STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. VIRGIL AT NAPLES By Norman W. DbWitt The precise moment in his career when Virgil gave up his forensic ambitions and retired to Naples can be fixed with some show of probability by means of a combination of the fifth poem of the Catalepton with the Introduction of the Ciris. From the former it is evident that his departure from the capital is to be ascribed to considerations of a purely personal nature. He is sick of the book- worm tribe, of the dull pedants, of the dandified snobs, and the jangling cymbals of the idle class room. Of any external event or calamity that might have necessitated his retirement against his will or desire there is no hint or mention, wherefrom we may infer that the murder of Julius had not yet taken place, after which, it need hardly be said, the activities of the Forum were of compulsion sus- pended. Turning now to the Ciris we find the poet laboring to complete a poem previously promised to Valerius Messalla and begun before the withdrawal, 1 and from the content of the Introduction we gather that his friend is in Athens. Now Messalla, we know from a letter of Cicero, 2 was about to start for Athens in March of 45. Consequently we may assume that by the time of the Panathenaic festival in July, which Messalla is supposed to be witnessing, Virgil is settled in his little Cecropian garden. 3 In other words, he is studying Epicureanism in the school of Siro. 4 Virgil did not go alone. It was a migration of friends, a group movement, just as the migration of Messalla and Cicero''! son to Athens was a group movement. One hardly needs to adduce proof of the latter fact. It is common knowledge that Brutus two years later repaired to Athens to recruit the ranks of his officers. 6 It was the natural thing for him to do just as it was the natural thing in the recent war for the belligerent nations to seek in the universities the material out of which the able officer is most quickly manufactured. 1 Ciris 9 and 47. 4 Catalepton 5. "- Ad Att. xii. 32. 2. 5 Plut. Brutus 24. 3 Ciris 3. [CtissicAL Philology XVII, April, 1922] 104 Virgil at Naples 105 In such centers the combination of high spirits and intelligence is sure to be found. At Naples, however, a far different group assem- bled. Virgil had already done his bit in 49, his health had been broken, and he was no longer fit for service. 1 Of Varius, Tucca, and Quintilius Varus we know less but they were almost certainly of that Epicurean company. 2 It is possible that the school of Siro migrated in a body. Cicero in the de Finibus, writing in this very year of 45, though the fictive date is 50, speaks of a movement among the Epicureans: "What hosts of friends did Epicurus entertain under a single roof, and that a very modest one, and in what marvellous unanimity! This very thing is actually going on today among the Epicureans." 3 Can we be sure he is not referring to the school of Siro, who had been busy in the capital for sufficient time to assemble a real colony ? The total amount of information that we possess concerning the sojourn of Virgil at Naples is not very great but it derives from good sources, his own poems, and Probus and Suetonius. From the closing lines of the Georgics we know that he was then living in that region and from the use of the word Parthenope we should judge that his residence was situated in the western suburbs of Naples, where the tomb of the Siren was located. 4 With this is consistent the use of the same word in his epitaph and the reliable data available for the site of the family tomb. 6 Probus gives us the names of his more prominent friends, Varius, Tucca, and Quintilius Varus. Sueto- nius gives us the data for discussing with greater certainty the location of his later residence. His statement runs that the poet preferred to his house at Rome, hard by the gardens of Maecenas, the solitude of Sicily and Campania. 6 His word for solitude is secessus and a consistent usage defines its meaning. The island of Capri was secessus to Augustus in his last illness and still more the adjacent islet of Apragopolis, an Epicurean 1 Catal. xiii. 1-4. 2 Probus, Diehl, p. 43. "Vixit pluribus annis liberali in otio secutus Epicuri sectam insigni Concordia et familiaritate usus Quintili, Tuccae et Vari." 3 i. 20. 65. 1 Beloch, Cam-panien im Altertum, p. 77. 6 Donat-Sueton., § 36. « Ibid., § 13. 106 Norman W. DeWitt name that we may render in Latin as Tranquillopolis. 1 One may compare the name of the villa of Vedius Pollio on the opposite main- land, the modern Posilipo, Uawlkvirov, in French, Sans Souci. Vedius, however, was an Epicurean of a different stamp. To return to secessus, Horace was in secessu at his Sabine farm 2 and Tacitus employs the same term to denote the retirement of Tiberius in Rhodes. 