STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. CHALCIDIUS AND NEO-PLATONISM By Roger Miller Jones In view of the fact that Chalcidius, the author of the Latin commentary on the Timaeus, falls within the period dominated by neo-Platonism, it is perhaps only natural that he has sometimes been regarded as a member of this school. Thus Baeumker 1 and Praech- ter 2 place him among the neo-Platonists of the West along with Macrobius and Boethius. More recent is Eduard Steinheimer's 3 effort to prove the neo-Platonic character of the commentary and to show that in certain sections Chalcidius' source was Porphyry. While I am in complete agreement with Steinheimer's arguments against the conclusion of Switalski 4 that Chalcidius' source is Posi- donius' commentary on the Timaeus, I find his own reasoning in behalf of the use of a neo-Platonic commentary so unsatisfactory that I desire to reopen the question. We shall have little occasion to discuss the mathematical, musical, and astronomical material which forms a large part of the first one hundred and eighteen chapters of Chalcidius. Hiller 5 and Switalski have shown from resemblances to Theon of Smyrna that most of this comes from the commentary of Adrastus upon the Timaeus. In chapters 21-22 Chalcidius sets forth the theory which assigns three qualities to each element. It seems that the only parallels to this are Nemesius (De natura hominis 5) and Proclus (In Timaeum ii. 40). Arguing from these parallels Steinheimer, following Krause, 6 regards it as probable that Chalcidius is following Porphyry. There appears to be no evidence to indicate where or when this theory of the elements arose. If it were the property of any one of his pre- 1 Das Problem der Materie, p. 428. 1 Richtungen und Schulen im Neuplatonismus, p. 155, Genethliakon, 1910. » Untersuchungen Qber die Quellen des Chalcidius, 1912. '"Des Chalcidius Kommentar zu Platos TimaeuB," BeitrOge zur Geschichte der Philosophic des Miltelaller, III, Part 6, 1902. s "De Adrasti peripatetici in Platonis Timaeum commcntario," Rheini&ches Museum, N.F., XXVI (1871), 582 ff. « Studia neoplatonica, 1904. [Classical Philology XIII, April, 1918] 194 Chalcidius and Neo-Platonism 195 decessors in the neo-Platonic school, Proclus would naturally indi- cate this, as he usually does in such cases. Steinheimer himself seems disposed to believe that it goes back to the neo-Pythagoreans. We know that it was current in the neo-Platonic school. If we find reason to believe that Chalcidius is dependent upon a neo-Platonist for the rest of his material, we may easily concede that he took this from the same source. In chapters 23-25 we have a discussion of the eternity of the world. The general purport is as follows: Plato asserts that the world, as corporeal, is a created thing, and that it is indissoluble. Since these two statements appear to be contradictory, he justifies his position by telling us who the creator is, what the material, what the pattern. The world is the creation of God. But God and the causes of his works are not in time, but are eternal. Therefore the world, while in causal dependence upon God, had no beginning in time, and accordingly will have no end. Further, since God used all existent matter in making the world, there can be nothing outside of it to cause it injury. While it is true that the corporeal is in a state of flux, this flux is all within the universe, hence there can be no loss. Finally, the pattern, the intelligible world, is in eternity; the copy ought therefore to be in the image of eternity, that is, time without beginning and without end. After citing passages to show how Crantor, Albinus, and Taurus reconciled the creation of the world with the theory that it was with- out a beginning in time, Steinheimer remarks: "Aber auch von den gekunstelten Erklarungen der vorerwahnten Platoniker findet sich bei Chalcidius keine Spur." But Chalcidius' first point, that the world is created in the sense of being dependent upon higher causes, is made by Taurus, Alcinous, and Crantor. 