Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content. JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Votume XV October I 920 NumBer 4 POSIDONIUS AND THE SOURCES OF PYTHAGOREAN ARITHMOLOGY! By Frank Ecieston Rossing It has become the practice in recent years, especially in Germany, to regard Posidonius’ Commentary on the Timaeus as the source of scientific pronouncements of various kinds in the ancient authors. Although this commentary was undoubtedly a most important and comprehensive work, it nevertheless seems somewhat strange, to mention at once the matter with which these pages are concerned, that the Greeks invariably went thither for information about Pythagorean number-theories at a time when the literary world was flooded with books, pseudonymous or otherwise, written by the Pythagoreans themselves. Posidonius became recognized as the chief ancient authority upon the Pythagorean lore of numbers chiefly through the argu- ments of A. Schmekel,? who used as the basis of his theory Sextus Empiricus Adv. math. vii. 91 ff. Since that time his conclusion has “ 1“ Arithmology”’ has been defined as ‘‘ce genre de remarques sur la formation, la valeur et l’ importance des dix premiers nombres, ot: se mélent la saine recherche scientifique et les fantaisies de la religion et de philosophie” by A. Delatte, ‘Etudes sur la littérature pythagoricienne,’’ Bibl. de Ecole des Hautes Etudes, fase. 217, Paxis, 1915, p. 139. 2 Die Philosophie der mitileren Stoa in ihrem geschichtlichen Zusammenhange dar- gestellt, Berlin, 1892, pp. 408 ff. [CLASSICAL PHILOLOGY XV, October, 1920] 309 810 FRANK EGLESTON ROBBINS generally been accepted as final.1 More may be drawn from the study of Sextus, however, than Schmekel took account of. In the first place, Schmekel used the passage designated almost to the exclusion of another in the same work, iv. 2 ff., which, since it agrees practically word for word with vii. 91 ff. throughout much of its length, is obviously ultimately derived from the same source. A proper diagnosis of the situation surely demands, first of all, that the two passages be examined side by side and their meaning analyzed;? hence one may infer whence each came and for what purpose it was written. If we do this, and take iv. 2 ff. first, we find that its outline is as follows: At the very beginning the general theme of the passage is stated, which is simply that the Pytha- goreans ascribed great power to numbers in the government of the universe; this caused them to use the expression ‘‘all things are like to number,” and in their well-known oath by Pythagoras to speak of the tetraktys as the “source that holds the roots of ever- lasting nature.’ The following sections develop the implications of this epithet and are therefore thoroughly consistent with the central theme of the passage; the numbers of the tetraktys, 1, 2, 3, 4, in their capacities as point, line, surface, and solid, respectively, rep- resent all bodily natures, and, furthermore, soul; for since 1, 2, 3, and 4 contain the fundamental concords they control the harmony whereby the world is ordered and the soul constituted. This passage, then, is thoroughly consistent within itself, its main thesis is kept in view throughout and supported by argument, and its logical struc- ture is admirable. The other, vii. 91 ff., treats an entirely different theme, the criterion. It may be summarized thus: Anaxagoras declared that the criterion was λόγος, using the term in a general way; but the Pythagoreans restrict it to the mathematical λόγος, because, as Philolaus said, if it takes cognizance of the universe it must be akin 1Cf. G. Borghorst, De Anatolit fontibus, Berlin, 1905; G. Altmann, De Posidonio Timaei Platonis commentatore, Berlin, 1906; Gronau, Poseidonios und die jildisch- christliche Genesisexegese, Berlin, 1914, p. 197, n. 1. 