STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE MEGARIAN DEGREES By Robert J. Bonner The earlier discussions of the Megarian decrees were confined mainly to the question of their date, number, and authorship. The results of these investigations have been conveniently sum- marized by Busolt 1 whose conservative conclusions regarding the questions at issue have been generally accepted. More recently the recognition of the importance of economic factors in ancient history has aroused fresh interest in the commercial policy of Athens as a contributing cause of the Peloponnesian War. 2 In the main Busolt's verdicts are sound, but in two instances he has accepted views not warranted by the available evidence. The period during which the decrees could have been in operation falls into three divisions, beginning respectively with the secession of Megara in 446, Athenian intervention in Corcyra in 433, and the opening of the Peloponnesian War in 431. No ancient source definitely records any steps taken by Athens to put economic pres- sure upon Megara during the first period. Duncker 3 was the first to suggest that Aristophanes refers to this period in Acharnians 515-23: r)/xS)v yap aVopcs, ov\i ttjv iroAiv Aeyo), l^ifivrjcrdi rovff, oti ov)(l rrjv iroXiv Xeyo), dAA' dvSpapta pxiyOrjpa, TrapaKtKOfJLfitva, aripa xai irapaopa (i. 67. 4) mentioned by the Megarians at the first Spartan congress may include grievances growing out of Athenian commercial policy toward Megara. viroipia would seem to be too mild a term even for Corinthians to use if the Megarians had actually been excluded from the Athenian market by discriminatory legislation. But the Corinthians speak softly, for they are asking a favor. On the other hand, however, why should Corinth take umbrage at the strict enforcement of the regular Athenian customs laws ? The answer lies ready to hand in Thucydides' narrative. When Megara joined the Athenian confederacy in 459, Thucydides remarks : " It was chiefly on this account that the vehement hatred of the Corinthians for the Athenians first arose." The Corinthian speaker at the first Spartan congress says: "We know too by what methods the Atheni- ans move against their neighbors — that it is here a little and there a little" (i. 69. 3). Being in this frame of mind, it is not impossible that the Corinthians should have viewed with grave concern the 1 "Das megarische Psephisma," Korrespondenzblatt fUr die Schulen Wurttembergs, XXXVIII, 357 ff. 240 Robert J. Bonner harsh and vexatious enforcement of the customs regulations lest the Megarians might be induced again to desert the Peloponnesian confederacy in order to have fair, if not favored, treatment in such a convenient market. While the Corinthian attitude is more intelli- gible if there was an embargo upon Megarian trade with Athens, it is still not incompatible with the other theory. Against the embargo theory there are several arguments that are not to be lightly rejected. Aristophanes expressly urges that the city is not to be blamed for the state of affairs he has described, but certain despicable persons, sycophants such as he brings upon the stage in a subsequent scene. 1 This would seem to imply very clearly that there was no legislative enactment regarding Megarian trade. 2 To the same effect is the statement that, bad as the situation was, it was just what one might expect in Athens (imx&P ia ) 3 an d trivial in comparison with the anti-Megarian legislation which fol- lowed : ivrtvOtv opyrj HepucXeqs olXvixmos irCOa vo/iavs* axrirtp erxoXta ytypcyi/AO'ovs, &S XPV Mtyapeas ywifrt yg /oJt* ev ayopa fiyr iv OaA&TTr] /jutjr' iv ovpavtS fitvuv. Infringements of customs laws were dealt with by means of <£acr«. 5 The property involved was sold and the informer received one half of the proceeds. This is precisely what happened in the case of Megarian offenders. The situation described in lines 515-23 can be quite satisfactorily explained without assuming special legislation. Indeed, much of the effectiveness of the attack on Pericles is lost if he merely put through additional legislation. 1 When the Megarian (11. 820-21) comes to the market of Dicaeopolis and sees the sycophant, he exclaims: "The same old story. Here comes the beginning of our woes." The audience would naturally regard this scene as an illustration of 11. 515-23. 2 Thieme believes there was no special law, but sees no support for his view in this statement which he regards as a comic exaggeration. 3 In a subsequent scene (1. 900) the Boeotian asks in exchange for his wares some- thing peculiar to Athens, 8 ti y' &tt' 'Afl&rais, iv Bouotoigiv Si pi), i.e., something ixi.X&>pu>v in Athens, a sycophant. 4 There is no significance in the plural vbnovs ; a few lines below the same legisla- tion is described as to t& i.a ixBpav, 8s 5' av 4irij3g rrjs 'Attuojs Mtyapeoiv Bavarq £i)iua8o0ai. 'Griechische Geschichte 489-413, pp. 176 ff.; Berliner Studien, VII, 89 ff. 3 Cf. Busolt, op. tit., Ill, 2, p. 814, n. 4. 4 ra x ot P^ La toIvvv kytj> 4>av& radl iroXk/iia Kal aivu> TroXknia ravrayi. ad ok ye 4>avw irpds rolaSe. [Ibid., 911 f.] 5 " Nam gumma vi comica hos versus instruxisset si Megarensem .... morte multatum iri significasset ob id solum quod intravit Atticam." — Op. cit., p. 42. 242 Robert J. Bonner more lucrative process in preference to summary arrest (airaycoyri). He would share in the confiscated property to the extent of one half; but the death of the poor, starved Megarian would have profited him nothing. Aristophanes was not primarily concerned with the realities of the situation he imagined; he was interested first and foremost in amusing his audience. And I fancy most of his readers will be thankful that he did not indulge in the type of humor which Thieme approves. Thieme develops the suggestion of Holzapfel that part of the Charinus decree might have been drawn from Aristophanes: Sed quae de implacabili bello et de necandis iis Megarensibus legimus, qui intraverint Atticam, idem Holzapfel iam diu recte intellexit fortasse nata .esse, si quis perperam explicavit Aristophanis Acharensium haec verba .... pyre yij p.r)T iv ayopa ixr/r' iv dakaTTr/ /lyr' iv oipav<5 /xcvciv. It is impossible to treat seriously a suggestion that any Athenian could have misunderstood the exuberant exaggeration of the comedian even if he did not catch the echo of Timocreon's 1 popular drinking- song: uxpfXev a', o) Tv(pki UXjovt€, p-rfTf. yrj li-qr' iv OaXaaar] IXtjt' iv ovpavu cpavfj/xtv, aWa Taprapov re vtuear koX A-^tpovra- Slot M 1 ?^ exvelvai. op'uraffdai, koli iav eiaeniropeveadai Kaff&irep reus is rr\v x&po.v. The Athenians base their protest on exactly the same grounds as do the Megarians. The action of Perdiccas is not dUaiou, i.e., it is irapi. ra Koiva StKtua, "contrary to common justice." Consequently there is no need to assume a provision in the treaty as a basis for the protest. Anybody who had a grievance against a neighbor could make it. No one would think of stipulating in a treaty the observance of ra Koivd. dinaia or to KaBearos rots "EXXqax vbyAftov (Thuc. iii. 9.) There is, however, a sense in which the policy of Athens was a violation of the treaty. It is known that in the Thirty Years' Truce as in the other treaties of the period there was a clause requiring the contracting parties to submit their differences to arbitration. In accordance with this provision Athens should have arbitrated her alleged grievances against Megara instead of resorting to reprisals. There is no evidence that the Megarians ever formulated their protest with reference to this particular clause. If they did, Pericles must have evaded the issue by wilfully misunderstanding the Megarian point of view and obscuring it in the Athenian assembly by comparing it with the Spartan exclusion act. University of Chicago 1 CIA, I, 40; Hicks and Hill, Greek Historical Inscriptions, No. 60, 11. 18 ff.