STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 355 which Peters' judgment may be amply confirmed. Since the text does not contain Her. 15, or 16.39-144 or 21.31-248, it obviously depends upon x 1 , as its corrupt readings also show. Herr Roese accepts Her. 2.18-19 as genuine — he wrongly prefers the textual variants given by the Gissensis — and naturally concludes that the verses were added in some ancestor of the Gissensis from another source. That is the very source that we were seek- ing, and have still to seek. As was apparent from the data given by Peters, the text of the Giessen manuscript is conflate and corrupt. A matter much needing investigation is the part played in transforming the text of Ovid's Carmina amatoria, by a set of scholia and glosses written, it would seem, in the ninth century. No manuscript gives such a com- mentary entire, but traces of it appear in the Oxoniensis of the Ars amatoria, the Sangallensis of the Amores and in various manuscripts of the Heroides. If the notes "quibus codex (Gissensis) large instructus est" belong to this early commentary and not to some late affair, they deserve more attention than is given them in this dissertation. We should have been more inter- ested in a selection of important specimens than in the author's comments on the nature of mediaeval glosses in general or in the information that he found it difficult to read the marginalia even with a glass and that he derived great help from Capelli's (otherwise not very satisfactory) lexicon of abbre- viations. On the whole, this is a slim performance. The writer expresses grief (valde doleo) that he could find out nothing about the bibliotheca Mentel- iana to which the Giessen book formerly belonged. Had he consulted Heinsius' Virgil and Tocker's Allg'emeines Gelehrtenlexikon, this grief might have been easily assuaged. Herr Roese's Latin though understandable is not elegant: it descends to a schoolboy's Formenlehre in: Attamen mihi contacturum esse, ut res obscuras explanem, sperare non desisto and becomes fairly desperate in: pro genuitate horum versuum pugnavit. Of the sixty- three pages of this work, five form the introduction, five discuss Her. 2 . 18-19, and the rest, except the brief summary at the end, are devoted to the descrip- tion of the codex and to the collation, which includes occasional remarks, of not much pith, on the proper readings. The whole makes a respectable Gymnasialprogram, but is hardly a dissertation. E. K. Rand Harvard University Das Motiv der Mantik im antiken Drama. By Rudolf Staehlin. Giessen: Topelmann, 1912. Pp.230. M. 7.20. This work is divided into six chapters corresponding to the seven Greek and Roman playwrights whose plays are extant, Plautus and Terence being considered together. The fragments of Menander happen to exhibit no instance of ixavriK-q (p. 187). The first chapter, dealing with Aeschylus, appeared in 1911 as a Heidelberg dissertation. Inasmuch as Emile Thomas 356 Book Reviews (De vaticinatione vaticinantibusque personis in Graecorum tragoedia, Paris, 1879) ignored Greek comedy and Roman drama and conceived his theme less broadly even in Greek tragedy, there was a real need of such an investigation. To classicists with anthropological leanings — and their tribe is rapidly increasing — such a collection of the data in classical drama should be ex- tremely helpful. Though Dr. Staehlin excludes such examples as involve Oeol wpoAoyi^ovTes (p. 83), he finds that nearly sixty plays exhibit at least one instance of /xavTiKrj and most of them employ several different kinds. He was wise enough to realize that the importance of his work would consist not merely in multiplicity of examples but also in determining the artistic or technical utility of the p.avn/07 in the dramatic economy of each piece. In every case he tries to do this. Some seventeen times it is employed as an exit or entrance motive (cf. pp. 12, 30, 33, 42, 45, 47, 48, 83, 89, 102, 104, 112, 120, 121, 147, 170, and 183), once to motivate the withdrawal of the chorus (p. 121), twice to detain characters either on or off the stage (pp. 21 and 101 f.), once to evade the unity of time (p. 9), and once as a substitute for an ayyeXos (p. 113). On p. 96 the author is bothered by the unwonted brevity of epxo/uw 