2 Zeller, Philosophie der Griechen, III, 1, p. 514, n. 5, concludes from such a com- parison that the Pythagorean element in Adv. math. vii, 92 ff. is not from Posidonius. Against this view Schmekel argues, op. cit., p. 407, n. 1. A proper comparative analysis of the two passages has not, however, been made. PosIDONIUS AND PYTHAGOREAN ARITHMOLOGY 911 to the universe, on the principle of the perception of like by like; Empedocles, who is quoted,! clearly states this principle. And as the light is perceived by the kindred sight, so Posidonius says in his Commentary on the Timaeus, and sound by the hearing, which is akin to air, so the universe ought to be apprehended by a λόγος of the same nature. But number is the source of the universe, where- fore the λόγος that is the criterion of all, not without its share in this, would be called number. It is to declare this that the Pytha- goreans often say “all things are like to number” and use their accustomed oath. Its author was Pythagoras; the tetraktys is 10, or 1+2+3+4, which is the “source of everlasting nature,” first, because it contains the basic concords; second, because it contains point, line, surface, and solid; furthermore, because, all things being numerable, number is fundamental. This is the outline of the pas- sage; I have more carefully reproduced the first portion in order to make clear the logical connection; but the last part, from the men- tion of the Pythagorean sayings, is that which is closest to iv. 2 ff., and no argument is needed to show that ultimately the two must have been derived from the same source. Now it must be equally clear, it seems to the writer, that there are signs of disjointedness and of compilation in the second, but not in the first, passage. For in the former there is one theme only, and that sustained consistently throughout; in the latter we begin with the criterion and then abandon it for a detailed discussion of certain Pythagorean theories about number, the transition being of the most formal character. The last portion of vii. 91 ff. leaves the impression of being an argument, already existent and ready to hand in the work of some earlier author, awkwardly forced into a new context by the writer of the part about the criterion, and betraying its alien origin by the noticeable lapse in logical connec- tion. This conclusion commends itself the more strongly because we know iv. 2 ff. also; having the latter, and seeing in it none of the marks of patching together, but on the contrary an admirable unity of construction, we must conclude that in iv. 2 ff. we have Sextus’ quotation of certain material in its original form and used as it was 1 Fragment 109, Diels; cited also by Aristotle De anima A 2 40468; Metaphysica B 4 1000 ὃ δ; and by Chalcidius in Plat. Tim. c. 50. 312 FRANK EGLESTON ROBBINS originally intended to be used, whereas in vii. 92 ff. he has employed a passage of another author who had himself cited this same material. There is still further proof that the Pythagorean part of vii. 92 ff. existed in another form (i.e., that of iv. 2 ff.) before it was taken into its present context; not only that, but we may infer the original purpose of its composition. This is afforded by the dis- covery of a probably identical origin for Adv. math. iv. 2 ff. and two passages of Theon of Smyrna and Anatolius respectively. Sextus Empiricus Adv. math. iv. 2 ff.: καθόλου μὲν οὖν οἱ ἀπὸ τῶν μαθημάτων Πυθαγορικοὶ με- γάλην ἀπονέμουσι δύναμιν τοῖς ἀριθμοῖς ὡς τῆς τῶν ὅλων φύσεως κατ᾽ αὐτοὺς διοικουμένης. ὅθεν καὶ ἀεί ποτε ἐπεφώνουν τὸ “ἀριθ- μῷ δέ τε πάντ᾽ ἐπέοικεν," ὀμνύοντες οὐ μόνον τὸν ἀριθμὸν ἀλλὰ καὶ τὸν ὑπο- δείξαντα αὐτοῖς τοῦτον Πυθαγόραν ὡς θεὸν διὰ τὴν ἐν ἀριθμητική δύνα- μιν, λέγοντες “Οὐ μὰ τὸν ἁμετέρᾳ ψυχᾷ παραδόντα τετρακτύν, Πηγὴν ἀενάου φύσεως ῥιζώματ’ ἔχου- σαν.᾽᾽ τετρακτὺς δὲ προση- γορεύετο παρ᾽ αὐτοῖς ὁ ἐκ τῶν πρώτων δ΄ ἀριθμῶν Theon, p. 99, ll. 8-23:! ὁ δὲ καὶ ἐκ τῶν τετρακτύων τούτων συστὰς κόσμος ἔσται «τέλειος > ἡρμοσμένος κατὰ γεωμετρίαν καὶ ἁρμονίαν καὶ ἀριθμόν, δυνάμει περιει- ληφὼς πᾶσαν ἀριθμοῦ φύσιν πᾶν τε μέγεθος καὶ πᾶν σῶμα ἁπλοῦν τε καὶ σύνθετον, TE λειός τε, ἐπειδὴ τὰ πάντα μὲν τούτου μέρη, αὐτὸς δὲ οὐδενός. διὸ πρώτῳ τῷ εἰρημένῳ ὅρκῳ οἱ Πυθαγο- ρικοὶ ἐλέγοντοξ.... καὶ ἀριθμῷ δέ re πάντ᾽ ἐπέοικε. καὶ τοῦτο εἶναι τὸ σοφώτα- τον πάντα μὲν γὰρ τὸν ἀριθμὸν εἰς δεκάδα ἤγα- γον, ἐπειδὴ ὑπὲρ δεκάδα οὐδείς ἐστιν ἀριθμός, ἐν δ τῇ αὐξήσει πάλιν ἡμῶν Anatolius, p. 29, 1-10:? ἡ δεκάδος καὶ τῶν ἐντὸς αὐτῆς ἀριθμῶν φύσις μυρία μὲν περιέχεται καὶ ἐπιδείκ- νυσι