STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 527 the civilization of his age. Future studies in the subject-matter of his work will undoubtedly enucleate valuable additions to our acquaintance with the second century. Clifford Hebschel Moore Haevaed Univeesitt Poeti Latini Minori, testo critico commentato da Gaetano Curcio. Vol. II, fasc. 2, Appendix; Vergiliana, "Dirae," "Lydia," "Ciris." Catania: Francesco Battiato editore, 1908. 8vo, pp. 196. The second fascicle of the Appendix Vergiliana follows the general plan of the first, containing the "Priapea," " Catalepton," "Copa," " Moretum," published in 1905. The appearance in 1907 of the critical edition by Kobinson Ellis of the Appendix Vergiliana lends a special interest to the problems of the text, and naturally suggests a comparison of the two works from this point of view. There is no evidence that C. had made any use of Ellis' edition, or had even seen it, and the work of the two scholars is therefore independent. For the "Ciris" they are on common ground, and make use of the same MSS; but in the "Dirae" and the "Lydia" the divergence is little short of remarkable. Of the six MSS used by Curcio, and the ten used by Ellis, they have only two in common, viz., Vat. 3252, s. ix (B), and Vat. 3269, s. xv (designated as A by Curcio and as v by Ellis). In addition to these Curcio has used the following, all Italian, collated by himself: Vat. 1586, s. xv (C), Vat. Urb. 350 (D), Laurentianus 33, 31, s. xiv (L), containing scholia on the •' Dirae," and Laurentianus 39, 18, s. xv. (L 1 ). ^In addition to the two MSS already mentioned Ellis made use of the readings of the following: Paris. 7927, s. x (P), Paris. 8093, s. x (E), Paris. 17177, s. xi (S=Stabu- lense fragmentum), Bodl. Auct. F. 1, 17, s. xiv (F), Harl. 3963, s. xv (h), Mus. Brit. 16562, script, a.d. 1400 (6), Monacensis. 18059, s. xi (T), Melli- censis, s. xi (M). It is difficult to see on what principle Curcio selected his MSS, other than their convenient location in Italy. A glance at his critical apparatus is sufficient to show that, of his six MSS, all Italian, the last five ACDLL 1 are closely related to each other and to b of Ellis' list, and are clearly descended from a common ancestor of a relatively late date. Their consensus alone has real value. His appara- tus, therefore, compared with that of Ellis is one-sided and defective. Ellis, on the other hand, gives from the family bACDLL 1 , just men- tioned, the readings of b A, which are fairly representative of the group, and the following MSS of the eleventh century or earlier, TMSPE, of considerable independent value. Although Curcio's apparatus is not representative, his collations of D C L L 1 have been made with care and will be useful to students of the "Dirae" and "Lydia." In dealing with the text of the three poems Curcio has been on the whole conservative 528 Book Reviews and in a considerable number of passages has returned from the conjec- tures of previous editors to MS readings. To the "Lydia" he has appended the verses contained in Laurent. 33, 31, which, however, have a curious rather than a real value, as examples of late mediaeval guess- work. The somewhat lengthy introductions to the poems include a literary analysis; a discussion of the metrical features of each, with statistics as to the various verse forms, caesurae, etc.; a section on language and style; and a complete collection of literary parallels from late republican and Augustan poets, especially from Lucilius, Lucretius, Catullus, and Vergil for the " Dirae " and " Lydia," and from Lucretius, Catullus, Vergil, Ovid, Propertius, Malius, and the other poems of the Appendix for the "Ciris." Most of this material, part of which is original, and part compiled from other sources, will be found useful and leads up to the debated question of the authorship and date of the poems. In the light of his own studies and those of other scholars, his conclusions are briefly as follows: that the "Dirae" and "Lydia" are the work of a single author, who is not Vergil, and who may from internal evidence be assigned to the " Catullian or pre-Vergilian" period; that the author of the "Ciris" cannot be iden- tified, but that he was an imitator of Vergil. These conclusions are negative and safe. In his commentary, which is relatively free from the unnecessary erudition with which learned commentaries are often overloaded, he confines himself for the most part to the elucidation of the poet's mean- ing. Many of the notes, however, strike one as a little elementary for the class of readers who would be likely to consult so pretentious a critical edition. F. W. Shipley Sancti Aurelii Augustini De Civitate Dei. Libri xxii. Vol. I, Libri i-xiii. Tertium recognovit B. Dombabt. Leipsic: Teubner, 1909. M. 5. The late Professor Dombart, who in the course of his long career did so much to advance the study of St. Augustine, had at the time of his death almost completed the first volume of his third edition of the De Civitate Dei. This revision was completed and prepared for the press by Alfonsus Kalb. The praefatio, increased from the five pages of the edition of 1877 to twenty-eight, is devoted to a study of the numerous manuscripts of the De Civitate Dei, incorporating considerable matter from Hoffmann's edition in the Vienna Corpus, especially the description of L and A examined by him. In conclusion, on the basis of a study of the read-