STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 97 No one can doubt that Homer must have drawn on preceding tradition and literature for his knowledge of the age described, but just because we have no independent knowledge of this literature or tradition it is impossible to decide what is due to the source and what is due to Homer. Even when we do have the source it is difficult to judge which is the source and which the imitation; Mulder is certain that the speech of Priam in Iliad xxiv is modeled after a poem of Tyrtaeus, while to most scholars the imitation seems just the reverse. Here we do have the original and the copy, yet cannot agree; but when one attempts to reconstruct an assumed original with no clue except that furnished by the copy there is no check on the most rash hypotheses. Where I have the material from which to form a judgment I cannot accept Mulder's theories in regard to original and copy, as in the assumed imitation of Tyrtaeus by Homer and the assumption that the anger of Poseidon in the Odyssey is copied from the anger of Achilles in the Iliad. While the arguments in regard to the sources are built upon too small a basis, the book is still one of unusual merit and every page is full of the most original and brilliant observations. John A. Scott Northwestern University Aristotle on the Art of Poetry. By Ingram Bywater. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1909. Pp. xlvii + 387. 16s. net. The peculiar value of the book lies in the wealth of illustration by which Professor Bywater endeavors to make Aristotle explain himself. A very striking use is also made of Isocrates. Add to this the scientific spirit, the fine sobriety, and textual acumen of Professor Bywater, and we have an edition which was much needed and which pretty well exhausts what antiquity can do to explain its own remains. It is a noble edition of the Poetics and in its way complete. But whether this famous book can be explained without venturing into a field from which Professor Bywater expressly excludes himself is another question. It is no doubt true that Aristotle " would be surprised to find how large a meaning we are able to read into some of his more incidental utterances." But if the appeal is to Aristotle redivivus, would he not be still more surprised at the enormous energy expended upon determining his ipsissima verba f Would he not find the scholarship more congenial which argued with him upon first principles ? Of course what Aristotle really did mean is what we want to know, whether or not we like it or him for saying it, and everything depends upon how the metaphor of /cdflapoxs originally suggested itself to him. All may agree that his first intention was a criticism of Plato. Does he not indeed consciously take up the mocking challenge which Plato makes to the champions of tragedy? Keducing to its simplest dimensions 98 Book Reviews Professor Bywater's fine summary and justification of the doctrine of Weil and Bernays, we are to make Aristotle say that tragedy, instead of nourishing certain normal though disturbing human emotions, affords a safe and pleasurable discharge of their overplus. To this pleasant cure, as to drugs in general, we should resort only occasionally. Here lies the healing power of poetry. If not an anodyne or narcotic, it is a cathartic. But there is after all more assumption in this argument than at first sight appears. Are we to believe that the why was not as present to the eager mind of Aristotle as the howi Why do we take a noble delight in what excites pain in ordinary life? Is it not more than possible that this mysterious power of art was the very thing that suggested the metaphor to our pioneer in the theory of art ? In short, are we not justi- fied in assuming that Aristotle is making the first fumbling attempt in history to detach a first principle of art ? Professor By water is not so happy in his summary of opposing views. They can neither be compre- hended under the one head of the lustratory use of Ka9api\dvOponrov (1452. b. 38) is dismissed, a consideration which perhaps decided the retention of (TToxatfivrcu. (1456. a. 21) and certainly accounts for the venturesome note on p. 254. But Aristotle says ko.1 6 avSpao's fn.lv aSiKos 8c, not ko.1 6 a&Kos //.ev dvSpetos Se. And, finally, there is no note on iw lv fieydXy 86$r/ ovrtov ko.1 tvTvxia .... (1453 a. 10-11; though he stops to note the apparent contradiction in ^ fitXriovos 1453 a. 16). But is there no significance in the doctrine that tragedy must be the " fall of something great " ? But when Professor By water deals with the text, and in the main body of the commentary, one can feel nothing but admiration for his refined, if hard-headed, sobriety. No one has so well pointed out or so carefully collected the lapses and contradictions in the Poetics, or so clearly shown the apparent waning of Aristotle's interest in his subject as the book goes on. Professor Bywater frankly undertakes at the start to prove that the Arabic version is of little or no value as against the final authority of A c . The notes on 1447. a. 17 t<3 yeva eWpois and 1448. a. 10-11, tc3 ittpl tovs \6yov; are good examples of the well-known judgment which appears on nearly every page. One observes casually that Vahlen's insertion of el before tru^ey in 1460. b. 36, is silently passed by, and, strangely, the commentary contains no note on the singular passage c£ ov fieraftaivav ei's €irv X (av .... (1455. b. 28). We heartily accept his position that a translation of Aristotle should lean toward paraphrase. If somewhat bold, his version is very sure- footed where others stumble, as e.g. 1455. a. 30-31, Tri6avs, where Butcher goes wrong. But one must object to " as having magnitude" in the definition of a tragedy, where the note also is defective, for the principle involved might have been illustrated at great length from Aristotle. Finally apfwvia may be equivalent to /«Aos in 1449. b. 29, though this is doubtful, and to rdvos in 1449. a. 27, but it is never our English "harmony." W. S. Milner University College Toronto Four- Plays of Menander: The Hero, Epitrepontes, Pericei- romene, and Samia. Edited with Introductions, Ex- planatory Notes, Critical Appendix, and Bibliography, by Edwabd Capps. Boston: Ginn & Co., 1910. x + 329 pp. Mr. Capps's edition of the four plays in the Cairo papyrus has a distinct individuality: the editor's liberal employment of his own supple- ments in the filling of lacunae, his independence in the distribution of