κἀλλη τοῖς ὀξυδέρκως τῷ νῷ καθορᾶν τὰ τοιαῦτα ὅσα μὲν οὖν ἐὰν οἷόν τε ἦ λέξομεν ἐφ᾽ ἑκάστου τῶν ἀριθμῶν, τοσοῦτον δὲ δυναμένοις. προλέγομεν νῦν, ὅτι οἱ Πυθαγορεῖοι τὸν πάντα ἀριθμὸν εἰς δέκα ἀνῆγον, ὑπὲρ δέκα δὲ οὐ- δεὶς ἔτι ἀριθμός, ἐν πάσῃ αὐξήσει πάλιν ἡμῶν ἐπι- 1 Expositio rerum mathematicarum ad legendum Platonem utilium, ed. Hiller, Leipzig, 1878. The work is generally acknowledged to be a compilation. Schmekel, op. cit., p. 410, believes this passage to come from Thrasyllus; so also Switalski, Des Chalcidius Kommentar zu Platos Timaeus, Beitrige z. Gesch. ἃ. Phil. ἃ. Mittelalters, III, 6, Minster, 1902, pp. 85-86; Borghorst, op. cit., pp. 17 ff., assigns it to Moderatus, and Altmann, op. cit., pp. 19 ff., to Adrastus. 2Ed. J. L. Heiberg, Annales internationales d’ histoire, Congres de Paris, 1900, 5¢ section, histoire des sciences, Paris, 1901. The title is περὲ δεκάδος καὶ τῶν ἐντὸς αὐτῆς ἀριθμῶν. Many excerpts from it appear in the anonymous Theologumena Artthmeticae, ed. Ast, 1817. 3 Theon has already quoted the oath given by Sextus in p. 94, ll. 6-7, a passage which contains probably more of the material found in Adv. math., IV, 2 ff. For other citations of this oath cf. Hiller, ad loc. Delatte, op. cit., p. 250, note. On the evident textual difficulties at this point see Hiller, ad loc. ῬΟΒΙΌΟΝΙΒ AND PyTHAGOREAN ARITHMOLOGY Sextus: συγκείμενος ι΄ ἀριθμός" a’ γὰρ καὶ β΄ καὶ y’ καὶ 8’ ι΄ γίνεται" ὅς ἐστι τελει- ότατος ἀριθμός, ἐπείπερ ἐπ’ αὐτὸν φθάσαντες πάλιν ἀναλύομεν ἐπὶ τὴν μονάδα καὶ ἐξ ὑπαρχῆς ποιούμεθα Theon: ὑποστρεφόντων ἐπὶ povd- Sa καὶ δυάδα καὶ τοὺς ἑξῆς" τὴν δὲ δεκάδα ἐπὶ τετράδα συνίστασθαι ἕν γὰρ καὶ β΄ καὶ y’ καὶ δ΄ ἐστι ι', ὥστε τοὺς δυνατωτάτους ἀριθμοὺς ἐντὸς τῆς τετράδος 313 Anatolius: στρεφόντων ἐπὶ μονάδα μετὰ τὸ συμπληροῦσθαι πᾶσαν δεκάδα " ἀλλὰ καὶ ὅτι ἐκ τετράδος σννίστα- ται ἣ δεκὰς εἰς τὰ μάλιστα τὴν τετρακτὺν ἐτίμων». τὰς ἀριθμήσεις. πηγὴν κτλ... . . . εἰρήκασιν αὐτὸν θεωρεῖσθαι. διὰ τὸ κατ᾽ αὐτοὺς ἐν αὐτῷ τὸν λόγον τῶν ἁπάντων κεῖσθαι συστάσεως, οἷον εὖ- θέως τοῦ τε σώματος καὶ τῆς ψυχῆς. . .. That all three of these passages occur in different contexts is the reason why there is divergency among them. No two contain exactly the same material, yet by pairs they show close agreement, and the same thought is implicit in all three. The close similarity of the latter parts of Anatolius and Theon leaves no doubt that both go back to the same ultimate source,! and their differences are to be ascribed to the position of the passage in Theon, as a link between the discussion of the tetraktyes and that of the first decade, and to Anatolius’ tendency to condense, noticeable throughout his whole treatise. He has here left out all mention of the Pythagorean oath and the other saying,? but his own last words, “‘they honored the tetraktys especially,’ its inclusion in both Sextus and Theon, and the fact that his statements about the Decad have point only as an explanation of the oath by the tetraktys, make it hardly doubtful that this is his own arbitrary omission. As for Sextus, his passage contains all the thought of the other two—the two Pythagorean sayings: the notion that 10 is made up of 1, 2, 3, and 4, the tetraktys; 1 1 there were any doubt, the verbal correspondence of Theon and Anatolius in the other passages dealing with numbers would dispel it. 2 This, however, is due only to the desire to condense, for the saying is found in a collection of excerpts from Anatolius, in this form: ὅτε τὴν ἀριθμητικὴν ob μόνος ἐτίμα Πυθαγόρας, ἀλλὰ καὶ of τούτου γνώριμοι ἐπιλέγοντες ᾿Αριθμῷ δέ τε πάντ᾽ ἐπέοικεν (see F. Hultsch, Heronis Alexandrini Geometricorum et stereometricorum reliquiae, Berlin, 1864, p. 279). 3 This phrase, and the concluding phrase of Theon, should be compared with the end of the passage of Sextus, which is quoted below, p. 318. 