STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. SOME FEATURES OF THE LATER HISTORIES OF ALEXANDER By R. B. Steele The present sources for the history of Alexander are the work of Curtius (incomplete), part of the works of Diodorus and Justinus, the Anabasis and Indica of Arrian, the Alexander of Plutarch, parts of the Geography of Strabo, and scattered statements in many- writers. The first three works give no indication of the ultimate sources from which they were derived, though it may be safely main- tained that much of the material contained came from Clitarchus. Strabo and Plutarch mention many writers, while Arrian for the Indica drew largely from Eratosthenes, Megasthenes, and Nearchus, and for the Anabasis from Aristobulus and Ptolemy. However, all his material has been transformed into a uniform style, and, except- ing where passages have been definitely assigned, the parts due to different writers cannot be distinguished. The facts for the history of Alexander had been long established when these authors wrote, and originality could be shown only in the form of presentation. It was only in varying this that justification could be found for any new work. Curtius is a good illustration of this, for, though the larger part of his facts are to be found in the work of Diodorus, with them are mingled his own reflections and material gleaned from Livy. In comparing statements in these writers we find what we may call points of assistance, as well as points of resistance. Some facts as put by other writers are accepted without question, while others are stated merely for the purpose of refutation. Not only these writers, but the followers of Clitarchus and of Aristobulus, clearly show their bias in presenting their material. Pliny the Elder in the indexes to Books xii and xiii mentions several Greek writers, and among them are Clitarchus, Nearchus, Onesic- ritus, and Ptolemy. No mention, however, is made of Aristobulus. On the other hand, Arrian, who sought to substitute for the Clitarchan [Classical Philology XIII, July, 1918] 301 302 R. B. Steele account that of Aristobulus and Ptolemy, does not mention Clitar- chus, and Onesicritus onlyto condemn him. In the Anabasis v. 20. 10 he gives the average width of the Indus as forty stades, and fifteen stades at its narrowest point. In vi. 14. 5 the width at the delta is given as 100 stades, and in v. 4. 2 Cteeias is named as authority for the statement that the least width was forty stades, and the greatest 100. This mention of Ctesias is merely a polite way of rejecting the statement of Onesicritus (Strabo xv. 1. 33, C 701) that the river was 200 stades in width where it divided at the delta. There is a similar indication of attitude in Anabasis vii. 15. 5, where Arrian cites Aristus and Asclepiades as authorities for the statement that the Romans sent an embassy to Alexander. Neither Aristobulus nor Ptolemy mentions this, and Arrian argues against it as improbable. However, the real explanation for the reference and the reasoning is found in Pliny H.N. iii. 9. 57, where it is stated that Clitarchus made mention of the embassy. There is a similar explanation for a passage in Anabasis vi. 11. 8, where he inveighs against the writers who named Ptolemy among the defenders of Alexander when he was wounded among the Malli. Curtius ix. 5. 21 ascribes the statement to Clitarchus and Timagenes. The larger part of the facts are stated without any specific source being mentioned, though Arrian frequently tells us that some writers state this, but others that. In cases where equivalent statements are given by different writers there are three noticeable features in the non-presentation or presentation of authorities: (1) sometimes no authority whatever is given; (2) one only of two may give his authority; (3) different writers may be named as giving some item in the narrative. 1. We find in Curtius v. 1. 12: "Campestre iter est in terra inter Tigrin et Euphraten iacenti, tam uberi et pingui, ut a pastu repelli pecora dicantur, ne satietas perimat." Pomponius Mela Choro- graphia iii. 53, though in different words, tells us the same thing of Iuverna: " Adeo luxuriosa herbis non laetis modo sed etiam dulcibus, ut se exigua parte diei pecora impleant, et nisi pabulo prohibeantur, diutius pasta dissiliant." There is a similar variation in phraseology and agreement in fact in Curtius iv. 7. 20: "Nasamones sunt, gens Syrtica navigiorum spoliis quaestuosa, quippe obsident litora et aestu Featubes of Histories of Alexander 303 destituta navigia notis sibi vadis occupant"; and Silius Italicus iii. 320: Hue coit aequoreus Nasamon, invadere fluctu Audax naufragia et praedas avellere ponto. Similar to these is the story given in Pliny H.N. xii. 32. 