STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 126 Book Reviews Professor Burnam has in his text made certain duly indicated correc- tions of the MS. These in general seem justified, but it may be ques- tioned whether two glosses dealing with the much-disputed title Dittocheum have received consistent treatment. The first of these, pre- fixed to the commentary on the poems, is a gloss upon Gennadius' life of Prudentius (Gennad., De Viris Illust. xiii), and reads (p. 11): " Dieoched dicitur duplex ref ectio et ideo sic praetitulatur quia de veteri et novo testamento compositus habetur." Dirocheu has here been emended by Burnam to Dittocheum, but in view of the fact that in the second passage (p. 185) he himself retains in the glosses the form Dirocheum and of the additional fact that in the passage of Gennadius which is here glossed the form Dittocheum rests upon conjecture (cf. Richardson's edition of Gennadius, app. crit.), and that the title is by some scholars regarded as corrupt (Schanz, Gesch. d. rdm. Lift., iv, 1, 229), the change from the consistent even though hardly intelligible form Dirocheu(m) seems unwise. Several misprints have been noted, of which but two need mention. On p. 130, 1. 347, the ori of the MS should be transliterated as 6pij, not opoi. On p. 281 the spelling idoliothitum is inconsistent with idoliotitum on p. 43 and idolotitum on p. 139. Which one or which two of these spell- ings should be cited ought to be stated, if the word is to be placed, as Professor Burnam has done, in a list of Addenda Lexicis Latinis at the end of his volume. The book closes with a list of rare words, one of Greek words, and a general index. Arthur Stanley Pease Thh University op Illinois Galeni de Usu Partium Libri XVII. Ad codicum fidem recen- suit. Geokgius Helmbeioh. Leipzig: Teubner, 1907. Vol. I, pp. xiv + 496 ; Vol. II, pp. v + 484. M. 16. In a brief preface the editor gives account of the relation of his edi- tion to manuscripts and previous editions. Since the few who deign to read Galen resort to the edition of Kuhn, it is well to know that it has no critical value. Our present editor, who has previously given evidence of sound method and critical insight, makes it possible to dis- pense with Kuhn in another work and thereby adds to our obligations; but while it may be said, as Helmreich says of himself (I. xii), that even he has not considered the claims of all known manuscripts, we cannot assume to have even approximately a definitive text. This particular work of Galen possesses considerable interest for the historian of Greek thought. Its aim is to apply thoroughly and consist- ently the teleological principle in explanation of the structure and func- tions of the human body, since, as Galen complains, Hippocrates, Plato, Book Reviews 127 and even Aristotle have failed to do so. Throughout the work there is a constant contrast drawn between those who explain structure and func- tion as due to natural law (dvay/07) and those who find in them an expres- sion of an ideal or a beneficent end. Galen says (I. 8) that earlier thinkers were untrained in the teleological method (dyu/wao-rovs 8' iv rrj fu068u> Trjs tSv xpauiv evpco-tw yevo/«Vot>s), and even Hippocrates was un- satisfactory (aXX' ovSk ra 'IiT7roKpaTovs rpr iKava, to. fthi a<7a<£rjs c. 23 (I. 8, p. 12, 23 ff. Helmreich) and to the distributive justice of tpvo-is (II. 16, p. 116, 9 ff. Helmreich et passim). It is evident that Galen, who knew his Hippocrates by heart, was hard put to it to prove that his hero was a teleologist. This is just what the critical student of Greek thought would have expected, since teleology as a method is the result and fruit of the Socratic movement. Yet eminent writers on Greek philosophy are constantly assuming that the teleological point of view was a thing to be reckoned with in pre-Socratic times. Thus Bernays said that Heraclitus employed the metaphor of the dice- playing boy (fr. 52 Diels) to forestall a teleological interpretation of nature, while Otto Gilbert boldly claims ("Heraklits Schrift Ilepl #vo-e(os," Neue Jahrbucher fur hi. Altertum, etc. [1909], 168 ff.) that the Koo-fws in the system of Heraclitus is the product of the divine reason operating to beneficent ends. Both are equally in error. Here, as elsewhere, the historian of Greek thought will do well to check his conclusions by reference to the priceless body of medical literature, which has been so much neglected but nevertheless constitutes perhaps the best means of tracing the growth of ideas. W. A. Heidel Wesleyan University %e 'Aflijww, 1909. Pp. 464. In the course of the years 1907-8 Dr. Arvanitopoullos discovered on the site of ancient Pagasae in Thessaly a large number of grave-stelae, dating from the third century B.C. and later, and bearing painted designs more or less well preserved. These are now in the newly built Museum of Volo. The present volume contains, besides some prefatory matter, a detailed catalogue of these stelae. In view of the scantiness of the remains of Greek painting, much interest has been aroused by the announcement of this accession to our