314 FRANK EGLESTON ROBBINS that 10 includes all the numbers (he says that it is ‘‘most perfect’’), because we find no new ones in counting above it. The order of the last two is reversed in Anatolius and Theon as compared with this, and in what follows the part quoted. Sextus elaborates further the powers of the numbers of the tetraktys. In general, we may con- clude that we have here two versions of the same thing, a longer one represented by Sextus, and a condensed one in Theon and Anatolius, the latter having still further condensed on his own account.! Possibly more material that originally belonged in this context and is still seen there in Sextus is to be found in Theon’s foregoing discussion of the tetraktyes.2 To make the relationship even more probable, we shall see later that in another section Ana- tolius agrees word for word with Sextus in the latter’s continuation of the citation above. As to the original nature of the passage, the clue, I believe, is given by Theon and Anatolius. In each it appears as the introduc- tion to a discussion of the numbers of the first decade; in Theon this is not so apparent, since it also happens to conclude the section about the tetraktyes, but Anatolius’ employment of it should be taken as the proper one. This conclusion will recommend itself if one simply reads over the Theonian context and notes the plain evidence of its disjointedness, and furthermore that in citing these words Theon is led to make an awkward repetition of statements already introduced relative to the first tetraktys.* We have, then, in this passage the introduction to a Pythagorean treatise on the first ten numbers, and surely nothing could be more appropriate for this purpose, from the Pythagorean standpoint, than a forceful exposition of the general powers of number in the cosmos, as epito- mized in 10 and the tetraktys. 1 There are other versions of the material presented in the three passages quoted. The original arithmological document, of which I assume these to cite the preface, apparently repeated most of the statements later, in the chapters devoted to 4 and 10, and from these probably are derived, as far as any connection exists, the reports of Philo De mundi opificio ce. 15-16, Lydus De mensibus iii. 4, iv, 64, Winsch, Chalcidius in Tim. c. 35, Hierocles in carm. aur. c. 20, Martianus Capella, Favonius, ete. 2 See p. 312, n. 3, above. 3 Cf. Theon, p. 99, ll. 21-23, with p. 93, ll. 19 ff., Hiller. POSIDONIUS AND PYTHAGOREAN ARITHMOLOGY 315 In order to clarify the situation still further, the words of Sextus immediately after what has been quoted may be compared with the following: Sextus Adv. math. iv. 4 (p. 722, 15 Bekker.): ἡ μὲν οὖν μονὰς ἀρχή τις ὑποκεῖται τῆς τῶν ἄλλων ἀριθμῶν ἀπεργαστικὴ συ- στάσεως, ἡ δὲ δυὰς μήκους ἐστι ἀπεργαστική. καθά- περ γὰρ ἐπὶ τῶν γεωμετρι- κῶν ἀρχῶν ὑὕὑπεδείξαμεν 1 πρῶτον τίς ἐστιν ἡ στιγμή, εἶτα μετ᾽ αὐτὴν ἡ γραμμὴ μῆκος ἀπλατὲς τυγχάνουσα, τὸν αὐτὸν τρόπον καὶ ἐπὶ τοῦ παρόντος ἡ μὲν μονὰς τὸν τῆς στιγμῆς ἐπέχει λόγον, ἡ δὲ δυὰς τὸν τῆς γραμμῆς καὶ τοῦ μήκους" ποθὲν γὰρ ποῦ ἐφέρετο ὁ νοῦς, καὶ προστιθεμένης τῇ κατὰ μῆκος διαστάσει τῆς κατὰ πλάτος διαστάσεως ἐπιφάνεια νοεῖται, ἀλλὰ κἂν ἐπιθεωρήσῃ τις τῇ τριάδι τετάρτην μονάδα, τουτέστιν τέταρτον σημεῖον, γίνεται πυραμίς, στερεὸν σῶμα καὶ σχῆμα᾽ καὶ γὰρ μῆκος ἔχει καὶ πλάτος καὶ βάθος" ὥστε ἐν τῷ τέσσαρα ἀριθμῷ τὸν τοῦ σώματος λογον. περιέχεσθαι Philo De mundi opificio 16: πρώτη yap αὕτη τὴν τοῦ στερεοῦ φύσιν ἔδειξε, τῶν πρὸ αὐτῆς ἀριθμῶν τοῖς ἀσω- μάτοις ἀνακειμένων. μὲν γὰρ τὸ ἕν τάττεται τὸ λεγόμενον ἐν γεωμετρίᾳ εἷ- ναι σημεῖον, κατὰ δὲ τὰ δύο γραμμή, διότι φύσει ἐκ ση- μείου συνίσταται. ἡ Ὑραμ- μὴ δέ ἐστι μῆκος ἀπλατές" πλάτους δὲ προσγενομένου γίνεται ἐπιφάνεια, ἣ τέτακ- κατὰ ται κατὰ τριάδα" ἐπιφάνεια δὲ πρὸς τὴν στερεοῦ φύσιν ἑνὸς δεῖται τοῦ βάθους, ὃ προστεθὲν τῇ τριάδι γίνεται τετράς... .. ὁ δὲ μὴ συ- νιεὶς τὸ λεγόμενον ἔκ τινος παιδιᾶς εἴσεται πάνυ συ- καρνατίζοντες τρία ἐν ἐπιπέδῳ νήθους. οἱ εἰώθασι προτιθέντες κάρυα ἐπιφέρειν ἕν, σχῆμα πυραμοειδὲς ἀπο- γεννῶντες. τὸ μὲν οὖν ἐν ἐπιπέδῳ τρίγωνον ἵσταται μέχρι τριάδος, τὸ δὲ ἐπιτεθὲν τετράδα μὲν ἐν ἀριθμοῖς, ἐν δὲ σχήμασι πυραμίδα γεννᾷ, στερεὸν ἤδη σῶμα. Anatolius, p. 32, 3 Hei- berg: πρῶτος ἔδειξε τὴν στερεοῦ φύσιν" σημεῖον γάρ, εἶτα γραμμή, εἶτα ἐπιφάνεια, εἶτα στερεόν, ὅ ἐστι σῶμα. τοῦτο τῶν καρυατιζόντων παιδιά, σχῆμα πυραμίδος. a ποιουσα The passage οἵ Anatolius comes, not from the introduction, but from the chapter on the tetrad, and there is a close parallel to it in Johannes Laurentius Lydus De mensibus iv. 64 (Wiinsch).?. There can be no doubt that Philo, Anatolius, and Lydus ultimately go 1 This is probably a reference to Adv. math. iii. 19 ff. 2 πρῶτος οὖν τετράγωνος ἀριθμὸς οὗτος καὶ rerpaxrbs, ἀλλὰ μὴν Kal πρῶτος ἔδειξε τὴν στερεὰν φύσιν" σημεῖον γάρ, εἶτα γραμμή, εἶτα ἐπιφάνεια, εἶτα στερεόν, ὅ ἐστι σῶμα. Theon, p. 101, 11 Hiller has so abbreviated his notice of the number 4 that little can be made of the parallel passage: ἡ δὲ τετρὰς στερεοῦ ἐστιν εἰκών, πρῶτός τε ἀριθμὸς [καὶ] τετράγωνός ἐστιν ἐν ἀρτίοις, κτλ. 316 FRANK EGLESTON ROBBINS back to an identical source; the former, however, apparently used it in an unabridged form, while Anatolius and Lydus both drew from an epitomized version. Without delaying to speculate upon these matters, in support of which further arguments could be stated, let us note that, although Sextus treats of similar topics, the form of his statement is very different from that of the other three. others from the body, of the common source. Comparing the immediately succeeding words of Sextus, again, with others of the arithmological writers, a somewhat different situation appears: Sextus Adv. math. iv. 68. (Bek- ker, p. 723): kal μὴν καὶ τὸν τῆς ψυχῆς ὡς γὰρ τὸν ὅλον κόσμον κατὰ ἁρμονίαν λέγουσι δι- οικεῖσθαι, οὕτω καὶ τὸ ζῶον ψυχοῦσθαι. δοκεὶ δὲ ἡ τέλειος ἁρμονία ἐν συμφωνίαις λαμβά- νειν τὴν ὑπόστασιν, τῇ τε διὰ τεττάρων τρισὶ καὶ τῇ διὰ πέντε καὶ τῇ διὰ πασῶν. ἡ μὲν οὖν διὰ τεσσά- ρων ἐν ἐπιτρίτῳ κεῖ- ται λόγῳ, ἡ δὲ διὰ πέντε ἐν ἡμιολίῳ, ἡ δὲ διὰ πασῶν ἐν δι- πλασίονι. ἐπίτρι- τος δὲ λέγεται ἀριθμὸς ὁ ἐξ ὅλου Anatolius, p. 32, 15 Heiberg: ob μόνον δὲ τὸν τοῦ σώματος ἐπέχει λό- γον ἐν ἀριθμοῖς τε- tpas,! ἀλλὰ καὶ τὸν τῆς ψυχῆς ὡς γὰρ τὸν ὅλον κόσμον φασὶ κατὰ ἁρμονίαν διοικεῖσθαι, οὕτως καὶ τὸ ζῶον ψυχοῦ- σθαι. δοκεῖ δὲ τέλε- tos ἁρμονία ἐν τρισὶ σνυμφωνίαις ὑφεστά- ναι, τῇ διὰ 5’, ἥτις ἐν ἐπιτρίτῳ κεῖται λόγῳ, τῇ διὰ ε' ἐν ἡμιολίῳ, τῇ διὰ πα- σῶν ἐν διπλασίονι. Philo, De mundi opifieio 15: περιέχει δὲ ἡ τετρὰς καὶ τοὺς λόγους τῶν κατὰ μουσικὴν συμ- φωνιῶν, τῆς τε διὰ τεττάρων καὶ διὰ πέντε καὶ διὰ πασῶν καὶ προσέτι δὶς διὰ πασῶν, ἐξ ὧν σύστη- μα τὸ τελειότατον ἀπογεννᾶται τῆς μὲν γὰρ διὰ τεττά- ρων ὁ λόγος ἐπίτρι- τος, τῆς δὲ διὰ πέντε ἡμιόλιος, διπλάσιος δὲ τῆς διὰ πασῶν, τετραπλάσιος δὲ τῆς δὶς διὰ πασῶν. ods ἅπαντας ἡ τετρὰς ἔχει περιλαβοῦσα" τὸν μὲν γοῦν ἐπίτρι- τον ἐν τῷ τέσσαρα This is probably because he drew from the introduction, the Chalcidius,Comm. in Tim. ο. 35: symphoniae quo- que ratio ex eorun- dem numerorum qui decimanum numerum con- plent quasi quo- dam fonte de- manat: siquidem ex his epitriti et sescuplares et du- plices et triplices et quadruplices numeri sonique nascuntur. ορὶ- triti quidem ut quattuor adver- sum tres. habent enim totum nu- merum trientem et eius tertiam partem, id est 1 Note that this parallels the final words of Sextus in the last passage quoted above. It is a very significant parallel. 2 The following section, containing matter explaining certain arithmetical terms, since it is not paralleled by Anatolius, might be regarded as an addition by Sextus; on the other hand it could as easily be an instance of an omission by Anatolius for the sake of brevity. Chalcidius presents similar details, without, however, the distinctive marks of close relationship present in Sextus and Anatolius. PosIpONIUS AND ΡΥΤΗΛΟΌΒΕΑΝ ARITHMOLOGY Sextus: τινὸς ἀριθμοῦ συνεσ- τηκὼς καὶ ἐκ τοῦ τρίτου μέρους ἐκεί- νου, ὡς ἔχει ὁ ὀκτὼ πρὸς τὸν ξξ᾽ καὶ γὰρ αὐτὸν τὸν ξδξ περιέ- σχῆκε καὶ τὸ τρίτον αὐτοῦ, τουτέστι τὴν δυάδα. ἡμιόλιος δὲ καλεῖται, ὅταν πε- ριέχῃ ἀριθμὸς ἀριθ- μὸν καὶ τὸ ἥμισυ ἐκείνου, ὡς ἔχει ὁ ἐννέα πρὸς τὸν et συνέστηκε γὰρ ἐκ τοῦ ἕξ καὶ ἐκ τοῦ ἡμίσεος αὐτοῦ, τουτέστι τῶν τριῶν. διπλασίων δὲ προσαγορεύεται ὁ δυσὶν ἀριθμοῖς ἴσος, ὡς ὁ τέσσαρα πρὸς τὸν dbo" δὶς γὰρ τὸν αὐτὸν περιέσχηκεν. ἀλλὰ γὰρ τούτων οὕτως ἐχόντων, καὶ κατὰ τὴν ἀρχῆθεν ὑπόθεσιν τεσσάρων ὄντων ἀριθμῶν, τοῦ τε ἑνὸς καὶ δύο καὶ τρία καὶ τέσσαρα, ἐν οἷς ἐλέγομεν καὶ τὴν τῆς ψυχῆς ἰδέαν περιέχεσθαι κατὰ τὸν ἐναρμόνιον λό- γον, ὁ μὲν τέσσαρα τοῦ δύο καὶ ὁ δύο τῆς μονάδος ἐστὶ διπλα- σίων, ἐν ᾧ ἐκεῖτο ἡ διὰ πασῶν συμφω- νία, ὁ δὲ τρία τοῦ δύο ἡμιόλιος (καὶ γὰρ αὐτὸν τὸν δύο Anatolius: ὄντων δὲ ἀριθμῶν τεττάρων τῶν πρώὠ- των