STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 194 Notes and Discussions tractates at the end of 416 a.d. The great number of the sermons (134 in all), as well as the likelihood that a good portion of them were not delivered on successive days, leads us to believe that they were extended over the major part of 417 and possibly into 418 a.d. Roy J. Defebrari Princeton University VARIA TOPOGRAPHICA The Basilica Opimia. — In 121 B.C. L. Opimius erected a basilica near the temple of Concord, which stood until it was removed by Tiberius in 10 a.d. Cicero in his oration for Sestius (140) contrasts the reputation of those Romans who have roused their fellow-citizens to revolt and sedition with that of those who have used their influence to check such uprisings, and writes: "ac ne quis ex nostra aut aliquorum praeterea casu hanc vitae viam pertimescat, unus in hac civitate, quem quidem ego possum dicere, praeclare vir de re publica meritus, L. Opimius, indignissime concidit; cuius monumentum celeberrimum in foro sepulchrum desertissimum in litore Dyrrachio relictum est." The meaning of celeberrimum, "much frequented," is perfectly clear, but not only have translators often fallen into error (cf. Bohn, "superb monument"), but Hiilsen misses the point and makes this passage his authority for the following statement (Forum?, 13): "Opimius erbaute .... eine Basilica die . . . . als stattliches Monument geriihmt wird: was, da der Bauplatz nur klein gewesen sein kann, wohl auf pracht- volle Ausstattung schliessen lasst." We may wonder that Hiilsen was caught napping, and still more that both his French and his English trans- lators perpetuate the error. Carcopino even quotes the Latin words. In this way is the old basilica made over into a stately edifice! Elephas herbarius. — The last monument mentioned in the Regionary Catalogue in region VIII is Elephas herbarius, which from its place in the list probably stood near the foot of the Capitoline, in the modern piazza Montanara. There is no other reference to the monument in antiquity, but the name was preserved during the Middle Ages as a local designation in the title of the Church of S. Abbaciro ad Alafantum. It was undoubtedly a bronze statue of an elephant, comparable with the elephantes aenei on the Sacra Via, which are mentioned by Cassidorus (Varia 30), but the epithet herbarius has proved a stumbling-block for topographers. Becker (601) hazards no conjecture, but simply says: "der so wenig mit dem Forum Olitorium gemein hat als herbae und olera gleichbedeutend sind." Preller (154) remarks: "Der Beiname herbarius mag auf einem besondern Umstande beruhen; sonst hiessen animalia herbatica oder herbaria grassfressende Thiere." Jordan (I, 2, 476) calls it Krautelephant, and comments thus: "Der Beiname herbarius sollte allerdings wie bei Hercules olivarius und Apollo sandaliarius auf der Nahe eines Geschafts von herbarii weisen. Notes and Discussions 195 Allein ein solches Gewerbe ist nicht nachweisbar, sicher nur dass es nichts mit hokra des Forum holitorium gemein haben konnte. Die Sache bleibt dunkel." Jordan did not notice that the analogy between Apollo san- daliarius, Hercules olivarius, and this is only superficial after all, for in the case of deities entirely other considerations may enter into the explanation of epithets. Hiilsen says (RE, V, 2525) : "Den Beinamen herbarius darf man natiirlich weder mit der holera des Forum holitorium noch mit einem Gewerbe von herbarii in Verbindung bringen; es heisst wohl einfach der zahme." This looks as if Hiilsen thought that wild elephants were carnivorous! Armellini (564) derives the name from a neighboring market of herbae, of which we know nothing, and Richter (191) says that it gave its name to a ricus in which the dealers in herbae carried on their trade. Gilbert (III, 418) thinks that it was connected with the Forum holitorium, which is altogether improbable. So there is much obscurity developed about a perfectly simple thing, of which, to be sure, Becker, as so often, had given a hint — a statue of an ele- phant eating grass, a most natural and suggestive pose. For this use of herbarius in imperial times we may compare two inscriptions: (CIL, VI, 10209) Aurel. Sabinus Aug. lib. praepositus herbariarum, that is, the super- intendent of the animalia herbaria that were used in the Colosseum; (NS, 1899, 149) M. Rebilus Macedo .... feris n. IIII ursis XVI noxeis III et ceteris herbariis, of a show given at Beneventum. Thermae Hiemales. — A passage in the Vita Aureliani (45) reads: thermas in transtiberina regione facere paravit hiemales, quod aquae frigidioris copia illic deesset; that is, Aurelian proposed to build some baths, thermae hiemales, in Trastevere because there was no sufficient supply of aquafrigidior, evidently water that was colder than that required for thermae hiemales. Hiilsen translates Kaltbad, and thus falls into a double error, first of neg- lecting to observe that the reason given has no sense if this is the kind of bath intended, and second of supposing that hiemales thermae can mean cold baths. There is no parallel for any such use of hiemales. The use of the word in Pliny (xviii. 69) : "totis hoc Alpibus notum et hiemalibus provinciis nullum hoc frumento laetius [triticum]," is no real exception, for here it is precisely equivalent to our own "wintry." Furthermore, there is no case of any such expression as thermae frigidae, although we cannot say that thermae had so far retained its original signification as to make such a usage impossible. Of aestivus, aestivalis, with thermae we have these cases from the later period: CIL, X, 5348, an inscription from Interamna: "opera thermarum estivalium restituit"; Vit. Gordiani, 32, 7: "cogitaverat praeterea cum Misitheo ut post basilicam thermas aestivas sui nominis faceret, ita ut hie- males in principio porticuum poneret, intus essent vel viridaria vel porticus." In these two cases hiemalis and aestivalis are clearly opposite in meaning, namely, for use in winter and for use in summer. In the trans-Tiberine 196 Notes and Discussions district there was not sufficient water available