STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE SYCOPHANT-PARASITE By J. O. Lofbbbq The writer has already made a detailed study of the important role of the crvKofyavTai in Athens. 1 The material for this study was drawn almost entirely from Aristophanes and the orators, and no effort was made to carry it beyond the period of Demosthenes. It is the purpose of the present article to note what light later writers, especially those of the New Comedy and Plautus and Terence, 2 throw on the subject. The value of such an extension of the study will be evident. These writers offer us the opportunity of looking at Athenian institutions from a different angle. The subject-matter of a comedy of manners of necessity furnishes some details not else- where found. They also give us a picture of an Athens different in many respects from the Athens of Pericles or even of the days of Demosthenes. Before proceeding to a discussion of what they con- tribute to this study it will be well to give a brief summary of the activities of the cvKo^avTai in the earlier period. Wealthy and non- litigious Athenians were rather at the mercy of these shrewd legal tricksters. 3 Payment of blackmail was a safer method of answering their threats of litigation than appearance in court; the popular courts were not disposed to favor a rich man, and therein lay the strength of the sycophant. 4 Familiarity with the courts rendered them formidable as witnesses 6 and advocates (avvfiyopoi).* As informers (ji-qwrai) they terrified guilty and innocent. 7 Through club organizations, permanent 8 or temporary, 9 they strengthened 1 Sycophancy in Athens, University of Chicago dissertation, 1917. 2 The use of the Roman writers as proper sources for this information can hardly be questioned. It has received the firm support of such a careful scholar as Philippe Legrand, Daos, p. 3 and chap. ii. Cf. also Lallier, "Le Proces de Phormion," in the Annuaire de V Association des Etudes Grecques, XII (1878), 49 ff. 3 See Sycophancy in Athens, pp. 32 ff., for details and references. 4 Ibid., p. 15. 6 Ibid., p. 54. 6 Ibid., p. 53. 7 Notably the hireling Dioclides And. i. 37. 8 The best known are the club of Menicles and Mnesicles (Dem. 39 and 40) and that of Melas (Isaeus 5). For full discussion and references see Sycophancy in Athens, pp. 59 ff . ; Calhoun, Athenian Clubs in Politics and Litigation, pp. 80 et passim. 9 Of this the cabal against Andocides is a good example (And. i. 121; Sycophancy in Athens, p. 67). [Classical Philology XV, January, 1920] 61 62 J. O. Lopberg their power and insured the success of their machinations. Acting alone or in groups they frequently served as the hired agents of others. In this capacity they were effective in bringing suits against personal or political enemies; in introducing laws and decrees; in acting as witnesses or advocates; in bribing juries and ecclesiasts. 1 Sycophanta impudens was apparently a stock character in the New Comedy. 2 This in itself is a fairly clear indication that the syc- ophant was still an active member of Athenian society. The Greek original of the Persa was composed at a time when their activities were still excessive. At least the author feels justified in making a direct attack upon them through the mouth of one of his leading characters. 3 Plautus, it is true, calls them not sycophantae but quadrupulatores. However, there can scarcely be any doubt that Plautus was merely translating his Greek original in this pas- sage and not commenting on a situation that obtained in Rome. Leo has shown 4 that the legal process mentioned in this passage is really Athenian and that the quadrupulatores are really avTai. The Greek original of this play was probably written before the con- quests of Alexander. 5 Such being the case, it is easily understood that the sycophants should still be the object of direct attack. There is a similar faithfulness to the Greek original in Plautus' treatment of the advocati in the Poenulus. They are typical Athenian ffwriyopoi (advocati) and naprvpes and belong to the class of hirelings that were regarded as sycophants. 