STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 284 Notes and Discussions ON A FRAGMENT OF GORGIAS Kal ^To ayiivKT/jjo.' ■q/JiMv Kara rov AtovTivov Topyiav 'Sirroiv [8«] aptrmv Scirai, To\it,TJ% Kal (TO<^ux%- to\/x^s /*€v to kivSvvov iiroixetvai, avoXSk tov Swd/ucvov.' [Clement Stromaia i. 11. 51: Stahlin, Vol. II, p. 33, 1. 18.] SiTTuv Si Cobet. [Si] Wilamowitz, Sn Bernays. to kIvSwov . ... to alviyiia {vXiyiw. Diels), tov k'ivSvvov .... to alaifia (cf. Iliad xv. 207) Bernays, Rheinisches Museum, 1853, p. 432 = Gesammelte Abhandlungen, I, 121. The text and apparatus are Stahlin's; in Diels's Vorsokratiker the fragment is numbered 8 (Vol. II [3d ed.], p. 249). The latter has inserted -irkiypjo. into his text, comparing the metaphor icaTa7rXiy^M to it, and that Clement actually turns Gorgias' vaunt against vain contending with words, then the text will be justified. When Gorgias arrived in Athens in 427, he professed himself able to answer any question addressed to him. This is the boast with which he opens the discussion in Plato's Gorgias, after custom had staled his triumphs. But his first exhibition in Athens was conducted in a manner so impressive that the story, repeated in the literature of rhetoric for centuries, was actually used by Themistius as the ground of a comparison with the universal instruc- tion of the sun-god. I arrange four of these passages below, as their language sheds light upon the origin of our fragment. 1. Quorum [sc. sophistaruni] e numero primus est ausus Leontinus Gorgias in conventu posoere quaestionem, id est, iubere dicere, qua de re quis vellet audire. Atidax negotium : dicerem impudens, nisi, etc. [Cicero De finihus ii. 1.1.) Notes and Discussions 285 2. Isque [$c. Gorgias] princeps ex omnibus ausus est in conventu poscere, qua de re quisque vellet audire [Cicero De oratore iii. 32, 129; cf. i. 22, 103.] 3. f) ov SoKci ' eKacTT?;? ij/u,€pas imSiiKwudai t^v iTOiav; oiiK th ttjv nvvKa cniXkeymv, ov8' cts Trjv Ov/xiXriv wapiotv Ad'^vrjaiv, uHTTTip o Topyuxi, dXA' ets to li.eya dmrpov tovto Kal aTtj^vSs OAvfwrioi', iv w v Kal ayupiov iravTas a.v6poiTrov% SiSacrKCt re icai iitiyiiTai irqvLKa p,tv Scot uirtipiiv, irtfVLKa St <^vT£v£iv, irrjViKa Se a/oov, k.t.X. [Themistius Or. 26. 331a.] 4. iei$ Tm Kaip<3), TOVTO S' eircX^ctv Tla of Greece, those who professed it began with such bold words as o'Sa or ■;rd\ai Sieo-Kt^i/uai.' Their art was like the mantic of the seers and the oracles, and took the form of the Pythian verse: oTSa S' iyo) i/'d/t/iov t' apiO/xov Koi fierpa OoXdcro'rfS. If we compare such words as ausus, audax,''- iOappria-ev, KivSwev/ia' with the language of Clement's quotation, and reflect that wpo^SdAAeTc of itself suggests amyfia,* it is a fair inference that Clement has preserved a boast with which Gorgias presented himself to the Athenians. If the tradition may be trusted, he came before the assembly in the theater of Dionysus — that must be the theater meant — and took his stand by the Ovixtki). There he risked discomfiture by proclaiming that he could answer any question impromptu. And in the sentence quoted by Clement he compared his new o-oi^ui. to the legendary feat of Oedipus, who dared to face the danger of the man-devouring Sphinx, and won a kingdom by knoudng the riddle. It seems probable that Gorgias marked his break with the line of Greek ui down to Anaxagoras (compare Hippias minor 281e) by this not unhappy comparison with the wise man who could say ofSa to the Sphinx, and who ' Gorgias answers Chaerephon (see below) thus: iyi> Si fKttvo iraXat olSa. - Plato's word isa<^63us; cf. Meno 70b: Kai Si) Kal rmro to Wos Ci/uSs tWiKfp i.(t>60a>s Tf Kai iieyaKoTper&s aroKplvtaBai, ikv ris n tpfirai. ^ vvv yap airas li^dSe kIvSvvos di'etTat tro^ias, ^s xept Tois l/io(; <^(Xo(s ioTiv i,yi>v m^7«»tos. [Clouds 955.] * Chaerephon's impertinent question, which has come down to us, might pass for a riddle. Georgias, oii&iv TapaxBtis, snubbed him well (Philostratus Vit. soph. i. 6: Diels, 76A, 24). 286 Notes and Discussions used his wisdom for political ends.' In ayiivur/ui we may see, not the intro- duction to a simile of the Olympian games, but the earliest example of the common metaphor for rhetoric, colored here, it may be, by the associa- tions of the stage. As it is doubtful whether Gorgias mentioned the herald at Olympia, I shall leave the point till I have asked how Clement in turn applied this saying. The chapter in the Strotnata with which our quotation ends is a warning against the wisdom of this world, against the ^i^rijo-as and Xoyofiaxuxi. of false philosophers. Such pursuits and contests belong to youth. But in the Christian search too — so, I think, the connection runs — there is room for daring and wisdom. It is not difficult to discover what part these virtues play in the life of the yvuta-riKOi. St. Paul's saying in the First Epistle to the Corinthians 3. 