STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Volume XVII July IQ22 Number 3 EARLY GREEK CODES By Gertrude Smith In the earliest phase of Greek civilization which is known from literature there was no conception of law. A divine agent which Sir Henry Maine 1 describes as " suggesting judicial awards (Themistes) to kings or to gods" was recognized. In the next stage of legal history there are still no written laws, but the ruling aristocracy claims to have exclusive knowledge of the principles by which disputes are settled. This may be called the age of customary law. The final stage is reached when the customary laws are codified and written down with the addition of new laws framed by the lawgiver to corre- spond to the exigencies of his time. 2 Euripides contrasts a state which has no written laws with a state in which the laws have been codified : No worse foe than a despot hath a state, Under whom, first, can be no written laws, But one rules, keeping in his private hands The law: so is equality no more. But when the laws are written then the weak And wealthy have alike but equal right. Yea, even the weaker may fling back the scoff Against the prosperous if he be reviled; And, armed with right, the less o'ercomes the great. 3 1 Ancient Law, p. 4. 2 Cf. the definition of laws given by the Xenophontic Pericles (Mem. i. 2. 42) : xdjT« yap ovtoi pojuoi eifflv ovs to ttXtjOos avvehdov Kal Sota/jtaffav £ypa^€, ippa^ov a t« Set iroieiv Kal a nv. 3 Supplices 429 ff. Way's translation. [Classical Philology XVII, July, 1922) 187 188 Gertrude Smith The demand in Greece for a revision and codification of the customary law was satisfied in the majority of cities in the course of the seventh century. 1 The codes originated not in the homeland, but in the colonies. 2 It is natural that the colonists, freed from the restraints of conservatism at home, should take the first step in the process of realizing their political aspirations 3 by substituting a set of rules binding upon all judges in place of the vague body of custom- ary law which could be modified and interpreted in the interest of the ruling class — the bribe-devouring judges of Hesiod. 4 In many cases codification was imperative because the members of a colony were recruited from different cities. Hence no single set of customary laws could be entirely satisfactory even if it proved suitable to the new conditions. The first codes were made in the western colonies which were farther from Greece than the eastern colonies both in distance and in the difficulty of the voyage. The western colonies were settled by Ionians, Dorians, and Achaeans. It is perhaps significant that each one of these races produced its own lawgiver, Zaleucus in Achaean Locris, 5 Charondas 1 In some cases the lawgiver had a twofold task to perform, since he reorganized the constitution in addition to writing a code. Such was the case with Pittacus of Mytilene; Lycurgus is reported to have changed the constitution, and the chief task of Pheidon of Cyme and his successor Prometheus was the remodeling of the consti- tution (Heracl. Pont. 11; cf. Holm, History of Greece, I, 270). When Draco did his work at Athens a fairly elaborate political system was already developed. The chapter of the Constitution of Athens which ascribes a constitution to Draco is now generally considered spurious (chap, iv; cf. Sandys, ad loc). Solon, however, entirely reorganized the constitution. 2 Cf. Meyer, Geschichte des Altertums, II, 566, for data on the lives of the various lawgivers. 3 In modern times there is the same tendency of a self-governing people, unhin- dered by external influences, to work out experiments in democracy. Australia and New Zealand furnish excellent examples. Cf. Bryce, Modern Democracies, II, 166 and 329. * Works and Days, 38-39. Cf. Bonner, "Administration of Justice in the Age of Hesiod," Classical Philology, VII. 23. The Locrians established laws in order to free themselves from civil discord (scholiast on Pindar Olymp. 10. 17). The work of Draco also was the result of contention between the nobility and the common people. Cf. Aristotle Ath. Pol. 2. 8 Aristotle (Pol. 1274, a 25) refers to Onomacritus the Locrian who was wrongly regarded by some (probably the reference is to Ephorus, cf. Newman, The Politics of Aristotle, II, 377) as the first person of note to draw up laws. He may be identical with the Athenian oracle monger of the age of Peisistratus. Cf. Newman, op. cit. II, 379. Early Greek Codes 189 in Ionian Catana, and Diodes in Dorian Syracuse. 