STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE EXPULSION OF JEWS FROM ROME UNDER TIBERIUS By Elmee Tbtjesdell Merrill A noteworthy incident in the reign of Tiberius (19 a.d.) is mentioned by more than one ancient writer,' but with difference of detail in the accounts, and without any comment on the puzzling questions it suggests — ^wherein they are followed by recent editors of their works. Modern historians do better than this, but none that have come to the attention of the present writer appear to deal with it in full appreciation of the problems involved. The conversion to Judaism of a highly placed Roman matron, and the subsequent embezzlement by a gang of Jewish rascals of munificent gifts they had solicited from her for the Temple at Jeru- salem, had so angered Tiberius that he resolved upon drastic action. Probably other unrecorded scandals had contributed to his frame of mind. The matter was laid before the senate, apparently with the recommendation by the emperor of the course to be followed. In accordance therewith 4,000 resident Jews of military age {quis idonea aetas, Tac. ; iuuentutem, Suet.) were drafted into the service, and sent to do guard-duty against the banditti in the fever-haunted island of Sardinia {in prouincias grauioris caeli, Suet.). All other Jews were to depart from Italy, unless they would abjure their faith. There is an additional statement in Josephus that the con- suls punished (perhaps as mutineers with death) a great number of other Jews (presumably of the same status as the 4,000 conscripts) who were unwilling to serve, and pleaded in excuse the necessity that rested upon them of keeping the laws of their forefathers. It may well be that in reality they alleged an established privilege of exemption from such duty. The three ancient accounts (the alleged reference by Philo is too uncertain in interpretation to be cited, and the others too brief), by their general outline of agreement, and by the conjoined reference in all to action taken against certain other cults, show indu- bitably that they were derived ultimately from the same source, ' loseph. Ant. xviii. 3. 5; Tac. Ann. ii. 85; Suet. Tib. 36; Philo Leg. ad Gaium 24 (159-61); Sen. Ep. 108.22; Dio C. Ivii. 18. [Classical Philology XIV, October, 1919] 365 366 Elmkb Truesdell Merrill and refer to the same event, and that the differences between them are due in the first instance to the choice by each writer of the ele- ments in the tale that most appealed to him. The accounts are to be treated as supplementing and interpreting one another. It of course is not to be denied that the careless imagination of each writer may have exerted some influence on his picture of the event. Ancient historians were not always scrupulously accurate and self- restrained in the use of their sources. When Tacitus speaks of the 4,000 as "tainted with this superstition" {ea superstitione infecta), and says the rest (ceteri) were to be expelled, he certainly means only that these persons were all of the Jewish religion, not neces- sarily that they were all of Jewish blood, still less that they were all proselytes. The number of the conscripts as 4,000 is given by both Josephus and Tacitus. There may of course be some error in the tradition of the numeral in their common source, but the number is not incredible or even suspicious in itself, especially if libertini generis, by which phrase Tacitus describes these men, is properly understood. What, then, did Tacitus mean by these words? Do they form merely a Tacitean variation for "freedmen," plain and simple, or does the phrase mean a class of freedmen and their de- scendants? The particular combination appears to be used by Tacitus in only one other place, ' where he speaks of a single person, a scoundrelly contractor, as Atilius quidam libertini generis. In the case of the 4,000 there might appear to be a prompting to the use of the variation in place of the single word libertinorum, in that he is speaking of a large number of persons taken together. But in the instance of Atihus no such reason is apparent for the use of a mere periphrasis (if Atilius was indeed himseK a libertinus, about which point we have no knowledge). Yet it might be asked whether Tacitus could have had a concept of freedmen and their descendants as constituting a social or political class such as might naturally be designated in this manner. The question may with much probabihty be answered in the affirmative. In the time of the Republic a slave set free by his master, a Roman citizen, became thereby himself a Roman citizen, and manumissions by living masters or by will appear to have been frequent. Yet even then 1 Tac. Ann. iv. 62. But cf . such expressions as Ann. vi. 15. 