a’ β' γ᾽ δ΄, ἐν τούτοις καὶ ἡ τῆς ψυχῆς ἰδέα περιέχε- ται κατὰ τὸν évap- μόνιον λόγον, ὁ μὲν 6’ τοῦ B’ καὶ ὁ β’ τοῦ α’ διπλάσιος, ἐν ᾧ κεῖται ἡ διὰ πα- σῶν συμφωνία, ὁ δὲ γ΄ τοῦ β' ἡμιόλιος, περιέχων αὐτὸν καὲ τὸ ἥμισυν, τὴν διὰ πέντε συμφωνίαν ὑποβάλλει, ὁ δὲ δ' Philo: πρὸς τρία, τὸν δὲ ἡμιόλιον ἐν τῷ τρία πρός δύο, τὸν δὲ δι- πλάσιον ἐν τῷ δύο πρὸς ἕν ἢ τέσσαρα πρὸς δύο, τὸν δὲ τε- τραπλάσιον ἐν τῷ τέσσαρα πρὸς ἕν. 317 Chalcidius: unum. sescu- plares uero, ut tres aduersum duo; habent enim tres totum nu- merum dualem et eius partem dimi- diam, id est unum. duplices uero ut sunt duo aduersus unum. _ triplices porro ut sunt tres aduersus unum. et quadruplices ut sunt quattuor ad- versus unum. epi- tritus autem in calculando idem est qui diates- saron dicitur in canendo. sescu- plaris uero idem est qui diapente dicitur in can- endo. duplex uero qui diapason dici- tur in canendo,! quadruplex qui di- diapason dicitur in canendo. 1 At this point Wrobel would add ‘‘triplex qui diapason et diapente dicitur in canendo,”’ following Fabricius and thinking that Chalcidius omitted the words, which appear neither in the MSS nor the first edition, through error or forgetfulness. Note, however, that the passage agrees with Theon, p. 58, 18 ff., as it stands. 818 Sextus: περιέσχηκε καὶ τὸ ἥμισυ τούτου, ὅθεν καὶ τὴν διὰ πέντε συμφωνίαν ὑπέβαλ- λεν), ὁ δὲ τέσσαρα τοῦ τρία ἐπίτριτος, ὑπέκειτο δὲ καὶ ἐν τούτῳ ἡ διὰ τεσ- Frank EGLEsToN ROBBINS Anatolius: τοῦ γ΄ ἐπίτριτος, ἐν ᾧ ἡ διὰ δ' συμφωνία. εἰ δὲ ἐν τῷ δ' ἀριθμῷ τὸ πᾶν κεῖται ἐκ ψυχῆς καὶ σώματος, ἀληθὲς ἄρα καὶ ὅτι αἱ συμφωνίαι πᾶσαι κατ᾽ αὐτὸν τελοῦν- Philo: Chalcidius: σάρων συμφωνία. rat} ὥστε εἰκότως τὸν τέσσαρα ἀριθμὸν παρὰ τοῖς Πυθαγο- ρικοῖς εἰρῆσθαι πη- γὴν ἀενάου φύσεως ῥιζώματ᾽ ἔχουσαν. In Theon’s arithmology, p. 101, 12 Hiller, he merely says καὶ αἱ συμφωνίαι δὲ πᾶσαι κατ᾽ αὐτὸν συμπληροῦνται, ws ἐδείχθη. This reference leads us back to p. 93, 17: ἐπειδὴ πάντες οἱ τῶν συμφωνιῶν εὑρέθησαν λόγοι, καθὰ δέδεικται, ἐν τῇ τῆς δεκάδος τετρακτύι, καὶ περὶ τούτων πρότερον λεκτέον. τὴν μὲν γὰρ τετρακτὺν συνέστησεν ἡ δεκάς. ἕν μὲν γὰρ καὶ B’ καὶ γ᾽ καὶ δ΄ ι΄" a’ β΄ γ΄ δ΄. ἐν δὲ τούτοις τοῖς ἀριθμοῖς ἐστιν ἥ τε διὰ τεσσάρων συμφωνία ἐν ἐπιτρίτῳ λόγῳ καὶ ἡ διὰ πέντε ἐν ἡμιολίῳ καὶ ἡ διὰ πασῶν ἐν διπλασίῳ καὶ ἡ δὶς διὰ πασῶν ἐν τετραπλασίῳ᾽ ἐξ ὧν συμπληροῦται τὸ ἀμετάβολον διάγραμμα. And in turn the reference here is to p. 58, 18: πάσας δὲ τὰς συμφωνίας περιέχει ἡ τετρακτύς. συνέστησε μὲν γὰρ αὐτὴν a’ καὶ β΄ καὶ γ΄ καὶ δ΄. ἐν δὲ τούτοις τοῖς ἀριθμοῖς ἐστιν ἥ τε διὰ τεσσάρων συμφωνία καὶ ἡ διὰ πέντε καὶ ἡ διὰ πασῶν, καὶ ὁ ἐπίτριτος λόγος καὶ ἡμιόλιος καὶ διπλάσιος καὶ τριπλάσιος καὶ τετραπλάσιος. Among these passages, there certainly exists an agreement between Sextus and Anatolius which is indicative of a common source; the others do not share this verbal similarity, and, besides, they include among the harmonic ratios the diapason, making four, while Sextus and Anatolius report only three. Chalcidius and Theon, here as elsewhere,? show marks of close relationship; they 1The concluding sentence of Anatolius is obviously modeled after what is seen in Sextus, but modified to suit its new context. 2 This alliance is manifested by several significant minor identities of phrase; for instance, of the triad, Theon says πρώτη λέγεται πάντα εἶναι and Chalcidius PosiIpONIUS AND PYTHAGOREAN ARITHMOLOGY 319 both mention the triple ratio, and each regards the number four as the tetraktys. The conditions may be explained by concluding that Sextus and Anatolius for this passage depend on the introduc- tion of the arithmological treatise, Philo, Theon, and Chalcidius upon its chapter on 4. The latter two, however, are probably derived from some common ancestor between the ultimate common source and themselves; this will explain their slight disagreement with Philo. The likeness between Sextus and Anatolius, however, is a most important confirmation of the conclusion reached above with regard to the first set of passages cited. Thus the passage of Sextus is seen to be connected most intimately with a lost book, the existence of which, however, is as certain as that of the Iiiad—namely, the common source of