STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 106 Book Reviews version in Vienna. These, containing Marcellus' discussion of pulse-beats, normal and abnormal, are given to us now in twenty-one carefully edited pages of this pamphlet. Not the least interesting feature of Marcellus' work is found in his quotations from the medical works of older authorities — Chrysippus, Era- sistratus, Herophilus, Asclepiades, Hippocrates, etc. An index of words, almost full enough to be a concordance, completes this issue of Dr. Zervos' series. Another, in which he will take up the detailed explanation of the text and of all the technical words and phrases in it, is promised. Walteb Miller TlJLANE UnIVEBSITT Dead Language and Dead Languages. By J. P. Postgate. London: John Murray, 1910. Pp.32. Is. = 30 cents. The inaugural lecture for the academic year of 1909-10 at the Uni- versity of Liverpool was given by Professor Postgate under the above lugubrious caption. But the address itself is full of life and vigor. It is a new and novel presentation of the claims of classical education for its time- honored place in the training of modern men. In these days our ears are continually dinned with opprobrious remarks about the "dead languages." Long ago Clarence King, at that time director of the United States Geologi- cal Survey, declared that "only dolts can refer to Greek as a dead language." And he was right. So Professor Postgate in his address takes up the case of Latin and proves that Latin is just as much alive as English, or French, or German. There is a world of difference, he shows, between a dead lan- guage and a language of people that are dead. Even so, "if a great and world-wide Church uses Latin every day in its ritual and in the converse of its colleges and religious houses, and if newspapers are published in Latin in more than one civilized community, then to call Latin dead is perhaps a little premature." Walter Miller Tulane University Die Kultur der Gegenwart. Herausgegeben von Paul Hinneberg. Allgemeine Geschichte der Philosophie. Des Gesamtwerkes Teil I, Abteilung V. Berlin und Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1909. M. 12. The method of collaboration employed in the Cambridge English Litera- ture, in Lord Acton's Cambridge Modern History, and in Petit de Julleville's History of French Literature is here applied to the general history of philosophy. From the artistic point of view, there is some loss of unity. But it is the Book Reviews 107 only method that will satisfy the scientific conscience of an age of speciali- zation. A Zeller or a Windelband may write almost equally well on Greek and on modern German philosophy, but no single scholar could do this and at the same time produce the admirable summary of mediaeval philosophy which Baeumker contributes to this volume, or write of prehistoric thought with the competence of Wundt, of Hindoo philosophy with that of Olden- berg, of the philosophy of Islam with that of Goldziher, of Chinese philosophy with that of Grube, of Japanese philosophy with that of Tetsujiro Inouye. The publishers' prospectus promises an "allgemein verstandliche Sprache," and accordingly technical terms and quotations from the original texts are eschewed. But in the endeavor to say as much as possible in brief compass, the writers employ a generalized, abstract style which presupposes in the German reading public which they address a singularly high culture. This is especially noticeable in Windelband's sketch of modern philoso- phy. His comment is full of interest and suggestion to those who already know the story. But its rapid comparisons and combinations of historical movements and tendencies in "-mus" from "humanismus," "Paracelsismus," and "Augustinismus," to "criticismus," "positivismus," and "pragmatis- mus" will baffle the uninitiated. Further criticism must be confined to the section which falls within the scope of this journal, von Arnim's history of the philosophy of classical antiquity. It is no paradox to say that its chief merit is due to the fact that the writer is not primarily a philosopher, but a philologist and student of literature. He does not attempt to probe to the bottom of metaphysical problems, and rarely loses himself in the cul de sac of epistemology. But he gives on the whole the most lucid and intelligible description of the general movement of philosophic ideas from Thales to Plotinus with which I am acquainted. His conception of the pre-Socratics, I am pleased to note, is that emphasized by my pupil, Dr. Clara Millerd, in her dissertation, On the Interpretation of Empedocles. He says (p. 119) "Indem man eine Ge- schichte erzahlt, wie aus dem Urstoff die Welt entstand, gibt man nicht nur eine genetische Erklarung des gegenwartigen Weltzustandes, sondern glaubt auch etwas auszusagen iiber das wahrhaft Seiende." He rightly affirms the practical identity of Anaxagoras' "Urgemenge" with the "Urstoff" of Anaximander. The omission of all reference to the Aoyos in connection with Heraclitus seems strange. He does not find two distinct cycles of creation in Empedocles, but blends them in one, to which he refers all four descriptions of the development of organic life. There seem to be some traces here of the confusion'of Zeller first clearly explained in Dr. Millerd's dissertation (p. 50). Unless we are to take Empedocles' words vaguely and symbolically of a general evolution from chaos, we must admit (1) that there are two world creations, (2) that the cycle in which we live is that in which strife is on the increase, (3) and that Zeller's interpretation confounds the two in hopeless ambiguity. 108 Book Reviews The account of the sophists is excellent, as we should expect from the author of the first chapter of the Leben und Werke des Dio von Prusa. At the most I should query whether too much of the Theaetetus is not attrib- uted to Protagoras, and too much of Xenophon to Socrates. The homo mensura is said to mean the individual man — rightly, so far as we may sup- pose Protagoras to have raised the question at all. The treatment of Plato is admirable in lucidity, directness, and warmth of appreciation. The ethical, religious, and social aspects of Plato's thought are properly emphasized. A specialist may take exception to some things said of the metaphysics. But as it is in any case impossible to make this intelligible to the general public even of philologists such criticism would be captious. There is real insight in the statement (p. 151) "Die Tatsache, dass ein Ding viele Eigenschaften hat, stellte sich fur den Griechen aus sprachlichen Griinden in der Form dar, dass Ein Ding vieles ist." He is right in denying that the Ideas are thoughts of God, that matter is //.ij ov, and that Plato changed his terminology in regard to /«&£«. But he misses the psychological or epistemological necessity for affirming ideas of everything, and he errs in tracing a development of the idea of immortality from the Symposium to the Phaedrus and the Phaedrus to the Phaedo; in affirming that the airo £<3ov of the Timaeus is God; and, as was to be expected, in his interpretation of the Idea of Good. With many other critics, he fails to see that the Idea of Good may be the highest idea for the ethics and sociology of the Republic and the teleological nature philosophy of the Timaeus, without being the most comprehensive idea in logical extension for the purposes of the dialectical and ontological dialogues. The only exceptions that I have to take to the clear and helpful sum- mary of Aristotelianism are (1) the distinction between ap\al= axioms and dpxcu = concepts is not sufficiently brought out; (2) the fundamental ambiguity of oio-ia in Aristotle, of which Gomperz makes so much, is ignored or evaded; (3) the statement (p. 183) that a plant has no sensation because "es fehlt ihr an einem seelischen Zentralorgan," repeats, I think, an old error of Zeller's to which I have elsewhere called attention. The /icaroTws does not mean a central organ of the soul, but as Themistius, says, (p. 144 . 5) to o~u>iJja. iv iitcroTtfri KCKpafievov t£>v airrlov tvavTubatiov. The Epicurean irpoXv^i.'s, von Arnim says, cannot be an innate idea. He explains it, if I may borrow the terminology of Romanes, as an infallible "recept" from sense experience. He does not attempt to reconcile this view with the fact that there is a irpoXrjipis or natural anticipation that the gods are eternal. Nothing is said of the beginnings of the development of an empirical logic of induction in the later Epicureans. There is a good account of Stoicism, and an admirable chapter on Plotinus, with which the sketch closes. The last two centuries of neo-Platonism are judiciously omitted. Little worth while could be said of them in the space available. Paul Shorey