STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Volume XIV April IQIQ Number z SCHERIA— CORCYRA II By A. Shewan As already stated, Mure was of the opinion that the poet was describing a people whom he knew. In Appendix E to the first volume of his Hist. Gk. hit. he goes farther and suggests that the Phaeacians were a colony of $oivuces, who were settled in Corcyra and who became "the butt of Homer's playful satire." Both $air)ices and ioiviKes are devoted to navigation and characterized by an epithet denoting magnificence or ostentation; both are vavaUXuroi and ayavol. The Qoivuces are, "in the true spirit of Homeric humour" — and we know how fond Homer is of paronomasia in a variety of forms — disguised as ^airjKes. 1 If the lively ways of the Homeric Phaeacians are the opposite of the "gravity, or even gloom" of the Phoenicians it is suggested that, in the case of a Phoenician community that happened to be of a frivolous disposition, the con- trast between such habits and the usual characteristics of the race might even add zest to the satire. I venture to think, after prolonged examination of the literature of Scheria, that Mure's view is substantially correct and that in fact it only needs to be brought up to date. As we now know much more 1 Schliemann, Tiryns, p. 24, note, mentions that Mahaffy thought Scheria might be a colony of Phocaeans who were thus taken off, but I cannot find Mahaffy's refer- ence to the point. [Classical Philoloot XIV, April, 1919] 97 98 A. Shewan about the early Mediterranean than was known in 1850, let us accept the guidance of the archaeologists and see if their discoveries assist the solution of our present problem. The study of the environment in or of which an old poet has written being admittedly a good guide to the proper understanding of his poetry, let us consider what has lately been revealed to us as to conditions in Greece and its sur- roundings in the age that is reflected in the Homeric epics. First we have a long period of Minoan civilization in Crete with its headquarters at Knossos. Then comes a transfer of power to the mainland of Greece and the Mycenaean age begins. This con- tinues during and ends with the period ca. 1350-1100 B.C., at or toward the close of which Knossos is destroyed. Homer — and in using the name I am following the archaeologists and disregarding the inops turba of the dissectors of the poems — flourished somewhat later. Our chief authority, Sir Arthur Evans, tells us in J.H.S., XXXII, 277 ff., one of the most valuable papers on the succession of the Minoan and Mycenaean ages and the age of Homer, that Homer is "at most sub-Mycenaean." His floruit is on the borders of the geometrical period, and he describes the "chalco-sideric" age, anterior to his own, in which, though bronze was still in general use, iron was beginning to be turned to account. Already in the Second Late Minoan period there had been (Scripta Minoa, p. 56) "Minoan pre- dominance, not to use a stronger expression, extending north of the gulf of Corinth," which in the chalco-sideric age had become "My- cenaean domination on the mainland of Greece," with its chief center, or at least one chief center, of power in the Peloponnesus. This is the political condition presupposed by the Homeric poems. Dr. Leaf and Professor Bury (Quarterly Review [July, 1916], p. 14) would "sweep away the Catalogue." To that one must object most strenuously. With or without it, however, we have in Homer, to use Professor Bury's words, "a consistent political map for 1200 b.c. " In the period preceding the Mycenaean, the Minoan empire, with its center at Knossos, had been extended far both east and west of the Mediterranean. For its influence in the West see Scrip. Min. (pp. 61 and 95 f.), Peet in B.S.A. (XIII, 405 ff.), and Myres in Proceedings of the Classical Association ([1911], pp. 50 ff.) and in The Year's Work ([1906], p. 27), referring to J.H.S. (XXIV, 125). Schema — Corcyra 99 We read that there were settlements in Sicily, Italy, Sardinia, and Spain, and that there is abundant evidence of intercourse, in the late Minoan age, between the Aegean and Italy, 1 and between the Aegean and the head of the Adriatic, as shown by the remains of a Mycenaean colony at Torcello near Venice. For the early obsidian trade see the Hellenic Society's Phylakopi, volume, 233. It need not surprise us if we hear of a Minoan settlement in Corcyra. I have already argued that the island could not have been overlooked. It would be "useful for the coasting voyage to Sicily." See Burrows (p. 13, and p. 208, n. 6) on the possibility of "genuine Minoan tradi- tions in the island." Corcyra would in fact be the Minoan traders' next landing-place after leaving Ithaka, which was the final port of call in Greece, on the voyage to the west, like Sicily and Sardinia farther on (Peet, ut supra, p. 420). Cf. Thompson on Leukas in Liverpool Annals (IV, 133). A Minoan settlement would be inevi- table in an island so attractive and so incomparably situated as