STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. LAND REGISTERS OF WESTERN ASIA UNDER THE SELEUCIDS By W. L. Westebmann Beginning with the publication in the Tebtunis papyri 1 of frag- ments of the land surveys made in the Fayum in Egypt, we have obtained a detailed knowledge of the meticulous methods followed by the village scribes in the villages of Egypt in keeping up the land lists in their village districts. Annually they corrected the land lists, with notations of the changes among the tenants. In their reports the land was classified under administrative categories, as royal domain, land under grant, or temple land. The village scribes also reported the land under its "production categories," stating what amount of each holding was entirely flooded (fiefipeyneurj), how much unflooded but subject to irrigation by ditching (affpoxos), and how much was dry (x^pcros). 2 On the basis of the information thus obtained and the local land register thus annually corrected and brought up to date, the land taxes and the rentals from the royal domains were calculated and collected. The village scribes formulated their reports and sent them upward annually through the regular bureaucratic channels to the royal scribe of the nome. In his office these reports by villages were formulated into a land register for each nome. 8 Ulrich Wilcken has assumed that a land register of the whole of Egypt was also kept in the central offices of the Ptolemies at Alexandria. 4 No positive proof of the existence of this general register has so far been found. But the assumption is no doubt correct; and I venture to add that it would necessarily be greatly curtailed, in the matter of detailed 1 Bernard P. Grenfell, Arthur S. Hunt, and J. Gilbart Smyly, The Tebtunis Papyri (P. Teb.) (London, 1902), see Appendix I, pp. 538 ff. 2 W. L. Westermann, "The ' Uninundated Lands' in Ptolemaic and Roman Egypt," in Classical Philology, XV (1920), April number. 3 H. Lewald, Beitr&ge zur Kentniss des rdmisch-Ogyptischen Grundbuchrechts (Leipzig, 1909), p. 82, n. 6. 4 Ulrich Wilcken, Grundzuge und Chrestomathie der Papyruskunde (Leipzig, 1912), I 1, p. 178. C lassical Philology XVI, January, 1921] 12 Land Registers under the Seleucids 13 information, in comparison with the registers of the nomes, and that the nome registers would necessarily be abstracts of the highly detailed registers by villages kept in the offices of the village scribes. From Egypt we have so far relatively little information from the bureaus of the nomes as compared with the mass of documents from the village bureaus. From the great central bureau of the diocetes at Alexandria we have nothing. For the land problem in Western Asia in the period of the Macedonian dynasties the situation is quite reversed. No lists are available of the peasants and their little hold- ings, no village registers. There are extant, however, a few inscrip- tions dealing with large grants of land made by the Seleucid kings, that is, by the central government, through its general registry office for the kingdom of Syria. These permit a tentative reconstruc- tion, in general outline, of the system of land registers of the royal domain of the Seleucids. This reconstruction is necessarily subject to change as further information comes to light. In the year 254-253 b.c. Antiochus II sold to his queen Laodice a stretch of the royal domain in the Troad, designated as the village of Pannus. 1 The transaction was carried through as follows: King Antiochus wrote to the satrap of the Hellespontine satrapy, Metro- phanes, bidding him determine the boundaries, or more exactly, make the legal "description of property," 2 mark off the property with boundary stones, and arrange for the publication of the sale. The satrap in this transaction was the regular avenue of communication between the king and the lower officials. Metrophanes, the satrap, transmitted the order to Nicomachus, the overseer of the royal domains of the Hellespontine satrapy.* Nicomachus sent the order downward to one crates the hyparch, who is the man who actually carried on the operations of determining the boundaries and marking with terminal stones the territory sold. 4 1 Dittenberger, Orientis Graeci Inscriptiones, 225; B. Haussoullier, Revue de Philologie, XXV (1901), 8-21. 2 O.G.I. 225, 1. 30, wepioplaai. That this is the official term for "description of the boundaries of the property" rather than for the actual determination by boundary stones on the spot is shown by the following words: onjXfioxu t1\v xipov koX trpoaavaypi^/at. rbv ■Ktpiopwp.bv tls tA.s ot^Xos. Cf. Haussoullier, Rev. de Phil., XXV, 32. In O.G.I. 221, 1. 24; 225, 1. 14, and 229, 1. 10, the verb wppoypaKanei' as opposed to Jji-ucexup^Ka/w, "we have granted to." Cf. Sovvai, 1. 27, and see Haussoullier, op. cit., 31, n. 2. 2 Ibid., 11. 21-25. 3 In the American Journal of Archaeology, XVI (1912), 11-82. 1 Ibid., p. 55. 6 Ibid., pp. 22-23. 6 The editors of the document (p. 69) suggest that these chiliarchies may be the same satrapal subdivisions later known as hyparchies. ' Wilcken, Papyruskunde, I 1, p. 284. Land Registers undeb the Selexjcids 17 The land granted to Mnesimachus, though regarded by him as a single estate 1 and mortgaged in its entirety, consisted of non- contiguous areas. The grant was made under two types of areal units, by villages, 2 and by much smaller units called "allotments" (kXtJpoi). 