Anatolius, Theon, Philo, and Lydus, which determines the form of the first two through- out the whole length of their arithmologies,! and from which Philo and Lydus excerpted lengthy fragments identifiable by their close likeness to Theon and Anatolius.2. Besides these, Chalcidius* was certainly affected by it, probably also the Theologumena Arith- meticae,* Varro,> Hermippus of Berytus,° and indirectly Macrobius, tria . . . . dicta sunt omnia; but Anatolius and Lydus (ii. 8) both have ὅτι πρῶτος τὰ πάντα σημαίνει. Otherwise the passages are much alike. Again, in the chapter on 7, Chalcidius inserts a block of material much resembling a similar block inserted by Theon, which disagrees with the corresponding parts of Anatolius, Philo, and Lydus. ΤῸ is to be identified with the ‘grand traité d’époque alexandrine ” mentioned by Delatte, op. cit., pp. 140, 207. * See Philo De mundi opificio cc. 3, 15-16, 20, 30-42; Lydus De mensibus ii. 7, 9, 11, 12; iii. 4; iv. 64 (allin part). The connection of other passages of both authors with this source is debatable. 3 In his commentary on the Timaeus cc. 35-37. 4 An anonymous treatise first edited by Ast in 1817, thought by most to have been compiled by Iamblichus; its chief sources are Anatolius and the Theologumena Arithmeticae of Nicomachus of Gerasa (this latter is otherwise known only through Photius, Bibliotheca, cod. 187). Probably Nicomachus’ Theologumena also was influenced by the anonymous arithmologist. 5In the first book of the Hebdomades or Imagines, ap. Aulus Gellius Noct. Att. ili. 10, and in Tubero or De origine humana, ap. Censorinus De die natali 9, 1 ff. 5 Clement of Alexandria, Strom. VI. xvi (see especially sec. 145, 2) quotes his περὶ ἑβδομάδος. 320 FRANK EGLESTON ROBBINS Martianus Capella, Favonius, and Isidore of Seville! By compari- sons among these and other writers it would still be possible to reproduce a large part of this source in its original form. It con- sisted of an introduction and ten chapters dealing with the ten numbers.?. The study of its transmission, which would be too lengthy to attempt here, would show that it circulated in several versions and epitomes,? and that its influence was spread still farther by those who derived their arithmology from it. But although it was the most generally quoted of all ancient arith- mologies, its very name and that of its author are lost and probably will never be known. It was probably written by at least 100 B.c., for Varro seems to have been influenced by it; Philo,* in the early first century A.D., certainly was. With regard to the question of the share of Posidonius in pro- mulgating Pythagorean lore, the conclusion must be that even if the whole of Sextus Adv. math. vii. 91-109 is his, the Pythagorean part of it must nevertheless be a citation on his part from the intro- duction of an already existent work, which was known to Sextus also from another source, that used in iv. 2 ff. This treatise, and not Posidonius, was the ultimate source of information used by the long list of writers just named. In conclusion, let us consider briefly the question whether or not the citation of vii. 91 ff. belongs to Posidonius, reviewing the arguments that connect him with the arithmological traditions. First, it has been claimed® that the mention of Posidonius’ name at 1The sources of these writers are not so easily determined. Macrobius in his commentary on the Somnium Scipionis (i. 6) parallels extensive passages of the Theologumena Arithmeticae. 2 There is a possibility that it formed a part of a large Pythagorean work dealing with the mathematical sciences generally. 3 Anatolius, Theon, and others seem to have used epitomes; Philo, discussing the number 7 in De mundi opificio 30-42, and Sextus, quoting the Introduction, apparently had access to the unabridged work. As has been seen above, Anatolius also quoted a section of this Introduction. ¢ Philo was the author of a book, now lost, called wept ἀριθμῶν, mentioned by title in Vit. Mos. iii. 11, Quaestiones et solutiones in Genesim iv. 110, 151, and less definitely in De mundi opificio cc. 16 and 43, Quaest. et sol. in Gen. ii. 14 and iii. 49. Apparently he collected here all that is said of the numbers in his extant works, and the treatise was doubtless affected, as they are, by the anonymous arithmologist. 