STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 519 Pausanias als Schriftsteller. Studien und Beobachtungen. Von Cakl Kobekt. Berlin: Weidmann, 1909. Pp. vii+347. Mit 2 Planen und 7 Planskizzen. This latest contribution to the study of Pausanias is exceedingly rich in suggestion and presents a new point of view. The attack of Wilamo- witz on the trustworthiness of Pausanias some thirty years ago, which was followed up by Kalkmann's exhaustive study to prove that the author of the Periegesis had seen very little of Greece but had compiled the bulk of his work from the manuals of earlier writers, called forth vigorous champions in Schoell, Gurlitt, Heberdey, and Frazer. Yet the effect of this investigation into the trustworthiness of the author — which is now universally admitted — had diverted the attention of scholars from the study of the literary qualities of Pausanias. Robert has entered upon this neglected field and in his Pausanias als Schriftsteller directs attention chiefly to the author's literary method, purpose, manner, and style. The book may be examined from two points of view: (1) the author's constructive work in developing a literary study of Pausanias; (2) the author's endeavor to show that the world of scholars has made a mistake in regarding the Description of Greece as a guide-book, when Pausanias intended it to be primarily a literary composition that would reflect credit upon a second-century sophist and rhetorician. An analysis of the volume will prepare us for a satisfactory appraisement of the work from these two considerations. In the introduction Robert comments on how the archaeological significance of Pausanias has caused the consideration of his literary qualities to fall into the background. What he seeks above all is to give the literary side of his writer full vindication. In the first chapter — "Die Tendenz des Werkes" — the author states his principal thesis. He quotes Pausanias i. 39. 3 and iii. 11. 1 to show that the material embraced in the work may be divided into two catego- ries, namely \6yoi and Oewprj/MTa, "stories" and "monuments," and then asserts that the monuments are to him nothing more than the prop, the occasion for the \6yoi, as in Athenaeus the banquet merely furnishes the framework for the stories. Or, to use his own language, "Es ist nichts als eine grosse Zusammenstellung von Aoyoi fur die die Periegese ebenso nur den Rahmen abgiebt, wie bei Athenaios das Gastmahl." The second chapter is devoted to an analysis of the \6yoi. These are varied in character so that one might well call the work a iravTo^awi) la-Topla. Here are to be found historical, mythological, and anecdotal narratives, biographies, antiquarian and scientific observations, ethical reflections. There is no lack of variety: dryness and tediousness are the last reproach the book deserves. Robert analyzes and paraphrases a 520 Book Kevibws great number of the Aoyoi, pointing out their characteristic features, and adds that he has treated but an inconsiderable portion of this varied collection of stories. The third chapter discusses Pausanias' handling of the Oewprj/mTa or, as he names them, ra U imSaiiv or to. 6eas &£ta. His description of build- ings leaves much to be desired. He speaks very rarely of the plan, of the size, of the style. The fullest account is that of the Zeus temple at Olympia. Of the Parthenon he gives us merely the name and the subjects of the pediment sculptures. His description of the cult-statues on the other hand leaves scarcely anything to be desired, as for example, that of the Athena Parthenos (i. 24. 57.), or of the Olympian Zeus (v. 11. 1-8). Yet Pausanias always writes as a litterateur, not as an archaeologist. Modern science would make him "ein gelehrter Anti- quar," " ein sorgf altiger Materialsammler." On the contrary, " Ein Belle- trist will er sein, wie man heute sagen wiirde; zu seiner Zeit nannte man das einen Sophisten." The fourth chapter is entitled " Die Anordnung der Beschreibung." Just as in a preceding chapter Robert has set aside the conception of Pausanias as an archaeological investigator, so here he finds entirely at fault the characterization of his book as "ein Handbuch fur Beisende, einen antiken Baedeker." He holds that Pausanias wished to write "keinen Reisefuhrer, sondern ein angenehm zu lesendes Buch" (p. 110). The writer did not concern himself at all with matters of transportation and food and lodging. He did not describe objects in the same order in which the reader would see them. The principle he follows is that of a system of radii from a common center, as, for example, in his description of Athens, combined with a series of categories as islands, mountains, demes, etc. The next chapter — "Die Stadtebeschreibungen" — is perhaps the best in the book. To ascertain Pausanias' method, he analyzes in an effective way the twenty-six most important descriptions of cities, including the sacred precincts, Olympia and Delphi. He discovers several schemata under which the descriptions may be grouped. These are as follows: A, Topographical Principle: (a) (1) Acropolis in 4 cases (Sicyon, Phlius, Patrai, Pheneos); (2) Agora in 5 cases (Corinth, Argos, Sparta, Messene, Troezen); (3) a single building in 3 cases (Tegea, Elis, and Epidaurus); (b) the gate in 6 cases (Athens, Pellene, Thebes, Plataea, Delphi, Aegina); (c) special cases (Megara, Megalopolis, Hermione); B, Systematic Prin- ciple in 5 cases (Olympia, Aigion, Mantineia, Tanagra, Thespiae). The topography of each of these places is discussed in detail. In the descrip- tion of Athens, Robert shows how, though beginning with the gate, it links itself closely with the market type. He accepts as proven Dorp- feld's theory as to the location of Enneakrounos. The sixth chapter, entitled " Einiges vom Stil des Autors," is very Book Reviews 521 short and adds but little to our knowledge. He recognizes Pausanias' dependence upon Hegesias, and holds that he modernizes the style of Herodotus in the manner of Hegesias. He discusses in some detail three peculiarities of style, namely, paraphrase, perissology, and oratio variata. The seventh chapter — "Der Gesamtplan des Werkes" — is a dis- cussion of the plan of composition as a whole and of the form and date of publication. He finds that the principle of "routes" and "radii" applies to the whole work as well as to single districts, that certain cities form the centers for the composition of the book and with the routes uniting them form a kind of genealogical tree, which he presents on p. 260. Robert thinks it is clear that the work is not complete. Though i. 1. 