1 The adoption of the laws of Charondas by the Ionian (Chalcidian) cities of Italy and Sicily is specifically mentioned by Aristotle. 2 These cities included Naxos, Zancle, Mylae, Himera in Sicily, Rhegium and possibly also Cyme in Italy. 3 Zaleucus' laws were adopted also in Sybaris and those of Diodes in other Sicilian cities. The fact that the Ionian colonies adopted the laws of Charondas suggests the possibility that the laws of Zaleucus were to be found in the other Achaean colonies of the west and those of Diodes in the Dorian colonies. The code of Charondas was introduced even into the island of Cos 4 and in Mazaka, a city of Cappadocia. 5 The Chalcidians of Thrace (Euboean Chalcidians) are said to have summoned Andro- damas from Chalcidian Rhegium to formulate laws for them. It is quite possible that he introduced the code of Charondas which was in force in his native city, although his name is connected with homicide laws which are not mentioned in the code of Charondas. 6 Other cities in Asia Minor and the islands produced their own lawgivers. Pittacus of Mytilene 7 established a code of laws for his native city and there is a bare reference to Aristides, the lawgiver of Ceos. 8 The code about which the most is known belongs to the city of Gortyn on the island of Crete. 9 The name of the lawgiver — if it be the work of an individual — is unknown. Various cities in the homeland had their own lawgivers. The institutions of Sparta were attributed to Lycurgus. But Spartan 1 Diodorus xii. 19; xiii. 35. For the dispute about the date of Diodes cf. Freeman, History of Sicily, III, 722 ff. Later Syracusan lawgivers are said by Diodorus to have been regarded merely as interpreters of Diodes' laws because of the ancient dialect in which they were written. 2 Pol. 1274, a 23 ff.; cf. Heracl. Pont. 25. 4. 3 Fully two centuries after the work of Zaleucus and Charondas was accom- plished the laws of one of the two are said to have been adopted by the mixed colony of the Thurians (founded 443 B.C.) on the founding of the colony. If it is true that one of the codes was adopted, the close proximity of the colony to Sybaris where the laws of Zaleucus were in force argues for the establishment of his code in Thurii. 4 Herondas 2. 46 ff. 8 Strabo xii. 2. 9. 6 Aristotle Pol. 1274, 6 23 ff. 7 Ibid. 1274, b 18; cf. Plutarch Sept. Sap. Conv. 13; Alcaeus Frag. 42. 8 Heracl. Pont. 9. 9 Plato, Laws 708, considered that the Gortynians had the highest character of all the Cretans. 190 Gertrude Smith laws were not reduced to writing. Athens is commonly supposed to have received her first code of laws at the hands of Draco. 1 Philolaus of Corinth made laws for the Thebans, 2 while the Corin- thians themselves were provided with a code by Pheidon. 3 The exact situation in Megara is not known, but from the statements of Theognis it is evident that a democracy must have prevailed there for a time during which the people acquired a written code of laws from some unknown lawgiver. 4 There are examples of lawgivers from all classes of society, but the majority were drawn from the middle class. This is natural, since the nobility were opposed to codification inasmuch as it deprived them of many privileges. Theognis makes strikingly clear the attitude of the nobles toward the new powers and privileges of the common people. His own sympathies were entirely with the nobility. There is no hope for the city in which the power has been transferred from the nobles (ol ayadoi) to the commons (oi nanoi). b Our commonwealth preserves its former frame Our common people are no more the same. They, that in skins and hides were rudely dress'd, Nor dreamt of law nor sought to be redress'd By rules of right, but in the days of old Flock'd to the town like cattle to the fold, Are now the brave and wise. And we, the rest (Their betters nominally, once the best), Degenerate, debased, timid and mean! Who can endure to witness such a scene ? Prompt to deride, to flatter and beguile! Their utter disregard of right or wrong, Of truth or honor! Theognis had a personal cause for grievance in the confiscation of his property. 6 Aristotle declares that the best lawgivers belonged to 1 Ancient writers ascribed to Athens the invention of lawsuits (Aelian V.H. iii. 38; cf. Lipsius, Attisches Rechl, p. 1). This does not mean, however, that they were the first people to have a written law. According to Strabo ( vi. 1.8) the western Locrians were the first Greeks to establish a written law. Cf. Scymnus of Chios 312 ff. 2 Aristotle Pol. 1274, b 2. 3 Ibid. 1265, b 12 ff. 4 289 ff . ; cf . 53 ff . 6 53 ff., Frere's translation. With the attitude of Theognis cf. that of the poet Alcaeus who lived in Mytilene at the time of Pittacus (Frag. 59). 