STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. HOMER AS THE POET OF THE THEBAIS By John A. Scott No argument advanced against the Homeric authorship of the Iliad and the Odyssey seems more convincing than the assumed fact that at an early date Homer was regarded as the source of all the earliest epics, the Thebais, the Epigonoi, the Cypria, and the rest, as well as of the Iliad and the Odyssey. This idea is most sweep- ingly stated by Verrall and by Wilamowitz; Verrall in the Quarterly Review for July, 1908: "Homer was a nebulous mass of old poetry reduced into distinct bodies, such as the Iliad, Odyssey, Cypria, Aethiopis, and so on, for educational purposes by learned Athenians between 600 and 500 b.c." Wilamowitz, H.U., 353: "Um 500 sind alle gedichte von Homer." The first reference to Homer is supposed to be to him as the author of the Thebais, H.U., 351 :* "Das alteste Homercitat, von dem wir wissen, ist das des Kallinos, das wir oben bei Pausanias angetroffen haben: es gieng die Thebais an." The same author in his Die Ilias und Homer, p. 365: "Wenden wir uns nun zu Homer, so nennt ihn unser altester Zeuge, Kallinos, um 600 Verfasser nicht der Ilias, sondern der Thebais, aber er nennt den Namen des Dichters." To a similar conclusion the remark by Finsler points in his Ho, ner, I, 63: "Im 7. Jahrhundert schreibt der Dichter Kallinos von Ephesos dem Homer die Thebais zu." Even so conservative a work as Christ- Schmid says without explanatory note or comment (p. 95): "Nach Pausanias ix. 9. 5 hat der Elegiker Kallinos die Thebais als homerisch anerkannt." There is not the slightest indication that in Pausanias the person quoted is Calaenus and not Callinus, that no manuscript has the name of the elegiac poet, and that Callinus is purely a conjectural reading. We have no other quotation from Callinus which shows him as a composer of anything but martial hymns, so that the conjecture is at best very doubtful; yet it is the sole support for the theory that Homer was regarded in the seventh century as the poet of the Thebais. iH.U.= Homerische Untersuchungen. [Classical Philology XVI, January, 1921] 20 Homer as the Poet of the "Thebais" 21 In discussing the story of "Thebes," Pausanias says that these things have been put in verse by Antimachus 'AvHuaxos imarpareiav 'Apyeiuv iroiiiaas is Qr)(3as, viii. 254. This Thebais of Antimachus was very popular and often quoted, so that Kinkel is able to print fifty-six fragments therefrom, while he is able to find but seven from what is regarded as the earlier Thebais, and most of these are doubt- ful, since the fragment quoted by Athenaeus is assigned to that earlier postulated poem on the basis of the phrase &s 6 rr\v kvkK\.kt\v Qr}j3ai8a irewoiriKas cj>r} (Athen. xi. 465 E.) There is no reason for not assigning this quotation to Antimachus, since he too was regarded as a cyclic poet. Horace refers to him as scriptor cyclicus in Ars Poet. 142, and had him in mind as the one who went back to Meleager when telling of the return of Diomede, as we know from Porphyrion's note to this passage in Horace, Antimachus j 'wit cyclicus poeta. There can be no doubt that cyclic poets were authors of cyclic poetry, so that the Thebais of Antimachus was regarded as cylic poetry long before either Pausanias or Athenaeus. The scholiast to Stat. Theb. iii. 466 says of this Thebais: Dicunt poetam ista omnia ex Graeco poeta, Antimacho, deduxisse, qui et ipse longam Thebaidem scripsit et veteribus in magno pretio habitam. Judg- ing from the frequency with which the Thebais of Antimachus is quoted and the high regard in which it was held, it seems safe to say that this would be the Thebais to which Pausanias referred, if there is no contrary evidence; but instead we do have positive evidence that it was the version of Antimachus he was following, for he begins the discussion with the words above quoted, "It was Antimachus who put in verse the story of the expedition against Thebes." I do not care to discuss all uses of the word Thebais in Pausanias, but they all occur in parts of his writings which are subsequent to the statement that he is relying on the poetical version of Antimachus. Nothing is more remarkable than the different ways in which Wilamowitz looks at the same thing, when this thing can be made to serve his different theories, since in discrediting Homer the slightest inference drawn from Pausanias becomes a foundation of granite capable of supporting the most far-reaching theories, but when he wishes to prove that all of the oldest poetry, except the Iliad and the Odyssey, were lost at an early period, then the most explicit 22 John A. Scott statements of Pausanias become utterly worthless. H.U., 338: "Paus. iv. 2 und sonstwerden epische citate mit einem unzweideuti- gen e-yci> iireke^a^v eingefiihrt. Es wird ohne zweifel vielen ganz lasterlich klingen, wenn ich auch nur die f rage aufwerfe ob Pausanias die gedichte gelesen hat. Dennoch scheue ich mich nicht, mit zuversicht und mit ruhe diese frage zu verneinen. Die belesensten manner, Plutarch und Porphyrius, haben die gedichte nie gesehen." Here he is discussing the early epic poems of the Homeric cycle. It seems to me further discussion of this passage is hardly necessary, for if the most explicit statements are to be thrown aside as worthless, it is hard to put much weight on a doubtful reference, and that a reference which depends on a most improbable conjecture. It is unlikely that Callinus ever wrote any literary discussion, so that even if all the manuscripts had the name Callinus, it would then be necessary to prove that the Callinus intended was the poet of Ephesus. The sole argument against the form Calaenus is that no man of that name is known, but at least one-half