STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 339 Homer, Dichtung und Sage. Erster Band : Bias. Von Erich Bethe. Teubner, 1914. Pp. x+374. M. 8. In this large volume, which is the first of a series, Professor Bethe offers a new and final solution of the problem of the composition of the Iliad. No one was ever more certain of presenting the absolute truth than the author of this book. His theory is briefly this: The Iliad is an intentional unity, every part of which owes its place to a great and comprehensive design. The Iliad was composed in the sixth century and has remained unchanged, so that it is identical with the poem known to Aeschylus and Plato. There are difficulties of many sorts, such as contradictions and lack of harmony, but these difficulties were faced by the poet himself and are due to the material in which he worked; hence they are older than the Iliad and are not the interpolations of later hands. No verse has been added since Homer. Homer took a mass of existing poems and combined them into an epic on a grand scale, but he was a great poet as well as a great compiler and wrote a large part of the Iliad to fill up the gaps and to unite the whole. Not only did he compose entire scenes but he changed the old songs and added verses in order to bring them into harmony with his plan, and also to let the hearer anticipate what is to come, or to remind him of what has gone before, and so accordingly in the very oldest songs may be found verses belonging to the latest stratum. These different songs betray their independent origin by those minute contradictions and discrepancies which the poet could not fully conceal. Like a builder who reshapes an old house into a new, the poet could not entirely ignore the existing structure. Bethe slowly and surely removes the parts due to Homer and finds that there still remains a group of songs of different origin and different merit: such songs are the Patrocleia, the Diomedeia, the Doloneia, the Menis, and perhaps a dozen others. The Menis, which is the very structure of the Iliad, is the framework into which the other poems were set and for which other verses were written. In order to make this into an epic poem on a grand scale other songs were reshaped and several thousand verses were composed by Homer himself. This Menis was spread out fairly thin over a large area, but it is prac- tically all preserved and the various verses are to be easily detected because of their coherency and superlative excellency. This poem consists of about 1,300 verses distributed as follows : 330 in A, 100 in A, 200 in n, about 50 in P and 2, about 300 in T and $, and finally a few over 300 in X. These verses when united into a harmonious whole form the illustrious poem whose might, and whose glory absorbed great masses of songs and the genius of Homer. A study will reveal the superb merit of this assumed Menis. The occasion for the Wrath and its setting take up about one-fourth of the poem, 340 Book Reviews and are as fully narrated as in the Iliad. Achilles vows that the Greeks will rue this day and withdraws with bitter anger from the struggle, the Greeks meet with slight reverses, Achilles sends Patroclus to their help, Patroclus is slain, Achilles rushes into the combat, rescues the body of his companion, joins in the fight, soon engages and slays Hector, and the poem closes with the lamentations of Hecuba. In this Menis so much emphasis is given to the anger of Achilles and the insults given him that we are certain that nothing but the direst straits and the mightiest efforts can induce him to join in the fight; yet without one word of entreaty and no suggestion from the Greeks that he is even desired, he sends Patroclus into the combat. There is no reconciliation and the Wrath is ignored. A poet who gave 330 verses to the origin of the Wrath should say something about the outcome. Then, too, Hector is left dead on the field. Is he to be thrown to the dogs, or is he to have decent funeral rites ? The Greeks gave too much care to the treatment of the dead to ignore the fate of Hector's body. The assumed Menis has a beginning, a beginning on a gigantic scale, yet it has no middle and no end. It is like attaching the head of an elephant to the body of a mouse. Because of evident contradictions or lack of harmony in the present Iliad, Bethe can detect the various joints, parts, and sutures. He starts with the supposition that the attitude of Achilles in the Patro- cleia proves that the author of that poem knew nothing of the proffered gifts in the Presbeia. These gifts appear in the reconciliation; hence the reconciliation is later than the Patrocleia and in harmony with the Presbeia- In order to prepare for the phase of the proffered gifts, the poet made an opening in A and inserted the Athena episode, in which the goddess tells Achilles that one day he shall have threefold greater gifts because of this insult. The Athena scene shows it is in strange surroundings by the fact that it would be a tame climax for Achilles to throw his scepter to the ground after he had already flashed his sword in the face of the Achaeans. So much depends on this passage and it is so large a part of Bethe's argument that I will quote his own words: p. 188, "He threw the scepter at the feet of the Achaeans, but this speech and this gesture would not have the desired effect if Achilles had already drawn his sword" ("wenn unmittelbar vorher Achill schon das Schwert gezogen hatte"); p. 190, "Auch das Hinwerfen des Scep- ters, das leer und gering erscheint, wenn das Schwert schon aus der Scheide geflogen war." Page after page is devoted to this theory and the book would hardly have been written without it. The Homeric phrase on which he bases this argument is found in A 194: eXKero 8' ck koXcoio //.eya |i<£os, not an aorist but an imperfect. Just at that moment Athena came to him and her command is not, "Put up thy sword," but instead she says, "Draw not thy sword" (/x^Se £ios lAjceo). The words of Athena and the imperfect tense make it most unlikely that Achilles flashed his sword in the face of the Achaeans, and so accordingly Book Reviews 341 there is no contradiction or anti-climax in the fact that he later threw down his scepter. P. 168, Professor Bethe argues that in the older account of the wounding of Diomede that hero could have had no chariot, because in the old stratum neither Ajax nor Odysseus had a chariot, ("weil in dem alten Gedicht weder Aias noch Odysseus einen Wagen haben"). This is only half a truth, since in no part of the Iliad or Odyssey does either of these heroes have a chariot. It is a fine proof of the unity of Homeric descriptions that these two warriors from small islands should in all parts of the Iliad be without horses or chariots. It is impossible to discuss in more detail this learned and suggestive book, but it seems to me that the author has found contradictions where none exist and that he has rather forced the Iliad to suit his theory than his theory to suit the Iliad. John A. Scott Northwestern University Invperium Romanum: Studien zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des romischen Reichs, I: Die Staatsvertrdge und Vertragsverhaltnisse. By Etjgen Taubleb. Leipzig and Berlin: Teubner, 1913. Pp. ix+458. This volume is a study of the form and content of treaties contracted by Rome during the period of the Republic. The first chapter deals with their classification. The chief principle of grouping is involved in the question whether or not one of the contracting states loses its independence through the agreement. On this basis the treaty of surrender — Deditionsvertrag — stands out distinctly from every other as the form through which the sur- rendering state destroys its own legal existence (for the formula, see Livy i. 38). It includes two reciprocal acts, dare in dieionem and accipere. From the very nature of the case the surrender is unconditional; legally the deditus is the same as the captivus. In early times, however, there developed a formula, dedere in fidem, in which the surrendering party appealed to the mercy of the conqueror, and a condition of fidelity took the place of the unmitigated right of the master. The usual effect was to bring the sur- rendered into the circle of citizenship — exceptionally the full citizenship or patriciate, generally the limited citizenship or plebitate. Here the reader discovers that, however thoroughly the author may have mastered his peculiar field, he clings with unruffled trust to Mommsen's obsolete con- ception of the early Roman state and society. Although not the slightest evidence has ever been found to invalidate the judgment of ancient writers on early Roman history that the patricians and plebeians were merely the nobles and commons, and although historians are now generally recognizing this fact, there will doubtless be some who will continue till Doomsday to repeat parrot-like the definition proposed by Mommsen. The reviewer