6 Cf. 1200 ff. Early Gbkkk Codes 191 the middle class. In proof of this statement he offers as examples Solon, Lycurgus, and Charondas. 1 The accounts of Zaleucus' rank are contradictory. According to one story the laws were given to him in a dream by Athena while he was a poor shepherd. 2 But in the account given by Diodorus he is described as av-qp evyevijs ical Kara Traibdav Ttdav^aajxevos. 3 Pittacus was not himself of noble family, but he married a daughter of the tyrant Penthilos. In some cases the task of establishing a code of laws was intrusted to one of the citizens, specially chosen for the task, and vested also with some high office. So at Athens, Draco was a special thesmothete in 621 b.c, the year to which his legislation is generally assigned. Solon, chosen as SiaXXa/crfc to revise the laws and constitution, was appointed archon. 4 Pittacus is an illustration of an extraordinary magistrate intrusted with the making of laws. He was appointed supreme ruler of the city (aesymnetes) for a period of ten years in order to restore civil peace. In general with regard to the other lawgivers there is no information about the circumstances under which they were appointed or about the official positions which they held. It is hardly to be supposed that a foreigner called in to estab- lish a code of laws would be given any political authority. 5 The earliest laws were generally believed to be of divine origin. 8 For example Zeus was responsible for the Cretan laws, since Minos and Rhadamanthus received their inspiration directly from him. 7 1 Pol. 1296, a 18 ff.; cf. Alh. Pol. 5; Plutarch Solon i. 14 and 16; Lycurgus 3; Cleom. 10. 2 Scholiast, Pindar Olymp. 10. 17. 3 xii. 20. 4 Cf. F. D. Smith, Athenian Political Commissions, pp. 13 f., who sees in these two lawgivers the beginning of the commission principle. 6 Cf. Androdamas, who came from Rhegium to make laws for the Chalcidians in Thrace. 6 There appears always to have been a feeling that there was some inspired person back of the laws (Plato Apology 24 e). Cf. the famous personification of the laws in Crilo 50 a ff. 7 Plato Laws 624. Beloch believes that these early codes were really all attrib- uted to gods — even that of Draco (Griechische Gcschichte I, 1, 350). So the Cretans referred their laws to Minos, and as he was reduced from a god to a hero they said that the laws were given to him by Zeus. The Lacedaemonians considered their laws a revelation of the god of light. Tyrtaeus believed that they came from Delphi. This is due to the story which grew up after Lycurgus had been reduced to a hero that he received the sanction for his laws from the Delphic oracle. In the same way 192 Gertrude Smith The laws of the western Locrians were said to have been given to Zaleucus by Athena in a dream 1 after he had been appointed to frame a code of laws in answer to the response of the Delphic oracle. There are many tales also of the visits of lawgivers to foreign countries for the purpose of studying the institutions of other cities, both customary and recorded. For instance Zaleucus is reported by Ephorus to have taken his laws from Cretan, Spartan, and Athenian law. 2 According to Plutarch, 3 Lycurgus studied the institutions of Crete, Ionia, Egyptian cities, Libya, Iberia, and even India. Herodo- tus 4 states that the Spartan institutions came from Crete. Before drawing up his code Charondas examined the laws of many peoples and chose from them the best. 5 The early codes were doubtless based on traditional and cus- tomary law. 6 In procedure this dependence on customary law would be most marked. In the case of homicide there would be a tendency to adhere to the existing practice, inasmuch as the pro- cedure was ritualistic. Religious conservatism would tend to prevent innovations. It is quite obvious that Draco followed the practice of the time in his homicide laws. For example, he fails to indicate the nature and purpose of the oath which was to be Zaleucus is the " Hellstrahlende " and Charondas the "Hellaugige" — both sungods. Diocles of Syracuse was a god, since he had a temple in Syracuse and was worshiped as a hero at Thebes. Philolaus is also a figure of mythology. The most ancient laws of Athens were attributed to Draco, the serpent god, who was worshiped under the names of Erechtheus and Cecrops on the Acropolis and who was regarded as the founder of the state. 1 Scholiast, Pindar Olymp. 10. 17. Cf. Plutarch De se ips. laud. 11. 