6 A glance at the episode will make this clear. They are regular men-of-the-courts (comitiales) , more regular even than the judges (praetor).'' When there is no litigation they "cook it up"; they are in the habit of persecuting rich men. 8 They show great ingenuity in introducing to the leno 1 See Sycophancy in Athens, pp. 48 f., for discussion and references. It is obviously impossible to treat the matter adequately here. 2 Terence Heaut. Prol. 38; Legrand, op. cit., p. 281. s Plautus Persa 62 ft* . 4 Plautinische Forschungen (2d ed.), pp. 123 ft*. For suggestions as to the reason for using the term guadrupulator instead of sycophanta see below, p. 69. 5 Legrand, op. cit., p. 18. 6 Legrand, op. cit., p. 52; Sycophancy in Athens, pp. 53 ff. 7 Plautus Poenulus 584 f . 8 Ibid. 517. The Sycophant-Parasite 63 the fake-foreigner who is to prove his undoing; 1 information that they happen to have can easily be purchased. 2 They render assist- ance to Agorastocles in getting his slave out of the house of the leno and make themselves generally useful. 3 It is quite clear that they were usually paid for their services and expected to receive pay on this occasion. 4 One of Terence's characters fears to lay claim to the estate of a deceased relative lest he be branded sycophanta. 6 We are not dependent upon the Latin versions of the Greek comedies for information about the continued prevalence of the sycophant. In Menander's Georgos a man bewails the disadvantage under which a poor man labors (in the courts, apparently) ; no matter how just his case may be, it is impossible to convince people that his whole purpose is not personal gain; avTr}s is the name given to a man with a threadbare suit, regardless of the justice of his case. 6 Another of Menander's characters moralizes on the unfairness of this life; decency and honesty go unrewarded and rascality has the upper hand: "Best of all fares the /c6Aa£ and second best the avKoavTijs." 7 So also in a fragment of Philippides we are told that the most violent sycophant will become as gentle as a lamb if you hand him a mina or two. 8 Theopompus in his Philippica? reports with apparent serious- ness the founding of a City of Rascals, 10 by Philip, for sycophants, false witnesses, and advocates. Elsewhere 11 he states that Athens was full of flatterers, sailors, pickpockets, false witnesses, and syco- phants. It is uncertain, perhaps, to what period of Athenian history he is here referring, but it is not unfair to assume that it deals with the latter part of the fourth century B.C. 12 Democracy was the soil in which sycophancy nourished. There- fore with the decline of democratic institutions which followed Philip » Ibid. 650 ff. 2 Ibid. 770 ff. 3 Ibid. 785. 4 Ibid. 807-10. 6 Andria 815. 6 Frag. 1 (reference is to Koerte, Editio Maior). 7 Frag. 223. s Frag. 29. 9 Frag. 107. It is not begging the question to assume that the majority of the inhabitants of such a city would hail from Athens. Where else in Greece did they flourish with such success ? 10 IIoowmWus. u Frag. 267. 12 See Legrand, op. cit., p. 281. 64 J. 0. LOFBERG and Alexander there came naturally limitations in the sycophants' sphere of activity. There still existed numerous opportunities for false accusation, professional advocacy, false witness, and blackmail, but it is doubtful if sycophants could rise to such positions of impor- tance as some had held in the older Athens. 1 Opportunities to sell their services to revolutionary parties, 2 to use their talents in attacks on men in high political office, 3 or to engage in activities of public nature would be few. It was rather the day of the petty sycophant, the €^TeXijs, to borrow Crito's term. 4 Between this type and those who hunted bigger game there is obviously no essential difference. It is in fact not unlikely that often the more prominent were also eureXeis. However, the New Comedy offers more information about the cheap hireling, whose chief occupation was to act as the ready agent for others, and less about those who engaged in litigation on their own initiative or even those who practiced blackmail. As has been suggested above, Athenians who wished to avoid the incon- venience or notoriety connected with any transaction found the sycophant a convenient agent. Often the business to be performed involved connection with the courts. For other affairs, however, no matter how trivial, the versatile petty sycophant was equally avail- able. Indications are not lacking in the orators of such use of the sycophants. Remarkably versatile agents are Pythodorus, 5 an assistant of Pasion, Stephanus, 6 who was the efficient helper of Phormio, and Aristophon. 