3 The view of the editors of the Mnesimachus document that the villages granted to him were "probably not laid off by metes and bounds "* is certainly incorrect. Just as in the case of the village of Pannus sold to Laodice, 5 the boundaries of each of the village units granted to Mnesimachus must have been sought out in the local registry and the actual local transfer of the land to Mnesimachus made with the greatest exactness as to boundary details. Without such provision the local land registry would have been in a continual state of confusion and a clear title to the property impossible to maintain. The central land register of the royal domain of the Seleucid kings was constructed necessarily upon broader lines, with an apparent absence of details of the delimitation of the properties. The units on the royal, or central, register were villages 6 and allot- ments, ickrjpot..'' The allotments were presumably of definite areas 8 at the outset of the Seleucid regime, as was probably the case also under the early Ptolemies in Egypt. 9 But in Egypt the size of the cleruch grants, even in the late second century B.C., had become quite variable in the same locality and the actual areas of the holdings of 1 AJA, p. 12, col. I, 11. 2, 4, olnov. 2 Ibid., pp. 12-13, KUjuat aXSe (at) KaXoOvrai rofiaknovpa .... (cat SXXai K&iiai. ij KaXelrcu ravSov Kal Ko/tPSiXuria .... Kal aXXij Kcipij UtpuuroarpaTa .... Kal oXXi; Kciv") h> 'ArroiSSois r) KaXelrcu IXou k&ixt). s Ibid., 11. 6, 8. 4 Ibid., p. 54. 6 O.G.I. 225, 11. 40-49. 6 AJA, XVI, 12-13. TO/3aX/u>upa lai/H) .... Ku^eu ravSov Kal KoiifSSikiina .... Kal ftXXij (cwjui) neptacroffTpara ; O.G.I, p. 225, 1. 2, Tlavvov nii/ii} ; O.G.I. 221, 11. 28-29, Typ Ukrpav . ... Kal t»js x&pas -rijs HerpiSos hpyaaiixov irXiflpa x^'" vevraKbaia ; O.G.I. 262, 1. 6, Kiifiriv rip> BatTOKauoj^v, granted by one of the kings named Antioehua to the temple of Zeus Baetocaece. 7 Mnesimachus document, AJA, XCI, 12-13. The xXflpoi about Smyrna granted to certain mercenaries colonized in Palaemagnesia are of two types, ordinary allotments and "cavalry" allotments, KKqpovs limxobs in O.G.I. 221, 11. 42-43. 8 AJA, XVI. 74. 9 P. Teb. I, Appendix I, p. 548. 18 W. L. Westermann the "hundred arourae" and the "thirty arourae" cleruchs fail in many cases to agree with the titles. 1 So also in Western Asia, varia- tion in the size of the allotments, as private ownership developed, must have come rapidly. In 125-26 a.d. Hadrian wrote to the pro- consul of Asia stating that he should take as a standard of measure- ment for the kleroi a mean between the largest and the smallest holdings in that vicinity, if it was impossible to find out the size of the allotments as established by the kings (the Seleucids). 2 The indications that the central land registry of the Seleucids was without detailed descriptions of its village and allotment units and unable to keep up to date its information upon transfers from the royal domain are as follows : 1. The king, in all the available cases, must order the satrap to have the delimiting done locally. 3 2. In the case of the sale to Laodice the central register is unable to indicate what t6toi (perhaps meaning single plots upon which peasants are living outside the village) are on the estate called " the village of Pannus." 4 3. The village of Petra, conferred upon Aristodicides of Assos, had already been granted to one Athenaeus and the grant had not, as yet, been recorded at the central registry. 5 The central register did, however, show, in the case of the village of Baetocaece, that it had once been held by an official named Demetrius, but was sixain available for assignment. 6 For the royal domains about Babylon the local, or detailed, register would, of 1 P. Teb. I, Appendix I, p. 547. Cf. P. Teb. I, 27, II. 7-8; 30, I. 17 (34 arourae) ; 31, 1. 13 (34& arourae); 32, note to line 18 (24 arourae); 54 (10 arourae). 2 The ingenious attempt of the editors of the Mnesimachus document (AJA, XVI, 73-75) to determine the actual size of the allotments granted to Mnesimachus leads to no acceptable result. The computation is based upon three factors, none of which is applicable with certainty to the situation about Sardes in the time of Mnesimachus. These are a 4 per cent return jn land values (this must have been quite variable) ; an unconvincing comparison between the size of plots of city land about Magnesia with the kleroi about Sardes; and an unproved assumption that these city plots of Magnesia were approximately oi the same productive quality as the allotments granted to Mnesimachus. 3 O.G.I. 225, 1. 30; 221, 11. 21-23; 262, 1. 8, "according to the existing boundaries." * Ibid., 225, II. 3-4. 6 Ibid., 221, 11. 50-54. • O.G.I. 262, II. 6-7. Land Registers under the Seleucids 19 course, be in Babylon itself and immediately available to the officials of the king. This explains why, in a grant made to his wife Laodice by Seleucus II 1 in 233-232 b.c., 2 the size of the grants (15, 12, 30 measures) is recorded. 3 There was a land register maintained for the Lydian satrapy at Sardes, at a bureau called the paaihucal 7pa<£cu. 4 This may have been the name of the land-registry office or of a general record office of the satrapy, of which the land registry was merely one department. In the sale to Laodice the satrap Metrophanes receives an order from the king to record the sale in this Sardian bureau. It is a justified assumption that similar land registers for the satrapies were established in the other provinces of i^he Seleucid kingdom. There is no evidence regarding the extent of the details kept upon the satrapal registers. I have shown, however, that the actual descriptions of the boundaries were obtained through the hyparch, an official of the subdivision of the satrapy. 6 One has, therefore, a strong impression that the satrapal registry office was not supplied with details as to the land units of villages and allotments. Cornell University Ithaca, N.Y. 1 Haussoullier, op. cit., 18. The cuneiform tablet recording this gift is in New York. * Rostovtseff in Klio I, 299, n. 1. 3 Rev. de Phil., XXV, 18. 4 O.G.I. 225, 11. 23-24, Kai ri)v iivijii i.vayp&'pai «£s tAs (8o<7tX«ds yp&s rds h> Xhp&erip. 6 O.G.I. 238, n. 2. See the fuller discussion by Haussoullier, op. cit., 22-26.