3 plebeii generis , "of plebeian descent." ExPTJiiSioN OF Jews fbom Rome undkb Tiberius 367 it took a couple of generations for the stain of slave origin to dis- appear,* and no one can imagine that, even in a country where slaves were not regularly (as they were in the United States of America) of an inferior race, a record of recent slave ancestry would socially be regarded as an utterly indifferent thing, although it carried with it no formal disabilities. By laws passed in the reign of Augustus (leges Aelia-Sentia, 4 a.d., Furia-Caninia, 8 a.d. [?]) and of Tiberius (lunia-Norbana, 19 a.d.) the right of manumission was distinctly — some would say drastically — limited, and grave political disabilities were laid upon the shoulders of freedmen. Chief among them was the very important one that the manumitted slave no longer became ipso facto a Roman citizen, but probably in most cases gained only the lesser rights of Latin citizenship. His children inherited his status. In the persons of such dues Latini was certainly thus established something that might properly be called a class (genus), a distinct group with hereditary character- istics; and Tacitus, who felt an ardent aversion for the sort of people that had furnished the emperors whom he hated with some of the most ready tools and emblems of their tyranny, surely might most naturally speak of men who either were themselves freedmen, or were in no long descent from slaves, by the scornful class appellation of libertini generis. In the case of these Jews Tacitus would have a double reason for his scorn, for he also appears to have despised the race. It is likely, then, that he uses the phrase in this sense. What other brief expression was naturally available for the postulated purpose ? That the number of freedmen in Rome was very great may be inferred not merely from the immense number of slaves, which aroused the anxious fears of the government,^ and from the fre- quency of manumission, but from the fact also that Augustus thought it necessary to check its increase. In the case of the Jews the pro- portion of freedmen to the rest of the Jewish populace of the capital 1 Cf . Mommsen, Staatsrecht, III, p. 422, n. 3. It may pertinently be noted that a fair inference from a passage in Suetonius (Claud. 24) is that in the censorship of Appius Claudius Caecus (312 b.o.) the son of a freedman was himself called libertinus. How much longer the custom continued it is impossible to say, Suetonius being the sole authority for the fact. Maecenas, according to Horace, was strikingly liberal in not asking about the status of a man's father, if the man himself was freeborn; but Maecenas would not admit a libertinus to his friendship. * Cf., e.g., Tac. Ann. iii. 53; iv. 27; and Wallon, Histoire de Vesdavage, II, chap. 3. 368 ElMEK TrUESDELL MERRIIiL was probably greater than in the case of people of other religions; for Philo, a contemporary witness, after commenting on the great size of the Jewish colony in Rome in the time of Augustus, says that the majority of it was composed of freedmen, captives in war, who had been brought thither as slaves, and later set free by their masters.^ (This statement, however, taken as it stands, must cer- tainly be an exaggeration. Philo perhaps, like Tacitus, is including in his general class both freedmen and those descended from freed- men.) It is not remarkable, then, that of Jewish freedmen and their descendants 4,000 or more men of military age should be found at Rome in 19 a.d. Many of the Jewish freedmen of this age (18- 45) were probably full Roman citizens (cf. Philo op. cit. 23. 157), for the limitations on manumission mentioned above were at the most of only fifteen years' standing. Many of the rest of the group were Latin citizens. Others yet were probably in numero dediti- dorum. The administrative temper of Tiberius was notoriously that of a strict legalist, with constant regard for conservatism and for ancient precedents. He was greatly incensed against the Jews in Rome, and meant to rid the city of them. Those who were pere- grini could be ejected without ceremony, as they were resident in Rome technically only on sufferance. But neither Roman nor Latin citizens could justly be subjected to the penalty of relegatio (simple banishment beyond a set boundary) by an arbitrary decree of the senate, but only on trial and conviction for a crime for which this was the penalty by statute provided. There was, however, another recourse. They were legally liable to military service, if duly conscripted. This is probably true also of all the Jews in Rome of proper age, for there is no evidence that Jews resident in Italy had ever been formally exempted from this burden, which rested upon socii as upon peregrini dediticii. It is quite possible, however, that in practice Jews had been passed over (as at times in other quarters of the Roman world), and they may have come to consider such exemption one of their estabhshed privileges. But if Tiberius permitted it to be pleaded by such resident Jews of military age as were Roman or Latin citizens, he would be left helpless against them in the present case, and would be supporting I Philo. Leg. ad Gaium 23 (155). Expulsion of Jews from Rome under Tiberius 369 the manifestly novel and pernicious theory