STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 512 Book Reviews Platon. Von Constant™ Eitter. Erster Band. Munchen: Beck, 1910. Pp. xv + 588. M. 9. The second volume of Professor Eitter's Platon will present a sys- tematic account of the Platonic philosophy, based on the content of the Republic and the later dialogues. The present volume contains the life of Plato, the necessary preliminary characterizations and classifications of the dialogues, and analyses of the Laches, Hippias Minor, Protag- oras, Charmides, Hippias Maior, Euthyphron, Apology, Crito, Gor- gias, Euthydemus, Cratylus, Meno, Menexenus, Lysis, Symposium, and Phaedo, which the author thinks were written in this order. The account of Plato's life and character, occupying 193 pages, is the best and most readable with which I am acquainted. Without strain- ing the evidence, or abandoning himself to fantastic conjectures, Pro- fessor Ritter contrives to bring the few known facts of Plato's life into plausible relation with the political and literary history of his time in the most illuminating fashion. Very attractive, too, is the warm, yet sober and restrained, enthusiasm for the personality of Plato that per- vades the whole. Professor Ritter refutes the cheap calumnies reported by Athenaeus, vindicates the patriotism of Plato against Niebuhr and others, and tells the story of the Sicilian journeys in such a way as to justify Plato's conduct on every point. In so doing, he makes much use of the seventh and eighth and third epistles, rejecting the second, the thirteenth, and others accepted by Eduard Meyer and Christ. I doubt the genuineness even of the seventh and eighth epistles, and absolutely reject the third, for reasons which I shall give later. But they are inter- esting early documents, and I have little exception to take to Professor Ritter's use of them. To the question of the genuineness of the dialogues he deigns to give only a few words. He refuses to discuss the older attempts to athetize the Parmenides and the Sophist. He rejects peremptorily the two Alcibiades, the Ion, for which much can be said, and the Epinomis, which Reuther has recently attempted to rehabilitate. For the dating of the dialogues, he recognizes the following methods : (1) The rare allusions to contemporary history, which he dismisses briefly, adhering to 385 for the Symposium, and preferring 369 for the Theaetetus; (2) allusions to other writers; he sensibly rejects most of the venturesome hypotheses of Teichmuller and Diimmler concerning the relations of Plato and Isocrates, and dismisses both the Busiris problem and the Ecclesiazousae problem with a non liquet; (3) distinct references of one dialogue to another, which are few and yield slight results; (4) variations (a) in Plato's thought, (6) in his style. With regard to (a), he virtually, though not explicitly, accepts the conclusion sup- ported by more detailed argument in my Unity of Plato's Thought, that Book Reviews 513 the attempts to date the dialogues in this way have thus far broken down. He could hardly do otherwise, since he dates so rich a work as the Protagoras before the death of Socrates, and agrees with me that the Oorgias does not really contradict the Protagoras, and that the fallacies which Gomperz and others find in Plato are mainly due to mis- interpretation (cf. Class. Phil. I, 297). His main interest is in (6) the evidence furnished by the statistical study of style, in which he has been a leader. He expounds the method clearly, gives illustrations that will make its applications clear to the general reader, defends it vigorously against the skepticism of Zeller and others, and verifies its validity on the writings of Goethe. The main result, as is now generally admitted, is the recognition of a later group of Platonic writings, the Laws, Philebus, Timaeus, Sophist, Politicus ; a central group comprising the Republic, Theaetetus, the Phaedrus, and, as many hold, the Parmenides, Symposium, and Phaedo ; and an earlier group, the precise limits and dating of which Bitter regards as uncer- tain. He takes the dialogues up for analysis in the order which seems most probable to him. The analyses are carefully made, but we may be permitted to regret the space given to them after the work of Grote, Jowett, Bonitz, Gom- perz, Horn, and so many others. Every interpreter of Plato should have made analyses of all the dialogues for himself. It is perhaps not neces- sary always to print them. A closer critical discussion of difficult, doubt- ful, or often misunderstood passages is what is needed now. The chief thing said of the minor dialogues is what I and others have already emphasized, that they point forward to the "good" as the one key to the problems which they leave unsolved. It is, I think, a mistake, on p. 294, to translate Laches 182 D, ■tcavra. yap iirurravOai ayaOov SoKti cfau, "alles sollte man eigentlich wissen," ard to treat it as the characteristic utter- ance of the Bildungsphilister. The words are spoken, not by Nicias, as Professor Bitter seems to imply, but as a concession by Laches, who is not a Bildungsphilister, and they mean, as Jowett correctly translates them, simply: "For all (that is, every kind of) knowledge seems to be a good." Professor Bitter holds, as I do in Unity, that the fallacies of the Hippias Minor are intentional. He adds the perhaps fanciful sug- gestion that, since even now many scholars fail to see this, Plato could not have intended the dialogue for publication, when it was written, because it would exhibit Socrates in an unfavorable light. In the analysis of the Charmides, he retains the Greek word auxfrpoavirq, because it is untrans- latable. The metaphysical problem of knowledge of knowledge he post- pones to the Theaetetus. The Euthyphro he thinks, was published between the accusation and the trial of Socrates. He does not discuss the difficult passages, or the theory that the dialogue eliminates piety from the list of cardinal virtues. The Apology and Crito are more fully 514 Book Reviews described, in the interest of the general reader. The discussion which follows the risume" of the Gorgias is confined to ethics, practically ignor- ing rhetoric. He holds, as I do, that there is no real contradiction with the Protagoras, and that the "fallacies" are only apparent. The deeper discussion of ethical theory he seems to reserve for the Philebus. The change of tone from the Protagoras he attributes to Plato's feeling that the seeming hedonism of the Protagoras might injure Socrates in the eyes of those who failed to understand it. The generally accepted allusion to Isocrates at the close of the Euthydemus he denies with some heat, because Zeller had used it in connection with the praise of Isocrates in the Phaedrus, as a reductio ad absurdum of the conclusions of Sprachstatistik. Isocrates is not named, and I am not concerned to insist that he is specifically meant. But I think it is certain that an Athenian reader would have thought of Isocrates. I cannot understand Blass's assertion (Att. Bered. II, 34) that the sentence attributed to the unknown is not in Isocrates' manner at all: irepl ovSevoi d&W ava£[av airovBrjv irouovfixviM seems to me a fair parody of the style of, e.g., <7TrovSa£a>v koX woAAovs Xoyovs 7ro«Mj/ievos rrtpl avdpumatv, ovs ov&els viretXrjfpev aijiovs thai, Aoyou (Isoc. 12. 22.), which is of course later. Nor can I accept Hitter's argument that since Crito says that he is quoting verbatim and the words are not to be found in our text of Isocrates, therefore we must look elsewhere. I do not believe that the phrase ovnoai yap irw koi cittc tois ovofuxai (304 E) necessarily implies ver- batim quotation from a published work — the emphasis is on the repro- duction of the manner, the tricks of style, not on textual fidelity, which would probably be otherwise expressed in Greek. (Cf. Isoc. 1. 9; Apol. 17 B; Phaedr. 234 T>; Hippias Minor 286 A; Symp. 198 B.) Professor Ritter, I am glad to see, apprehends the fact that the etymologies of the Cratylus are mainly jests. The serious thought of the dialogue he again postpones, as he does that of the Meno, which follows. I note on p. 483 what seems to me a slight inaccuracy with regard to the Meno — the omission in the summary of tovto S'i