STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. ATHENIAN CASUALTY LISTS By Gertrude Smith In CIA 1. 432-62 1 are collected a number of Athenian casualty lists covering a period of years in the fifth century which yield some interesting information regarding the method of publishing the names of those who died in action. Of the many questions suggested by these lists only a few have been treated with any degree of complete- ness. 2 Before proceeding to a discussion of them it will be advisable to outline the Athenian military organization. A psephism of the assembly authorized the mobilization of the troops and specified the number required for a particular campaign. The citizens of the first three Solonian census classes served as hoplites grouped in tribes which were identical with the civil tribes. The tribes again were subdivided into classes, each class containing those who had been enrolled for service in the same year. The Athenians rendered military service from 18 to 60 years of age and so there would in any year be 42 classes of hoplites enrolled under the names of 42 archons, the oldest group passing out each year and being replaced by the incoming epheboi under the name of the archon of the current year.* The mobilization psephism specified the classes from which men were to be called. 4 The ten generals managed the selection of the troops. Under them as chief commanders of the army as a whole were the taxiarchs who commanded the various tribes, two hipparchs, each commanding the cavalry of five tribes, and ten phylarchs, 1 Cf . also 4. 1 (suppl. to Vol. 1) pp. 107-11. For a convenient collection of Athenian casualty lists see Malzer, Verluste und Verlustlisten im griechischen Altertum bis auf die Zeit Alexanders des grossen, 1912. * Malzer, op. cit., on the basis of the historians and the casualty lists, attempts to estimate the losses suffered in the various battles in the fifth and fourth centuries. He reprints the Athenian casualty lists with brief comments on the date of the inscrip- tions and identification of battles and of individuals. His final summary, entitled "Die Einrichtung der Listen" (pp. 108 ff.), leaves many interesting problems un- touched. 8 For epheboi see Taylor, "The Athenian Ephebic Oath," Classical Journal, XIII [1918], 495 ff. 4 On the whole subject of Athenian military organization see Gilbert, Constitutional Antiquities, pp. 310 ff. For the organization of the cavalry see Aristotle Politeia 49.2. [Classical Philology XIV, October, 1919] 351 352 Gertrude Smith each commanding the cavalry of one tribe. After the selection of the number required by the psephism had been made the names of the soldiers were posted. 1 From a passage in Aristophanes, which speaks of a soldier as not knowing that he was drafted until he saw his name on the statue of Pandion, it is apparent that they were posted by tribes, the list of each tribe being fixed upon the statue of the eponymous hero of that tribe. 2 Two passages in Aristophanes refer to tampering with the lists of hoplites. In The Knights Demos after his regeneration promises that when a hoplite is placed on a muster list he shall stay there regardless of any influence that may be used. Zirei$' bir\iTT}sevTedels Iv KarakSya ovStls (card tit' • ob yap V Sav h£t&V etra xparrds vpds t6v ivSpiavra t6v TlavSlovos eldev aitrdv, K&vopap $et r$ Kaxcfi f}\tiro>v 6tt6v' » Knights 1369 S. 4 Lines 1180 f. The passage speaks first of the cowardice of the taxiarchs abroad and then of their unfairness at home in making out the muster rolls: toAs litv frtyph.iTK>i as possible restorations). The SryAjriot are mentioned in several tribute lists and the MaMrioi are included in the rdjis 6pov. Again, cleruchs were called by the name of the people among whom they settled. Hence the two names might refer either to allies or to cleruchs. As there is no certain instance of the recording of allied casualties on the Athenian lists nor any reason for recording them there, any names of people in the casualty lists which are found in the tribute lists or the tA£« 6pov are almost certainly cleruchs. Furthermore these two names occur apparently in the enumeration of the dead of one of the tribes. Athenian Casualty Lists 359 opinion, for the technical name for allies is trfyujuaxoi. Aside from this there is one possible reference to metics: tyy pcuj>oi in the same inscription. Boeckh so construes the word. Several other inter- pretations have been suggested: that there were strangers resident in Athens who had received the right of participating in the ephebia as iiciyypaoi; that there were strangers who had received by special decree the right of serving with the Athenians. Clerc rejects the first of these conjectures altogether and argues that the word refers to metics who had the rights of wroTeXeux. This seems to be the correct view: the %ivoi are the ordinary metics and the £77 pcupoi the ItroreXeis. It seems quite reasonable to suppose that the metic casualties were cared for by the state in the same way as citizen casualties and that some provision was made for their burial at the annual funeral. It is merely an accident that so few inscriptions have been found in which they are recorded. To i/aXot as a class there is no reference on the monuments, but twice rot-orai are men- tioned, one of the references being in the Erechtheid inscription, which refers to casualties only in the one tribe. That there were to£6tcu recruited from the citizens is known. 1 Another case occurs in CIA 1. 446, where 9 rol-brai are recorded along with the 6 t-ivoi and 2 lyypaoi. It seems reasonable that if the men were citizens in this case they were thetes. With regard to mercenaries some arrangement must have been made, although there is no reference to them on the monuments if it is agreed that £ewi of 1. 