that a man could plead religious scruples as a pacificist in order to avoid his duty to Rome as a citizen; and this in face of the fact that Jews would fight in their own quarrels without hesitation. About the theoretical duty that rested even upon peregrini of military age to render service in the auxiliary forces, Tiberius apparently cared nothing. He was content to let that question rest, so long as he could effectively rid the city of such non-Roman and non-Latin Jews by order of expul- sion. Hence the discrimination that was made. What was done about Jews who were Roman citizens but not libertini generis, we are not informed. It was open to Tiberius, of course, to draft such men into the legions, if he did not choose to lump them in with the men libertini generis, in disregard of precedent. As it was, he probably took no action concerning them, their number being so small as to be negligible.^ As regards the Jews libertini generis who were over or under military age, they also probably escaped discipline altogether (unless they were in numero dediticiorum), and with the Roman citizens just mentioned furnished the nucleus for that large and flourishing colony that repeopled the Ghetto in Trastevere in the later years of Tiberius and, with brief intervals of exclusion, for many centuries thereafter. Acts of expulsion like this, frequently mentioned in Roman history, were never intended to be permanent in their application. For the probable fate of the third class of freedmen, those in numero dediticiorum, see what is said below. Freedmen were as a rule not enrolled in the legions, but, like Latin citizens and socii in general, only in the auxiliary forces. Emergency, however, might lead even to the legionary enrolment of such plebs uernacula,^ perhaps regularly conjoined in the case of freedmen with the grant (to those who did not already possess it) of full citizenship under the fiction of restitutio natalium, and in 1 The somewhat amusing anecdote recorded of himself by Seneca (.Ep. 108. 22) does not interfere with this conclusion. Seneca of course would not be in danger of being suspected of Jewish birth, but at the most of adhering to the Jewish religion. It is not necessary to suppose that Roman citizens, even of Jewish faith, were actually being subjected to any legal persecution, but only that Seneca's father thought that in the excited state of public feeling his son might better avoid any ostentatious peculiarities of living that could be wrongly interpreted. * Cf. Tac. Ann. i. 31 ; Mommsen, Die Conscriptionsordnung der roemischen Kaiser- zeit, in Hermes, XIX (1884), pp. 14 £f. {=Ges. Schr., VI, p. 33). 370 Elmer Tbuesdbll MEBRiLii the case of peregrini possibly the same grant without the fiction. The police-duty in Sardinia was of the nature of service usually assigned to auxiliary forces, and Tiberius had a precedent for it in the action of Augustus, who had in similar need conscripted freed- men and sent them, organized as auxiliaries, for guard duty in Pan- nonia and along the Rhine.* In the case of the conscripts libertini generis Tiberius probably made no distinction between Roman and Latin citizens; whether Augustus had done so or not, we do not know.^ The statement made by Suetonius that in the case of the rest of the Jews, if they did not obey the order of expulsion, they were to be punished by perpetual slavery, offers a problem of some diffi- culty. We might be disposed to believe that Tiberius, notwith- standing his consistent regard for law and formal justice, would not have revived, even in terrorem, a penalty with regard to pere- grini that might have been inflicted in the early days of the Republic, but was so far as we know without actual precedent in recent times. At all events, even in those most ancient days we are not aware that persons were ever condemned to slavery without hope or possibility of eventual manumission. But the lex Aelia- Sentia had provided that freedmen who had, on account of a record of especially bad conduct when they were slaves, been classed upon manumission in numero dediticiorum were forbidden to stay within a hundred miles of R6me, under penalty of being reduced again to slavery that should thereafter be perpetual.' It is quite con- ceivable that in the immense population of the city of Rome this severe provision of the law of 4 a.d. had not been very rigorously enforced, inquisition being difiicult and concealment of precise status easy. It is also conceivable that among Jewish freedmen in Rome were many of this class, and that Tiberius now put into execu- tion against them the stringent provisions that had fallen somewhat 1 Cf. Suet. Aug. 25. 2. 