8« ■a-pos Aios fiavTeia AioSwvata, Andromache 885 f . He supposes Euripides must be referring to some well-known journey or preferably that the use of oracles for an entrance motive had become stereotyped. I think the obvious interpretation is that Orestes is simply lying: he has come deliberately to see Hermione but pretends his call upon her is an accidental feature of a longer trip; he hurries through with his false excuse as quickly as possible. Aeschylus is fond of binding the parts of his trilogies together with prophecy (pp. 18, 29, 34, and 38). For example, in the Prometheus Bound we hear a prophecy of the Titan's release, which is afterward fulfilled in the Prometheus Unbound. It is a peculiarity of Sophocles to have the warnings of fjtuvTiKrj come too late to give any assistance (pp. 43 f. and 45). Aeschylus and Sophocles seem to differ in their views concerning imvriKiij. To the former it is a blessing to enable mankind to escape impending ills; to the latter it is a lightning flash which reveals the ineluctable precipice of their doom (p. 62). Staehlin claims that Sophocles borrowed from Euripides the motive of having both parties in a tragic conflict actuated by pxtvTi/o; (p. 78, note). Seneca stands alone in having vitals actually inspected on the stage and in using human victims for this purpose (p. 159). The pseudo-Senecan Octavia is singular in containing two dreams (p. 170). Oracles more usually occur in connection with men, and dreams in connection with women (p. 117, n. 3, and p. 215, note); but exceptions are found on pp. 138 and 196. The ghost of Darius in the Persians does not prophesy but merely recalls old prophecies, as Atossa or the chorus might have done. This proves that Aeschylus introduces the ghost for the sake of the spectacular effect (p. 8 and n. 3). Book Reviews 357 On p. 2 Dr. Staehlin expresses the fear that something germane may have escaped his notice in the voluminous literature dealing with the ancient drama, but, so far as I have noticed, this fear is unwarranted. He even cites one American writer (p. 95, n. 2). Naturally some things of value have appeared on this topic since his book was written. Thus, rpk in Septem 746 (p, 22, n. 3) has now received a new interpretation from Halliday (himself the author of a work on Greek Divination) in Class. Review, XXVII, 162 f ., and Corssen, Berl. phil. Woch., XXXIII, 92, has advanced a new explanation of the oracle in Medea 679 (p. 85, n. 1). There is reason, however, to com- plain of the author's use of "aaO" in citing authorities. A lengthy search is sometimes needed to identify the title. I have noted the following misprints : p. 101, n. 2, "Euripides " (genitive) ; p. 157, n. 2, "Marck" for "Marek"; and p. 183, dire /wi. Roy C. Flickingek Northwestern University Repertorium lateinischer Worterzeichnisse und Speziallexika. By Paul Rowald. Leipzig: Teubner, 1913. Many teachers must have wished at times for a convenient and readily accessible list of the lexicons and indices of the classical languages, either for their own use or for that of their students. This gap was filled for Greek by the Repertorium of H. Schone, Leipzig, 1907, and Rowald's contribution to the "Bibliotheca Teubneriana" furnishes the Latinist with a similar catalogue of the general and special lexicons, the works and periodicals of a lexical character, and the editions which are provided with indices. The etymological dictionaries and Onomastica are included, as well the lexicons of the Italic dialects, mediaeval Latin, and inscriptions. Those indices which offer only a selection from a writer's vocabulary are marked with an asterisk. John C. Rolfe University of Pennsylvania Apulei Platonici Madaurensis Metamorphoseon Libri XI iterctm edidit Rudolfus Helm. Lipsiae in aedibus B. G. Teubneri, 1913. In his second edition Helm has not only considered suggestions made since the first appearance of his book but has, quite independently, recon- sidered the crucial problems of the text, often revising his former opinion; though the changes are not considerable in amount, they are proof of a genuine revision. Thus a text which was admirable in its sane treatment of the Latinity of Apuleius has been improved by further sympathetic acquain- tance with the trickiness of Late Latin.