62, and Plutarch, Alexander 25, about Alexander sending the perfume to his preceptor Leonidas. 2. Some statements are definitely assigned at one place and not at another. Curtius has in vi. 4. 22: "Frequens arbor faciem quercus habet, cuius folia multo melle tinguntur, sed, nisi solis ortum incolae occupaverint, vel modico tepore sucus extinguitur." Pliny H.N. xii. 8. 34 gives the same fact in entirely different words : "Onesic- ritus tradit in Hyrcaniae convallibus fico similes esse arbores quae vocentur occhi, ex quibus defluat mel horis matutinis duabus." Arrian Anabasis vii. 20. 5 (from Aristobulus) in an account of Icarus has the words TanivTos rov Krjpov. . . . ra wrepa, which fix the source of the account of Strabo (xiv. 1. 19, C 639), though it has ra irrtpa raicivTos rod K-qpov. Strabo, quoting from Nearchus in xv. 1. 5, C 686, and xv. 2. 5, C 722, uses the verb i\oveui\oi>tiidav, in a general remark by Plutarch at the close of chapter 26 of the Alexander. One of the best illustrations is the use by Strabo of the words Kara^iptiv \}/rjyiJ.a xpverov. They occur in xiii. 4. 5, C 625 describing the Pactolus, and in xv. 1. 57, C 711 (from Megasthenes) they are applied to the rivers in Iberia. Strabo, men- tioning the Iberian rivers in section 69, C 718, changes the order of the words, and still later in xv. 2. 14, C 726, the fourth time used, reveals their source by quoting from Onesicritus a statement applied to the rivers in Carmania. 3. Strabo in xv. 1. 68, C 717 mentions the disagreement among writers, and as an illustration gives different versions on the death of Calanus, and in this connection quotes from Megasthenes. Arrian Anabasis vii. 3 has a similar discussion, but quotes from Nearchus. Athenaeus x. 437 gives an item from Chares, while Lucian De morte Peregrini 25 gives one from Onesicritus. Freedom in quotation or in adaptation renders differences in form of statement of little or no weight in determining sources. This 304 R. B. Steele applies, not only to long sections, but also to short passages. Each writer took the material at hand and transformed it into his own diction. Only a few illustrations of this are necessary. Arrian Indica 11-12, and Strabo in xv. 1. 39, C 703 ff. give an account of the different classes in India. Conveying about the same facts, the terms used are largely different, and a fair illustration of this is the beginning of the description of the sixth class. Indica 12. 5: ol eTTLffKoiroi. . . . oStoi t(/>opw6p.ei>a. Strabo, section 48: ol (4>opoi: tovtois 8' eiroTTTeiieiv deborai ra wpwrrbptva. Strabo, in vi. 3. 8, C 302, tells the story (from Ptolemy) of Alexander asking the Getae what- they feared. Their reply was, ovhkv irXriv el apa p.ri 6 ovpavbs odrrois einirea-oi. Arrian Anabasis i. 4. 8 has p.v\iroTt 6 ovpavbs avrols enwiaoi. The use of different compounds or of synonyms is not uncommon. Arrian Anabasis vi. 1. 1 and Indica 18. 1, has irape- app.aKov Oava.olp.ov Sw&juet. Features of Histories of Alexander 305 Strabo in xv. 3. 7, C 723 places the incident among the Orites, using the words xpieotfai davai.s apnaKoi.s. Similar to this is the story of the offering of water to Alexander, either in the wastes of Gedrosia or among the Parapamisidae, according to Arrian Anabasis vi. 26. Iff. Plutarch Alexander 42, and Curtius vii. 5. 11 place the incident at the earlier period. There are two elements — names and numbers — in which there is frequent disagreement. Some of these differences existed from the beginning, and of this there are numerous examples. Strabo, in xvi. 3. 27, C 785 gives two names for several places, and in xvi. 3. 2, C 825 states that a place was called Trigga by the barbarians, Lygga by Artemidorus, and Lixon by Eratosthenes. Arrian Anabasis v. 20. 2 has Glauganikai from Aristobulus, Glausai from Ptolemy, and adds the comment that he is not concerned about the real name. Plutarch Alexander 66 gives the name Skilloustis, which others call Psiltoukis. Notice also Batis in Arrian Anabasis ii. 25. 4, but Bebemeses in Josephus Antiq. Jitd. xi. 8. 3. Some of the forms used, especially by Curtius, are due to errors in transcribing, as his use of Phradates for the Autophradates of Arrian, and Oxartes for Oxyartes in Arrian and Plutarch. But the most noticeable of all the differ- ences are the names given by Pliny H.N. vi. 23 (from Onesicritus) which appear in an entirely different form in Arrian's Indica (from Nearchus). The numbers are still more uncertain. Even when the sum of them is the same, the form of statement may differ, for they had the same rhetorical setting as other items. Diodorus xvii. 16. 