1. may be regarded as an adequate prooemium, there is an abrupt conclusion to book x. Stephanus of Byrantium evidently had other books before him in preparing his Lexicon, and there were probably originally 14 books, of which the last four were distributed as follows : xi, Aetolia and Akarnania; xii, Doris, Opus, etc.; xiii, Thessaly; xiv, Euboea. The final chapter bears the caption "Lebenzeit und Heimat des Autors." Robert favors Damascus as the place of his birth rather than Magnesia on Mt. Sipylus. He thinks he was born under Hadrian not later than 115 a.d., and that his work as we have it appeared in four parts: 1, the Atthis about 160; 2, 1, 39, 4, ii, iii, iv, between 160 and 174; 3, v, vi, vii, in 174; 4, viii-xii, after 177. Robert concludes his work with lengthy appendices on Delphi; (1) Die Tempel auf der Marmaria; (2) Die heilige Strasse, and on Athen; die Agora. We are deeply indebted to Robert for emphasizing so fully the literary qualities of Pausanias. His treatment of the author shows how unjust it is to regard him merely as a cicerone, and that he is well deserving of being read in our colleges and universities, not merely for the topo- graphical and archaeological information he imparts, but as a good story- teller and literary craftsman as well. So on the literary side Robert has contributed greatly to our knowledge. Yet we must differ absolutely from Robert as to the main thesis of his work, namely, that the Description of Greece was not intended as a guide-book, but places and monuments were mentioned merely for the sake of the stories. This is for the following reasons: (1) It is a guide- book. Every student and archaeologist who visits Greece uses Pausanias as his Vademecum. With Baedeker in one pocket and Pausanias in the other he explores the sites of ancient cities, and by a study of the two he seeks to restore them in his imagination as they were in the bright days of their splendor. In the excavations at Olympia, at Mycenae, at Delphi, at Corinth, and elsewhere Pausanias was at every turn the chart and 522 Book Reviews guide-book, and every effort was made to identify the objects he mentions and fit them into his plan. If Pausanias is a guide-book today, why was he not a guide-book to Greece when its monuments still retained the splendor and freshness of the older time? 2. Robert objects to the characterization of the work as " ein Hand- buch fur Reisende, einen antiken Baedeker." True, it is not a guide- book in the modern sense with its details about transportation, comfort, and lodging. But it was a guide for the special lines of aesthetic interest for which it was intended. To illustrate this as far as Athens and Attica are concerned, see the introduction to my edition of The Attica of Pau- sanias, pp. 6, 7, where I compare in detail his topographical method with that of Baedeker's Greece; also my Topographical Outline, pp. 12-25 with the Index to Baedeker. Similar comparisons may be made for other books. 3. Robert himself is the best refutation of his pet theory. He, for the first time, has thoroughly analyzed Pausanias' topographical method. A careful perusal of the chapters on the description of cities and the plan of the work adds to the reader's appreciation of Pausanias' effective- ness as a guide and leads him to believe that Pausanias told the stories to increase interest in the monuments rather than to describe the monu- ments for the sake of the stories. So, for example, the centers and radii, given in the table on p. 226, correspond in a striking way with the "routes" outlined by Baedeker. Why are there so many "routes" and "radii," if only to tell stories? Why so many phrases like lv 8e£ia, ev apuTTtpa, oi ir6pp<», TrXr}criov, and the like, if not to indicate directions? In conclusion, Robert's masterful work presents results in harmony with the brief characterization of Pausanias in my Attica (Introduction, p. 7): Similarity of treatment shows that we have in Pausanias the prototype of Baedeker and Murray. The second century was an age of travel, like our own, and many needed systematic direction to help them on the way. The public-house system was poor, but private hospitality, as in the earlier days, made some amends. Accordingly, the description of inns and other accom- modations which Dionysus in the Frogs feels to be such a desideratum and which our Murray or Baedeker offers in great detail, is wanting, but in other respects the likeness between the ancient and the modern cicerone holds. Book I was meant primarily to be a guide-book for the Greek visitor to Athens and Attica, just as the whole volume was a guide-book for the gener- ally frequented parts of Hellas, with special reference to works of art, like the modern Burckhardt. To gratify the intellectual curiosity of his readers, Pausanias fills his volume with mythical, antiquarian, and historical lore and he doubtless felt that his work would be serviceable to the historian as well as the traveller. Yet his main purpose was, without doubt, to provide a guide-book for visitors to the historic sites of Greece. Mitchell Carroll