1 The second argument, which concerns matter, is derived from Timaeus 32 D-33 D. The argument that the world is of infinite duration, since it is the copy of the intelligible world, which is eternal, is an easy extension of Timaeus 37 D, which would naturally be made when the denial of the creation in time became general in the Platonic school. 1 Cf. Taurus in Philoponus De aeternitate mundi 147. 5; Alcinous 14; Proclus /n Timaeum i. 277. 8. 196 ROGEB MlLLEB JONES In view of these facts it is clear that Steinheimer would gain very- little for his theory of a neo-Platonic origin of this passage even if all the parallels he cites were genuine. But upon investigation we see that the argument of Proclus In Timaeum ii. 55. 5 ff . is not the same as that of Chalcidius in these three chapters. Proclus, in his contention that the world is indissoluble, asserts that everything that is destroyed is destroyed irapa rrjv likqv or xapa t6 elSos or irapa t6 ■Kovqoav. The argument irapk rb iroirjaav differs widely from Chal- cidius' first argument, since Proclus is here concerned with proving the indestructibility of the world from considerations of the power and will of the creator, whereas Chalcidius is asserting that the works of God have no beginning in time. The argument irapa t6 eldos bears no resemblance to Chalcidius' third argument; in fact, tl8os here means the immanent form, not the transcendent idea. Further, Plotinus Enneads v. 8. 12 and Proclus i. 277, 18 are not parallel to the third argument. The quotation of the former passage may serve to illustrate the wide divergence between Chalcidius and the neo-Platonists: irao-a 81 fom tlidov Iutiv, Sow av t6 apxtrwrov h&vq. hub oi)K bpdw, ol deipov ov pfyrore ra dXXa ^XXetirj;, &XX' 1% o5 Ioti., /cat ravra i(TTW. fy b'atl koX earai. 1 In chapter 26 Chalcidius denies the creation of the world-soul in time. This also goes back to the Old Academy. The nearest parallel to Chalcidius' statement is Taurus, quoted by Philoponus, De aeternitate mundi 187. In chapter 29 two theories of the composi- tion of the world-soul are presented. The second of these has long been recognized as that of Plutarch and Atticus. The first, con- cerning which there is no such agreement, reads as follows: "num speciem intellegibilis mundi, ad cuius similitudinem formas mente conceptas ad corpora transferebat, individuam substantiam nun- cupaverit, dividuam vero silvam, quae velut exordium et fons est corporum, ita ut tertium illud mixtum substantiae genus formam esse intellegendum sit, qua informata sint tarn mundi quam cetera 1 It seems more probable that the argument of Porphyry, referred to in Philoponus De aeternitate mundi 224. 22 is a restatement of this position of Plotinus than that it is Chalcidius' third argument. Chalcidius and Neo-Platonism 197 quae mundus complectitur corpora." Concerning this, Steinheimer remarks (p. 13): "Diese Auslegung deckt sich mit keiner der von Proclus in Tim. ii, p. 153, 17 ff. vorgetragenen, kommt aber der des Aristandros und Numenius wohl am nachsten. Proclus selbst stimmt inhaltlich mit Chalcidius zusammen (p. 139, 14 ff.) : obicovv apApiarov pjkv ovaiav 4>&(iep rriv vot\ry\v iraaav ical rr/v voepav rtfv re o\ucriv ical jr\v p&piKt\v rqv t€ avXov koX xwpKmjP *at Tpb alwros rj b> aucvt ovaav, pepicrrriv hi iraaav rriv irtpl t& aiofxara irpoiovaav" ; p. 140, 24 ff.: &a.To tIjv otoiav Trjs lpvxys ix av & to-vrg roiis appovucovs \6yovs ovx &s fiXXow einovas, oi>8' «s &px&s iripwv, dXX' 6k vtikov irravBa /xr/Sa/xov tov JIXAtuivos p.i$' &XpK ovoftaros wapaAa/Sovros. Porphyr hat also die Mitte des Alls mit dem Sitz des Lebens identifiziert genau wie oben Chalcidius. Im folgenden Kapitel (100) spricht Chalcidius von einer Philosophengruppe, welche die Sonne als Sitz der Weltseele bezeichne. Dies bezieht sich jedenfalls auf Kleanthes, wie Switalski (p. 28), bemerkt. AUein mit Unrecht sagt dieser, Chalcidius folge dem Kleanthes. Dies beweist nicht nur die Ausdrucksweise, sondern es lasst die Auffassung des Kleanthes sich mit dem in c. 99 vertretenen Stand- punkt schlechterdings nicht zusammenbringen; denn bier wird die Mitte nicht ortlich, womit zugleich die korperliche Auffassung der Seele involviert ist, da nur das Korperliche an den Raum gebunden ist. Steinheimer's error lies in identifying the view expressed in chap- ter 99 with that of Porphyry. The phrase "a vitalibus mundi per extimas partes" has clearly a spatial significance, indicating the radia- tion, so to speak, of the soul from a central rtyepoviKbv. Furthermore, in Proclus ii. 282. 