5 By Schmekel, loc cit. ῬΟΒΙΡΟΝΙῦΒ AND PYTHAGOREAN ARITHMOLOGY 321 the beginning marks him as the author. This is a double-edged argument and by no means conclusive; for ancient writers quite as often concealed the name of their primary source as they revealed it, and frequently they veiled their action by mentioning freely the authorities named in their real source.! Furthermore, we have now seen that in any case Posidonius himself must have been quot- ing; and this will also apply to the purely subjective argument that attempts to decide, from the nature of the passage, that the whole belongs to him.? More satisfactory in some respects is an argument based on the commentary of Chalcidius, ὁ. 50, where the following occurs: uult igitur animam sensibilis mundi tamquam permissa usurpandi licentia nasci, cognitricem tamen rerum omnium, quae sunt tam intellegibiles quam sensibiles. est porro Pythagoricum dogma similia nonnisi a similibus suis comprehendi. quod etiam Empedocles sequens ait in suis uersibus: terram terreno conprendimus, aethera flammis, humorem liquido, nostro spirabile flatu, pacem tranquillo, litem quoque litigioso. haec quippe constituebat elementa et initia uniuersitatis, ex quibus animae quoque censebat constare substantiam. The thought of this passage is parallel to Sextus Adv. math. vii. 91 ff., and the citation of the same verses of Empedocles, and the possible reference to Philolaus, are remarkable. The reappear- ance of all these matters in conjunction could be offered as evidence that the passage in Sextus is a unity, and from the pen of Posidonius; it has, in fact, been argued that Chalcidius (probably through Adrastus) and Sextus both depend upon him.? Even if this is so, however, it does not prove that the Posidonian quotation in Sextus extends over the arithmological sections as well, of which in any case he could not have been the author. 1Cf. Eyssenhardt’s introduction to his edition of Martianus Capella, p. xxxii, and Hiller in Rheinisches Museum, XXVI (1871), pp. 582 ff., cited by Switalski, op. cit., p. 62. ? For the controversy over the exact extent of the Posidonian quotation, cf. Zeller and Schmekel, cited above, p. 310, n. 2, and R. M. Jones, The Platonism of Plutarch, Chicago dissertation, Menasha, 1916, p. 77, ἃ. 21. The latter agrees with Zeller that the Pythagorean material does not belong to Posidonius. It may be noted that at the conclusion of the debated passage Sextus (vii. 110) appends the words ταῦτα μὲν οἱ Πυθαγορικοί. 3 Borghorst, op. cit., p. 60. 322 FRANK EGLESTON ROBBINS Finally, there is some interest in the citation of Posidonius by Theon in his arithmology, p. 103, 16 ff.: ἑπόμενος δὲ τῇ φύσει καὶ ὁ Πλάτων ἐξ ἑπτὰ ἀριθμῶν συνέστησε τὴν ψυχὴν ἐν τῷ Τιμαίῳ. ἡμέρα γὰρ καὶ νύξ, ὥς φησι ὁ Ποσειδώνιος, ἀρτίου καὶ περιττοῦ φύσιν ἔχουσι. μὴν δὲ καθ᾽ ἑβδομάδας τέσσαρας συμπληροῦται, τῇ μὲν πρώτῃ ἑβδομάδι διχοτόμου τῆς σελήνης ὁρωμένης, κτλ. At this point, it may be noted, begins a block of material! which, unlike most of the chapter on the number 7, seems to be taken from a source different from that of Anatolius—that is, probably not from the anonymous arithmology of which we have spoken.? Opinions as to the extent of the Posido- nian citation may, of course, differ; there seems to be no reason, how- ever, to think that it did not at least include the sentence describing the influence of the number 7 on the moon and the lunar month. Nevertheless, all that can be held proven is that Posidonius was interested in Pythagorean arithmology, and that he may have influ- enced some lines of its tradition, not that he was the author of any part of the general source of Theon, Anatolius, Philo, and the rest. At most, he may have been responsible for introducing alien elements into the descendants of this arithmology. UnIvERsITY oF MICHIGAN 1 Egpecially p. 104, ll. 1-5, but in all the rest of the section about the hebdomad there are striking differences of detail between Theon and Anatolius. 2 This special source, however, was probably itself influenced by the Anonymous.