7 The latter belonged to a group of HoxOyp&v avdp&wuv who hung around the Piraeus looking for employment of this sort. Real life in Athens and the life depicted in the New Comedy may not exactly correspond. There are undoubtedly exaggerations. We meet certain episodes, incidents, and characters more often than we should in real life. In the main, however, there is no violence 1 See the careers of Theocrines (Dem. 58) and Aristogiton (Dem. 25 ; 26) in Syco- phancy in Athena, pp. 78 ff. 2 See the career of Agoratua (Lysias 13) in Sycophancy in Athens, pp. 72 ff. 3 Both Aristogiton and Theocrines boasted of doing this. 4 Plato Crito 45 A. 5 Isoc. 17. 4 et passim. • Dem. 45, 57-58, 64. 7 Dem. 32, 10-12 et passim. The Sycophant-Pakasite 65 done to realism, 1 and it is safe to regard the behavior of the people in the comedies as a fair sample of what really went on in Athens. Apparently trickery of a more or less harmless nature played a large part in the life of the average Athenian family. The senex credulus, the leno, and the miles gloriosus were the natural targets of deception. Often clever and resourceful slaves invented the schemes and carried them out, as in the Andria, with no other considerable assistance. At other times, however, assistants were required. When necessary they were hired. This was especially true when some- one was desired to represent the "stranger from abroad." The best instance of this is found in the Trinummus. It may be well to note the plot in some detail. Megaronides and Callicles, two elderly Athenians, decide to use a little harmless deception upon young Les- bonicus, the son of their old friend, Charmides. The latter's property during his absence from Athens has been practically ruined through the recklessness of his son, Lesbonicus. This Lesbonicus has a sister who is sought in marriage by Lysiteles. The brother, her patronus in the absence of the father, has no objection to the match, but his pride forces him to withhold his consent to the wedding unless Lysiteles will accept as dowry the only remaining piece of land that belongs to Charmides. The prospective bridegroom refuses to do this. At this juncture Megaronides and Callicles, who know of a buried treasure in the house of Charmides, hit upon a plan to bring about the marriage. They propose to hire a sycophant 2 to pose as a messenger from Lesbonicus' father. He is to bring letters to Les- bonicus and to Callicles. 3 In the former's letter is to be a statement that the messenger brings a bag of gold from Charmides to Callicles to be used as a marriage portion for the daughter. Their plan is, of course, to dig up some of the treasure and give that as the dowry. As their agent they choose aliquem mendaciloquem i .... falsidicum, confidentem 6 .... sycophantam .... deforo. 6 The timely arrival 1 Legrand, op. eit., pp. 264 ff., especially p. 287. 2 Plaut. Trin. 765 ff., 815. 8 It is noteworthy that they did not intrust the money to the sycophant to give to Lesbonicus. The character of neither was suited to such a scheme. * Plaut. Trin. 769. 6 Ibid. 770. • Ibid. 815. This reminds us of the implication of litigation that was involved in the term iyopaios. Cf. also &• &yopas Arist. Knights 180. 66 J. O. LOFBERG of Charmides just as the sycophant is trying to deliver his letter to Lesbonicus supplies us with one of the best dialogues in all Latin comedy. 