15, Porphyry says that the middle of the soul is t6 4>vtik6v, whereas in Chalcidius the words "ex quo adparet a vitalibus mundi per extimas partes" are an interpretation of "orsam ex medietate usque ad extremitatem mundani corporis." Chapter 100, far from being opposed to chapter 99, places the "vitalia mundi" in the sun. We learn from Proclus ii. 104. 17, which is a commentary upon Timaeus 34 B, that there were many spatial interpretations of r^rxftv els rb fUaov avrov dels, one of which regarded the sun as the center referred to, is h rimy KapSias ISpvfUvov. The closest parallel to Chalcidius, however, is Theon 187. 13 — 188. 7. Here a certain grouping of planets is approved iva tov KOffftov, is Koapov koX f^ou, 200 ROGEB MlLLEB JONKS rrjs ipfw-xias y rbiros ofrros, bffavti KapSias rod iravrbs tov ijKlov Tokvdipfwv 816. rf)v Klvrjatv ml rb piytBos mi tJiv avvoSiav tG>v irtpl airrbv. That this passage is from a commentary on the Timaeus is made probable by the language of 188. 3 ff. which contains reminis- cences of Timaeus 34 B. In chapter 122 we may note a statement of Pythagorean astron- omy at variance with that which seems to have been current among the neo-Platonists. One of the explanations of Timaeus 40 B which Chalcidius gives introduces the idea that the earth and the counter- earth revolve with the rest of the planets about the central fire. But Simplicius 1 and Asclepius 2 deny that this is a correct understanding of Pythagorean doctrine, and interpret the central fire as r-bv Sr/fuovpyiKJiv 8vvap.iv i~bv in pAffov tcUtcw rty yrjv ^(poyovovvav ml rb aireipvypivov airrrjs &va6&\irovaav, the countereartb as the moon. 3 In chapters 129-36 Chalcidius discusses demons, introducing this topic in connection with Timaeus 40 D. He follows the Epinomis closely: There are, according to Plato, five regions in the universe, the first of fire, the second of ether, which is a denser fire, the third of air, the fourth of moisture, which is a denser air, the fifth of earth. Each one of these supports living beings. Since the stars, which dwell in the region of fire, are immortal and impassive, and men, the inhabitants of earth, are mortal and subject to passions, demons, who occupy the intermediate spaces and constitute a mean, so to speak, between the two extremes, must be immortal and subject to passions. The ethereal demon may be defined as animal rationabile, immortale, patibile, aetherium, diligentiam hominibus impertiens. Ethereal demons are called holy angels by the Hebrews. It is they who mediate between the divine and the human. Aerial demons are like ethereal demons except that they have an aerial body and are more subject to passions, inasmuch as they are nearer the earth. Both ethereal and aerial demons are invisible. Demons of the third class, however, are sometimes visible. It is they who avenge crime; often they do evil to men unprovoked. Because of their proximity 1 Commentary upon Aristotle's De caelo 512. 9. * Commentary upon Aristotle's Metaphysics 35. 24. ' Wrobel, in the Index Verborum attached to his edition of Chalcidius, incorrectly interprets drrlxSav as "hemisphaerium alteram, antipodum sedes." Chalcidius and Neo-Platonism 201 to earth and their close contact with matter they are touched by earthly desires. They are the so-called desertores angeli. Many Platonists believe that souls freed from bodies become demons, and that they are incarnated every thousand years, But Plato distinguishes between souls and demons. He does teach, however, that souls which have lived with extraordinary virtue through three incarnations are restored to regions of air or even ether and remain