Corcyra. "The Homeric poems," we read in Scrip. Min. (p. 61), "them- selves afford a convincing proof that the traditions of the earlier Minoan and Mycenaean culture lived on in that of the Viking race of Greece," and Professor Burrows (p. 209) tells us that the story of the poems presupposes the civilization of Late Minoan III, a period in which, as we have seen, intercourse with the West was active. It is the sea lore of that age that is preserved in the Odyssey (Myres, Geogr. Aspect, p. 52, and Ramsay, CR, XVIII, 167). But we have in the epic only a tradition; there is no direct account of the Minoan empire, its connections, or its commerce. But we do have a descrip- tion of its representatives and their proceedings in the Mediterranean. Homer's $oivuces are not Phoenicians; they are the Minoans. The distinction in Homer between Qoivwes and Si&frtot has not always been recognized, but it was seen by Gladstone (Juv. Mundi, p. 143, and Synchronism, p. 162, and cf. his remark quoted in Scrip. Min., p. 94, note), by Hayman (App. D.), and by Seymour {Life in the Homeric Age, p. 52, note), who gives the Homeric references and the Homeric character, not a very high one, of these trafficking Qoivuces or "red men." They have in these days come into their own as the 1 It goes back even to the fourth millennium B.C. (Evans in B.S.A., VIII, 123). 100 A. Shewan Minoans of the archaeologists see Scrip. Min. (pp. 56, 80); Fick (Hattid., p. 4), referring to his Ortsn. (pp. 123 ff.), Burrows (p. 142), Frost (J.H.S., XXXIII, 196, note), Aly (loc. tit.), Wace on Poulsen, Year's Work ([1913], p. 50), and on the subject generally, Hall (B.S.A., VIII on "Keftiu and the Peoples of the Sea"). There is truth in the dictum of Assmann (Das Floss der Odyssee, p. 19), ohne die Phoiniker hdtten wir vielen von der Odyssee nicht, wahrscheinlich uberhaupt keine Odyssee, if for Phoinikes we now read Minoans. Are there then any indications of a settlement of $oivuia QripSov ? Figurines of the huntress goddess, apparently of an archaic character, have been found in Corcyra (B.S. A., XIV, 64). SCHEBIA — COROTBA 101 M in., p. 133). For manners and costume see Berard (I, 574 ff.) ; for the palace, with its dpiyxbs Kvavoio — a substance "indications" of which were found in the palace at Knossos, see B.S.A. (VI, 10), Burrows (pp. 206, 209); and for the comfortable life, see Drerup, Omero, pp. 265 f . As regards place-names I have compared those in Fick's Cretan lists in Hattid. (pp. 8 ff.) with those for Corcyra given by Bursian and others and have found that the names which are similar in both correspond generally to those mentioned by Paulatos, IIATPIS (p. 56 and note), and which he says are not Greek but Semitic. Certainly there are points of community. But then there are, as the upholders of the Cretan theory themselves admit, some very decided differences. Professor Burrows (p. 208, note) remarks on a difficulty as to boxing, which does not, however, appeal to me, as I explain elsewhere. And there is no reference to that peculiarly Minoan sport, the taurokathapsia or bull-baiting in the arena. Such reminiscences of the heyday of the Minoan empire could hardly have been omitted. And then the bow; ov yap $avi)Keo hrl fiwu&v (rj 100), which held lighted torches inside the palace, I can find no parallel from Minoan Crete. /Swjuoi or pedestals for lamps have been found, but not, so far as I know, surmounted by \ap,iradr)6poi. The nearest approach to these seems to be the Petsofa figurines, with a saucer lamp on the head, mentioned in B.S.A., IX, 372. And then there are the various references in antiquity to the occu- pation of Corcyra by Colchians. Dodwell, in his Tour through Greece (I, 36), reports a tradition that as early as 1349 B.C., that is, in 1 Cf. B.S.A. , VI, 40 for a doorway with "griffins facing it on either side." 2 It may be worth noting that in another Cretan settlement, Gezer of the Philis- tines, "architectural features of the Cretan type" have been found (Scrip. Min., p. 78). 104 A. Shew an the Mycenaean period, there was an immigration of Colchians, but he does not give his authority, and I can obtain no confirmation. Another, in Apollonius Rhodicus, is to the effect that Alkinoos allowed the Colchians who pursued the Argonauts to settle in Corcyra, where they stayed till the time of the Bacchiadae of Corinth, when the Corinthians, according to Strabo (vi. 269), turned them out. Cf. Wilamowitz (H.U., pp. 170 ff.) and Nitzsch (Anmkgn., II, 74). The most likely settlers in prehistoric times would be the Minoans, and if we cannot assume that the Minoans have been converted into Colchians through the story of the Argonauts, they at least appear to have been of the same kin. Rawlinson (on Herodotus, I, 2) sug- gested an ethnical relation between the Colchians and the Phoeni- cians, or, as he might now say, the Minoans. Herodotus regarded the Colchians as Egyptians, a remnant of the army of Sesostris, but his identifying marks might apply to Minoans. The latter were connected