446 refers to metics. 2 Isaeus 3 cites the case of an Athenian citizen who was killed probably while serving as a mercenary in a Persian army. His ashes were sent home by his comrades. It cannot be inferred from this, however, that this practice was followed in the case of other mercenaries. That some arrangement was made with the mercenaries when they were hired as to the burial they would receive if killed in the service of the Athenians seems natural if one considers the great stress which the Greeks laid upon proper burial. 4 There is 1 CIA 1. 54. 1 Malzer (op. cit., p. 109) regards £&>oi as mercenaries. He does not cite Clerc. 8 Oration 4. Cf. Wyse's introduction and notes. * Xen. Hell. 6. 1. 6. Medical care as well as funeral rites are promised: oi)s S' &v ipif. tpt\oTr6vais Kal t\oKtv8vvojs ixovras irpds roiis irohktxovs, Tipq. roiis p-iv 5tjuotptat$ roifs Si rpipoipiais roiis Si rerpa/xotptcus Kal SXXois Swpois, nai vbauv yt depaireiais /cot jrepj ra0ds fcoa/icjj. 360 Gertrude Smith no certain instance of allies on the casualty lists. Probably they published their own lists at home. One non-combatant casualty is listed on the Erechtheid inscription, a priest whose name with the place of his death is set off, iv Aiyfarrw TekiviKos pavris. This same inscription furnishes an interesting illustration of revision, for there are eight names added at the end in a different hand, including a general, three men presumably hoplites, and four archers. Either a revision of the lists must have been made after the original stele was set up or else these eight men were wounded and and did not die until after its erection. But since they received their wounds on the campaign which the stele commemorates, their names were inscribed upon it. Frequently along with the names of the dead soldiers an epitaph is given in the conventional epigrammatic form praising the valor of the dead heroes. 1 Occasionally the grave stone of an individual who died in war is found. Perhaps the most perfect and loveliest of these is that of Dexileos, the young horseman, 2 which belongs to the fourth century. This was not an official monument. It would be interesting if it were possible to get information about the yearly loss of the Athenians as compared with the numbers which could be brought into the field in a given year. Pericles estimates the man power of Athens at the beginning of the war as 13,000 hoplites, and 16,000 others on garrison duty at home, 1,200 cavalry including mounted archers, 1,600 archers, and the crews of 300 triremes. 3 But for no single year of the war can the casualties be estimated, since Thucydides' statements are vague and no unmutilated inscrip- tion exists. For the year 458-59, for which the Erechtheid inscription remains entire, it is possible, by supposing another such inscription for each of the other tribes, to gain a general idea of the total casualties 1 Cf. Hicks and Hill, op. cit., 46. OtSe Tap' 'EWtio-kovtov b.Twk«rav byXabv fi^r\v fiapvaiievoi afarkpav 6' ebKhkurap. warpl&a &ios. 9 With regard to the maintenance of those who were invalided in war, provision was made by law that they should be supported at public expense. The date of the law is not known with certainty, although Plutarch assigns it to Peisistratus. 10 While there is no 1 An estimate of the losses in the Sicilian expedition is impossible on account of Thucydides' indefinite statements: 6. 52, "some troops"; 6. 71, "not more than 50"; 6. 101, "Lamachus and 5 or 6 others"; 7. 41, "crews of 7 ships"; 7. 45, " consid- erable number"; 7. 72, "great slaughter." For an estimate based upon all available sources cf. Malzer, op. cit., p. 33. 2 2. 34. 8 Plato Menex. 2496; Arist. Panalh. p. 310 (Dindorf). 4 Isocrates 8. 87. 6 Diogenes Laertius Sol. 8. 55. 8 Pausanius (1. 32. 3) mentions stelae at Marathon set up over the graves of the dead and containing the names arranged by tribes. ' Hauvette, "Les fileusiniens d'Eschyle et l'institution du discours funfebre a Athene" in Melanges Henri Weil (1898), pp. 159 ff. 8 By "missing" is meant those who could not be found and were thought to have been killed. The term does not, of course, include those who had been taken prisoner. 9 Burgess, Epideictic Literature, pp. 147 ff. io Solon 31. 364 Gertrude Smith information on the subject, it may be assumed that their dependents were cared for at the public expense just as in the case of the widows and orphans of those who actually died in battle. That the state took care of these orphans m«X/* 1 yfiys is a fact mentioned by several authors. 1 In addition to furnishing financial support, the state apparently had control of the education of the children. 2 Aristotle speaks of the custom as existing in his time in Athens and also in other cities. 3 When the sons became the proper age to enter the class of epheboi, the state assembled them in the theater at the greater Dionysia and presented each with a panoply after an exhortation to virtue. For that day they occupied the front seats at the theater. After this ceremony they entered the regular ranks of the citizen body and were trained during the two years of the ephebia along with those whose fathers were still living. 4 Isocrates 6 speaks of a yearly parade of orphans in the theater at the time of the Dionysiac festival. Doubt- less he is referring to the same ceremony which Aeschines describes. University op Chicago 1 Thucydides 2. 46. 1 ; Demosthenes 60. 32; Plato Mehex. 248<2; Lysias 2. 75-76. 2 Diogenes LaeTtius 1. 55. 8 Politics 2. 5. 4. * Aeschines. Ctea. 154. 6 8. 82.