2 Strabo 260. Meyer believes that in this statement Ephorus was wrong. Gilbert (Beitrage, pp. 478 f.) on the other hand argues that Ephorus' statement is sound, inasmuch as identical provisions are found in Cretan and Locrian law and also in Athenian and Locrian law. But according to this method of reasoning all of the early codes could be assumed to be related, for similar provisions occur in many of them. 3 Lycurgus 4. * 1. 65 ff. 6 With these tales may be compared the alleged embassy of the Romans to Athens at the time of the decemviral legislation. Cf. Jefferson Elmore, The Purpose of the Decemviral Legislation, Classical Philology, XVII, 131 ff. Cf. also Beauchet, Histoire 6m droit privi des Alheniens, I, xxiii, and Hofmann, BeitriXge zur Geschichte des griechischen und rb'mischen Rechts, pp. 1 ff. 6 In some cases there would be some written material available for the lawgiver. The work of the Thesmothetae, for instance, may have afforded Draco some material as a basis for his work. Their task consisted partly in recording judicial decisions. Early Greek Codes 193 taken by the relatives of the deceased when they started the prose- cution. This oath must already have been in use. 1 His omission of the formula of the interdict to be pronounced against an alleged murderer shows that the interdict was already known and used. 2 Similarly his failure to mention the participation of the king archon in the interdict is further evidence to the same effect. 3 It may well be also that the procedure used at Cyme in homicide trials, that is the evidentiary oath with oath helpers, 4 represents customary practice which was seized upon by the legislator and introduced into the code. It is quite probable that the tendency, observable in homi- cide cases, to make use of a procedure which was already familiar spread to other types of cases also. As to substantive law there is no actual instance of the perpetuation of customary law in written form. On the other hand, there are several indications that early legislation was not a mere record of customary law. The fact that in general the lawgivers were regarded as inspired would seem to indicate that their laws were quite different from the customary law. The new conditions both political and social had to be met by many new provisions. Thus Charondas is said to have invented many new provisions. 5 To the common belief in the divine origin of their laws is prob- ably due the reluctance of the Greeks to alter them. 6 At any rate there are provisions in some of the codes which rendered it extremely difficult to change the laws. There was a provision in Locris that if anyone wished to introduce a new law or to change an old one he 1 CIA i. 61. 16 ff. The phrase tot opkov is used as if it were a familiar oath. 2 Ibid. 20 ff. It is of course possible that there was no standardized formula for the interdict. Cf. Demosthenes Leplines 158; Pollux 8. 66. 3 Ibid. 20 ff. Aristotle says expressly that he made the proclamation (Ath. Pol. 57. 2 ; cf . Pollux 8. 90) . In view of the conservative character of procedure in homi- cide courts it is likely that Aristotle is right even for the early period. 4 Cf. infra, p. 197, n. 1. 5 Diodorus xii. 11. According to Aristotle (Pol. 1325, a) it was the duty of a good legislator to examine his state and the nature of his people and likewise their relations with neighbors in order to satisfy their needs by his laws. 6 Cf. Stobaeus Flor. 44. 21, where he records a provision of Zaleucus which was passed as a protection for the laws and the state: Mr/Seh Si Xeyiru kokus, jui?t« koipjj tt)v ttoKiv, nr}T€ idiq. Toy iroXtrijc. dXX' ol t&v vbfxoiv <£u\cuces kTifXi\el(rdo>aav toiv ttA^jum*- \ovvtoiv, TrpaTOV fiki> vovBtTOVVTts, iav 5i /ir) weiffavrai., fji^toSvres. 194 Gertrude Smith had to argue the matter with a rope about his neck before the council of 1,000. If the council voted against him he was choked to death on the spot. 1 Only one law was so changed during a period of 200 years. 2 Diodorus ascribes a similar provision to Charondas. 3 He says that only three laws were ever changed by this procedure at Catana. The work of the lawgiver was made possible by the discovery and diffusion of the art of writing. 4 The laws were regularly recorded on the walls of some public building or on separate steles set up in a public place. The extant fragment of the laws of Draco is a later copy of the homicide laws on stone, but there is no reason to suppose that they were not published in the same way in the time of Draco. Solon's laws were carved on wooden pillars called KvpPeis because of their shape, and also al-ovts from the fact that they could be turned round. They were set up in the aroa )3a7)