STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 352 Book Reviews stress, are shown to be of no value, because they were corrected and supple- mented in the Aldine and subsequent editions from inferior MSS of Hippoc- rates. So far, then, there is clear gain, though of a negative character. The lemmata as recovered from the authentic Galen tradition are found to be in general agreement with the text presented by the best Hippocrates tradition, notably with A. But the question now arises — and, so far as one can at present see, it is an open question — whether there is any great positive gain for the text of Hippocrates to be derived from Galen aside from the confirmation of the superior worth of the oldest extant MSS of Hippocrates. In other words, may it not be the true conclusion from this finding that the lemmata in the texts of Galen were supplied at an early date, to be sure, but subsequent to Galen, from current MSS of Hippocrates, just as the Aldine supplied deficiencies at a later date? In that case we should still have only the Hippocrates tradition, not the witness of Galen to the state of the Hippocratic text as it existed in the days of Galen, except, of course, where we have the certainly uncorrected text of Galen himself in the context of his commentaries. The several editors are apparently not quite in agreement on this head, and the writer is somewhat skeptical of the final gain. But Professor Mewaldt promises a full discussion of the subject, and we shall do well to await it before deciding the question. Meanwhile much has been accomplished for Galen and it behooves us to be thankful. W. A. Heidel Wesleyan University Die Mppokratische Schrift von der Siebenzahl in ihrer vierfachen Uberlieferung zum erstenmal herausgegeben und erldutert. By W. F. RoscHEB. Paderborn: Ferdinand Schoningh, 1913. Pp. xii-fl75. Scholars will without doubt cordially welcome this work of the veteran scholar and editor, which appears as VI. Band. 3/4 Heft of the well-known Studien zur GeschicMe und Kultur des AUertums, edited by Professor Drerup, of Wiirzburg. Dr. Roscher's contention that the earlier chapters of Hippoc- rates IIcpi lySSo/xaSw are the oldest extant document of Greek Uterary prose, perhaps antedating even the treatise of Anaximander, has done much to focus the attention of scholars on it, and many have no doubt been repelled by the sad condition of the text. The condition of the text is due to the mischances of the tradition. The original Greek is represented by a page of MS long ago found by Daremberg and published by Littr6 and by Roscher (t)ber Alter, Ur sprung und Bedeutung der hippokratischen Schrift von der Siebenzahl, Leipzig, 1911), and by certain fragments of later parts of the treatise discovered and pubhshed by Helmreich in Hermes, XLI (1911), 437-43. There is also an Arabic version, apparently a rendering of an earlier Syriac version, of which Harder published a German translation, Book Reviews 353 and there exist likewise two unintelligent Latin versions which were prob- ably made from the Arabic. Of the Arabic version and of the Arabic ver- sion of a pseudo-Galenian commentary on it, of which Harder had given extracts, an edition and complete German translation are announced for early pubhcation by Dr. G. Bergstrasser. Dr. Roscher has seen and utilized a typewritten copy of the latter, from which he pubUshes extracts in addi- tion to the other lines of tradition above mentioned. Dr. Roscher Ukewise offers in the volume here noticed a sketch of the history of the treatise Ilept €J38ofmSuiv, a number of more or less parallel texts relating to the num- ber seven drawn from other ancient sources, and several appendices in which he deals with the review of his views by Dr. Lortzing and with the points raised by Professor F. Boll, Die Lebensalter, Leipzig, 1913. An analytical table of contents and full indexes complete the volume. No one will question the value of Dr. Roscher's work, though it cannot be said that he has made good his main point. It is altogether likely that the treatise is pre-Hippocratic, dating from the middle or second quarter of the fifth century B.C., at least in its earlier chapters; but it is unlikely that it dates from the sixth century. The striking similarity to certain parts of Ilept SiatTjjs is a factor of considerable importance of which Dr. Roscher has taken no account. The subject is, however, too large to be discussed here. A great deal still remains to be done before the text of the first Greek fragment can be read and understood. Perhaps it is best to await the appearance of Dr. Bergstrasser's work before attempting further emenda- tion. Professor Boll anticipated some corrections in chaps, i and ii which I had noted; in c. 3 a/j/i irvcovtriv, aTrvtv/uiTi, and dva Trviv/jacnv are clearly corrupt, and the versions suggest dvdirvfvcn, d/jtirvcujuaTi, and dvawveucriv. W. A. Heidel Wesletan University De Ovidii Heroidum Codice Gissensi. Dissertatio .... quam .... scripsit Henricus Roese. Gissae, 1913. In Ovid's second Heroid, Phyllis addressing the faithless Demophoon says (vss. 17-20) : Saepe decs supplex ut tu scelerate valeres Sum prece turicremis devenerata focis. Saepe videns ventos caelo pelagoque faventes Ipsa mihi dixi, "si valet, ille venit." So the Vulgate text reads, with approval from various recent scholars — Sedhnayer, Peters, Housman, Purser — despite the fact that vss. 18 and 19 are found in only a few of the manuscripts mentioned in early editions and in only one of the manuscripts known today, a Giessen codex {Bihl. Acad., LXVI) of the fourteenth century. The lines are necessary for the