3 mentions games to Zeus and to the Muses, while Arrian Anabasis i. 11. 1 says that Alexander sacrificed to Zeus, and some say to the Muses. The same difference in form is seen in the statement of the number of Macedonians killed at the battle of the Granicus. Arrian Anabasis i. 16. 4 says that there were 25 knights. Plutarch Alexander 16 (from Aristobulus) puts the loss at 34, of which 9 were footmen. Plutarch Alexander 70 (from Chares) states that 41 died in the drink- ing bout at Susa. Athenaeus x. 437 (also from Chares) says that 35 died in the bout, and 6 later in their tents. The writers themselves recognized the uncertainty attaching to numbers and frequently wrote a little less or more than a certain number. Arrian Indica 306 R. B. Steele 19. 7 gives the number of the ships of Alexander as 1,800; Anabasis vi. 2. 4 as a little less than 2,000. The mutual relation of the historians is an interesting question which especially concerns the influence exerted on later writers by Strabo. This extends not merely to individual statements, but to the general critical attitude as well. He freely criticized his predecessors, collectively as well as individually. In xi. 7. 4, C 509 he refers to the many falsifications caused by zeal for Alexander; and in xv. 1. 9, C 688 to lack of agreement among those flattering him. In ii. 1. 9, C 70 he condemns a number of those who wrote about India, and in xv. 1. 2, C 685 gives as his reason for doing so that they learned things on the run, or received them from hearsay. See also a similar statement in ii. 1. 6, C 69. He mentions lies or liars in ii. 3. 5, C 102; iii. 5. 7, C 172; iv. 5. 5, C 201. He accepts in xv. 1. 6, C 686 the judgment of Megasthenes with regard to the untrust- worthiness of the early histories of India, and in section 7 prefers him to Eratosthenes. The latter, however, is considered the most reliable of those writing about India when Alexander came (xv. 1. 10, C 688), though what he gives is supplemented by the accounts of others, C 691 ff . The quotations by Strabo from Onesicritus and especially the comments on them are interesting. One in xv. 1. 28, C 698 says that some ambassadors brought word to Alexander with regard to some serpents, one of which was 80 cubits in length, and another 140. Well for the reputation of Onesicritus that there were only two! Arrian Anabasis v. 8. 3 mentions the embassy, but says nothing of the snakes. Strabo adds the comment that one might call Onesic- ritus not more the chief pilot of Alexander than of the marvelous. He calls attention in xv. 1. 33, C 701 to a misstatement by Onesicritus, and gives a criticism like that in Arrian Anabasis vi. 2. 3. These citations are sufficient to show the attitude of Strabo, and his method must have had in it a suggestion for later writers. There are indications that the critical attitude of Arrian was the same as that of Strabo. Their criticism of Onesicritus has already been mentioned. In addition to this, Strabo (xi. 5. 4, C 505) and Arrian (Anabasis vii. 13. 2) reject the current views with regard to the Amazons, and their reasons are similar. Strabo (xv. 1. 10, Features of Histories of Alexander 307 C 688) has iruTTbrara referring to the statements of Eratosthenes, while Arrian (Indica 3. 1) applies wiffrortpos to the writer. Strabo (xv. 1. 7, C 687) states his views with regard to Hercules and Diony- sus, and Arrian (Anabasis v. 3. 1-4) discusses the same question, dissenting from the views of Eratosthenes. Strabo (xvi. 1. 3, C 737) has a passage explaining why the last fight of Alexander was placed at Arbela (naroiidav a^ib\oyov) rather than at Gaugamela (KUfirj). Arrian (Anabasis vi. 11. 5) cites Aristobulus and Ptolemy for the location of the fight, and then adds that it appeared to him that Arbela OnSXis) had received the credit due to Gaugamela (kwju??). The words of Arrian (Indica 5. 1) that whoever wishes to state the cause of the size of the rivers of India, let him state, appear to be a reference to the discussion in Strabo (xv. 1. 17, C 691 ff.), in which he gives the views of Aristobulus, Nearchus, and Onesicritus. How- ever this may be, the view of Strabo (xv. 1. 35, C 702) that after the Ganges and the Indus, the Ister and the Nile come third and fourth in size, is evidently the basis of the polemic by Arrian (Anabasis v. 6. 7, and Indica 4. 13-16) that the Ister and the Nile ought not to be classed with the Ganges and the Indus. He further states (Indica 3. 10) that it appeared to him that the Acesines (perhaps other Indian rivers) was larger than the Ister and the Nile. There are two other passages in which the references given by Arrian seem to have been influenced by Strabo. Curtius says of the Abii in vii. 6. 