. His point of view is philological, not archaeological. "From the poet's language he has attempted to discover what was before the poet's mind." Those who hope for definite pronouncements on disputed points of Homeric controversy will be somewhat disappointed. Such questions 454 Book Reviews are but lightly touched in a very readable introduction. The problem of the origin of the Homeric poems is raised only that the author may make a clear statement of his view, assumed throughout the book, that the Iliad and the Odyssey present in the main a consistent and trustworthy picture of the life of a single age. He believes in a modified form of the development theory but not in the original multiplicity of distinct lays. The poems were "in a manner 'sung to pieces' rather than composed separately and stitched together." Different strata, no doubt, exist in the epics. "Some parts of them may have been two or even three cen- turies older than others," but as yet attempts to determine the limits of the old and the new have not been successful, mainly because the archaeological and philological tests point to embarrassingly inharmo- nious conclusions. A large part of the introductory chapter is occupied with a lucid argument to prove that "Homer was not an archaeologist," which Homeric students will find more convincing than Andrew Lang's more diffuse treatment of the same question in his recent volume, Homer and His Age. The poet sings of a time somewhat remote, but reflects the customs, ideas, and life of his own day. He was entirely unembar- rassed by the purely modern insistence on accurate historical reconstruc- tion or " local color." The chapter on Homeric "Cosmography and Geography" is, naturally, more up to date than the corresponding account of Buchholz. Here, as elsewhere, the author shows his sane and conservative judgment. He prefers to wander vaguely with Homer in "No Man's Land," rather than accept the too definite guidance of the ingenious M. Berard or his under- study, M. Champault. He discusses at some length Dr. Dorpfeld's identification of Homeric Ithaca with modern Leucas and appears to accept his view, though with Homeric inconsistency he ignores it later (see p. 94). A chapter on the Troad, which would properly follow this, is one of the most useful in the book. Details are here collected from scattered and not easily accessible sources into a clear and interesting account of the topography of the Troad, the disputes regarding the site of Ancient Ilium, the history of the excavations conducted by Schliemann and DOrpfeld on Hissarlik and the discovery of the well-walled " sixth city " now generally held to be the ruins of Homeric Troy. Other divisions of the book take up various phases of Homeric life from "Animals, Fishes, Birds and Insects" to "Olympus and the Gods." In most cases the subjects are brought before the reader with great wealth of citations together with appropriate and sensible comments. The plan of making the poet speak for himself as much as possible, which is admirable in its way, produces occasionally a monot- onous catalogue effect which might have been avoided in some degree by the use of illuminating summary and generalization. The author's conservatism in the matter of generalizing and his caution in guarding Book Reviews 455 against overstatement result, now and then, in a negative impression which is somewhat misleading. One illustration of this is the comment he makes on the gloomy words of Achilles' wraith in the eleventh Odyssey : " If the proud Achilles would rather serve on earth than reign in Hades, doubtless the ordinary man expected to gain nothing by death." To most readers, Buchholz's statement that the Homeric picture of the phantom abode of men outworn is "duich und durch pessimistisch " seems mild enough. Nor is any account taken in the book of the shadow of melancholy cast by this dread prospect over the living. On the con- trary, " Homer is buoyantly optimistic." " The Homeric Greeks take a wholesome, cheerful view of life." The numerous pessimistic reflections in the poems are explained away on one ground or another, leaving no dark cloud to trouble the serene Homeric sky. "Lack of uniformity in the extension of the original plan" as the book grew in the hands of the author probably accounts for a manifest disproportion in the treatment of some subjects as compared with others. Recent interest in the discussion of Homeric "War and Arms" may justify a hundred and twenty-four pages devoted to them, but nine pages on "Ethics," loosely appended to the chapter on "Olympus and the Gods," and seven pages on " Psychology," relegated to the end of the chapter on " Hades and His Realm " are disappointingly inadequate. In the brief digest of Homeric ethics, little or no mention is made of such cardinal words as de/us, cuSuis, vfipis, vefucru, ai-jj. The author perhaps contented himself with a summary review of these subjects because they are so thoroughly handled in Buchholz's third volume, but his compara- tive neglect of them is to be regretted because in most working libraries Life in the Homeric Age will doubtless supersede former handbooks of Homeric antiquities. George Norlin The University of Colorado Inscriptiones Graecae ad res Romanas pertinentes, auctoritate et impensis Academiae Inscriptionum et Litterarum Humani- orum collectae et editae. Paris: Leroux. Each fasc. ca. Fr. 2. The first seven fasciculi of this important collection of late Greek inscriptions were reviewed in Vol. I, pp. 193 f ., of this Journal. In 1906 two further instalments appeared, viz., Tom. I, fasc. iv, containing the inscriptions of Samothrace; Sarmatia, Bosporus; Mauretania, Numidia, Africa; Creta et Cyrenaica (Nos. 843 to 1042); and Tom. Ill, fasc. v, containing addenda et corrigenda to the preceding four parts of this volume with two indices of the personal names and cognomina found in Vol. III. It is to be regretted that with the names in the former index