of a temperature cool enough for summer use. Two aqueducts supplied this region, the Alsietina built by Augustus to feed his naumachia, and the Traiana, built by Trajan to supply drinking-water. The first brought water from Lake Martignano, the second from springs. Severus had already constructed baths in this region, and it is quite clear that no further demands could be made on the cold spring water of the Traiana. The Porta Romana or Bomanula. — According to Varro there were three gates in the wall of the original Palatine city, and that on the northwest corner of the hill was called Romanula— 06 Roma dictam (LL., V, 164). Festus (262) says: "Appellata autem Romana a Sabinis praecipue quod ea proximus aditus erat Romam." There is little doubt that Romana is the proper form, and the explanation of the name is the problem which confronts us. So far as we know, the gates of Latin cities were frequently named after the towns on the roads that ran out of them, or after the roads themselves. Compare the f amiliar examples, p. Praenestina, Collatina, Ardeatina, Ostiensis, etc., in Rome, and the p. Esquilina in Tibur. Other gates in Rome were named after local designations of sections of the city, as Collina, Pinciana; still others, of course, bore names of different significance, but, so far as I know, we have no other case like Porta Romana, where the name of the town itself is given to a gate. Against any hesitation on this ground, however, is Varro's direct testi- mony — ah Roma dictam — and if he saw nothing unusual, or at least impos- sible, in such usage, why should we ? But we cannot, unfortunately, follow this simple rule in dealing with Varro, and Festus seems to hint that such an explanation was not satisfactory to all Romans. He, at least, draws a little nearer to the apparent practice when he says that the name was given by the Sabines to the gate through which they found their nearest approach. We do not know the source from which Festus draws here, but the explana- tion seems to be an infelicitous attempt to avoid the Varronian view. Cer- tainly it does not appear probable that this was the true origin of the name. In the good old days when we could connect Roma with ruma, rumon, "a stream," it was easy to explain the name of the gate, for it would be alto- gether natural to call that nearest the river the river-gate. But now that Schulze has made his theory so fashionable that everybody says without hesi- tation that Rome got its name from an Etruscan clan, the case is different. Kretschmer a few years ago (Glotta, I, 295, n. 2) wrote as follows: "Da Tore nach den Oertlichkeiten zu heissen pflegen, in deren Nahe sie liegen oder fuhren, so diirfte die Porta Romana das Tor gewesen sein das nach Rom fuhrte. Dann kann natiirlich die alte Stadt auf dem Palatin, die sogenannte Roma quadrata, ursprilnglich nicht den Namen Rom getragen haben, sie wird viel- mehr Palatium geheissen haben, und der Name Roma muss dann ursprilng- lich an der Oertlichkeit westlich vom Palatin (spater Velabrum, eventuell Notes and Discussions 197 auch Forum und Capitol) gehaftet haben und ist, als diese Ansiedlung mit der Palatinstadt verwuchs, auf das Ganze fibertragen worden." Now the idea of a settlement in the swampy Velabrum or Forum in early- times is quite preposterous, and I do not mean to assert that Kretschmer insists on a settlement in Oertlichkeit, but if there had been a village on the Capitoline which was called Roma, some trace of the transfer of the name to the Palatine would surely be found in tradition. Such a transfer would have resulted, normally, from causes that would have found some reflection in later times. Some support for this view might possibly be found in Festus' statement, were it not for the difficulty of explaining how a Sabine settlement came to have an Etruscan name — although, to be sure, one might ask whether there was any greater difficulty here than in giving an Etruscan name to a Latin settlement — and for the fact that it implies a complete reversal of the traditional place occupied by the Capitoline in Roman tra- dition, a reversal that demands more effective support than this hypothesis affords. If Schulze's view is true, why can we not explain the Porta Romana most easily by supposing that this powerful Etruscan clan, or family, dwelt at this northwest corner of the hill — where tradition puts the first settlement — and that the gate, as well as the whole inclosure, got its name from this fact ? I cannot cite any exact parallel, but it seems a more plausible explana- tion than to derive the name of the gate directly from that of the city. Samuel Ball Platneb TACITUS AGRICOLA 44.1 Agricola 44.1 states: "excessit [Agricola] .... Collega Priscoque consulibus." All the manuscripts 1 give the name of the consul in the form "Prisco," and the editors of the Agricola have unanimously followed them. A few 2 have called attention to the fact that there was some inscriptional evidence 3 for "Priscinus" as the name of the consul. One editor, K. Tucking, goes so far as to say, "Statt Prisco ist wohl zu lesen Priscino"; he does not, however, introduce "Priscino" into his text. 4 Recently Liebenam, in his 1 C. AnDibaldi, V Agricola e La Germania di Cornelio Tacito (Citta di Castello, 1907), p. 105, shows that the reading of E is "Prisco," and does not point out any other reading in his comparisons with the other manuscripts. See, too, the edition by Katherine Allen and G. L. Hendrickson (Boston, 1913), p. 117. 2 H. Furneaux (Oxford, 1898), p. 161, note 5; A. Gudeman, edition of Agricola and Germania (Boston, 1900), p. 145; A. Draeger's edition revised by W. Heraeus (published by Teubner, 1905), note on the passage 44. 1. » J. Klein, Fasti Consulares (Leipzig, 1881), p. 50, gave Priscinus as the correct name. He was followed by J. Asbach, "Fasti Consulares" in Bonner Jahrblicher, LXXIX (1885), 125, and D. Vaglieri, in De Ruggiero, IP, 1060. The evidence for the name Priscinus was found on two brief non-official inscriptions in Annali dell' Inst., XLII (1870), 185, Nos. 196 and 197. 1 K. Tucking, edition of Agricola (Paderborn, 1890), p. 71.