3 It plainly conveyed the idea of a quiet and inaccessible retreat, far from the madding crowd, from the turmoils of politics, and the irksome intrusions of curious and uncongenial callers. It is manifest here that Suetonius, whose keenness for details is joined to a singular neglect of perspective, is speaking of Virgil's later retreat at Sorrento and not to his previous residence in the western suburbs of Naples. The last poem of the Catalepton, prob- ably written just before the fatal journey to Greece, contains the lines: "Adsis, Cytherea; tuos te Caesar Olympo et Surrentini litoris ora vocat." That the peninsula of Sorrento was little exploited as yet by the prying Roman is made plain by the fact that Augustus many years later chose it as a place of exile for his vulgar grandson, Agrippa Postumus, 4 which incidentally proves that an imperial villa was there located. The relative seclusion of the whole coast on this side of Naples is borne out by other evidence. Cicero found more comfort at Pompeii than at Cumae, 5 which he declared to possess all natural advantages except solitude. It had become, as a matter of fact, a veritable Atlantic City and at the height of the season was so congested with crowds of pleasure seekers as to be a Pusilla Roma. 6 That Capri, on the other hand, was still a quaint and undeveloped place may be inferred from the fact that Augustus was able to acquire the whole island from the Neapolitans, 7 and also from the well-known fact that it reached its bloom only under Tiberius. 8 Combining this information we reach the conclusion that the Romans, in late repub- lican and early Augustan days, had not as yet penetrated to any great extent beyond Naples, and that the vogue of Cumae and Baiae as the Nice and Monte Carlo of antiquity knew no danger of eclipse. 1 Suet. Aug. 98. 6 Ad Att. ii. 1. 11. 2 Suet. Vita Hot. Roth, p. 298. 6 Ibid. v. 2. 2. 8 An. i. 4. 7 Suet. Aug. 92. 4 Suet. Aug. 65. 8 Beloch, p. 282. Virgil at Naples 107 Of Sorrento itself we hear little or nothing until a century later when Statius described the elaborate villa of his friend Pollius. 1 That Virgil was the proprietor of an estate at Nola, on the oppo- site side of Vesuvius from Naples, is to be gleaned from a note of Aulus Gellius, 2 which tells of a dispute over water rights which resulted in the poet deleting the name of the town from his works. It may be remarked by the way that an ancient feud, as might be expected, existed between the neighboring Nola and Naples, 3 and as the poet had been adopted by the Neapolitans under the name of Parthenias, it is possible that he suffered a petty injustice because of this connection. His estate in that region, however, was probably an investment rather than a home and his earlier residence is to be looked for in the suburbs of Naples itself, and that on the Puteoli side. This would have been a very secluded spot in late republican and early Austan days since the Via Puteolana was only put through by the first princeps himself, Cocceius having the superintendence of it. 4 Before this work was completed, including the rock-cut gallery, the only road to Puteoli was the Via Antiniana, starting from near the modern Museum and following the cliff. Indeed, it may have been the unwelcome publicity of the new road that drove Virgil to seek a safer seclusion at Sorrento. Before it was built the modern Chiaia, ancient Plaga, would have been a blind avenue. Virgil's sojourn in this quarter must have continued with inter- ruptions from his first arrival in 45 down to the moment when he wrote the closing lines of the Georgics, and the sight of his tall muscular figure would long have been a familiar sight in the streets and shops of the quaint old city. That they knew him well is evidenced by the soubriquet Parthenias, which had reference to the purity of his life, a novelty, we may well believe, to the Italic Greek. It was doubtless during these years, and very early in these years, that the family acquired a burial plot on what was later called the Via Puteolana. Virgil's father, as we learn from the eighth of the Catalepton, when the confiscations began to threaten, was occupying or about to occupy 1 Ibid., p. 269. * Gellius vi. 20; Servius to Geo. ii. 224 and Aeneid vii. 740. 3 Cio. de Off. i. 10, 33; Beloch, p. 406. 4 Beloch, p. 83. 108 Norman W. DeWitt the villa of Siro. He cannot have long survived that date since the widow married again and bore a half-brother to the poet, the same to whom he bequeathed his estate at death. 