STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. NOTES AND DISCUSSIONS PHILOLAUS, FRAGMENT 6, DIELS. STOBAEUS i. 21. 460 The passage purports to be an excerpt from a work of Philolaus entitled iripl Koo-pov, and has therefore been subjected to scrutiny both by general editors of Stobaeus and by collectors of the fragments of Philolaus. Among the former are such well-known names as Heeren, Gaisford, Meineke, and Wachsmuth; while chief among the latter are Mullach (followed by Ritter et Preller), Boeckh, Schaarschmidt, Bywater, and H. Diels in the first volume of his Fragmente der Vorsokratiker. Boeckh argued that all the fragments of Philolaus were genuine, and Zeller accepted all but those taken from a work called irtpl i/'v^s; Valentine Rose and Professors Bywater and John Burnet have held that they were all spurious; and Diels considers some of them genuine, some doubtful, and some certainly false. The question of authenticity depends partly on linguistic factors and partly on the thought, but the two phases are inex- tricably tied up together owing to the extreme corruption of the text. Your emendations are bound to reflect your interpretation of the author's meaning, and vice versa; so that there is no escape from going round in an endless circle. It is thus necessary to define one's attitude on the general subject before attacking any particular fragment. My own view is that all the fragments which Diels accepts and possibly some of the others are genuine; that they set forth a doctrine which is con- sistent in its various aspects — as consistent as Pythagorean doctrines ever were; and that this doctrine is a development of earlier Pythagoreanism to meet the tendencies then current in philosophy. It thus can be fitted into its proper chronological place in the development of Pythagoreanism as well as in the larger current of Greek philosophy. Diels reads for the first sentence of his fragment 6 as follows: 7repl Si 8e «X el ' °- / /, ' v ''J" 1 ""' ™' / ffpay/iaTtov di'Sios evv iavTtov Kal yiyvuxTKO/tevov {up' d/xcov ya yevecr&u p.rj wapxotxra? Tas «<7toBs tu>v TrpaypAriov, l£ S>v v tre.po.i- vovriav Kal ru>v aireiputv. The general topic of the passage is <£ixns koI appovia. The former is the generic word for the real essence or nature of the world, and is used by various authors with differing connotations according to their particular views. Here it is immediately defined in a Pythagorean sense by the addi- 353 354 Notes and Discussions tion of dp/xovia, which according to the fragments was the active, creating, regulating force in nature (frags. 1, 2, 7, 10). In the next phrase, however, it is similarly linked with lurw. tcrrta t5>v irpayfuxTo>v is an emendation of Boeckh's, on the basis of rav ia-ria tS>v irpo.yiM.Twv Archytas ap. Stobaeus i. 714. la-Til) is a Doric form from the root Is (ei/u), but does not appear to be a dialect equivalent for ova-ia, as Doric has also uxrta. In the fragment of Archytas, lorco is defined as v\r) substance, and as such is distinguished from 6t6s creative artist and from px>p creative art or model. An examination of the fragments of Philolaus tends to establish a similar significance for lorco; thus at the end of the passage quoted above, the author speaks of the lort6 of things, out of which (things) the ordered universe arose, and this terra) is described as underlying (wrapxovtras) the world that we see and know. This can hardly mean anything but the basic stuff or matter. Now Pro- fessor Burnet on other evidence has shown that "what distinguished the Pythagoreanism of this period from its earlier form was that it sought to adapt itself to the new theory of 'elements,'" of which Empedocles was the chief exponent. 1 The twelfth Philolaic fragment of Diels expressly mentions the four Empedoclean elements and joins them with the "hull of the sphere," a phrase which even Professor Burnet, though holding the fragments to be spurious, acknowledges as "a genuine Pythagorean expression." 2 If then Philolaus took over the elements, lorci in the present passage would signify the material substance of the world, existing as earth, air, fire, and water. And the author would thus imply that nature t/>w« had two aspects — the one active apfwvia, the other material Icrrt6. Since then iaru> is one side of epverts, the two notions linked together in the phrase d p-iv ia-rm . . . . kou aira piv a though it may be better translated with yvuMTiv. Professor A. A. Bowman has suggested to me that the on clause be taken closely with yvaxnv, or that rijv yvuxriv be supplied after ^ from the preceding. The phrase would then be rendered: "no more at any rate than the knowledge that." It is in this on clause that the greatest difficulty of the whole passage lies. The manuscripts are read as follows: on ov% olov rrjv ovOevi t£>v iovrwv KOi yi-yvtoo-KO/xeVcov va>v .... ytvia-Oai in the fifth German edition of his Philosophie der Griechen (I, 346, n. 1), so that the reading which I am advocating is really his. It would be perhaps easier to correct ytyvia-Oai to ytyv«T0' &fiS>v. We must be careful to understand what Philolaus means by this yevla-dai. In the first part of the present fragment, he says that the substance of things is eternal, and thus he takes his stand squarely on the fundamental postulate 356 Notes and Discussions of all Greek cosmology: ex nihilo nihil fit. Hence ycvcb-Au must refer to the formation of individual things out of the eternal stuff, and its subject ovOiv tu>v i6vTu>v is in line with this interpretation. In the latter part of the passage the author uses the expression o-wio-ra 6 Koo-fw;, by which he means that the ordered universe which we see is a construction. The action which brought it about is spoken of in different fragments under the terms dpfioxOij, s t&W, ol 8' s dXXoTpiois 7rpoo-«xovo-i TOV VO vv. It is one of a long series of antitheses (extending through 18-21) which set forth the advantages of the rule of kings over that of citizens in a democracy or an oligarchy. The meaning here, as the context shows, must be: kings give attention to affairs of state as if they were their own concern; citizens in other governments, as if they were the concern of others. But in all the other antitheses in the midst of which this one is set, ol p.ev is used consistently for officers or ministers in a democratic or an oligarchical state, while ol Be is used for kings. It is, therefore, hardly conceivable that in the single sentence above quoted so careful a stylist as Isocrates could have reversed the order. It is easier to assume that the words iSt'ois and aWorpiois have somehow changed places. The mere carelessness of a copyist may have been to blame, or the transposi- tion may have been due to a mental confusion produced by the fact that the doctrine here stated is contrary to Isocrates' own tributes to the old Athenian