1 A large part of its excellence is due to the wit and clever sparring of the sycophant, and this in turn indicates clearly the suita- bility of the. sycophant for his job. It is quite obvious that any clever person unknown to Lesbonicus could have played the part of this messenger from foreign parts and that it was not imperative that a professional hireling be found. But the reason for his being used is that there were so many triflers 2 loitering about the agora looking for such employment that it was easier to pay a small 3 sum to one of them than to hunt up some unknown non-professional per- son to play the part. The plot of the Pseudolus also calls for someone to masquerade as a foreigner. The intention seems to be to hire a sycophant. 4 This, however, is rendered unnecessary in this instance. One of the characters offers the services of a newly acquired slave, who is un- known to the leno and who therefore runs slight risk of discovery. 5 He also fortunately possesses the same qualifications 6 for the part that the professional hireling of the Trinummus does. 7 It would, of course, be absurd to assume that the comedies supply statistical material about the number of sycophants or their activities. Both their presence and their behavior in the plays are matters of convention. But the readiness to call any unknown person who is suspected of playing a part sycophanta is a clear indication of the extent to which men were hired to perpetrate tricks of this sort. One of the best instances of this is found in the Pseudolus. Simia, the "slave-sycophant" 8 mentioned above, was so successful in passing 1 Plaut. Trin. 843 ff. 2 nugator, ibid., 1138. 'He himself admits that his pay is small: subigor trium nummum (848). Cf. Crito's eireXtis. * Plaut. Pseud. 724. 6 Ibid. 729-30. « Ibid. 725, 729, 739-41, 1017 ff. 7 Similarly in the Persa and in the Poenulus the masqueraders are slaves. In the former this is practicable because the leno who is to be tricked is a recent arrival in Athens. In the latter a vilicus who is in town for the day is naturally employed. In both of these cases sycophantia is the term applied to the trick: Persa 325; Poenulus 425. 8 Argumentum ii. 14, sycophanta cacula. The exact reading is uncertain. He is also called sycophanta in the scene heading. The Sycophant-Parasite 67 himself off as Harpax, 1 the messenger from "the captain," that when the real Harpax arrived he was welcomed by the leno as an imposter made up to play the part, 2 called an out-and-out sycophant, 3 and told that men of that profession would find business dull there that day. 4 Not only did sycophanta come to be the regular word for swindler and imposter, 6 but a similar change took place in the use of kindred words. Sycophantia was often merely a synonym for trickery, 6 deception, and "bluff," and was interchangeable with faUacia, doli, or nugae. 7 This change of meaning is not limited to the Latin words. avTttv is used by Menander 8 just as sycophantari is by Plautus. 9 Outside of comedy we find the term used with force of "perverting facts," 10 misrepresenting a matter," and even for a "logical fallacy." 12 This is not far removed from the loose use of avTeiv by litigants in the orators to imply that their opponents are attacking on slight provocation. A dialogue in the Samia offers an excellent opportunity for the study of this use of the word: De. 8' 4t' eXevOipav yvvatKa \anfihvas /SaKriJpioi' Kal dibuceis; Ni. (rvKo^avrels. 13 Will you take a stick to a free woman and run her off ? You're a liar! Here ffVKo^avrelt approaches the somewhat technical "That's blackmail!" but there is no suggestion of litigation. 14 1 Plautus Pseud. 963 ff. * Ibid. 1184 ff. » Ibid. 1200. 4 Ibid. 1197. A similar comic effect is obtained in Trinurnmus 972 when the syco- phant calls Charmides a trickster because he insists that he is Charmides. 6 Plautus Arnph. 506 gives a striking use of the term. There it applied to Zeus playing a part. Cf. Plautus Menaech. 260, 283, 1087; Poen. 1032; Pseud. 1204. •Plautus Asin. 71; Aid. 649; Bacch. 764, 806; Capt. 521; Miles 767; Pers. 325; Poen. 425, 654; Pseud. 527, 572. 7 Plautus Pseud. 485, 672, 1204; Trin. 856, 972. 8 Epitrepontes 1; Periceiromene 178 (references are to Koerte, Editio Maior). ' Trin. 787, 958. 10 Dem. 19, 98. « Dem. 23, 61. n Aristotle Rhetoric II. 24. 