STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE FIFTH FORM OF 'DISCOVERY' IN THE POETICS OF ARISTOTLE By Lane Coopeb The universal longing for knowledge is the keynote in the philos- ophy of Aristotle; doubtless the most familiar sentence in his works is the opening maxim of the Metaphysics: 'AH men by nature desire to know.' And the satisfaction of this desire is to him the basic pleasure, not only in the pursuit of science and philosophy, but also in the realm of art, and hence of poetry. When we see a face drawn to the life, the difference between the work of the artist and the living original occasions a moment of suspense — there is a sudden inference, we catch the resemblance, and we cry out in recognition: 'Why that is he! That is the man we know so well.' So (one may add) the hasty reader, snatching at delight, foregoes the cumulative satisfaction to be had from the successive disclosures of a long story, and skips to the end of the book to know at once the main outcome of the whole. Or again (to return to Aristotle), the essential mark of genius in a poet is the ability to discover the underljdng resemblances of things that are superficially unlike, the power being shown in his command of figurative language — similes, for instance. And again, the style which gives the greatest pleasure is that in which the current diction, instantly intelligible, is diversified with just the right admixture of strange or rare terms — archaic words and the like. The perfection of style is to be clear without being ordinary; an infusion of the less familiar, so long as we do not convert our language into an enigma or a jargon, gives opportunity for a suc- cession of delights arising from the recognition of meanings. Aristotle does not say all this, but I trust no injury has been done to his remarks on diction if we detect in them a latent resemblance to other parts of his theory. There can at all events be no question as to the importance he attaches to that element in the plot of a drama or an epic poem which he calls 'Discovery' (avayvupiais), or, as we sometimes render it, 'Recognition.' Like other terms found in the Poetics, this may be Classical Philology XIII, July, 1918] 251 252 Lane Cooper taken first in a more general sense, and then in a more special or technical sense. Discovery in general is simply a transition from ignorance to knowledge. You may discover the identity of a person, or of your dog Argus, or of inanimate, even casual, things. You may discover the solution of a riddle propounded by the Sphinx. You may discover that such and such a thing has or has not occurred, or that you yourself have or have not done a particular deed. Thus Oedipus discovers, or thinks he discovers, all sorts of things true or untrue — that Creon is plotting against him; that Teiresias is basely involved in the plot; that he, the hero, could not have killed his father and married his mother, fulfilling the oracle, since he discovers that Polybus and Merope are dead; that the dead Polybus and Merope were not after all his parents; that the man he killed at the crossroads was his father, and the queen he subsequently married, his mother; that, as Teiresias had said, he himself, Oedipus, is the accursed defiler of the land whom he has been seeking. 'Oedipus' is the final answer to the riddle of the Sphinx. All the while the unfamiliar, as it is added on, is converted into the familiar; the unexpected turns out to be the very thing we were awaiting, and the unknown stranger is seen to be the firstborn of the house — who must again become a stranger, and yet again seek a familiar home and final resting-place, no longer at outlandish Thebes but here in the neighborhood of our own Athens, at the grove beloved of his and our poet. And all the while we, with Oedipus, desire further knowledge, and our desire, momentarily bafHed, is as constantly satisfied — until the entire design of the poet is unfolded and we know all. Even when the knowledge is painful the satisfaction is a satisfaction. And for us, the spectators, the pain is tempered, since we behold it, not in real life, but in a spectacle whose close resemblance to reality — ^with a difference — keeps us inferring, and saying: 'Ah, so it is — just like human fortune and misfortune as we see it every day!' The story itself, being traditional, is familiar, yet old and far away; and it now has an admixture of the strange and rare which only Sophocles could give it. How delightful to learn — to discover fundamental similarity under superficial difference! So much for Discovery in general. More specifically, in the technical sense, a Discovery is the recognition, in a drama or the Fifth Form of 'Discovery' in the "Poetics" 253 like, of the identity of one or more persons by one or more others. A may know B, and then B must learn the identity of A, or the mutual ignorance of both may pass into mutual recognition, causing love or hate, and hence pleasure or pain, to one or both; but, if the poet does his work aright, always with pleasure to the man who sees the play or hears the story — ^the pleasure of inferring and learning. In particular, the poet must let his audience do its own observing and draw its own inferences without too much obvious assistance. We do not want formal proofs of identity, the display of birthmarks, scars, or tokens — necklaces and so on. Nor do we want a purely artificial declaration from the unknown individual, with no preceding incident to make it necessary. Tokens and declarations are the last resource of a feeble or nodding poet, who has forgotten that all men desire to learn by inference and must not be cheated of the universal satisfaction. They like to fancy themselves wholly responsible for their own mental operations; they do not wish to have their wits insulted. The various kinds of Discovery, in the more technical sense, are, according to Aristotle, six in number. Of these, the first is that brought about by signs or tokens; the second is the formal declara- tion; the third is the one effected by memory, when the occasion stirs a man's emotions, and his display of feeling reveals who he must be; and the fourth is that resulting from inference, when one agent in a drama identifies another by a process of reasoning. It is easy to see that these four divisions (and indeed all six) are not mutually exclusive, since, for example, a scar might be subsidiary to a declaration, or serve to stir a memory; or a necklace, or a bow, or a garment might prompt an inference. The fifth is the 'synthetic' (or 'composite,' or fictitious — otherwise fallacious or false, or perhaps 'concocted') Discovery, and is the form I wish specially to examine in the latter part of this article. The sixth is the best form. In it the identity of the hero, say, is revealed, not by a scar, or by his own declaration (artificially dragged in by the poet), or by his weeping when he hears the tale of his wanderings told by another; or by an inference made by his long-lost sister, but through the inevitable sequence of incident after incident in the plot itself. Here the action of the reader's mind follows the very action of the play, and 254 Lane Cooper the pleasure of learning the particular identity is but one item in an orderly series — ^in that passage from ignorance to knowledge which is effected by the work as a whole. And pleasure, we must recollect, is not a state of being, but a form of action. The right functioning of the mind is pleasure. Pleasure and free activity are convertible terms. Thus the emphasis of the Poetics is always laid upon what is rational and orderly. An excess of delight occurs when a regular advance from antecedent to consequent brings a sudden addition to our knowledge; when by a rapid, unlabored, logical inference the desire to know the truth is satisfied. All learning is essentially rapid; the recognition dawns, then comes as a flash of pleasure. Yet the poet has a use for what is not strictly true and logical. Even the irrational may escape censure if it be made plausible. And the marvelous is sweet. It is legitimate too to represent a dramatic character as deceiving himself or another, the poet being aware that it is hard for a man swayed by anger, or fear, or any other powerful emotion to see and tell the exact truth. People are always magnifying the things that comfort their self-love and minifying whatever may ruffle or hurt it. Then there are characters who like to mystify their fellows, as well as those who deceive for some obvious advantage. The poet must on occasion set before us a crafty Odys- seus, who delights in all manner of wiles. It requires art also to portray the slippery Clytaemnestra, not to mention the lying Lady Macbeth. Superior mental activity as such is ever interesting, and the false inferences of the deceived are not unpleasing, but the reverse, unless they exceed the bounds of the credible. Furthermore, as we have seen, a sUght admixture of the strange or rare gives a spice to the known and obvious. In fact, we all Uke to add a Uttle something in the telling of a tale — with a view to pleasing the neigh- bor who hears it. Accordingly, in his discussion of epic poetry Aristotle says (1460 a 17-26): That the marvelous is a source of pleasure may be seen by the way in which people add to a story [wpoori^en-ts] ; for they always embellish the facts in the belief that it will gratify the Usteners. Yet it is Homer above all who has shown the rest of us how a he ought to be told [in effect: who Fifth Fobm of 'Discovery' in the "Poetics" 255 has shown how a poet ought to represent Odysseus, for example, deceiving some other personage]. The essence of the method is the use of a para- logism, as follows: Suppose that whenever A exists or comes to pass, B must exist or occur. Men think, if the consequent B exists, the antecedent A must also — but the inference is illegitimate. For the poet, then, the right method is this: if the antecedent A is untrue, and if there is some- thing else, B, which would necessarily exist or occur if A were true, one must add on [Trpoo-^eivat] the B; for, knowing the added detail to be true, we ourselves mentally proceed to the fallacious inference that the antece- dent A is likewise true. We may take an instance from the 'Bath Scene' in the Odyssey} Turning to the 'Bath Scene' in Odyssey 19, we see the force of Aristotle's illustration. Here Odysseus, disguised in rags, wishes to convince Penelope that he, the Beggar, has seen the real Odysseus alive = A, a falsehood. Accordingly, he adds an accurate description of the hero's clothing = B. Penelope knows B to be true, since the garments came from her. If A were true, that is, if the Beggar had seen Odysseus, the natural consequence, B, would be a true descrip- tion of the clothing. From the truth of B, Penelope mistakenly infers the occurrence of A and believes the Beggar. The illusion, which is shared by anyone who hears the story, witnesses to the artistic method of the poet.^ At this point it is well to remember several things. First of all there are the words TrfxxxTidivres and irpoffdelvai (compounds of tWtjiu), used in the sense of 'adding to,' as if putting together truth and falsehood were characteristic of deception. Then there is the ' Here and subsequently I follow, with little deviation, my 'amplified rendering,' Aristotle on the Art of Poetry (p. 82). 2 Ibid., pp. 82-83. It is interesting to see in detail how Homer makes Odysseus add on the B (Odyssey 19. 218 ff., translation of Butcher and Lang) : 'Tell me what manner of raiment he was clothed in about his body, and what manner of man he was himself, and tell me of his fellows that went with him.' Then Odysseus of many counsels answered her saying: 'Lady, it is hard for one so long parted from him to tell thee all this, for it is now the twentieth year since he went thither and left my country. Yet even so I will tell thee as I see him in spirit. Goodly Odysseus wore a thick, purple mantle, twofold, which had a brooch fashioned in gold, with a double covering for the pins, and on the face of it was a curious device: a hound in his forepaws held a dappled fawn, and gazed on it as it writhed. And all men marveled at the workmanship, how, wrought as they were in gold, the hound was gazing on the fawn and strangling it, and the fawn was writhing with his feet and striving to flee. Moreover, I marked the shining doublet about his body, as it were the skin of a dried onion, so smooth it was, and glistering as the sun ; truly many women looked 256 Lane Cooper logical term paralogism {wapaKayurtws) employed in the same con- nection. Again, it must be borne in mind that the stock example of a liar could hardly be any other than Odysseus. Finally we are to recall that Aristotle remarks in the Poetics (1459 & 14-15) upon the number of Discoveries in the Odyssey; the poem is, he says, an example of an involved plot, since Discovery is employed through- out, and it is a story of character. The incident of the false tidings, just mentioned, has in fact the nature of an erroneous recognition effected in the heroine by the disguised hero, and might suggest the title '05i;