with the Anatolian stock (Scrip. Min., p. 61, and J.H.S., XXXII, 279). Trade connection between Crete, Egypt, and Armenia, which bordered on Colchis, is proved by the archaeology of the spiral form of ornamentation. Mackenzie (Myths of Crete, pp. 28 f., also p. 325) says that the Minoans penetrated the Dar- danelles and tapped the trade which came from the East to the shores of the Black Sea. Colchis may have been a settlement of theirs. Those who are now coming to believe that the rape of Helen was not wholly mythical may perhaps go farther and believe that the carrying off of Medea from Colchis was a reprisal for the abduction of Io by Qoivwes, or Minoans, and that Corcyra became involved in this feud between East and West. On the "debtor and creditor account" of such abductions drawn up in later story, see Grote, History ([ed. 1888], I, 224, note), referring to the opening of Herodotus' history. And finally there is the portrait figured by Sir Arthur Evans in a paper in the J.H.S., the reference to which I have lost, which is perhaps "the actual likeness of a Minoan dynast," and is pronounced to be curi- ously Armenoid in its general traits. Now the Colchians are said to have been of Armenoid race, and in Minoans and Egyptians, according to Mackenzie (pp. 150 and 197), there was an Armenoid strain. But with this meager contribution I must leave the matter, if it be worth pursuing, to wiser heads than mine in the hope that Schema — Corcyra 105 further research will tend to identify these Colchians, in their old home on the Euxine and in Corcyra, with the Minoans. The Liburnians also had an ancient connection with Corcyra which is perhaps worth noting: Bursian (op. tit., II, 359, note) quoted by Fick (Hattid., p. 30) tells us that they were the oldest inhabitants of Corcyra. They also (Smith's Diet. Geog., s.v.) occupied the northern part of Illyricum, having migrated there from Italy, and Niebuhr considered them "Pelasgians." Cf. Helbig in Hermes (XI, 257 ff.), who repeats the story that Idomeneus, driven from Crete after the Trojan War, came to Illyricum and went on thence with the Illyrians to Italy. Much the same was told of Diomede. Meriones was said to have settled in Sicily. Bursian (I, 17 f.) gives the tradition about the arrival of Helenus with a Trojan band in Epirus. Cf. Bethe, Rhein. Mus., LXV, 210, nach Sizilien vrie nach Korkyra Splitter des Keftiuvolkes von Kreta axis verschlagen sind, and for an interpretation of the meaning of move- ments of this kind see Casson, "The Dispersal Legend," in CR, XXVII, 156a. They may reflect actual migrations from Crete to Italy and a return movement thence to the neighborhood of Corcyra, just of the nature of the one which Berard and others see in the Odyssean transfer of the Phaeacians from Hypereia to Scheria (cf. Burrows, p. 208, n. 6). Fick and Kretschmer have noted many linguistic indications of the early connection between the two shores of the Adriatic. 'laruvr), a mountain in Corcyra, and Histonium of the Frentani are only one of many such (Fick, Ortsn., p. 142, and Hattid., p. 31, quoting Helbig, ut supra). But whether future investigations of the relation of the Colchians and Libumians to Corcyra and the mainland near it helps our present view or not really matters little, for we have one fact which is as nearly decisive as anything can be in regard to so remote a matter. There was a Minoa in Corcyra (see Burrows, p. 13 and the reference there). That is taken as a certain sign of Minoan occupation, and it makes it more than mere hypothesis that it is a Minoan settlement which Homer, with, if we please, added touches of fancy (Eustathius' irXatrfxara irtBava) and certainly with humor playing over the whole, has described for us in an imperishable lay. Bergk (Hist. Gk. Lit., p. 787) saw in it Dichtung und Wahrheit verschmolzt. The poet 106 A. Shewan followed the Volksglaube in its mingling of fiction with truth. Cor- cyra, on the borderland between Greece and the West, was a likely locality to tempt to such treatment, "mixed treatment," as Glad- stone calls it (Juv. Mund., pp. 476 f.). The regions beyond were in a sense the haunts of mystery, and the jurisdiction of the god Poseidon, 1 from whom pre-Achaean families or peoples like the Phaeacians and the Cyclopes traced their descent, and the theme of the life and ways there must, as the Odyssey shows, have been an attractive one to the Achaeans of the Greek mainland. It is likely enough, when one considers how it has struck some authorities, that Homer is describing the people and the locality from personal observation, and certainly it is quite possible that the poet himself had visited Corcyra. That he was a traveler no one can doubt who reads his works, notes how much of the earth he has seen with his own eyes, and recalls his remarkable simile in 80 ff . : us 5' or' av cuiffl vbos kvipos, 6s t' eirl iroWqv yaiav eXrfKvdus pe66vos de&v as Herodotus was later, sees in this material for the further embellishment of his picture, \pev8e