11, "iustissimos barbarorum constabat." There is nothing like this in Diodorus xvii. 81, nor in Justinus xii. 5. 9. Arrian Anabasis iv. 1. 1 quotes diKaiorarovs avdpairovs from Homer. But Strabo mentions the Abii at least half a dozen times and regularly applies the Homeric epithet to them. In the Anabasis v. 6. 5, Arrian names Herodotus and Hecataeus as authorities for the statement that Egypt is the gift (b&pov) of the Nile, and says that it is shown by Herodotus that the land itself is the eponym (ewaipvuov) of the river. Strabo (xv. 2. 17, C 691) quotes the first part of the state- ment (dupov) from Herodotus, and the latter part with a different word (dn&vvfM>i>) from Nearchus. There is one noticeable passage in both Strabo and Plutarch. The latter, Alexander 69, closes the account of the self-immolation of Calanus with the statement that many ages later another Indian 308 R. B. Steele did the same thing at Athens in the presence of Caesar, and that there was still extant a memorial of the act. Strabo (xv. 1. 4, C 686) has the first part of the statement, and in section 73, C 719 it is the first sentence of a quotation of twenty-six lines from Nicolaus Damascenus, the last sentence of which gives the inscription on the tomb. Plutarch has utilized only the first and the last sentences of the quotation. There are several pieces of information given by Curtius which are found in Strabo also. Some of these are apparently observations of the former adapted by the latter, though not really germane to the history of Alexander. Others are largely curious items. On the basis of facillima derivatio they can be explained more easily as glean- ings from Strabo than as the results of a reading of the original sources by Curtius. The comment of Curtius (iv. 4. 21) on the peacefulness of Tyre under the gentleness of Roman sway resembles Strabo xvi. 2. 23, C 757, and also reproduces a comment, differently applied, in vi. 3. 4, C 281. With regard to Ecbatana, Curtius says in v. 8. 1 : "Caput Mediae urbs haec: nunc tenent Parthi eaque aestiva agentibus sedes est." Strabo (xi. 13. 1, C 522) differs from this only in stating that the kings spent their summers there, and there is a similar remark in section 6, C 524. Among the curious items is the one in Curtius vii. 2. 18 that the journey of Polydamas on camels, when he was carrying the orders for the killing of Parmenio, lasted eleven days, and this is also given by Strabo in xv. 2. 10, C 724, with the addition that the time was usually thirty or forty days. Curtius (vi. 4. 18) says that the Caspian, sweeter than others, nourishes serpents of great size. Pliny H.N. vi. 13. 36 names Clitarchus as authority for the state- ment that the sea is not smaller than the Pontus, and mentions the serpents in section 43. Plutarch, Alexander 44, refers to the size and the sweetness. Neither of the writers has both items given by Curtius, though Strabo (xi. 7. 4, C 510) gives them in a quotation from Polyclitus. The distance between the Tigris and the Euphrates is given by Curtius in v. 1. 13, "ii milia et quingenta stadia emensi sunt, qui amplissimum intervallum circa Armeniae montes notave- runt." This statement is at the end of the account of the rivers given by Strabo in xi. 12. 3, C 521. Features of Histories of Alexander 309 The putting of a few geographical data is interesting. Curtius has in iii. 4. 8 a description of the Cydnus, and further says in iii. 5. 1, "mediam Cydnus amnis .... interfluit." The description by Strabo in xiv. 5. 5-10, C 671 and 672, has the words 6 Kbdvos 6 diapptcov n&ariv tt\v Tapaov (also in sec. 12), though he frequently uses pei. . . . Sid. In section 5, C 670 he tells of the Corycian cave in which the best saffron is produced. Compare Curtius (sec. 10), "Corycium nemus, ubi crocum gignitur." Strabo also speaks of Typhon in xiii. 4. 6, C 626, as also of Theba and Lyrnessus in xiii. 1. 61, C 612. Curtius has the last two in reverse order, and the entire passage (sees. 8-10) seems to have been gathered from Strabo. The evidence adduced indicates that there was a certain partisan- ship among the followers both of Clitarchus and of Aristobulus. The attitude of Arrian is the most marked in this respect. Critically he is akin to Strabo, whose work he, as well as Plutarch and Curtius, seems to have studied. Names and numbers are uncertain elements, and the same account, adapted by different writers, may appear in different forms, though at times there is some distinctive element. Vandebbilt Univebsitt Nashville, Tenn.