1, is virtually the text of the fifth book of the Strotnata: uiv Se XoAoS/iev iv rots rcXciois, uiv St oil tov otcovos tovtov oiSi tZv dp)(6vTu>v TOV allavoi tovtov tS>v KaTapyovfi-evrnv aXXa XaXov/xtv 6 tov aoia,v iv /jJixTTriptio, T^y &troK€Kpvi>,(i,€vrfv (see, e.g., V. 4. 25; 10. 65; 12. 80). A great part of this book is devoted to showing that the Christian religion, like those of the Hebrews, Greeks, and barbarians, reveals its central mysteries to the few who are' chosen, in aiviy/uun koI av/ifioKoii iXXr/yopian re av koi jucrai^opaK (v. 4. 21). But again those who seize the kingdom (v. 3. 16) are '/Sioo-Tot' ov ToCi ipuTTiKoti Xoyoii, €v8t\txiia. St 6p0ov fiiov dZiaXeTrroK Tt €i)(aK CK/Sio^ccrdat dp-qVTai ov yap iv ixiaoun Kcirai htopa Sva'fM)(r)Ta MoktSv Ta)iriTv;(<)VTi (pia/. Courage, then, and the wisdom to solve the enigmas of the mysteries are needed by those who turn their backs on the ^efiriXoi Kevotfxoviai. (i. 10. 49) of this world. There is no convincing evidence that Gorgias added the comparison of the Olympic games to his parallel with Oedipus. True, Themistius may have made his implied contrast between the theater made by hands and the true Olympian temple because Gorgias had named the Olympic games. But little weight can be attached to that, since his own figure of itself suggests the contrast. Nor do the balanced style and the commonplace contrast of fiovXcffdai and &vva(r$ai, give any firm ground for detecting the style of ' For a similar application of the legend of the Sphinx, see Cebes Tabula iii: IffTi yip ■/) i^iiyriffis ioiKvia tiyyis alvlyiiari, 8 tKfiiT} irpoc/SiXXeTO tois &vdp6i- jrots. el liiv mv airi avvltj ti%, effifero" d 5k fiij avpirf, ajriXero biro T^j "Zt^iyybs. It is just conceivable that Gorgias made a topical allusion it it is true, as Fr. Marx ingeniously argues, that the Oedipus Tyrannus was acted in 427; but this hardly makes the comparison more happy. 2 There is an echo of this phrase at the beginning of Str. i. 11, the chapter under discussion. Notes and Discussions 287 Gorgias here. In Str. vii. 3. 20 the same antithesis is fused with a reminis- cence of Repvblic x. 617e.' IXetTot 8k 6 Swajucvos koi 6 fia/vXr/Odi lo^wrti.* If we bear in mind that Clement twice draws upon II Timothy, chapter 2, in this discussion, the second time immediately before our quotation, and that the fifth verse of that chapter runs thus, lav Sk ml aOky tk, oi crT«<^avovTai cav ij.ri voiuft.ia, had compared his art to that of Oedipus. Even if the presence of alviyim did not compel us to see an allusion to the story of Oedipus here, the argument gains in coherence if we suppose that the contrast between the true and the false ia is carried through by such a reference to an older claim. A. S. Ferguson Queen's University Kingston, Canada DEMOSTHENES AGAINST BOEOTUS I (xxxix). 37-38 Blass regarded these sections as an afterthought, awkwardly interpolated by the orator after the delivery of the speech; consequently he enclosed them in double parentheses, together with a later allusion to their contents (41). His reasons for refusing to give them their traditional place in the text are twofold: "Dies Sttick wird ganz abgerissen eingefiihrt, imd 39 schliesst sich genau an 36 an, nicht aber an 38. Die § 38 erwahnte Thatsache trat erst nach dem Schiedsgericht, also kurz vor der Gerichtsverhandlung ein" {Att. Bered., Ill [1893], i, 476, n. 1). Paley and Sandys of course follow Blass in their critical notation of the passage, since they have adopted the Dindorf- Blass text for the convenience of students. However, the inclusion of Blass's argument without comment in the explanatory notes indicates con- currence in his judgment. We must regard the passage as under suspicion. To begin with the second objection, it is difficult to see why matters that took place after the arbitration, and consequently, as Blass puts it, shortly before the trial, might not have formed part of the address to the court. Blass perhaps had in mind the rule that only those facts that are introduced in evidence at the arbitration may be introduced at the trial on appeal. If so, the words "also kurz vor der Gerichtsverhandlung" are quite beside the point. In any case, the argument seems to be founded on a fundamental misconception of the procedure involved in the /t^ ova-a Sikjj, which leads Blass to assume that the filing of Boeotus' petition brought the case directly before a dicastic court, just as if an appeal had been taken. ' JXeiTOi (Bywater) ; i