STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 531 contagion. In the case of Minucius Felix, however, the peculiar posi- tion of his Octavius in the transition from pagan to Christian Latin and its surprising dependence upon its chief source, the De natura deorum of Cicero, suflBciently explain the importance and the interest of such an investigation as that here presented. Ausserer finds his starting-point in the four forms which Zielinski in the well-known study Das Klausel- gesetz in Ciceros Reden has shown to be the favorite clausulae of Cicero. To the first three of these belong approximately 95 per cent of jihe 679 clausulae of the Octavius, while the fourth is but slightly repre- sented and a few other metrical combinations of a rather bewildering variety are also discovered. Probably the greatest interest of this investigation is to be found in the possible light thrown upon the dark places of the readings of the one poor manuscript in which the Octavius has been preserved. Some seventy passages are discussed by Ausserer from this point of view, and it is noteworthy that in several instances (e.g., labiis pressit, chap, ii) the reading of P is preferred on metrical grounds in opposition to the emendations accepted by modern editors. The text of Boenig has been followed in the main, while for the con- venience of the reader, references are also given to the edition of Halm in the Vienna Corpus. Edward A. Beohtel TULANS UnIVBESITY Plato, Apology of Socrates and Crito, with Extracts from the Phaedo and Symposium and from Xenophon's Memorabilia. Edited by Louis Dyee, revised by Thomas Day Sbymouk. With a Vocabulary. Boston: Ginn & Co., 1908. Pp. 246. This is a revision of the Cron-Dyer Apology and Crito, to which Professor Seymour has added other passages with commentary, a vocabulary, and indices. The notes have been simplified and better adapted to the needs of the American schoolboy. The critical notes are limited to a list of the changes from Dyer's text and another list showing the deviations from the texts of notable German editions, viz., the Cron-Uhle ed. of the Apology and Crito, Wohlrab's Phaedo, Hug's Symposium, and the Breitenbach-Milcke ed. of the Memorabilia. One readily accepts the changes from Dyer's text, except the bracketing of TrdXai Apol. Sid which removes an effective reijetition; less readily, some of the deviations from the texts of the Ger- man editors. The following readings, adopted by Seymour, are open to criticism: Apol. 22a, Iva luoi. The conjecture of Stephanus Zva \x.-l] fxai is now confirmed by A and the Armenian version. Socrates' assumed " attitude of opposition," shown in his effort to refute the oracle ( COS .... iXir^iiiyv 21 c), is kept up consistently in this and succeeding passages (cf . 532 Book Eeviews 0)5 ... . KaToAiji/'dfiei/os 22&). — 24a, Tois avTOLs is ill-suited to the context, whereas either Heindorf .=! tovtok airoTs or avrols tovtok which is implied in the Arm. vers, gives the desired meaning. — 26e, fiiev is unnecessary and has little support. — 316, ^eiroi, though accepted by Baumlein, does not go well with the koi that precedes or the Si that follows. Read iiiy (Cobet's conj.) with W or accept GObel's attractive emendation KatVot d liev Ti. — 31d, avoXioXr], 36a, airoTrecfKvyri should have the augment; of. Schanz XII, p. xii, Meisterhans 170, 6.— Crito 46a, Si n. Prefer S'lri; cf . In 1. 24. The commentary contains many corrections and improvements on Dyer's notes. The following points, however, may be criticized: 25b, Tovvavriov Trav. It is somewhat better to explain this as being in apposition with the following sentence than as an adverbial accusative. The same is true in 34a, where it is not the object of oipija-eTc, as the punctuation would seem to indicate. — 26d, war' ovk elSevaL. ov is due to the indirect discourse, as Professor Gildersleeve showed in his review of Dyer (AJP VI 523; cf. VII 174, XXI 110). Yet S. still keeps most of Dyer's note.— 27d, tovt' av at], ^avai is not "appended" to the relative clause. It explains tovto the subject, not the relative clause which is the predicate. — 35c, o/jiiofioKev ov xapield-^ai. ov does not go with the inf., as S. thinks, but with onwfWKev (cf. AJP I 49). S. finds ov in the dicasts' oath (ovrc xdpiTOi eveKo) and believes that this ov is retained here in indir. disc. But "ofiwfu .... is perfectly steady" in taking /jlt^ after it. Since this and other negatives are discussed, a note is needed on "oracular" /x-q 21a, deliberative /jltj 22e, and ov in a protasis 34c (ei=oTt). — 416, ayovra. S.'s note to the effect that "extreme accuracy [in the use of tenses] is not aimed at" here, is hard to understand; cf. his "indifferent" in the note on 26d 22. ayovra = " who was the leader of," the durative tense causing the mind to dwell on the exercise of the office of leader, ayayovra which most editors adopt is simply "who led." — Crito 44c, ov; p. 56, 1 n., 33d for 31b; p. 117, 32 n., fin. for init; p. 194, changes from Dyer's text at 28d 30 and 31d 12 have been omitted; pp. 194-5, omissions occur in the other list at 23d 14, 27e 34, Sid 13, 33e 25, 36a 7, 416 37. Charles W. Peppler Emory Collkgb