10. Aeschines (2. 99) states that the term auxo^&j'rijs had come to be applied to all scoundrels. 13 Menander Samia 232. 14 It is quite obvious that there is a conscious punning use of legal vocabulary in Sut>K€lS .... aVT(is. 68 J. 0. LOFBEEG The most easily employed agent that a family of wealth could find was naturally the parasite. Men of this profession admitted that they were available for any service. 1 The parasite Artotrogus is sent by Pyrgopolynices to conduct the latrones that he had collected to Seleucus. 2 The wife of Epigonus sends the family dependent (parasite) Gelasimus to the harbor for news of her husband.* The parasite in the Asinaria is his master's clerk. 4 Curculio is a very efficient agent for Phaedromus. He goes on a mission to borrow money for his rex. 6 To further the latter's interests 6 he steals an important seal ring, 7 connives at a forgery, 8 and is ready to serve as witness in a "shady" affair. 9 His master unquestionably has, in the words of the Choregus, acquired nugatorem lepidum .... halo- phantam an sycophantam. 10 This identification of the parasite with the sycophant was but natural. The only essential difference was in the remuneration they received. This very difference rendered the parasite a much more "comic" character than the sycophant. An edax parasitus would provoke more laughter on the stage than sycophanta impudens. 11 And since they were practically alike in methods, availability, and general character, 12 and since the parasite was an established convention in the New Comedy, 13 a playwright could easily motivate his presence in a comedy by letting him serve as Jack-of-all-trades. This confusion in everyday life between sycophanta and parasitus naturally affected the semitechnical force 1 Vid. Legrand, op. tit., pp. 94-95 with references. 2 Plautus Miles 948. It matters little that this may not be at all the mission on which he had been sent. For the present purpose it is enough to observe that he was the natural one to send on a mission. 3 Plautus Stichus 150. In this instance it may well be that the only reason for sending the parasite was to get him on the stage (see Prescott, "The Interpretation of Roman Comedy," Class. Phil., XI, 136-37). The audience was apparently accus- tomed to a parasite's being sent on errands. * Plautus Asinaria 746 ff. 6 Plautus Cure. 67. 6 Ibid. 329 ff. 7 Ibid. 360. s Ibid. 365. 9 Ibid. 62. 10 Ibid. 462 f. There is remarkable similarity in all this between Curculio's methods and activities and those of the sycophant-agents, Stephanus (Dem. 45, 57-58), Fythodorus (Isoc. 17. 4, 23, 33-34). a Terence Heaut. Prol. 38. 12 Cf. Leo, op. tit., p. 125, "der Sycophant und Parasit aber sind gerade in der KomOdie Charaktere derselben Sphare, oft in einer Person vereinigt." 18 See Legrand, op. tit., pp. 292 f., with references cited. The Sycophant-Pakasite 69 of the former term. It was inevitable that a cheap hireling should become a flatterer. 1 Omnia assentari 2 is no more characteristic of a Gnatho who is known by the title of kolax* than of a Curculio who may be called a sycophant. 4 This situation probably explains why Plautus (Pers. 62 ff.) used quadrupulator and quadrupulari instead of sycophanta and sycophantari. A parasite is speaking. Sycophanta and parasitus so often had the same connotation that there would have been slight point in his insisting that he did not wish to be sycophanta. His intention is to make it perfectly clear that he does not care to copy those of his profession who engage in litigation and blackmail (cf. Leo, op. cit., p. 125). It might be added that the force of sycophanta suggested, as has been shown, swindler rather than pettifogger. Many individuals called parasites by a playwright would doubt- less be known as sycophants in real life. Phormio is really an excel- lent example of an expert sycophant of the old school, bonorum extorter, legum contortor. 5 He would surely have been so called by Aristophanes, and the commentary of Donatus does give him this name on several occasions. 