of all the proper names given by Pape are names occurring but a single time. The theory that Pausanias was here quoting the elegiac poet, Callinus, needs some support for itself and cannot alone and unaided furnish the proof that in the seventh century B.C. Homer was gener- ally regarded as the poet of the Thebais. Pausanias may in the very passage quoted be expressing his surprise that a Calaenus should assign a poem by Antimachus to Homer, just as I might be surprised that a prominent writer in a recent magazine assigned She Stoops to Conquer to Sheridan, or that Secretary Lane confused Achilles and Antaeus, or that many educated people think the Bible is the source of the phrase, "The Lord tempers the weather to the shorn lamb." The meaning of Pausanias is not clear; the word Callinus is a conjecture, and Wilamowitz accuses Pausanias, H.U., 340: "er hat sich eine gelehrsamkeit angeschwindelt die er nicht besass," so that if a clear statement is set aside, we feel that an obscure passage founded on an emendation is poor support for arguments which discredit the literary judgment of the entire ancient world, for that ancient world chose to neglect the Thebais, Homer as the Poet of the "Thebais" 23 The second writer quoted to prove that Homer was regarded as the author of the Thebais is Herodotus from whom the following passage is confidently quoted (v. 67): KKeiadevrjs yap 'Apyeioiit] &fo)(a 8' Apycious, ot ryv dtoTtiyat. Tpoirjv r)pu\pav rtoivtjv r/vKO/wv EAev^s ov x° L P lv ECTrjercv 8»J//.os /u.e-yaAoirroXis avrov ivOaZt Kai Ti/tats d/x^>cV«t dOavdraiv. This is divine Homer, who adorned all proud Hellas with his wonderful poetic skill, but most of all he honored the Argives, who humbled the god- built city Troy, as a requital for the wrongs done to the fair-haired Helen, and hence the proud-citied state worships him now with divine honors. Here we have from the Argives themselves the thing in Homer which they viewed with such boundless pride, and this thing was no exploit connected with Thebes, but it was the expedition against Troy, that is, they felt exalted because Homer had honored them in the Iliad and Odyssey, and they never mentioned in this inscription anything in regard to Thebes. There can be no doubt that hostile neighbors would envy them just the thing in which they themselves took this unbounded pride, and that thing is found in no assumed Thebais, but in Homer, our Homer, the Homer who wrote the Iliad and the Odyssey. In no place in Herodotus do the Argives lay any claim to honor or favor because of their connection with Thebes, but oddly enough the Athenians at the battle of Plataea claimed as one of the reasons HOMEB AS THE POET OF THE "THEBAIS" 25 for commanding the wing opposite the Spartans their own services at that time; Her. ix. 27: "When the Argives led their troops with Polynices against Thebes and were slain and refused burial, it is our boast that we went out against the Cadmaeans, recovered the bodies and buried them at Eleusis in our own territory." Yet in the face of this, these lynx-eyed critics assume that there was nothing in the Iliad and Odyssey to stir the pride of the Argives or to arouse the envy of jealous neighbors, hence they must flee to a poem which told how these same Argives could not bury their own slain but depended on the mercies of a foreign race to bury them in a foreign soil. The love the people of Argos had for Homer is shown by the fact that Aristarchus quoted readings from the Argive state manuscript for both the Iliad and the Odyssey, but there is not the slightest evidence that they made any attempt to preserve any copy of the Thebais. In the Panegyricus, 158, Isocrates tells of the sadness the Greeks always feel when told in poetry of the wars between the Greeks, and then he adds: "I think that the poetry of Homer has received the greater glory because he pictures them as fighting the barbarians, and it was just because of this that our ancestors honored him in musical festivals and in the education of the young." If Isocrates could pick out as the especial merit of Homer that he represented the Greeks as fighting the barbarians and not one another, then there is no doubt that Homer was not regarded as the poet of the Thebais in Athens in the fourth century B.C., and if Isocrates had ever heard of such a tradition he could not have used this argument. This speech was no sudden and careless production, but a work of art in the preparation of which the orator had spent many years, so that it must be regarded as evidence of the greatest weight. These two passages, one from Herodotus, the other from Pau- sanias, are the only assumed allusions in any classical Greek writer to a Thebais by Homer, yet on this slender foundation Wilamowitz has erected all his stupendous theory of Homer's name and fame in connection with the Thebais. Many sentences like the following could be quoted from his recent Die Ilias und Homer (p. 375) : " The testimony of Callinus proves that in his age the rhapsodists in 26 John A. Scott Ephesus recited the Thebais as Homeric, perhaps these very reciters called themselves Homeridae. Homer is only in a restricted sense the poet of the Iliad." In all of this book the author gives the impres- sion that the only solid fact in connection with Homer is that he was the poet of the Thebais, yet everything rests on a wrong interpreta- tion of a passage in Herodotus, an interpretation refuted by an inscrip- tion set up by the Argives themselves, and on a passage in Pausanias where all the manuscripts have Calaonus, and where Pausanias him- self said that Antimachus had put in verse the story of the expedition against Thebes, 'Avrifiaxos eirurTpareiav 'Apyeiwv iroirjaas « 9i7j3as. Northwestern University