forever freed from rebirth. The elements of the account which are not derived from the Epinomis are unimportant. The latter work does not contain the statement that ether is a denser fire and moisture a denser air. It does not say directly that the virtue of demons is proportionate to the fineness of the matter of which their bodies are composed. Yet the statement that water-demons are sometimes visible, whereas ethereal and aerial demons are always invisible, seems to indicate that, dwelling in a grosser element, the former are less pure than the latter. The belief in evil demons goes back at least as far as Xenoc- rates. Chalcidius' definition of demon contains nothing at variance with the Epinomis, and bears a striking resemblance to the definitions found in Apuleius De deo Socratis 13 and Maximus Tyrius, Diss. 15. The equation of demons and angels may, of course, go back to Chal- cidius' source, but it was so common that it may have been added by Chalcidius himself. 1 Steinheimer, however, exaggerates the differ- ences between Chalcidius and the Epinomis by several misinterpreta- tions of the latter. On page 22 he says that the ethereal demons of the Epinomis are stars. On page 25 he applies the statement that water-demons are sometimes visible to ethereal and aerial demons. He then tries to establish Porphyry as Chalcidius' source. His first argument is that Porphyry classifies demons as good and evil, and that he divides good demons into angels and demons proper, according as they dwell in ether or air. But the statement of Augustine De civitate dei x. 9, that the abode of angels according to Porphyry is "loca aetheria vel empyrea" allows only the interpretation that their abode is the heaven of the planets and the fixed stars; cf. Zeller, III, 2, 1 Cf. Heinze, Xenocrates, p. 110, n. 1: "Die ganzen Ausfuhrungen des Chalcidius iiber Damonen schliessen sich eng an die Epinomis an und halten sich von neuplato- nischen Fhantastereien fern. Naturlich kann es der Christ Chalcidius nicht unter- lassen, die guten Damonen mit den Engeln zu identificieren." 202 Roger Milleb Jones 727, n. 5. And this seems to be supported by Porphyry De absti- nentia ii. 37, where it is said that demons are the souls which dwell beneath the moon. Thus Porphyry's angels are not the angels or ethereal demons of Chalcidius, since the latter is careful to place the region of ether beneath the moon. There is no need to discuss the remaining arguments of Stein- heimer, the omission of heroes in both Porphyry and Chalcidius, the occurrence of the idea that the vice of demons is due to connection with matter, and the supposed resemblance between the two in the matter of the visibility of demons. We may point out further that Steinheimer fails to see the absolute contradiction between Chalcidius chapter 135, "immortale porro, quia non mutat corpus aliud ex alio, sed eodem semper utitur," and Porphyry De abstinentia ii. 39: t6 Si irvedfia jj fiiv kari aufiarucdv, TraB-qTucbv Am ko.1 fflaprbv. t$ Si bird t&v ipvx&v oJircos SeSicdai, Sxrre t6 elSos avr&v SiapAvav irXcia; Xpbvov, ob \a\v iartv al&viov. Steinheimer furthermore points to the fact that both Chalcidius and Porphyry distinguish demons from human souls freed from bodies. But in the first place, the Epinomis does not contain the slightest hint that demons and souls are the same, and, in the second place, the theory which distinguished them existed in the Academy along with the theory which identified them; cf. Plutarch De defectu oraadorum 431 E. Finally Steinheimer calls attention to the fact that both Chal- cidius and Porphyry hold that certain souls, restored to the upper regions, are free thereafter from reincarnation. While the doctrine of Chalcidius, chapter 136, differs from that of many Platonists, it is a combination of the ideas of Phaedrus 249 and Phaedo 114 C, tovtuv Si avr&v ol ^>iKo(rolq. itcavws naBTip&fievot, &vev re ffw/tdnoj' fwffi t6 ira.pa.Tav els t6v hreira -xpbvov. Summing the matter up, we may say that Chalcidius' theories of demons and of the fate of the soul after death may be explained from the use of the Epinomis, the Phaedrus, the Phaedo, and ideas which demonstrably were present in the Academy before the neo- Platonists; that his theories are at variance with those of Porphyry in several important details. We may also call attention to the fact that, according to Proclus iii. 153. 