6 Any man so expert in litigation and such a source of concern to the wealthy would have been a welcome mem- ber of the club of sycophants headed by Menecles and Mnesicles. 7 Terence, however, calls him a parasite in spite of the fact that, barring a few mild passages, 8 there is little to justify the term, if he is to be 1 Efforts have been made to classify parasites. Giese, De parasiti persona capita selecta (Berlin, 1908), p. 22, distinguishes three kinds: those antiquioris generis, the hungry, dirty sort; the assentator who attends a miles gloriosus; those similes servis illis callidissimis comoediae novae. Cf. also Ribbeck, Kolax (Abhandlungen der k. s&chsi- echen Ges. der Wiss., IX [1884], 27). There may be varying degrees of servility dis- cernible, but there is nothing that prevents one type from merging in another. If it were possible to draw a hard-and-fast distinction, it would be convenient to say that those that Giese puts in his third class were really the sycophant-parasites whom we have been describing. 2 Terence Eun. 253. 4 Plautus Cure. 463. * Terence Eun. Prol. 30. 6 Terence Phormio 374. e Donatus on Phormio 279, 319, 352. Modern commentators frequently recognize the sycophantic characteristics in Phormio even when they continue to refer to him as a parasite: Legrand, op. cit., p. 93; Dziatzko-Hauler, p. 70, n. 1, "Halb Parasit, halb Sycophant" ; Fredershausen, De iure Plautino et Terentiano 70; Leo, op. cit., p. 125, "der Sycophant und Parasit aber sind gerade in der Komddie Charaktere derselben Sphare, oft in einer Person vereinigt, wie tor allem Phormio zeigt." 7 Dem. 39 and 40; Sycophancy in Athens, pp. 60 ff. 8 Terence Phormio 335, alere nolunt hominem edacem; 337 ff. ; 1052, me ad cenam voca. 70 J. 0. LOFBERG considered a typical hungry parasite. There is even a tradition that Terence gave enthusiastic approval when his magister gregis, in acting the part of Phormio, represented him as a fawning K6Xa£, and that the author said that such was his idea of the part. 1 So strong was the demand for that type of character on the stage. 2 This play furnishes a good opportunity for observing how a sycophant, and that, too, one who was too prominent to be called evTekfc, succeeded in becoming attached as parasite to a well-to-do family. Phormio was apparently well known about town as a suc- cessful pettifogger, 3 a dread of the wealthy and non-litigious, 4 and an expert in legal trickery. 6 Phaedria and Antipho naturally turn to him for a solution of their difficulties. 6 His management, not only of the legal side of their affairs, but of all their schemes, of which he was the author, 7 was successful. 8 He had been unknown to the elders of the family previous to his employment by the young men, 9 but he had little difficulty in winning the position of hanger-on. He was more acceptable as friend than foe. It was unwise for a family with skeletons in its closets to have an outsider, so able and unscrupu- lous, familiar with its affairs. The immediate cause of his success was a trick that seems to have been a favorite with parasites. He brought over to his side the ill-used wife of the senex by informing her 1 Donatus on Phormio 315. On the occasion referred to the actor was drunk and his delineation of the part was partly due to his condition. 2 From one point of view the New Comedy ridicules the parasite in very much the same way that the Old Comedy attacked the sycophant; the parasite in the Persa argues for the dignity of his "profession" in the following manner: "The old calling of my forefathers do I follow and cultivate with great care. For never was there any one of my forefathers who did not fill his belly by acting the parasite; father, grand- father, great grandfather, great-great grandfather, his grandfather and great grand- father, like mice always fed on the victuals of others" (52 ft.). In Aristophanes' Birds (1432 ff., 1451 ff.) it is the sycophant who refuses to give up his profession. He had it from his father, who got it from his, who in turn got it from his; to give it up would be to disgrace his ancestors. ' Phormio 327 ff., 122-23. * Ibid. 330 ff ., 623, 766 ff. 5 Ibid. 125 ff., 330 ff. 6 Ibid. 122 ff., 560 f. 7 Ibid. 130 ff., 317, 650 ff. 8 Cf. the sycophants Menecles and Mnesicles and their activities in Dem. 39; 40. • Ibid. 307, 618, 991. The Stcophant-Paeasite 71 of her husband's deliction. 