2 If, as Suetonius {loc. cit.) appears to say, these uexilla were composed entirely of slaves who had just been manumitted for this especial purpose, it seems likely that none of them had been given full Roman citizenship upon manumission, but only Latin. But the certain date of the action is unknown. Probably Augustus meant to accomplish two things; to provide needed reinforcements after the severe losses under Varus (which would establish a date post quern), and to lid the capital of a part of the large slave population (see above) . Suetonius distinctly states that he did not mix freeborn men with them. » Cf. Gains Inst. i. 13, 27. Expulsion of Jews from Rome under Tiberius 371 into abeyance, and it is an echo of this procedure that we find imperfectly reproduced in Suetonius. Perhaps also it is unsafe to say, merely because we have no actual instances recorded, that the seizure and sale of the person as well as the property of a peregrinus who disregarded the order of expulsion might not still be the ordi- nary legal penalty for his disobedience. It hardly needs remark that the mandate of expulsion doubtless did not extend to slaves, who were under the control and restraint of their masters. It will be noted that even if the other interpretation of libertini generis be espoused { = liber tint), in the main the explanation of the incident may yet stand as it is given above. There would be but two especial difficulties concerning its application. The number of actual freedmen in Rome who were Jews between the ages of 18 and 45 might seem extravagant, forcing the assumption of a total Jewish population in excess of that which it is easy to account for. This is doubly so if the additional item furnished by Josephus is true, and a great number of other Jews of the same status must be added to the enumeration of the 4,000 specifically mentioned. All these, and in addition those libertini who were above or below military age, and all women of like status (libertinae) , and all liber- tini dediticii, would certainly make a surprisingly large number of actual freedmen from which to compute the total population of the Roman Ghetto. The second difficulty is that there must then also be a larger number than the preferred interpretation makes it necessary to postulate of those persons who could escape all discipline. For with the understanding of libertini generis as equivalent to libertini, no mere descendants of freedmen were con- scripted, and on the other hand, as they would all (except probably the descendants of dediticii) be either Roman or Latin citizens, they could not be banished by executive decree. Their number would probably swell considerably — too much for comfortable assur- ance on the part of the inquirer — the number of Jews who were escaping between the Scylla of expulsion and the Charybdis of conscription. From these considerations also the interpretation of libertini generis as designating a class of their freedmen and descendants is the more satisfactory. 372 Elmer Truesdell Merrill The alleged reference in Philo* to the expulsion of the Jews from Rome under Tiberius calls for brief comment. Philo says in substance that the favorable opinion and treatment of the Jews that had prevailed under Augustus was continued in the main under Tiberius, except when Sejanus, wishing to wreck the whole race, trumped up charges against them. Tiberius, however, ascer- tained after the fall of Sejanus that his accusations against the Jews were nothing but malicious slanders, and ordered the Roman governors everywhere to direct their punitive action not against the Jews as a whole, but only against such evil-doers as might be found among them (and they were few), but to take the race under their protection and show its members favor as persons disposed to peace and quietness. Nothing is plainly said by Philo about any active measures against the Jews in Rome, but on the contrary it is a fair inference from his words that such persecution as had been undertaken was confined to the provinces, and had not pro- ceeded far until it was interrupted by the downfall and death of Sejanus (31 a.d.), soon after which the order was rescinded, with other of his acts, by Tiberius. This would explain the absence of any mention of it by Tacitus or Suetonius. Moreover, the great influence of Sejanus in the administration of the empire does not appear even to have begun till some four years after 19 a.d. It is therefore hardly possible that Philo's story has any reference to the events of that year: if it has, the account is inexcusably blun- dered or perverted. But the indicated reversal by the emperor of the policy of hostility to which he had been in a manner committed by his action of a dozen years before, may be responsible for the growth of the Jewish colony in Rome which apparently marked the later years of his reign. Philo, it may be observed, had a diplo- matic reason for n9t recording any severe action against the Jews for which Tiberius must be held personally responsible. It would interrupt the array of uniformly favorable precedents of imperial procedure that he was concerned as an advocate to present. It is a great pity that the especial book which Philo devoted to a full dis- cussion of the persecution of the Jews by order of Sejanus has been lost. University of Chicago 1 Leg. ad Gaium 24 (159-61).