28 ff., the 8at/xows of Timaeus Chalciditjs and Neo-Platonism 203 40 D are not demons, as Chalcidius regards them, but yevetriavpyol 6toi. Chapters 143-90 contain a discussion of providence, fate, chance, and free will, which is partly Platonic, partly Peripatetic. The same elements are found in the pseudo-Plutarchean De fato in much the same form as here. 1 The passages which concern us chiefly are chapters 176-77 and 188. Here Chalcidius gives a hierarchy of powers. The highest god is the good; he is beyond essence, he transcends thought; after him all things yearn. Next comes providentia, which the Greeks call povs, an intelligible essence, participating in goodness because of its unceasing conversio (iirurrpoii) toward the highest god. It is ordered (ornatur) by the latter, just as everything else is reduced to order through its instrumentality. It is dei voluntas. Men call it prov- identia, because intellegere is the proper activity of the divine mind. Providentia is followed by the secunda mens, that is, the world-soul, the guardian of eternal law, ergo summus deus iubet, secundus ordinat, tertius intimat. Apropos of chapter 188 Steinheimer remarks (p. 31): "Es sind also die drei gottlichen Hypostasen der Schule Plotins mit solcher Klarheit vorgefuhrt, dass man sich wundern muss, wie dies nicht erkannt werden konnte." Let us first examine the parallels between Chalcidius and the pseudo-Plutarchean De fato. We read in this latter treatise, 573 B: 17 5' avuT&ra itpbvoia. rp&rfiirrarop arravrup, irX^p ovrip iarw. Are Potihyais Art pbriois Are koa hcartpov Ion 5' d« irporepop Aprrrax, rod iravrav irarpfc re dviiiovpyod; cf. also 572 F. In 574 B the author says that the highest providence produces fate. But in 568 E fate (/car' ovaiav) is identified with the tripartite world-soul just as in Chalcidius, chapter 144. The similarity between the two dis- cussions is obvious. The De fato, however, omits the statements concerning the transcendence of the first god and the conversio of providentia. * For parallels in Nemesius De natura hominit, Proolus De fato, and elsewhere, of. Gereke, "Eine platonische Quelle des Neuplatonismus," Rheinisches Museum, XLI, 266 ff. The Peripatetic ideas are elaborated in the De fato of Alexander of Aphro- disias. A similar account of fate and free will must have been the basis of the short treatment in Alcinous, chapter 26. 204 Rogee Miller Jones We have no difficulty in finding parallels in other authors before Plotinus. God is regularly identified with the good: cf. Plutarch De Iside et Osiride 382 D, Alcinous, chapter 10. Plato himself says that the good transcends being, Republic 509 B. The pseudo- Archytas, in Stobaeus Eclogues i. 716, says that God is higher than vovs. The thought that all things yearn for God, while originally from Aristotle Metaphysics 1072 a, 19, is found in Plutarch De facie in orbe lunae 944 E, and Alcinous, chapter 10. In this latter chapter we have also a hierarchy consisting of the first god, also called the first vovs, the obpdvim vovs, and the world-soul. Perhaps the closest parallel to Chalcidius is in the Poemandres, where we find a hierarchy of 9e6s, vovs, xfoxh- God, as the ground of all being and the source of vovs, transcends both being and wDj. His activity is will. The vovs depends upon God, as the yf/vxh upon vovs. Besides being able to cite these parallels from authors before Plotinus, we can show that Chalcidius' idea could not have come from Plotinus or his school. Whereas Chalcidius calls providentia the will of God and says that God commands (summus deus iubet), Plotinus expressly says, vi. 9. 6: t ivl ovhkv a/yadbv eiiT€pov, which is the resultant, not of a union of body and soul, but of body and an emanation, an effluence, given off by the soul; cf. Plotinus i. 1. 