1 Starting with the knowledge that the poet was born in 70, it is not difficult to arrive at the foregoing conclusion. It is likely that the ashes of his two full brothers reposed in the same vault and perhaps his mother's also. 2 Thus we easily understand why Virgil should have been buried here when his residence was at Sorrento on the opposite side of the city. It is timely to say a word about the use of the name Parthenope in place of Naples. That the memorial of the Siren Parthenope, the tomb of Virgil, and the harbor of Naples were situated close together is manifest from Statius Silvae iv. 4. 51 ff. En egomet somnum et geniale secutus litus, ubi Ausonio se condidit hospita portu Parthenope, tenues ignavo pollice chordas pulso, Maroneique sedens in margine templi sumo animum, et magni tumulis adcanto magistri. Now Virgil's tomb was almost two Roman miles from the Porta Puteolana of the new town that was called Neapolis. Thus we are in the suburbs of Virgil's Naples and this is the spot that the poet refers to in the conclusion of the Georgics: Illo Vergilium me tempore dulcis alebat Parthenope studiis fiorentem ignobilis oti. At large the poetical name, we believe, might be taken as synonymous with Naples, but at Naples it signified the old harbor town, which must have been practically abandoned after the city was deprived of its ships under Sulla's regime. 3 We can thus understand how Lucullus could acquire the site of the Castel dell'Ovo and likewise how an unambitious Epicurean colony might find in the abandoned and quaint old town a tranquil and undisturbed retreat. Here was probably the villa of Siro and the home of the Virgils. It would seem as if Naples and the parts to the southward became the home of Epicureanism from this time onward. We have mentioned the names of Apragopolis and Posilipo as suggesting an Epicurean neighborhood. To this may be added the long familiar association of the Epicurean Philodemus with Herculaneum. It is i Donat-Sueton., § 37. 2 Ibid., §§ 14 and 37. 3 Appian B.C. i. 89. Virgil at Naples 109 possible that the Virgilian fraternity was somewhat closely associated with him since the names of Varius and Quintilius, and possibly Virgil's own, have been deciphered in one of the rolls. 1 Originally the Epicurean school was rather associated with Cumae. Cicero places there the scene of the Epicurean part of the de Finibus while Stoicism is discussed at Tusculum, and we happen to learn from Suetonius that a certain Marcus Pompilius Andronicus, like Philo- demus, an Epicurean teacher from Syria, had migrated from Rome to Cumae. 2 In the first century of the Empire, we learn from Statius, 3 Naples became the rendezvous of vast numbers of students from various parts of Italy and across the seas. Docta Neapolis, Martial calls it. 4 That this learning was Epicurean in color seems likely from the fact that the atmosphere of the capital during the first two centuries was distinctly Stoic. The two schools seem to have exhibited a tendency to separate as early as 45 B.C. and it may be for this reason that Cicero was moved to write his de Finibus in that particular year. He was not lacking in the journalistic sense and the perception of what was timely in controversial matters, as his rhetorical writings prove. If we are on the right trail a welcome light is thrown upon the origin of the Augustan literary coterie. It would appear that Roman society before the death of Julius began to divide in an unplanned and spontaneous way into three groups. At Naples assembled a pacific, Epicurean company of men who had no desire to embroil themselves in civic dissensions. To Athens repaired the republicans who shortly afterward committed their fortunes to Brutus and Cassius. At Rome remained the ribald circle of Antonius that had begun to gather about him in the two years of Caesar's absence and rallied once more to his side when the fateful Ides replaced the bounty of the state once more in his hands. Antony himself was never destined to return to Rome after Philippi but this permanent absence was never contemplated, and his followers, headed by his brother Lucius and the more dangerous and audacious Fulvia, set 1 Korte, Bh. Mus., LXV, 172. 2 Suet. Gram. 8. 3 Beloeh, p. 56; Statius Silv. v. 162-72. 4 Epig. v. 78. 14. 110 Norman W. DeWitt on foot a multifarious propaganda that ended only with the fiasco of Perusia in the spring of 40. Thereupon the active Antonians went to Greece or Egypt and left Italy to the Octavian faction. Virgil, drawn out of his retirement into the maelstrom by the calamity of Mantua, attaches himself to the circles of Pollio, Alfenus Varus, and Cornelius Gallus, plays his part in the literary campaign against the Antonian poets Anser, Bavius, and Maevius, wins himself a new and powerful friend in Maecenas, and definitely joins the Neapolitan group to the cause of the young Caesar. Later he intro- duces Horace. He is the founder of the literary coterie of the Augustans. Victoria College Toronto