STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 109 Ethos. Studien zur alteren griechischen Rhetorik. Von Dr. Wil- helm SOss. Leipzig und Berlin: B. G. Teubner, 1910. Pp. v+273. M. 8. In the broader sense of the word, Dr. Suss identifies the doctrine of ethos with the psychological theory of rhetoric in general. The old Sicilian rhetoric of Corax, Tisias, Antiphon, and Lysias dealt, he tells us, objectively with the facts by arguments based on abstract probability, to. dKora. Its method of teaching was the memorizing of tottoi. The rhetoric of Gorgias, fol- lowed, he thinks, by Plato, Isocrates, and Alcidamas, applied psycho- logical insight to the influencing of the subjectivity of the hearer or judge. It thus came to attribute more importance to ornamental diction, order, and disposition, as also to the xcupos, or fit occasion, and to the faculty of extempore speech which enables a speaker to adjust himself to Kcupos. In the working out of these ideas, Dr. Suss rehandles the old prob- lem of the historical relation of Plato, Isocrates, and Alcidamas, and con- cludes that we must attribute to Gorgias not only nearly everything which these writerB have in common but everything in the context of his parallel passages for which he can find any conceivable association with real or conjectured words and ideas of the Leontine rhetor. The remainder of the book follows the doctrine of ethos in the more specific sense through the Rhetoric to Alexander, and Aristotle, and analyzes the later authorities in the course of an investigation of the sources of Aris- totle's third book. This study of the theory is followed by a chapter on the practice, supplemented by a Topik of Bescheltung, or billingsgate, extending from Eupolis to Claudian. No student of Greek rhetoric can fail to derive much stimulus and instruction from this work. If I proceed to indicate some reserves, they are only such as cautious minds must feel with regard to a large part of present-day philological inquiry. The desire to get new results, to make a point, to establish a system, the endeavor to extract more from defective evidence than it contains, constantly confuses both the logic and the critical judgment of excellent scholars. Dr. Siiss's previous book, Be personarum antiquae comoediae Atticae usu atque origine, showed that he had not escaped this tendency, of which Dummler was the most conspicuous representative. He there (p. 38) actually cites Lucian Nigrinus 2 to illus- trate the combination of oculist and Platonic philosopher in the same person! As regards the present work, it is entirely conceivable that Plato and Isoc- rates owed more to Gorgias than we can now perceive, and it is certain that there must have been some personal and historical connection between Plato's Phaedrus, Isocrates' tract against the Sophists, and Alcidamas' polemic against written speeches. But on neither of these points is the certainty which Dr. Suss aims at to be attained by the method of reasoning which he 110 Book Reviews employs. I must limit myself to a few illustrations. On p. 81, he says "Die <£iW stellen alle drei in Gegensatz zu der Memoriertechne an die Spitze des Systems." It is impossible to reconcile Isocrates and Alcidamas in this fashion, or to dispose of the fact that Alcidamas' essay is mainly directed against Isocrates. Isocrates and Plato emphasize vo-K in protest against the exaggerated professions of those who claim for teaching more than it can accomplish, while Alcidamas merely affirms that it requires more natural ability, Qvvk, to speak extempore than to write an elaborate speech. On p. 20, Dr. Suss explains the resemblance of Isocrates' phrase, ipvxv's ■ ■"• ■ So$a- £a to the Platonic imi> in Isoc. 13. 10 is unsuccessful. The entire context absolutely requires ypafxfxa.T(av. Sec. 11 is merely a personal digression, and the argument against the justice of the comparison of the teaching of rhetoric to the teaching of ypaft-imra is con- tinued and elaborated in sec. 12. As a final and typical example I may take the arguments used to transfer to Gorgias the Platonic definition of rhetoric as a ipvxaywyui Sta Aoywv. This is proved by a citation of the Zv$eoi Sia \6yu>v eVco&u eirayayol rjhovrjs from Gorgias Helena 10, and by reference to Isocrates 2. 49 and 9. 10. Now it is of course possible that Gorgias may have used the word ipvxa-y^yia somewhere. The weakness of the argument is that it totally overlooks the fundamental distinction between Isocrates' and Plato's use of the word. In 2. 49 Isocrates is not speaking as a rhetorician, but as a moralist. The multitude prefer entertainment to profit, hence poets (and epideictic rhetors) seek to entertain ({Irvxaycoyeiv) rather than to admonish. So in Evag. 10 the point is merely that poetry possesses in rhythm and other ornaments means of entertaining and moving the feelings which prose lacks. Plato on the other hand is thinking of the art of persuasion, and with a char- acteristic recurrence to etymology defines rhetoric as a guidance of the soul by discourses. This appears in the later statement that some souls are easily persuaded, that is, led, by one type of argument, and others by another. There is no real connection between the Isocratean and the Platonic passages, and Dr. Siiss's insistence on the mere word is as uncritical as is Dummler's argument that the Isocratean passage is an intentional sneer at Plato. It would require a volume to test all of Dr. Siiss's hypotheses in this way. I can only repeat in conclusion that, despite my distrust of much of the conjec- tural reasoning, the book is one which no student of the history of Greek rhetoric can afford to neglect. Paul Shorey