7; vi. 4. 15. Neither can Chalcidius' strange interpretation of Timaeus 46 E be neo-Platonic (chapter 261): "illas vero, inquit, quae ab aliis motae movent alias, secundas existimandum. perspicue patibilem partem rationabilis animae vitiosamque significat. in qua est im- petus, quippe inpetus principaliter quidem ab ea parte animae movetur, quae motu intimo genuinoque ex semet ipsa movetur, ex accidenti vero etiam desideriis moventibus. ipse autem inpetus movet corpus." The phrase "patibilem partem rationabilis animae" is utterly inconsistent with Plotinus' statements that the soul is ewra&js, and that the effluence which combines with the body is no part of the soul (iii. 6. 1; vi. 4. 15). In chapters 275-320 Chalcidius gives a discussion of matter. After setting forth the ideas of the Hebrews, the atomists, the Eleatics, Empedocles, Aristotle, the Stoics, and Pythagoras (accord- ing to Numenius), he gives, in chapters 300-320, the theory of Plato. Steinheimer (pp. 40-45) indicates many close parallels between this latter section and Plotinus, and concludes, notwithstanding several slight discrepancies which he points out, that Chalcidius' source is a neo-Platonist. The argument would be very plausible if we found the same agreement between Chalcidius and Plotinus concerning the question of the origin of matter that we find concerning its nature. But in chapters 300-301 Chalcidius divides Platonists into two main classes : those who declare that matter is the creation of God, and those who regard it as uncreated. This latter class is again divided into those who hold that matter was animated by an evil soul before the creation of the world-soul by God, and those who hold that the disordered motion of which Plato speaks was not in unqualified matter, which is immobile, but in bodies. Whether Chalcidius is referring in his first class to the neo- Platonists or to earlier philosophers such as Eudorus, is uncertain. Those who taught the doctrine of the original, evil world-soul are Plutarch, Atticus, and their school. The second division of the 208 Rogbb Miller Jones second class seems to include the Platonists who, while regarding matter as uncreated and a separate dpx^, maintained that the world was not created in time. There can be no doubt that Chalcidius himself follows this latter class. Throughout the work he argues for the eternity of the world. His opposition to those who declare matter to be created is seen from the phrase which he uses concerning them, "verba quaedam potius quam rem secuti." Furthermore, in chapters 303-5 he demonstrates that there are three principles — God, matter, and the ideas. If Chalcidius had used a neo-Platonic commentary on the Timaeus, there is no doubt that he would have found in it the doc- trine that matter is not an independent principle, but is derived. For we see from the arguments of Porphyry and Proclus 1 that the neo-Platonists laid a great deal of emphasis upon this point. Being a Christian and knowing that according to commentators the Hebrew Scriptures taught that matter was created, 2 Chalcidius could have had no reason for substituting the theory of the independence of matter for that of its derivation. The resemblances between Chalcidius and Plotinus are to be explained most easily by the assumption that they drew from the common fund of ideas of the Platonic school. For the doctrine of the nature of matter which they set forth is plainly a development of the teachings of Plato and Aristotle. 3 In conclusion, our investigation has shown us that there is much in Chalcidius utterly at variance with the theories of the neo- Platonists; that the ideas which he has in common with them are found in earlier writers, with the apparent exception of the three- quality theory of the elements, and the denial of the transmigration of souls into the bodies of the lower animals; that consequently we cannot assume a neo-Platonic commentary or treatise as the source. Ghinnbll College 1 Proclus i. 384, 391, 457. * Of. chap. 276. < Cf. Baeumker, Das Problem der Materie, p. 403.