1 This caused a speedy change in the attitude of the old men toward him, and the play closes with his installation as amicus and parasitus. 2 Roughly speaking, the term sycophant may be applied to an agent employed for some particular business, parasite to one who serves one or several patrons regularly. To the latter class belongs Phormio. 3 A striking parallel to all this, that has apparently been overlooked, is found in Xenophon's Memorabilia*' Socrates persuades Crito to employ a "watch-dog" to keep off the sycophants that beset him. 8 Archedemus is the man chosen. Like Phormio, he is "poor but able." 6 Although he is not called by the name of sycophant, he is clearly one of their kind. 7 Crito is in constant fear that he may turn upon him, and for that reason does his utmost to keep his good-will. 8 So Chremes finds Phormio a dangerous enemy. 9 Archedemus undertakes to protect Crito's friends also from legal difficulties, 10 just as Phormio proves himself the efficient manager of the affairs of several members of one family and apparently of several families. 11 Phormio felt no hesitation in admitting that the title of parasite applied to him. 12 Archedemus was twitted about his servility cbs wro Kpircows fofrekobftevos KoXeuce&oi avrdv 13 and justified his position by maintaining that it was less disgraceful to be friends of the -xptiaroi than of the irovqpoi. 1 Ibid. 985 ff.; cf. Plautus Menaech. 519; cf. Asin. 810. 2 Phormio 1049, 1053, me ad cenam voca. 8 Terence Phormio 122, "est parasitus quidam Phormio, homo confidens" implies either that he was a professional hanger-on or else the term means little else than adventurer or hireling. * Memorabilia ii. 9. 6 Ibid. ii. 9. 1-3. * Ibid. ii. 9. 4, Ucavdv tltretp rt koX irpafyu, irkvriTa Si. Cf. Terence Phormio 902, haec mea paupertas. Proof of his ability has already been given. 7 It was his reputation for shrewdness in litigation that got him his position with Crito. Cf. also his methods, ii. 9. 5-6. 8 Ibid. 9. 3-5. 8 Terence Phormio 980 ff., 900 ff. « Terence Phormio 122 et passim. 10 Xen. Mem. ii. 9. 7-8. " Ibid. 335 ff., 345. 13 Xen. Mem. ii. 9. 8. The use of nokaictboi is significant. It is in a sense the fore- runner of the freer use of «6XaJ and vapiuriros. It is also interesting to notice that a part of Archedemus' salary was produce from Crito's farm and an occasional invita- tion to dinner (sec. 4). Cf. Ter. Phormio 1053, me ad cenam voca. 72 J. O. LOFBERG The New Comedy shows us the following things in regard to this phase of life in Athens: 1. The survival of sycophants of the old school, formidable experts in litigation, false witness, advocacy, and blackmail, e.g., the advocati of the Poenulus, and especially Phormio. 2. A noticeable change in the meaning of the term avuocfr&vTris. Its technical and litigious connotation is giving way to a new mean- ing, "imposter" or "swindler." 3. The consequent practical identity of sycophant and parasite. A cheap hireling loses independence and keeps his job only by flattery. The parasites of whom Curculio is a type are not distinguishable from sycophants. 4. The greater comic possibility in a parasite as compared to a sycophant. The only important difference between petty sycophants and parasites is the form of remuneration for their services. The fondness for a meal is more suitable for comic effect than the willing- ness to work even for "three pieces of money" (Trinummus). There is therefore a tendency to put a parasite rather than a sycophant into a New Comedy. 5. The tendency to consider a permanent agent a parasite. The distinctive parasite qualities are entirely lacking in Phormio. Except for an occasional use of the term and a few references to the pleasures of a meal and the blessed lot of the parasite, there is nothing about Phormio to justify the term. The fact that he is a regular and per- manent assistant helps to confuse him with men of that class. University op Texas